Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1703.07768

Quantum Communication-Query Tradeoffs

William M. Hoza

Published Mar 22, 2017• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For any function $f: X \times Y \to Z$, we prove that $Q^{*\text{cc}}(f) \cdot Q^{\text{OIP}}(f) \cdot (\log Q^{\text{OIP}}(f) + \log |Z|) \geq Ω(\log |X|)$. Here, $Q^{*\text{cc}}(f)$ denotes the bounded-error communication complexity of $f$ using an entanglement-assisted two-way qubit channel, and $Q^{\text{OIP}}(f)$ denotes the number of quantum queries needed to learn $x$ with high probability given oracle access to the function $f_x(y) \stackrel{\text{def}}{=} f(x, y)$. We show that this tradeoff is close to the best possible. We also give a generalization of this tradeoff for distributional query complexity. As an application, we prove an optimal $Ω(\log q)$ lower bound on the $Q^{*\text{cc}}$ complexity of determining whether $x + y$ is a perfect square, where Alice holds $x \in \mathbf{F}_q$, Bob holds $y \in \mathbf{F}_q$, and $\mathbf{F}_q$ is a finite field of odd characteristic. As another application, we give a new, simpler proof that searching an ordered size-$N$ database requires $Ω(\log N / \log \log N)$ quantum queries. (It was already known that $Θ(\log N)$ queries are required.)

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1703.07768

Related papers

Symmetry and Quantum Query-To-Communication Simulation

Sourav Chakraborty, Arkadev Chattopadhyay, Peter Høyer +3 more

Buhrman, Cleve and Wigderson (STOC'98) showed that for every Boolean function f : {-1,1}ⁿ → {-1,1} and G ∈ {AND₂, XOR₂}, the bounded-error quantum communication complexity of the composed function f∘G equals O(𝖰(f) log n), where 𝖰(f) denotes the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f. This is achieved by Alice running the optimal quantum query algorithm for f, using a round of O(log n) qubits of communication to implement each query. This is in contrast with the classical setting, where it is easy to show that 𝖱^{cc}(f∘G) ≤ 2𝖱(f), where 𝖱^{cc} and 𝖱 denote bounded-error communication and query complexity, respectively. Chakraborty et al. (CCC'20) exhibited a total function for which the log n overhead in the BCW simulation is required. This established the somewhat surprising fact that quantum reductions are in some cases inherently more expensive than classical reductions. We improve upon their result in several ways. - We show that the log n overhead is not required when f is symmetric (i.e., depends only on the Hamming weight of its input), generalizing a result of Aaronson and Ambainis for the Set-Disjointness function (Theory of Computing'05). Our upper bound assumes a shared entangled state, though for most symmetric functions the assumed number of entangled qubits is less than the communication and hence could be part of the communication. - In order to prove the above, we design an efficient distributed version of noisy amplitude amplification that allows us to prove the result when f is the OR function. This also provides a different, and arguably simpler, proof of Aaronson and Ambainis’s O(√n) communication upper bound for Set-Disjointness. - In view of our first result above, one may ask whether the log n overhead in the BCW simulation can be avoided even when f is transitive, which is a weaker notion of symmetry. We give a strong negative answer by showing that the log n overhead is still necessary for some transitive functions even when we allow the quantum communication protocol an error probability that can be arbitrarily close to 1/2 (this corresponds to the unbounded-error model of communication). - We also give, among other things, a general recipe to construct functions for which the log n overhead is required in the BCW simulation in the bounded-error communication model, even if the parties are allowed to share an arbitrary prior entangled state for free.

Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Jan 1, 2022•3 citations

The Role of Symmetry in Quantum Query-to-Communication Simulation

Sourav Chakraborty, Arkadev Chattopadhyay, Peter Høyer +3 more

Buhrman, Cleve and Wigderson (STOC'98) showed that for every Boolean function f : {-1,1}^n to {-1,1} and G in {AND_2, XOR_2}, the bounded-error quantum communication complexity of the composed function f o G equals O(Q(f) log n), where Q(f) denotes the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f. This is achieved by Alice running the optimal quantum query algorithm for f, using a round of O(log n) qubits of communication to implement each query. This is in contrast with the classical setting, where it is easy to show that R^{cc}(f o G) is at most 2R(f), where R^{cc} and R denote bounded-error communication and query complexity, respectively. We show that the O(log n) overhead is required for some functions in the quantum setting, and thus the BCW simulation is tight. We note here that prior to our work, the possibility of Q^{cc}(f o G) = O(Q(f)), for all f and all G in {AND_2, XOR_2}, had not been ruled out. More specifically, we show the following. - We show that the log n overhead is *not* required when f is symmetric, generalizing a result of Aaronson and Ambainis for the Set-Disjointness function (Theory of Computing'05). - In order to prove the above, we design an efficient distributed version of noisy amplitude amplification that allows us to prove the result when f is the OR function. - In view of our first result above, one may ask whether the log n overhead in the BCW simulation can be avoided even when f is transitive, which is a weaker notion of symmetry. We give a strong negative answer by showing that the log n overhead is still necessary for some transitive functions even when we allow the quantum communication protocol an error probability that can be arbitrarily close to 1/2. - We also give, among other things, a general recipe to construct functions for which the log n overhead is required in the BCW simulation in the bounded-error communication model.

arXiv:2012.05233•Dec 9, 2020•5 citations

Quantum Query-To-Communication Simulation Needs a Logarithmic Overhead

Sourav Chakraborty, Arkadev Chattopadhyay, Nikhil S. Mande +1 more

Buhrman, Cleve and Wigderson (STOC'98) observed that for every Boolean function f:{-1,1}ⁿ → {-1,1} and •:{-1,1}² → {-1,1} the two-party bounded-error quantum communication complexity of (f ∘ •) is O(Q(f) log n), where Q(f) is the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f. Note that the bounded-error randomized communication complexity of (f ∘ •) is bounded by O(R(f)), where R(f) denotes the bounded-error randomized query complexity of f. Thus, the BCW simulation has an extra O(log n) factor appearing that is absent in classical simulation. A natural question is if this factor can be avoided. Razborov (IZV MATH'03) showed that the bounded-error quantum communication complexity of Set-Disjointness is Ω(√n). The BCW simulation yields an upper bound of O(√n log n). Høyer and de Wolf (STACS'02) showed that this can be reduced to c^(log^* n) for some constant c, and subsequently Aaronson and Ambainis (FOCS'03) showed that this factor can be made a constant. That is, the quantum communication complexity of the Set-Disjointness function (which is NOR_n ∘ ∧) is O(Q(NOR_n)). Perhaps somewhat surprisingly, we show that when • = ⊕, then the extra log n factor in the BCW simulation is unavoidable. In other words, we exhibit a total function F:{-1,1}ⁿ → {-1,1} such that Q^{cc}(F ∘ ⊕) = Θ(Q(F) log n). To the best of our knowledge, it was not even known prior to this work whether there existed a total function F and 2-bit function •, such that Q^{cc}(F ∘ •) = ω(Q(F)).

arXiv:1909.10428•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Sep 23, 2019•5 citations

Matching upper bounds on symmetric predicates in quantum communication complexity

Daiki Suruga

In this paper, we focus on the quantum communication complexity of functions of the form $f \circ G = f(G(X_1, Y_1), \ldots, G(X_n, Y_n))$ where $f: \Bset^n \to \Bset$ is a symmetric function, $G: \Bset^j \times \Bset^k \to \Bset$ is any function and Alice (resp. Bob) is given $(X_i)_{i \in [n]}$ (resp. $(Y_i)_{i \in [n]}$). Recently, Chakraborty et al. [STACS 2022] showed that the quantum communication complexity of $f \circ G$ is $O(Q(f)\QCCEX(G))$ when the parties are allowed to use shared entanglement, where $Q(f)$ is the query complexity of $f$ and $\QCCEX(G)$ is the exact communication complexity of $G$. }{In this paper, we first show that the same statement holds \emph{without both shared entanglement and shared randomness}, which generalizes their result. Based on the improved result, we next show tight upper bounds on $f \circ \mathrm{AND}_2$ for any symmetric function $f$ (where $\textrm{AND}_2 : \Bset \times \Bset \to \Bset$ denotes the 2-bit AND function) in both models: with shared entanglement and without shared entanglement. This matches the well-known lower bound by Razborov~[Izv. Math. 67(1) 145, 2003] when shared entanglement is allowed and improves Razborov's bound when shared entanglement is not allowed.

arXiv:2301.00370•Quantum Information and Computation•Oct 1, 2024•3 citations

Near-Optimal Bounds on Bounded-Round Quantum Communication Complexity of Disjointness

Mark Braverman, Ankit Garg, Young Kun Ko +2 more

We prove a near optimal round-communication tradeoff for the two-party quantum communication complexity of disjointness. For protocols with r rounds, we prove a lower bound of Omega(n/r) on the communication required for computing disjointness of input size n, which is optimal up to logarithmic factors. The previous best lower bound was Omega(n/r̂2) due to Jain, Radhakrishnan and Sen. Along the way, we develop several tools for quantum information complexity, one of which is a lower bound for quantum information complexity in terms of the generalized discrepancy method. As a corollary, we get that the quantum communication complexity of any boolean function f is at most 2 ̂O(QIC(f)), where QIC(f) is the prior-free quantum information complexity of f (with error 1/3).

arXiv:1505.03110•SIAM Journal on Computing•Oct 1, 2015•33 citations

Noisy Quantum Query Complexity via Fractional Block Sensitivity

Mehil Agarwal, Shravas Rao, Fang Song

We study quantum query complexity under several models of imperfect oracle access, and develop lower bounds through a common framework based on fractional block sensitivity ($\operatorname{fbs}$). For a negligent oracle that applies the correct query with probability $1-p$, we prove a lower bound in terms of $\operatorname{fbs}(f,0^n)$. We also show, perhaps surprisingly, that negligence need not destroy quantum speedups: any function $f$ can be transformed into a partial function $f'$ whose negligent query complexity essentially preserves the quantum query complexity of $f$. This gives partial functions with exponential quantum speedups even under negligent queries, and in particular rules out a general lower bound in terms of $\operatorname{fbs}(f)$ for partial functions in this model. For two other models, we obtain general lower bounds in terms of $\operatorname{fbs}(f)$ for all Boolean functions. For hybrid algorithms using $Q$ coherent and $C$ classical queries, we prove the tradeoff $C+Q^2=Ω(\operatorname{fbs}(f))$. For an IID dephasing noisy model where each query dephases the query-index register at rate $p$ independently, we prove $Ω\!\left(p\,\operatorname{fbs}(f)\right)$ queries are necessary. Finally, we introduce a broader family of time-varying dephasing models and identify a variational resource that is always lower bounded by $\operatorname{fbs}(f)$. Computing this resource reduces to a convex optimization problem, providing a simple way to derive lower bounds for new noise schedules. As applications, we recover the hybrid and IID dephasing bounds and determine the query complexity of unstructured search when the dephasing rate grows over time.

quant-pharXiv:2610.00506•Oct 2, 2026•0 citations
For any function f:X×Y→Zf: X \times Y \to Zf:X×Y→Z, we prove that Q∗cc(f)⋅QOIP(f)⋅(log⁡QOIP(f)+log⁡∣Z∣)≥Ω(log⁡∣X∣)Q^{*\text{cc}}(f) \cdot Q^{\text{OIP}}(f) \cdot (\log Q^{\text{OIP}}(f) + \log |Z|) \geq Ω(\log |X|)Q∗cc(f)⋅QOIP(f)⋅(logQOIP(f)+log∣Z∣)≥Ω(log∣X∣). Here, Q∗cc(f)Q^{*\text{cc}}(f)Q∗cc(f) denotes the bounded-error communication complexity of fff using an entanglement-assisted two-way qubit channel, and QOIP(f)Q^{\text{OIP}}(f)QOIP(f) denotes the number of quantum queries needed to learn xxx with high probability given oracle access to the function fx(y)=deff(x,y)f_x(y) \stackrel{\text{def}}{=} f(x, y)fx​(y)=deff(x,y). We show that this tradeoff is close to the best possible. We also give a generalization of this tradeoff for distributional query complexity. As an application, we prove an optimal Ω(log⁡q)Ω(\log q)Ω(logq) lower bound on the Q∗ccQ^{*\text{cc}}Q∗cc complexity of determining whether x+yx + yx+y is a perfect square, where Alice holds x∈Fqx \in \mathbf{F}_qx∈Fq​, Bob holds y∈Fqy \in \mathbf{F}_qy∈Fq​, and Fq\mathbf{F}_qFq​ is a finite field of odd characteristic. As another application, we give a new, simpler proof that searching an ordered size-NNN database requires Ω(log⁡N/log⁡log⁡N)Ω(\log N / \log \log N)Ω(logN/loglogN) quantum queries. (It was already known that Θ(log⁡N)Θ(\log N)Θ(logN) queries are required.)
Buhrman, Cleve and Wigderson (STOC'98) showed that for every Boolean function f : {-1,1}ⁿ → {-1,1} and G ∈ {AND₂, XOR₂}, the bounded-error quantum communication complexity of the composed function f∘G equals O(𝖰(f) log n), where 𝖰(f) denotes the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f. This is achieved by Alice running the optimal quantum query algorithm for f, using a round of O(log n) qubits of communication to implement each query. This is in contrast with the classical setting, where it is easy to show that 𝖱^{cc}(f∘G) ≤ 2𝖱(f), where 𝖱^{cc} and 𝖱 denote bounded-error communication and query complexity, respectively. Chakraborty et al. (CCC'20) exhibited a total function for which the log n overhead in the BCW simulation is required. This established the somewhat surprising fact that quantum reductions are in some cases inherently more expensive than classical reductions. We improve upon their result in several ways. - We show that the log n overhead is not required when f is symmetric (i.e., depends only on the Hamming weight of its input), generalizing a result of Aaronson and Ambainis for the Set-Disjointness function (Theory of Computing'05). Our upper bound assumes a shared entangled state, though for most symmetric functions the assumed number of entangled qubits is less than the communication and hence could be part of the communication. - In order to prove the above, we design an efficient distributed version of noisy amplitude amplification that allows us to prove the result when f is the OR function. This also provides a different, and arguably simpler, proof of Aaronson and Ambainis’s O(√n) communication upper bound for Set-Disjointness. - In view of our first result above, one may ask whether the log n overhead in the BCW simulation can be avoided even when f is transitive, which is a weaker notion of symmetry. We give a strong negative answer by showing that the log n overhead is still necessary for some transitive functions even when we allow the quantum communication protocol an error probability that can be arbitrarily close to 1/2 (this corresponds to the unbounded-error model of communication). - We also give, among other things, a general recipe to construct functions for which the log n overhead is required in the BCW simulation in the bounded-error communication model, even if the parties are allowed to share an arbitrary prior entangled state for free.
Buhrman, Cleve and Wigderson (STOC'98) showed that for every Boolean function f : {-1,1}^n to {-1,1} and G in {AND_2, XOR_2}, the bounded-error quantum communication complexity of the composed function f o G equals O(Q(f) log n), where Q(f) denotes the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f. This is achieved by Alice running the optimal quantum query algorithm for f, using a round of O(log n) qubits of communication to implement each query. This is in contrast with the classical setting, where it is easy to show that R^{cc}(f o G) is at most 2R(f), where R^{cc} and R denote bounded-error communication and query complexity, respectively. We show that the O(log n) overhead is required for some functions in the quantum setting, and thus the BCW simulation is tight. We note here that prior to our work, the possibility of Q^{cc}(f o G) = O(Q(f)), for all f and all G in {AND_2, XOR_2}, had not been ruled out. More specifically, we show the following. - We show that the log n overhead is *not* required when f is symmetric, generalizing a result of Aaronson and Ambainis for the Set-Disjointness function (Theory of Computing'05). - In order to prove the above, we design an efficient distributed version of noisy amplitude amplification that allows us to prove the result when f is the OR function. - In view of our first result above, one may ask whether the log n overhead in the BCW simulation can be avoided even when f is transitive, which is a weaker notion of symmetry. We give a strong negative answer by showing that the log n overhead is still necessary for some transitive functions even when we allow the quantum communication protocol an error probability that can be arbitrarily close to 1/2. - We also give, among other things, a general recipe to construct functions for which the log n overhead is required in the BCW simulation in the bounded-error communication model.
Buhrman, Cleve and Wigderson (STOC'98) observed that for every Boolean function f:{-1,1}ⁿ → {-1,1} and •:{-1,1}² → {-1,1} the two-party bounded-error quantum communication complexity of (f ∘ •) is O(Q(f) log n), where Q(f) is the bounded-error quantum query complexity of f. Note that the bounded-error randomized communication complexity of (f ∘ •) is bounded by O(R(f)), where R(f) denotes the bounded-error randomized query complexity of f. Thus, the BCW simulation has an extra O(log n) factor appearing that is absent in classical simulation. A natural question is if this factor can be avoided. Razborov (IZV MATH'03) showed that the bounded-error quantum communication complexity of Set-Disjointness is Ω(√n). The BCW simulation yields an upper bound of O(√n log n). Høyer and de Wolf (STACS'02) showed that this can be reduced to c^(log^* n) for some constant c, and subsequently Aaronson and Ambainis (FOCS'03) showed that this factor can be made a constant. That is, the quantum communication complexity of the Set-Disjointness function (which is NOR_n ∘ ∧) is O(Q(NOR_n)). Perhaps somewhat surprisingly, we show that when • = ⊕, then the extra log n factor in the BCW simulation is unavoidable. In other words, we exhibit a total function F:{-1,1}ⁿ → {-1,1} such that Q^{cc}(F ∘ ⊕) = Θ(Q(F) log n). To the best of our knowledge, it was not even known prior to this work whether there existed a total function F and 2-bit function •, such that Q^{cc}(F ∘ •) = ω(Q(F)).
In this paper, we focus on the quantum communication complexity of functions of the form f∘G=f(G(X1,Y1),…,G(Xn,Yn))f \circ G = f(G(X_1, Y_1), \ldots, G(X_n, Y_n))f∘G=f(G(X1​,Y1​),…,G(Xn​,Yn​)) where $f: \Bset^n \to \Bset$ is a symmetric function, $G: \Bset^j \times \Bset^k \to \Bset$ is any function and Alice (resp. Bob) is given (Xi)i∈[n](X_i)_{i \in [n]}(Xi​)i∈[n]​ (resp. (Yi)i∈[n](Y_i)_{i \in [n]}(Yi​)i∈[n]​). Recently, Chakraborty et al. [STACS 2022] showed that the quantum communication complexity of f∘Gf \circ Gf∘G is $O(Q(f)\QCCEX(G))$ when the parties are allowed to use shared entanglement, where Q(f)Q(f)Q(f) is the query complexity of fff and $\QCCEX(G)$ is the exact communication complexity of GGG. }{In this paper, we first show that the same statement holds \emph{without both shared entanglement and shared randomness}, which generalizes their result. Based on the improved result, we next show tight upper bounds on f∘AND2f \circ \mathrm{AND}_2f∘AND2​ for any symmetric function fff (where $\textrm{AND}_2 : \Bset \times \Bset \to \Bset$ denotes the 2-bit AND function) in both models: with shared entanglement and without shared entanglement. This matches the well-known lower bound by Razborov~[Izv. Math. 67(1) 145, 2003] when shared entanglement is allowed and improves Razborov's bound when shared entanglement is not allowed.
We prove a near optimal round-communication tradeoff for the two-party quantum communication complexity of disjointness. For protocols with r rounds, we prove a lower bound of Omega(n/r) on the communication required for computing disjointness of input size n, which is optimal up to logarithmic factors. The previous best lower bound was Omega(n/r̂2) due to Jain, Radhakrishnan and Sen. Along the way, we develop several tools for quantum information complexity, one of which is a lower bound for quantum information complexity in terms of the generalized discrepancy method. As a corollary, we get that the quantum communication complexity of any boolean function f is at most 2 ̂O(QIC(f)), where QIC(f) is the prior-free quantum information complexity of f (with error 1/3).
We study quantum query complexity under several models of imperfect oracle access, and develop lower bounds through a common framework based on fractional block sensitivity (fbs⁡\operatorname{fbs}fbs). For a negligent oracle that applies the correct query with probability 1−p1-p1−p, we prove a lower bound in terms of fbs⁡(f,0n)\operatorname{fbs}(f,0^n)fbs(f,0n). We also show, perhaps surprisingly, that negligence need not destroy quantum speedups: any function fff can be transformed into a partial function f′f'f′ whose negligent query complexity essentially preserves the quantum query complexity of fff. This gives partial functions with exponential quantum speedups even under negligent queries, and in particular rules out a general lower bound in terms of fbs⁡(f)\operatorname{fbs}(f)fbs(f) for partial functions in this model. For two other models, we obtain general lower bounds in terms of fbs⁡(f)\operatorname{fbs}(f)fbs(f) for all Boolean functions. For hybrid algorithms using QQQ coherent and CCC classical queries, we prove the tradeoff C+Q2=Ω(fbs⁡(f))C+Q^2=Ω(\operatorname{fbs}(f))C+Q2=Ω(fbs(f)). For an IID dephasing noisy model where each query dephases the query-index register at rate ppp independently, we prove Ω ⁣(p fbs⁡(f))Ω\!\left(p\,\operatorname{fbs}(f)\right)Ω(pfbs(f)) queries are necessary. Finally, we introduce a broader family of time-varying dephasing models and identify a variational resource that is always lower bounded by fbs⁡(f)\operatorname{fbs}(f)fbs(f). Computing this resource reduces to a convex optimization problem, providing a simple way to derive lower bounds for new noise schedules. As applications, we recover the hybrid and IID dephasing bounds and determine the query complexity of unstructured search when the dephasing rate grows over time.