Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1703.08438 · Physical Review A

Exact electrodynamics versus standard optics for a slab of cold dense gas

Juha Javanainen, Janne Ruostekoski, Yi Li, Sung-Mi Yoo

Published Sep 20, 2017• 45 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study light propagation through a slab of cold gas using both the standard electrodynamics of polarizable media and massive atom-by-atom simulations of the electrodynamics. The main finding is that the predictions from the two methods may differ qualitatively when the density of the atomic sample $\ensuremath{\rho}$ and the wave number of resonant light $k$ satisfy $\ensuremath{\rho}{k}^{\ensuremath{-}3}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1$. The reason is that the standard electrodynamics is a mean-field theory, whereas for sufficiently strong light-mediated dipole-dipole interactions the atomic sample becomes strongly correlated. The deviations from mean-field theory appear to scale with the parameter $\ensuremath{\rho}{k}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$, and we demonstrate noticeable effects already at $\ensuremath{\rho}{k}^{\ensuremath{-}3}\ensuremath{\simeq}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}2}$. In dilute gases and in gases with an added inhomogeneous broadening the simulations show shifts of the resonance lines in qualitative agreement with the predicted Lorentz-Lorenz shift and ``cooperative Lamb shift,'' but the quantitative agreement is unsatisfactory. Our interpretation is that the microscopic basis for the local-field corrections in electrodynamics is not fully understood.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.96.033835

Related papers

Light propagation beyond the mean-field theory of standard optics

Juha Javanainen, Janne Ruostekoski

With ready access to massive computer clusters we may now study light propagation in a dense cold atomic gas by means of basically exact numerical simulations. We report on a direct comparison between traditional optics, that is, electrodynamics of a polarizable medium, and numerical simulations in an elementary problem of light propagating through a slab of matter. The standard optics fails already at quite low atom densities, and the failure becomes dramatic when the average interatomic separation is reduced to around k(-1), where k is the wave number of resonant light. The difference between the two solutions originates from correlations between the atoms induced by light-mediated dipole-dipole interactions.

arXiv:1409.4598•Optics Express•Jan 12, 2016•85 citations

Shifts of a Resonance Line in a Dense Atomic Sample

Juha Javanainen, Janne Ruostekoski, Yi Li +1 more

We study the collective response of a dense atomic sample to light essentially exactly using classical-electrodynamics simulations. In a homogeneously broadened atomic sample there is no overt Lorentz-Lorenz local field shift of the resonance, nor a collective Lamb shift. However, the addition of inhomogeneous broadening restores the usual mean-field phenomenology.

arXiv:1308.6254•Physical Review Letters•Mar 21, 2014•155 citations

Coherent Scattering of Near-Resonant Light by a Dense Microscopic Cold Atomic Cloud

Stephan Jennewein, Mondher Besbes, Nick J. Schilder +6 more

We measure the coherent scattering of light by a cloud of laser-cooled atoms with a size comparable to the wavelength of light. By interfering a laser beam tuned near an atomic resonance with the field scattered by the atoms, we observe a resonance with a redshift, a broadening, and a saturation of the extinction for increasing atom numbers. We attribute these features to enhanced light-induced dipole-dipole interactions in a cold, dense atomic ensemble that result in a failure of standard predictions such as the "cooperative Lamb shift". The description of the atomic cloud by a mean-field model based on the Lorentz-Lorenz formula that ignores scattering events where light is scattered recurrently by the same atom and by a microscopic discrete dipole model that incorporates these effects lead to progressively closer agreement with the observations, despite remaining differences.

arXiv:1510.08041•Physical Review Letters•Jun 8, 2016•141 citations

One-dimensional modeling of light propagation in dense and degenerate samples

Juha Javanainen, Janne Ruostekoski, Bjarne Vestergaard +1 more

We study propagation of low-intensity light in a medium within a one-dimensional (1D) model electrodynamics. It is shown that the coupled theory for light and matter fields may be solved, in principle exactly, by means of stochastic simulations that account for both collective linewidths and line shifts, and for quantum statistical position correlations of the atoms. Such simulations require that one synthesize atomic positions that have correlation functions appropriate for the given type of atomic sample. We demonstrate how one may simulate both a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) and a zero-temperature noninteracting Fermi-Dirac gas. Results of simulations of light propagation in such quantum degenerate gases are compared with analytical density expansions obtained by adapting the approach of Morice, Castin, and Dalibard [Phys. Rev. A 51, 3896 (1995)] to the 1D electrodynamics. A BEC exhibits an optical resonance that narrows and stays somewhat below the atomic resonance frequency as collective effects set in with increasing atom density. The first two terms in the analytical density expansion are in excellent agreement with numerical results for a condensate. While fermions display a similar narrowing and shift of the resonance with increasing density, already in the limit of very dilute gas the linewidth is only half of the resonance linewidth of an isolated atom. We attribute this to the regular spacing between the atoms, which is enforced by the Pauli exclusion principle. The analytical density expansion successfully predicts the narrowing, and also gives the next term in the density expansion of the optical response in semiquantitative agreement with numerical simulations.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1999•91 citations

Cooperative Effects in the Optical Response of Dense Atomic Gases

Yi Li

At high density, dipole-dipole interactions between the atoms may have a major impact on light propagation in a dense gas. We have developed a classical-electrodynamics simulation to study the cooperative response of a near-resonant gas to light. We take into account the motion of the radiators using classical trajectories, including collisions with the walls of the container and atom-atom collisions, and describe the transition from homogeneously broadened to inhomogeneously broadened phenomenology.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Near-resonant light transmission in two-dimensional dense cold atomic media with short-range positional correlations

Boxiang Wang, Chang Zhao

Light–matter interaction in cold atomic ensembles is one of the central topics in modern quantum and atomic optics with important applications in various quantum technologies. The collective response of dense atomic gases under light excitation depends crucially on the spatial distribution of atoms and the geometry of the ensemble. We analyze near-resonant light transmission in two-dimensional dense ultracold atomic ensembles with short-range positional correlations. Based on coupled-dipole simulations, we show that the collective effects, manifested as notable shifts of transmission resonance frequency and considerable modification of optical depths, are influenced strongly by positional correlations. Mean-field theories such as the Lorentz–Lorenz relation are not capable of describing such collective effects. We also investigate the statistical distribution of eigenstates and provide a connection between the transmission spectra and eigenstate distribution by utilizing the population weighted detuning and decay rate of all eigenstates. We further demonstrate the intricate interplay between dipole–dipole interactions and positional correlations by increasing the number densities of atoms.

arXiv:1911.11583•Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Apr 28, 2020•12 citations
We study light propagation through a slab of cold gas using both the standard electrodynamics of polarizable media and massive atom-by-atom simulations of the electrodynamics. The main finding is that the predictions from the two methods may differ qualitatively when the density of the atomic sample \ensuremathρ\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremathρ and the wave number of resonant light kkk satisfy \ensuremathρk\ensuremath−3\ensuremath≳1\ensuremath{\rho}{k}^{\ensuremath{-}3}\ensuremath{\gtrsim}1\ensuremathρk\ensuremath−3\ensuremath≳1. The reason is that the standard electrodynamics is a mean-field theory, whereas for sufficiently strong light-mediated dipole-dipole interactions the atomic sample becomes strongly correlated. The deviations from mean-field theory appear to scale with the parameter \ensuremathρk\ensuremath−3\ensuremath{\rho}{k}^{\ensuremath{-}3}\ensuremathρk\ensuremath−3, and we demonstrate noticeable effects already at \ensuremathρk\ensuremath−3\ensuremath≃10\ensuremath−2\ensuremath{\rho}{k}^{\ensuremath{-}3}\ensuremath{\simeq}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}2}\ensuremathρk\ensuremath−3\ensuremath≃10\ensuremath−2. In dilute gases and in gases with an added inhomogeneous broadening the simulations show shifts of the resonance lines in qualitative agreement with the predicted Lorentz-Lorenz shift and ``cooperative Lamb shift,'' but the quantitative agreement is unsatisfactory. Our interpretation is that the microscopic basis for the local-field corrections in electrodynamics is not fully understood.
With ready access to massive computer clusters we may now study light propagation in a dense cold atomic gas by means of basically exact numerical simulations. We report on a direct comparison between traditional optics, that is, electrodynamics of a polarizable medium, and numerical simulations in an elementary problem of light propagating through a slab of matter. The standard optics fails already at quite low atom densities, and the failure becomes dramatic when the average interatomic separation is reduced to around k(-1), where k is the wave number of resonant light. The difference between the two solutions originates from correlations between the atoms induced by light-mediated dipole-dipole interactions.
We measure the coherent scattering of light by a cloud of laser-cooled atoms with a size comparable to the wavelength of light. By interfering a laser beam tuned near an atomic resonance with the field scattered by the atoms, we observe a resonance with a redshift, a broadening, and a saturation of the extinction for increasing atom numbers. We attribute these features to enhanced light-induced dipole-dipole interactions in a cold, dense atomic ensemble that result in a failure of standard predictions such as the "cooperative Lamb shift". The description of the atomic cloud by a mean-field model based on the Lorentz-Lorenz formula that ignores scattering events where light is scattered recurrently by the same atom and by a microscopic discrete dipole model that incorporates these effects lead to progressively closer agreement with the observations, despite remaining differences.
We study propagation of low-intensity light in a medium within a one-dimensional (1D) model electrodynamics. It is shown that the coupled theory for light and matter fields may be solved, in principle exactly, by means of stochastic simulations that account for both collective linewidths and line shifts, and for quantum statistical position correlations of the atoms. Such simulations require that one synthesize atomic positions that have correlation functions appropriate for the given type of atomic sample. We demonstrate how one may simulate both a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) and a zero-temperature noninteracting Fermi-Dirac gas. Results of simulations of light propagation in such quantum degenerate gases are compared with analytical density expansions obtained by adapting the approach of Morice, Castin, and Dalibard [Phys. Rev. A 51, 3896 (1995)] to the 1D electrodynamics. A BEC exhibits an optical resonance that narrows and stays somewhat below the atomic resonance frequency as collective effects set in with increasing atom density. The first two terms in the analytical density expansion are in excellent agreement with numerical results for a condensate. While fermions display a similar narrowing and shift of the resonance with increasing density, already in the limit of very dilute gas the linewidth is only half of the resonance linewidth of an isolated atom. We attribute this to the regular spacing between the atoms, which is enforced by the Pauli exclusion principle. The analytical density expansion successfully predicts the narrowing, and also gives the next term in the density expansion of the optical response in semiquantitative agreement with numerical simulations.
At high density, dipole-dipole interactions between the atoms may have a major impact on light propagation in a dense gas. We have developed a classical-electrodynamics simulation to study the cooperative response of a near-resonant gas to light. We take into account the motion of the radiators using classical trajectories, including collisions with the walls of the container and atom-atom collisions, and describe the transition from homogeneously broadened to inhomogeneously broadened phenomenology.
Light–matter interaction in cold atomic ensembles is one of the central topics in modern quantum and atomic optics with important applications in various quantum technologies. The collective response of dense atomic gases under light excitation depends crucially on the spatial distribution of atoms and the geometry of the ensemble. We analyze near-resonant light transmission in two-dimensional dense ultracold atomic ensembles with short-range positional correlations. Based on coupled-dipole simulations, we show that the collective effects, manifested as notable shifts of transmission resonance frequency and considerable modification of optical depths, are influenced strongly by positional correlations. Mean-field theories such as the Lorentz–Lorenz relation are not capable of describing such collective effects. We also investigate the statistical distribution of eigenstates and provide a connection between the transmission spectra and eigenstate distribution by utilizing the population weighted detuning and decay rate of all eigenstates. We further demonstrate the intricate interplay between dipole–dipole interactions and positional correlations by increasing the number densities of atoms.