Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1702.00347

Optimal weak value measurements: Pure states

N. D. Hari Dass, R. Rajath Krishna, Sai Smruti Samantaray

Published Feb 1, 2017• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We apply the notion of \emph{optimality} of measurements for state determination(tomography) as originally given by Wootters and Fields to \emph{weak value tomography} of \emph{pure states}. They defined measurements to be optimal if they 'minimised' the effects of statistical errors. For technical reasons they actually maximised the state averaged information, precisely quantified as the negative logarithm of 'error volume'. In this paper we optimise both the state averaged information as well as error volumes. We prove, for Hilbert spaces of arbitrary (finite) dimensionality, that varieties of weak value measurements are optimal when the post-selected bases are \emph{mutually unbiased} with respect to the eigenvectors of the observable being measured. We prove a number of important results about the geometry of state spaces when expressed through the weak values as coordinates. We derive an expression for the Kaëhler potential for the N-dimensional case with the help of which we give an exact treatment of the arbitrary-spin case.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1702.00347

Related papers

Optimal weak measurements: Mixed States

N. D. Hari Dass, R. Rajath Krishna

In an earlier publication we had given an exhaustive analysis of the criteria for weak value measurements of pure states to be optimal in the sense considered by Wootters and Fields. We had proved, for arbitrary spin cases, that the measurements are optimal when the post-selected state is mutually unbiased wrt the eigenstates of the observable being measured.Here we extend the discussion to mixed states. For these, weak value measurements have several problems which we illustrate with the protocol proposed by Shengjun Wu. We discuss tomography of mixed states based on weak measurements and show that while the principal results of Wootters and Fields hold, namely, the set of observables needed for complete tomography are such that their eigenstates form a mutually unbiased bases, weak tomography removes a serious lacuna from the Wootters and Fields analysis i.e the need to consider only state averaged error volumes or information. We also consider another proposal for weak tomography of mixed states by Lundeen and Bamber, and reach similar conclusions about MUB.

arXiv:1804.10792•Apr 28, 2018•0 citations

Three Results on Weak Measurements

N. D. Hari Dass

Three recent results on weak measurements are presented. They are: i) repeated measurements on a single copy can not provide any information on it and further, that in the limit of very large such measurements, weak measurements have exactly the same characterstics as strong measurements, ii) the apparent non-invasiveness of weak measurements is \emph{illusory} and they are no more advantageous than strong measurements even in the specific context of establishing Leggett-Garg inequalities, when errors are properly taken into account, and, finally, iii) weak value measurements are optimal, in the precise sense of Wootters and Fields, when the post-selected states are mutually unbiased with respect to the eigenstates of the observable whose weak values are being measured. Notion of weak value coordinates for state spaces are introduced and elaborated.

arXiv:1509.04869•Current Science•Dec 1, 2015•5 citations

Optimal Pure-State Qubit Tomography via Sequential Weak Measurements

Ezad Shojaee, Christopher S. Jackson, Carlos A. Riofrío +2 more

The spin-coherent-state positive-operator-valued-measure (POVM) is a fundamental measurement in quantum science, with applications including tomography, metrology, teleportation, benchmarking, and measurement of Husimi phase space probabilities. We prove that this POVM is achieved by collectively measuring the spin projection of an ensemble of qubits weakly and isotropically. We apply this in the context of optimal tomography of pure qubits. We show numerically that through a sequence of weak measurements of random directions of the collective spin component, sampled discretely or in a continuous measurement with random controls, one can approach the optimal bound.

arXiv:1805.01012•Physical Review Letters•Sep 26, 2018•25 citations

Quantum state tomography as a numerical optimization problem

Violeta N. Ivanova-Rohling, Guido Burkard, Niklas Rohling

Abstract We present a framework that formulates the quest for the most efficient quantum state tomography (QST) measurement set as an optimization problem which can be solved numerically, where the optimization goal is the maximization of the information gain. This approach can be applied to a broad spectrum of relevant setups including measurements restricted to a subsystem. To illustrate the power of this method we present results for the six-dimensional Hilbert space constituted by a qubit–qutrit system, which could be realized e.g. by the 14N nuclear spin-1 and two electronic spin states of a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Measurements of the qubit subsystem are expressed by projectors of rank three, i.e. projectors on half-dimensional subspaces. For systems consisting only of qubits, it was shown analytically that a set of projectors on half-dimensional subspaces can be arranged in an informationally optimal fashion for QST, thus forming so-called mutually unbiased subspaces. Our method goes beyond qubits-only systems and we find that in dimension six such a set of mutually-unbiased subspaces can be approximated with a deviation irrelevant for practical applications.

arXiv:2012.14494•New Journal of Physics•Nov 23, 2021•1 citation

Optimal quantum tomography of permutationally invariant qubits

A. B. Klimov, Gunnar G. Bjork, Luis Lorenzo Sánchez-Soto

Mutually unbiased bases determine an optimal set of measurements to extract complete information about the quantum state of a system. However, quite often a priori information about the state exists, making some of the measurement bases superfluous. This is, for example, the case when multiqubit states belong to the permutationally invariant subspace. In this paper we derive the minimal sets of mutually unbiased bases needed to tomographically reconstruct such states.

arXiv:1301.2123•Physical Review A•Jan 10, 2013•27 citations

Learning pure quantum states almost without regret

Josep Lumbreras, Mikhail V. Terekhov, Marco Tomamichel

We initiate the study of sample-optimal quantum state tomography with minimal disturbance to the samples. Can we efficiently learn a precise description of a quantum state through sequential measurements of samples while at the same time ensuring that the post-measurement states are only minimally perturbed? We quantify the accumulated cost of the protocol over T samples by an additive regret objective, which controls the cumulative expected post-measurement infidelity of the consumed copies. The challenge is to balance informative measurements with measurements that keep this accumulated cost small. Here, we answer this question for all pure states by exhibiting an adaptive protocol whose expected regret is \(O({d}^{3}{\log }^{2}T)\) , while the infidelity of the online estimate after t samples scales as \(\widetilde{O}(1/t)\) . We also prove a logarithmic lower bound, showing that for fixed dimension, the dependence on the number of samples is optimal up to one logarithmic factor.

arXiv:2406.18370•npj Quantum Information•Jun 26, 2026•14 citations
We apply the notion of \emph{optimality} of measurements for state determination(tomography) as originally given by Wootters and Fields to \emph{weak value tomography} of \emph{pure states}. They defined measurements to be optimal if they 'minimised' the effects of statistical errors. For technical reasons they actually maximised the state averaged information, precisely quantified as the negative logarithm of 'error volume'. In this paper we optimise both the state averaged information as well as error volumes. We prove, for Hilbert spaces of arbitrary (finite) dimensionality, that varieties of weak value measurements are optimal when the post-selected bases are \emph{mutually unbiased} with respect to the eigenvectors of the observable being measured. We prove a number of important results about the geometry of state spaces when expressed through the weak values as coordinates. We derive an expression for the Kaëhler potential for the N-dimensional case with the help of which we give an exact treatment of the arbitrary-spin case.
In an earlier publication we had given an exhaustive analysis of the criteria for weak value measurements of pure states to be optimal in the sense considered by Wootters and Fields. We had proved, for arbitrary spin cases, that the measurements are optimal when the post-selected state is mutually unbiased wrt the eigenstates of the observable being measured.Here we extend the discussion to mixed states. For these, weak value measurements have several problems which we illustrate with the protocol proposed by Shengjun Wu. We discuss tomography of mixed states based on weak measurements and show that while the principal results of Wootters and Fields hold, namely, the set of observables needed for complete tomography are such that their eigenstates form a mutually unbiased bases, weak tomography removes a serious lacuna from the Wootters and Fields analysis i.e the need to consider only state averaged error volumes or information. We also consider another proposal for weak tomography of mixed states by Lundeen and Bamber, and reach similar conclusions about MUB.
Three recent results on weak measurements are presented. They are: i) repeated measurements on a single copy can not provide any information on it and further, that in the limit of very large such measurements, weak measurements have exactly the same characterstics as strong measurements, ii) the apparent non-invasiveness of weak measurements is \emph{illusory} and they are no more advantageous than strong measurements even in the specific context of establishing Leggett-Garg inequalities, when errors are properly taken into account, and, finally, iii) weak value measurements are optimal, in the precise sense of Wootters and Fields, when the post-selected states are mutually unbiased with respect to the eigenstates of the observable whose weak values are being measured. Notion of weak value coordinates for state spaces are introduced and elaborated.
The spin-coherent-state positive-operator-valued-measure (POVM) is a fundamental measurement in quantum science, with applications including tomography, metrology, teleportation, benchmarking, and measurement of Husimi phase space probabilities. We prove that this POVM is achieved by collectively measuring the spin projection of an ensemble of qubits weakly and isotropically. We apply this in the context of optimal tomography of pure qubits. We show numerically that through a sequence of weak measurements of random directions of the collective spin component, sampled discretely or in a continuous measurement with random controls, one can approach the optimal bound.
Abstract We present a framework that formulates the quest for the most efficient quantum state tomography (QST) measurement set as an optimization problem which can be solved numerically, where the optimization goal is the maximization of the information gain. This approach can be applied to a broad spectrum of relevant setups including measurements restricted to a subsystem. To illustrate the power of this method we present results for the six-dimensional Hilbert space constituted by a qubit–qutrit system, which could be realized e.g. by the 14N nuclear spin-1 and two electronic spin states of a nitrogen-vacancy center in diamond. Measurements of the qubit subsystem are expressed by projectors of rank three, i.e. projectors on half-dimensional subspaces. For systems consisting only of qubits, it was shown analytically that a set of projectors on half-dimensional subspaces can be arranged in an informationally optimal fashion for QST, thus forming so-called mutually unbiased subspaces. Our method goes beyond qubits-only systems and we find that in dimension six such a set of mutually-unbiased subspaces can be approximated with a deviation irrelevant for practical applications.
We initiate the study of sample-optimal quantum state tomography with minimal disturbance to the samples. Can we efficiently learn a precise description of a quantum state through sequential measurements of samples while at the same time ensuring that the post-measurement states are only minimally perturbed? We quantify the accumulated cost of the protocol over T samples by an additive regret objective, which controls the cumulative expected post-measurement infidelity of the consumed copies. The challenge is to balance informative measurements with measurements that keep this accumulated cost small. Here, we answer this question for all pure states by exhibiting an adaptive protocol whose expected regret is O(d3log⁡2T)O({d}^{3}{\log }^{2}T)O(d3log2T) , while the infidelity of the online estimate after t samples scales as O~(1/t)\widetilde{O}(1/t)O(1/t) . We also prove a logarithmic lower bound, showing that for fixed dimension, the dependence on the number of samples is optimal up to one logarithmic factor.