Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1702.04411 · Physical Review A

Extension of the Nakajima-Zwanzig approach to multitime correlation functions of open systems

Anton Ivanov, Heinz‐Peter Breuer

Published Sep 11, 2015• 25 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We extend the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection operator technique to the determination of multitime correlation functions of open quantum systems. The correlation functions are expressed in terms of certain multitime homogeneous and inhomogeneous memory kernels for which suitable equations of motion are derived. We show that under the condition of finite memory times, these equations can be used to determine the memory kernels by employing an exact stochastic unraveling of the full system-environment dynamics. The approach thus allows us to combine exact stochastic methods, feasible for short times, with long-time master equation simulations. The applicability of the method is demonstrated by numerical simulations of two-dimensional spectra for a donor-acceptor model, and by comparison of the results with those obtained from the reduced hierarchy equations of motion. We further show that the formalism is also applicable to the time evolution of a periodically driven two-level system initially in equilibrium with its environment.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.92.032113

Related papers

Nonequilibrium quantum dynamics in the condensed phase via the generalized quantum master equation

Ming-Liang Zhang, Being J. Ka, Eitan Geva

The Nakajima-Zwanzig generalized quantum master equation provides a general, and formally exact, prescription for simulating the reduced dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a quantum bath. In this equation, the memory kernel accounts for the influence of the bath on the system's dynamics, and the inhomogeneous term accounts for initial system-bath correlations. In this paper, we propose a new approach for calculating the memory kernel and inhomogeneous term for arbitrary initial state and system-bath coupling. The memory kernel and inhomogeneous term are obtained by numerically solving a single inhomogeneous Volterra equation of the second kind for each. The new approach can accommodate a very wide range of projection operators, and requires projection-free two-time correlation functions as input. An application to the case of a two-state system with diagonal coupling to an arbitrary bath is described in detail. Finally, the utility and self-consistency of the formalism are demonstrated by an explicit calculation on a spin-boson model.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 28, 2006•90 citations

Projection Operator Techniques

Heinz‐Peter Breuer, Francesco Petruccione

Abstract This chapter is devoted to the foundations and to the basic mathematical structure of the non-Markovian quantum dynamics of open systems. It gives a survey of the Nakajima–Zwanzig projection operator methods with the help of which one derives so-called generalized master equations for the reduced system dynamics. In the non-Markovian regime, these master equations involve a retarded memory kernel, i.e. a time-convolution integral taken over the history of the reduced system. The chapter also describes an alternative method of particular relevance in many applications, which is based on a time-local quantum master equation, and which is known as the time-convolutionless projection operator method. This method serves as a starting point for a systematic expansion in terms of ordered cumulants and forms the basis for a non-Markovian stochastic unravelling of the reduced system dynamics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jan 25, 2007•19 citations

Tomographically reconstructed master equations for any open quantum dynamics

Felix A. Pollock, Kavan Kishore Modi

Memory effects in open quantum dynamics are often incorporated in the equation of motion through a superoperator known as the memory kernel, which encodes how past states affect future dynamics. However, the usual prescription for determining the memory kernel requires information about the underlying system-environment dynamics. Here, by deriving the transfer tensor method from first principles, we show how a memory kernel master equation, for any quantum process, can be entirely expressed in terms of a family of completely positive dynamical maps. These can be reconstructed through quantum process tomography on the system alone, either experimentally or numerically, and the resulting equation of motion is equivalent to a generalised Nakajima-Zwanzig equation. For experimental settings, we give a full prescription for the reconstruction procedure, rendering the memory kernel operational. When simulation of an open system is the goal, we show how our procedure yields a considerable advantage for numerically calculating dynamics, even when the system is arbitrarily periodically (or transiently) driven or initially correlated with its environment. Namely, we show that the long time dynamics can be efficiently obtained from a set of reconstructed maps over a much shorter time.

arXiv:1704.06204•Quantum•Jul 11, 2018•63 citations

Density Operator and Multitime Correlation Functions for Open Systems

Fritz Haake

We describe the dynamics of an open system $\mathcal{S}$ in terms of a nonunitary time evolution operator. The latter is defined to solve the generalized master equation for the density operator of $\mathcal{S}$ as obtained using Zwanzig's projector technique. Multitime correlation functions of observables of $\mathcal{S}$ are expressed in terms of this time evolution operator. Our results generalize well-known fluctuation dissipation (or regression) theorems valid for Markovian motions of open systems. Moreover, they can be used to combine density-operator and Green's-function methods in dealing with open systems. As an example we treat the retarded electron-electron interaction in superconductors.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1971•32 citations

A new approach to calculating the memory kernel of the generalized quantum master equation for an arbitrary system–bath coupling

Qiang Shi, Eitan Geva

The Nakajima–Zwanzig generalized quantum master equation provides a general, and formally exact, prescription for simulating the reduced dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a quantum bath. In this equation, the memory kernel accounts for the influence of the bath on the system’s dynamics. The standard approach is based on using a perturbative treatment of the system–bath coupling for calculating this kernel, and is therefore restricted to systems weakly coupled to the bath. In this paper, we propose a new approach for calculating the memory kernel for an arbitrary system–bath coupling. The memory kernel is obtained by solving a set of two coupled integral equations that relate it to a new type of two-time system-dependent bath correlation functions. The feasibility of the method is demonstrated in the case of an asymetrical two-level system linearly coupled to a harmonic bath.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 4, 2003•167 citations

Projection-Based Memory Kernel Coupling Theory for Quantum Dynamics: A Stable Framework for Non-Markovian Simulations

Wei Liu, Rui-Hao Bi, Yu Su +4 more

We present a projection-based, stability-preserving methodology for computing time correlation functions in open quantum systems governed by generalized quantum master equations with non-Markovian effects. Building upon the memory kernel coupling theory framework, our approach transforms the memory kernel hierarchy into a system of coupled linear differential equations through Mori-Zwanzig projection, followed by spectral projection onto stable eigenmodes to ensure numerical stability. By systematically eliminating unstable modes while preserving the physically relevant dynamics, our method guaranties long-time convergence without introducing artificial damping or ad hoc modifications. The theoretical framework maintains mathematical rigor through orthogonal projection operators and spectral decomposition. Benchmark calculations on the spin-boson model show excellent agreement with exact hierarchical equations of motion results while achieving significant computational efficiency. This approach provides a versatile and reliable framework for simulating non-Markovian dynamics in complex systems.

quant-pharXiv:2602.10629•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 12, 2026•3 citations
We extend the Nakajima-Zwanzig projection operator technique to the determination of multitime correlation functions of open quantum systems. The correlation functions are expressed in terms of certain multitime homogeneous and inhomogeneous memory kernels for which suitable equations of motion are derived. We show that under the condition of finite memory times, these equations can be used to determine the memory kernels by employing an exact stochastic unraveling of the full system-environment dynamics. The approach thus allows us to combine exact stochastic methods, feasible for short times, with long-time master equation simulations. The applicability of the method is demonstrated by numerical simulations of two-dimensional spectra for a donor-acceptor model, and by comparison of the results with those obtained from the reduced hierarchy equations of motion. We further show that the formalism is also applicable to the time evolution of a periodically driven two-level system initially in equilibrium with its environment.
The Nakajima-Zwanzig generalized quantum master equation provides a general, and formally exact, prescription for simulating the reduced dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a quantum bath. In this equation, the memory kernel accounts for the influence of the bath on the system's dynamics, and the inhomogeneous term accounts for initial system-bath correlations. In this paper, we propose a new approach for calculating the memory kernel and inhomogeneous term for arbitrary initial state and system-bath coupling. The memory kernel and inhomogeneous term are obtained by numerically solving a single inhomogeneous Volterra equation of the second kind for each. The new approach can accommodate a very wide range of projection operators, and requires projection-free two-time correlation functions as input. An application to the case of a two-state system with diagonal coupling to an arbitrary bath is described in detail. Finally, the utility and self-consistency of the formalism are demonstrated by an explicit calculation on a spin-boson model.
Abstract This chapter is devoted to the foundations and to the basic mathematical structure of the non-Markovian quantum dynamics of open systems. It gives a survey of the Nakajima–Zwanzig projection operator methods with the help of which one derives so-called generalized master equations for the reduced system dynamics. In the non-Markovian regime, these master equations involve a retarded memory kernel, i.e. a time-convolution integral taken over the history of the reduced system. The chapter also describes an alternative method of particular relevance in many applications, which is based on a time-local quantum master equation, and which is known as the time-convolutionless projection operator method. This method serves as a starting point for a systematic expansion in terms of ordered cumulants and forms the basis for a non-Markovian stochastic unravelling of the reduced system dynamics.
Memory effects in open quantum dynamics are often incorporated in the equation of motion through a superoperator known as the memory kernel, which encodes how past states affect future dynamics. However, the usual prescription for determining the memory kernel requires information about the underlying system-environment dynamics. Here, by deriving the transfer tensor method from first principles, we show how a memory kernel master equation, for any quantum process, can be entirely expressed in terms of a family of completely positive dynamical maps. These can be reconstructed through quantum process tomography on the system alone, either experimentally or numerically, and the resulting equation of motion is equivalent to a generalised Nakajima-Zwanzig equation. For experimental settings, we give a full prescription for the reconstruction procedure, rendering the memory kernel operational. When simulation of an open system is the goal, we show how our procedure yields a considerable advantage for numerically calculating dynamics, even when the system is arbitrarily periodically (or transiently) driven or initially correlated with its environment. Namely, we show that the long time dynamics can be efficiently obtained from a set of reconstructed maps over a much shorter time.
We describe the dynamics of an open system S\mathcal{S}S in terms of a nonunitary time evolution operator. The latter is defined to solve the generalized master equation for the density operator of S\mathcal{S}S as obtained using Zwanzig's projector technique. Multitime correlation functions of observables of S\mathcal{S}S are expressed in terms of this time evolution operator. Our results generalize well-known fluctuation dissipation (or regression) theorems valid for Markovian motions of open systems. Moreover, they can be used to combine density-operator and Green's-function methods in dealing with open systems. As an example we treat the retarded electron-electron interaction in superconductors.
The Nakajima–Zwanzig generalized quantum master equation provides a general, and formally exact, prescription for simulating the reduced dynamics of a quantum system coupled to a quantum bath. In this equation, the memory kernel accounts for the influence of the bath on the system’s dynamics. The standard approach is based on using a perturbative treatment of the system–bath coupling for calculating this kernel, and is therefore restricted to systems weakly coupled to the bath. In this paper, we propose a new approach for calculating the memory kernel for an arbitrary system–bath coupling. The memory kernel is obtained by solving a set of two coupled integral equations that relate it to a new type of two-time system-dependent bath correlation functions. The feasibility of the method is demonstrated in the case of an asymetrical two-level system linearly coupled to a harmonic bath.
We present a projection-based, stability-preserving methodology for computing time correlation functions in open quantum systems governed by generalized quantum master equations with non-Markovian effects. Building upon the memory kernel coupling theory framework, our approach transforms the memory kernel hierarchy into a system of coupled linear differential equations through Mori-Zwanzig projection, followed by spectral projection onto stable eigenmodes to ensure numerical stability. By systematically eliminating unstable modes while preserving the physically relevant dynamics, our method guaranties long-time convergence without introducing artificial damping or ad hoc modifications. The theoretical framework maintains mathematical rigor through orthogonal projection operators and spectral decomposition. Benchmark calculations on the spin-boson model show excellent agreement with exact hierarchical equations of motion results while achieving significant computational efficiency. This approach provides a versatile and reliable framework for simulating non-Markovian dynamics in complex systems.