Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1703.04709 · Nature Communications

Entanglement between more than two hundred macroscopic atomic ensembles in a solid

Parisa Zarkeshian, Chetan Deshmukh, Neil E. Sinclair, Sandeep K. Goyal, G. H. Aguilar, Pascal Lefebvre, Marcel.li Grimau Puigibert, Varun Boehm Verma, Francesco Marsili, Matthew D. Shaw, Sae Woo Nam, Khabat Heshami, Daniel Oblak, Wolfgang Tittel, Christoph Simon

Published Oct 9, 2017• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

There are both fundamental and practical motivations for studying whether quantum entanglement can exist in macroscopic systems. However, multiparty entanglement is generally fragile and difficult to quantify. Dicke states are multiparty entangled states where a single excitation is delocalized over many systems. Building on previous work on quantum memories for photons, we create a Dicke state in a solid by storing a single photon in a crystal that contains many large atomic ensembles with distinct resonance frequencies. The photon is re-emitted at a well-defined time due to an interference effect analogous to multi-slit diffraction. We derive a lower bound for the number of entangled ensembles based on the contrast of the interference and the single-photon character of the input, and we experimentally demonstrate entanglement between over two hundred ensembles, each containing a billion atoms. We also illustrate the fact that each individual ensemble contains further entanglement.Multipartite entanglement is of both fundamental and practical interest, but is notoriously difficult to witness and characterise. Here, Zarkeshian et al. demonstrate multipartite entanglement in an atomic frequency comb storing a single photon in a Dicke state spread over a macroscopic ensemble.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-017-00897-7

Related papers

Experimental certification of millions of genuinely entangled atoms in a solid

Florian Fröwis, Peter C. Strassmann, Alexey Tiranov +6 more

Quantum theory predicts that entanglement can also persist in macroscopic physical systems, albeit difficulties to demonstrate it experimentally remain. Recently, significant progress has been achieved and genuine entanglement between up to 2900 atoms was reported. Here, we demonstrate 16 million genuinely entangled atoms in a solid-state quantum memory prepared by the heralded absorption of a single photon. We develop an entanglement witness for quantifying the number of genuinely entangled particles based on the collective effect of directed emission combined with the non-classical nature of the emitted light. The method is applicable to a wide range of physical systems and is effective even in situations with significant losses. Our results clarify the role of multipartite entanglement in ensemble-based quantum memories and demonstrate the accessibility to certain classes of multipartite entanglement with limited experimental control.The presence of entanglement in macroscopic systems is notoriously difficult to observe. Here, the authors develop a witness which allow them to demonstrate entanglement between millions of atoms in a solid-state quantum memory prepared by the heralded absorption of a single photon.

arXiv:1703.04704•Nature Communications•Oct 9, 2017•39 citations

Demonstration of Light-Matter Micro-Macro Quantum Correlations

Alexey Tiranov, Jonathan Lavoie, Peter C. Strassmann +4 more

Quantum mechanics predicts microscopic phenomena with undeniable success. Nevertheless, current theoretical and experimental efforts still do not yield conclusive evidence that there is or is not a fundamental limitation on the possibility to observe quantum phenomena at the macroscopic scale. This question prompted several experimental efforts producing quantum superpositions of large quantum states in light or matter. We report on the observation of quantum correlations, revealed using an entanglement witness, between a single photon and an atomic ensemble of billions of ions frozen in a crystal. The matter part of the state involves the superposition of two macroscopically distinguishable solid-state components composed of several tens of atomic excitations. Assuming the insignificance of the time ordering our experiment indirectly shows light-matter micro-macro entanglement. Our approach leverages from quantum memory techniques and could be used in other systems to expand the size of quantum superpositions in matter.

arXiv:1510.02665•Physical Review Letters•May 11, 2016•13 citations

Solid-state optical quantum memory: from large entanglement to telecom wavelengths

Peter C. Strassmann

Quantum mechanics is leading to many modern technologies, e.g. based on laser physics. Emerging fields are for example nonlinear optics, hybrid systems, or quantum communication. Despite these applications, there are still limitations of our understanding of quantum mechanics. Even though it is broadly accepted that decoherence limits the size of entangled states, we currently do not know how to overcome these limitations. How large can commonly entangled states be? Can we observe macroscopic quantum phenomena with coarse-grained detectors or even with our bare eyes? This thesis contributes towards answering these fundamental questions and to technological advances. The experiments are based on a light-matter platform of quantum optical states and atomic ensembles. The ensembles consist of rare-earth ion-doped crystals. Additionally, the atomic frequency comb protocol turns the ensemble into a quantum memory. In the scope of quantum communication we work on a quantum repeater. First, we investigate fundamental quantum mechanical states and their validity at macroscopic scales. We show that the detection of a collectively emitted excitation can be used to measure the size of the entangled ensemble. The entangled ensemble shared this excitation in a coherent superposition. This superposition of an atomic excitation in an ensemble is called W-state. We certify a new lower bound to the possible size of an entangled W-state between at least 16 million atoms. The proof of entanglement of this size relies on two measures: one determines the number of atoms involved in the storage process. The other one determines the state "quantumness" by examining the re-emitted light. Another experiment studies a macroscopically distinguishable superposition state. The superposition survives the storage in an atomic ensemble. Second, we perform two more experiments that contribute to a quantum repeater. One experiment probes the quantum states simultaneously stored in a multi-mode quantum memory. In this work we also develop the concept of indirect entanglement witness. For the other experiment, a frequency down-conversion platform is set up. The conversion overcomes the wavelength compatibility issue between some quantum memories and the telecommunication C-band. The narrow spectral filtering of the conversion performs better than expected. In summary, our work analyzes large entangled states and building blocks for a quantum repeater. The presented quantum memories are capable of temporal multi-mode storage. Its temporally precise re-emission is due to the re-phasing of the atoms of the W-state. We also show a good way to set up frequency down-conversion for the sake of quantum repeaters. This work emphasizes the atomic frequency comb protocol as a viable and reliable platform for quantum repeaters.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Multiphoton Entanglement by Delocalized Single Photon Addition

Nicola Biagi, Luca S. Costanzo, Marco Bellini +1 more

We report about the generation of entangled states obtained by applying delocalized single-photon addition between two uncorrelated light modes populated by coherent states. Such entangled states can contain an arbitrary large number of photons while preserving their non-classical correlations. Besides their importance to study quantum effects in large-scale systems, these states are found to be surprisingly robust against losses and thus well suited to travel over long distances and to be stored in atomic ensembles.

International Conference on Transparent Optical Networks•Jul 1, 2019•1 citation

Coherent Control of Entanglement with Atomic Ensembles

Kyung Soo Choi

Quantum networks are composed of quantum nodes which coherently interact by way of quantum channels. They offer powerful capabilities for quantum computation, communication, and metrology. A generic requirement for these realizations is the capability to generate and store quantum states among multiple quantum nodes, and to disseminate these resources throughout the network via the quantum channels. In this thesis, I describe a series of experiments whereby single excitations in atomic ensembles are strongly coupled to optical modes and provide efficient means for the coherent control of entangled states between matter and light. By following the seminal proposal by Duan et al., we have generated measurement-induced entanglement of an excitation between two cold atomic ensembles. Using this system, we investigated the relationship for the global bipartite entanglement and local correlations in its subsystems. In addition, we achieved functional quantum nodes for entanglement distribution. Two pairs of remote ensembles at two quantum nodes were prepared into entangled states in a heralded and asynchronous fashion by the conditional controls of the entanglement. The quantum states of the ensembles were then distributed into polarization entangled states of photons. We also prepared an analogous quantum state and transferred the nonlocal coherence between two pairs of heralded entangled atomic ensembles, providing a step towards entanglement connection. Beyond such probabilistic approaches, we demonstrated an experiment where entanglement between two quantum memories is created by the reversible and deterministic mapping of an entangled state of light via dynamic electromagnetically induced transparency. This experiment opens novel prospects of integrating hybrid quantum systems by way of reversible quantum interfaces between light and matter. Then, we extended our work to multipartite quantum systems. We theoretically investigated the characterization of multipartite mode-entangled states by way of quantum uncertainty relations, and introduced theoretical tools to verify the entanglement orders in multipartite systems. In particular, we achieved entanglement for one delocalized photon among multiple optical modes (N > 2). Finally, we have achieved measurement-induced entanglement of spin waves among four quantum memories. The individual atomic components for the entangled W state of the four ensembles were then coherently converted into four propagating entangled beams of light via superradiant emissions. We observed the statistical and dynamic transitions for the multipartite entangled spin waves. Experiments described in this thesis thereby represent significant advances of experimental and theoretical capabilities to generate, store, transfer, and characterize entanglement of matter and light over quantum networks.

•May 27, 2011•4 citations

Multipartite entanglement of billions of motional atoms heralded by single photon

Hang Li, Jian-Peng Dou, Xiao-Ling Pang +6 more

Abstract Quantum theory does not prevent entanglement from being created and observed in macroscopic physical systems, in reality however, the accessible scale of entanglement is still very limited due to decoherence effects. Recently, entanglement has been observed among atoms from thousands to millions levels in extremely low-temperature and well isolated systems. Here, we create multipartite entanglement of billions of motional atoms in a quantum memory at room temperature and certify the genuine entanglement via M-separability witness associated with photon statistics. The information contained in a single photon is found strongly correlated with the excitation shared by the motional atoms, which intrinsically address the large system and therefore stimulate the multipartite entanglement. Remarkably, our heralded and quantum memory built-in entanglement generation allows us to directly observe the dynamic evolution of entanglement depth and further to reveal the effects of decoherence. Our results verify the existence of genuine multipartite entanglement among billions of motional atoms at ambient conditions, significantly extending the boundary of the accessible scale of entanglement.

arXiv:2002.11759•npj Quantum Information•Oct 5, 2021•13 citations
There are both fundamental and practical motivations for studying whether quantum entanglement can exist in macroscopic systems. However, multiparty entanglement is generally fragile and difficult to quantify. Dicke states are multiparty entangled states where a single excitation is delocalized over many systems. Building on previous work on quantum memories for photons, we create a Dicke state in a solid by storing a single photon in a crystal that contains many large atomic ensembles with distinct resonance frequencies. The photon is re-emitted at a well-defined time due to an interference effect analogous to multi-slit diffraction. We derive a lower bound for the number of entangled ensembles based on the contrast of the interference and the single-photon character of the input, and we experimentally demonstrate entanglement between over two hundred ensembles, each containing a billion atoms. We also illustrate the fact that each individual ensemble contains further entanglement.Multipartite entanglement is of both fundamental and practical interest, but is notoriously difficult to witness and characterise. Here, Zarkeshian et al. demonstrate multipartite entanglement in an atomic frequency comb storing a single photon in a Dicke state spread over a macroscopic ensemble.
Quantum theory predicts that entanglement can also persist in macroscopic physical systems, albeit difficulties to demonstrate it experimentally remain. Recently, significant progress has been achieved and genuine entanglement between up to 2900 atoms was reported. Here, we demonstrate 16 million genuinely entangled atoms in a solid-state quantum memory prepared by the heralded absorption of a single photon. We develop an entanglement witness for quantifying the number of genuinely entangled particles based on the collective effect of directed emission combined with the non-classical nature of the emitted light. The method is applicable to a wide range of physical systems and is effective even in situations with significant losses. Our results clarify the role of multipartite entanglement in ensemble-based quantum memories and demonstrate the accessibility to certain classes of multipartite entanglement with limited experimental control.The presence of entanglement in macroscopic systems is notoriously difficult to observe. Here, the authors develop a witness which allow them to demonstrate entanglement between millions of atoms in a solid-state quantum memory prepared by the heralded absorption of a single photon.
Quantum mechanics predicts microscopic phenomena with undeniable success. Nevertheless, current theoretical and experimental efforts still do not yield conclusive evidence that there is or is not a fundamental limitation on the possibility to observe quantum phenomena at the macroscopic scale. This question prompted several experimental efforts producing quantum superpositions of large quantum states in light or matter. We report on the observation of quantum correlations, revealed using an entanglement witness, between a single photon and an atomic ensemble of billions of ions frozen in a crystal. The matter part of the state involves the superposition of two macroscopically distinguishable solid-state components composed of several tens of atomic excitations. Assuming the insignificance of the time ordering our experiment indirectly shows light-matter micro-macro entanglement. Our approach leverages from quantum memory techniques and could be used in other systems to expand the size of quantum superpositions in matter.
Quantum mechanics is leading to many modern technologies, e.g. based on laser physics. Emerging fields are for example nonlinear optics, hybrid systems, or quantum communication. Despite these applications, there are still limitations of our understanding of quantum mechanics. Even though it is broadly accepted that decoherence limits the size of entangled states, we currently do not know how to overcome these limitations. How large can commonly entangled states be? Can we observe macroscopic quantum phenomena with coarse-grained detectors or even with our bare eyes? This thesis contributes towards answering these fundamental questions and to technological advances. The experiments are based on a light-matter platform of quantum optical states and atomic ensembles. The ensembles consist of rare-earth ion-doped crystals. Additionally, the atomic frequency comb protocol turns the ensemble into a quantum memory. In the scope of quantum communication we work on a quantum repeater. First, we investigate fundamental quantum mechanical states and their validity at macroscopic scales. We show that the detection of a collectively emitted excitation can be used to measure the size of the entangled ensemble. The entangled ensemble shared this excitation in a coherent superposition. This superposition of an atomic excitation in an ensemble is called W-state. We certify a new lower bound to the possible size of an entangled W-state between at least 16 million atoms. The proof of entanglement of this size relies on two measures: one determines the number of atoms involved in the storage process. The other one determines the state "quantumness" by examining the re-emitted light. Another experiment studies a macroscopically distinguishable superposition state. The superposition survives the storage in an atomic ensemble. Second, we perform two more experiments that contribute to a quantum repeater. One experiment probes the quantum states simultaneously stored in a multi-mode quantum memory. In this work we also develop the concept of indirect entanglement witness. For the other experiment, a frequency down-conversion platform is set up. The conversion overcomes the wavelength compatibility issue between some quantum memories and the telecommunication C-band. The narrow spectral filtering of the conversion performs better than expected. In summary, our work analyzes large entangled states and building blocks for a quantum repeater. The presented quantum memories are capable of temporal multi-mode storage. Its temporally precise re-emission is due to the re-phasing of the atoms of the W-state. We also show a good way to set up frequency down-conversion for the sake of quantum repeaters. This work emphasizes the atomic frequency comb protocol as a viable and reliable platform for quantum repeaters.
We report about the generation of entangled states obtained by applying delocalized single-photon addition between two uncorrelated light modes populated by coherent states. Such entangled states can contain an arbitrary large number of photons while preserving their non-classical correlations. Besides their importance to study quantum effects in large-scale systems, these states are found to be surprisingly robust against losses and thus well suited to travel over long distances and to be stored in atomic ensembles.
Quantum networks are composed of quantum nodes which coherently interact by way of quantum channels. They offer powerful capabilities for quantum computation, communication, and metrology. A generic requirement for these realizations is the capability to generate and store quantum states among multiple quantum nodes, and to disseminate these resources throughout the network via the quantum channels. In this thesis, I describe a series of experiments whereby single excitations in atomic ensembles are strongly coupled to optical modes and provide efficient means for the coherent control of entangled states between matter and light. By following the seminal proposal by Duan et al., we have generated measurement-induced entanglement of an excitation between two cold atomic ensembles. Using this system, we investigated the relationship for the global bipartite entanglement and local correlations in its subsystems. In addition, we achieved functional quantum nodes for entanglement distribution. Two pairs of remote ensembles at two quantum nodes were prepared into entangled states in a heralded and asynchronous fashion by the conditional controls of the entanglement. The quantum states of the ensembles were then distributed into polarization entangled states of photons. We also prepared an analogous quantum state and transferred the nonlocal coherence between two pairs of heralded entangled atomic ensembles, providing a step towards entanglement connection. Beyond such probabilistic approaches, we demonstrated an experiment where entanglement between two quantum memories is created by the reversible and deterministic mapping of an entangled state of light via dynamic electromagnetically induced transparency. This experiment opens novel prospects of integrating hybrid quantum systems by way of reversible quantum interfaces between light and matter. Then, we extended our work to multipartite quantum systems. We theoretically investigated the characterization of multipartite mode-entangled states by way of quantum uncertainty relations, and introduced theoretical tools to verify the entanglement orders in multipartite systems. In particular, we achieved entanglement for one delocalized photon among multiple optical modes (N > 2). Finally, we have achieved measurement-induced entanglement of spin waves among four quantum memories. The individual atomic components for the entangled W state of the four ensembles were then coherently converted into four propagating entangled beams of light via superradiant emissions. We observed the statistical and dynamic transitions for the multipartite entangled spin waves. Experiments described in this thesis thereby represent significant advances of experimental and theoretical capabilities to generate, store, transfer, and characterize entanglement of matter and light over quantum networks.
Abstract Quantum theory does not prevent entanglement from being created and observed in macroscopic physical systems, in reality however, the accessible scale of entanglement is still very limited due to decoherence effects. Recently, entanglement has been observed among atoms from thousands to millions levels in extremely low-temperature and well isolated systems. Here, we create multipartite entanglement of billions of motional atoms in a quantum memory at room temperature and certify the genuine entanglement via M-separability witness associated with photon statistics. The information contained in a single photon is found strongly correlated with the excitation shared by the motional atoms, which intrinsically address the large system and therefore stimulate the multipartite entanglement. Remarkably, our heralded and quantum memory built-in entanglement generation allows us to directly observe the dynamic evolution of entanglement depth and further to reveal the effects of decoherence. Our results verify the existence of genuine multipartite entanglement among billions of motional atoms at ambient conditions, significantly extending the boundary of the accessible scale of entanglement.