Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1701.07404 · Entropy

Leaks: Quantum, Classical, Intermediate and More

John H. Selby, Bob Coecke

Published Apr 19, 2017• 26 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We introduce the notion of a leak for general process theories and identify quantum theory as a theory with minimal leakage, while classical theory has maximal leakage. We provide a construction that adjoins leaks to theories, an instance of which describes the emergence of classical theory by adjoining decoherence leaks to quantum theory. Finally, we show that defining a notion of purity for processes in general process theories has to make reference to the leaks of that theory, a feature missing in standard definitions; hence, we propose a refined definition and study the resulting notion of purity for quantum, classical and intermediate theories.

DOI
10.3390/e19040174

Related papers

A process theoretic triptych: two roads to the emergence of classicality, reconstructing quantum theory from diagrams, looking for post-quantum theories

John H. Selby

This thesis asks what can be learnt about quantum theory by investigating it from the perspective of process theories. This is based on the diagrammatic compositional structure of Categorical Quantum Mechanics, leading to a very general framework to describe alternate theories of nature. In particular this framework is well suited to understanding the relationship between different theories. In the first part of the thesis we investigate the relationship between quantum and classical theory, showing how an abstract description of decoherence in terms of leaking information leads to emergent classicality. Moreover, this process theoretic notion of a `leak' allows us to capture the distinction between quantum and classical theory in a particularly simple way, highlighting how the quantum and classical worlds diverge. In the second part we look at how to reconstruct quantum theory from diagrammatic principles showing that i) the existence of a classical interface with the theory plus ii) standard notions of composition and iii) a time symmetric form of purification are sufficient to reconstruct the standard quantum formalism. Thereby demonstrating that the standard tools of Categorical Quantum Mechanics come very close to capturing the essence of quantum theory. In the third part we abstract the key features of this emergence of classicality to define a notion of `hyperdecoherence' whereby some post-quantum theory might appear quantum due to an uncontrolled interaction with an environment. We prove a no-go theorem which states that any operational post-quantum theory must violate the purification principle, and so must radically challenge our understanding of how information behaves. To summarise, we use the framework of process theories to gain a better understanding of quantum theory, its sub-theories, and its potential super-theories.

•Aug 1, 2017•2 citations

The Emergence of Classicality from Quantum Theory

Erich Joos

A thoroughgoing and consistent application of quantum theory shows that the connection between classical and quantum physics is very different from what can be found in standard textbooks. In the last two decades it has been shown that the elements of classical physics emerge through an irreversible quantum process called ‘decoherence’. According to decoherence theories, quantum objects acquire classical properties only through interactions with their natural environment as a consequence of the holistic features of quantum theory. In view of the interpretation problem of quantum theory, only two directions out of the host of proposals suggested in the course of time appear to remain consistent solutions. Whatever solution is preferred, the message of decoherence remains the same: classical notions are not needed as the starting point for physics. Instead, these emerge through the dynamical process of decoherence from the quantum substrate.

Oxford University Press eBooks•May 15, 2008•12 citations

Purity through Factorisation

Oscar Cunningham, Chris Heunen

We give a construction that identifies the collection of pure processes (i.e. those which are deterministic, or without randomness) within a theory containing both pure and mixed processes. Working in the framework of symmetric monoidal categories, we define a pure subcategory. This definition arises elegantly from the categorical notion of a weak factorisation system. Our construction gives the expected result in several examples, both quantum and classical.

arXiv:1705.07652•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Feb 27, 2018•15 citations

Two Roads to Classicality

Bob Coecke, John H. Selby, Sean Tull

Mixing and decoherence are both manifestations of classicality within quantum theory, each of which admit a very general category-theoretic construction. We show under which conditions these two 'roads to classicality' coincide. This is indeed the case for (finite-dimensional) quantum theory, where each construction yields the category of C*-algebras and completely positive maps. We present counterexamples where the property fails which includes relational and modal theories. Finally, we provide a new interpretation for our category-theoretic generalisation of decoherence in terms of 'leaking information'.

arXiv:1701.07400•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Feb 27, 2018•30 citations

Reconstructing quantum theory from diagrammatic postulates

John H. Selby, Carlo Maria Scandolo, Bob Coecke

A reconstruction of quantum theory refers to both a mathematical and a conceptual paradigm that allows one to derive the usual formulation of quantum theory from a set of primitive assumptions. The motivation for doing so is a discomfort with the usual formulation of quantum theory, a discomfort that started with its originator John von Neumann. We present a reconstruction of finite-dimensional quantum theory where all of the postulates are stated in diagrammatic terms, making them intuitive. Equivalently, they are stated in category-theoretic terms, making them mathematically appealing. Again equivalently, they are stated in process-theoretic terms, establishing that the conceptual backbone of quantum theory concerns the manner in which systems and processes compose. Aside from the diagrammatic form, the key novel aspect of this reconstruction is the introduction of a new postulate, symmetric purification. Unlike the ordinary purification postulate, symmetric purification applies equally well to classical theory as well as quantum theory. Therefore we first reconstruct the full process theoretic description of quantum theory, consisting of composite classical-quantum systems and their interactions, before restricting ourselves to just the ‘fully quantum’ systems as the final step. We propose two novel alternative manners of doing so, ‘no-leaking’ (roughly that information gain causes disturbance) and ‘purity of cups’ (roughly the existence of entangled states). Interestingly, these turn out to be equivalent in any process theory with cups & caps. Additionally, we show how the standard purification postulate can be seen as an immediate consequence of the symmetric purification postulate and purity of cups. Other tangential results concern the specific frameworks of generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs) and process theories (a.k.a. CQM). Firstly, we provide a diagrammatic presentation of GPTs, which, henceforth, can be subsumed under process theories. Secondly, we argue that the ‘sharp dagger’ is indeed the right choice of a dagger structure as this sharpness is vital to the reconstruction.

arXiv:1802.00367•Quantum•Apr 28, 2021•86 citations

A Top-down View of the Classical Limit of Quantum Mechanics

Sebastián Fortín, Olímpia Lombardi

At present there is a consensus about the fact that the emergence of the classical world from the underlying quantum reality involves the physical phenomenon of decoherence, which is usually studied in the version proposed by Zurek and his collaborators. According to this version, decoherence is a process resulting from the interaction between a quantum system and its environment (environment-induced decoherence, EID); this process singles out the observables that receive definite classical values. The aim of this paper is to propose a top-down approach to decoherence, which takes the perspective of the whole closed system, and considers whether each set of degrees of freedom decoheres or not. This approach is more general than the orthodox open-system perspective and dissolves some of its conceptual problems. Although decoherence becomes relative to the way in which the closed system is decomposed, the quantum-to-classical transition defines unequivocally the realm of classicality by identifying the observables with classical-like behavior.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Nov 14, 2016•11 citations
We introduce the notion of a leak for general process theories and identify quantum theory as a theory with minimal leakage, while classical theory has maximal leakage. We provide a construction that adjoins leaks to theories, an instance of which describes the emergence of classical theory by adjoining decoherence leaks to quantum theory. Finally, we show that defining a notion of purity for processes in general process theories has to make reference to the leaks of that theory, a feature missing in standard definitions; hence, we propose a refined definition and study the resulting notion of purity for quantum, classical and intermediate theories.
This thesis asks what can be learnt about quantum theory by investigating it from the perspective of process theories. This is based on the diagrammatic compositional structure of Categorical Quantum Mechanics, leading to a very general framework to describe alternate theories of nature. In particular this framework is well suited to understanding the relationship between different theories. In the first part of the thesis we investigate the relationship between quantum and classical theory, showing how an abstract description of decoherence in terms of leaking information leads to emergent classicality. Moreover, this process theoretic notion of a `leak' allows us to capture the distinction between quantum and classical theory in a particularly simple way, highlighting how the quantum and classical worlds diverge. In the second part we look at how to reconstruct quantum theory from diagrammatic principles showing that i) the existence of a classical interface with the theory plus ii) standard notions of composition and iii) a time symmetric form of purification are sufficient to reconstruct the standard quantum formalism. Thereby demonstrating that the standard tools of Categorical Quantum Mechanics come very close to capturing the essence of quantum theory. In the third part we abstract the key features of this emergence of classicality to define a notion of `hyperdecoherence' whereby some post-quantum theory might appear quantum due to an uncontrolled interaction with an environment. We prove a no-go theorem which states that any operational post-quantum theory must violate the purification principle, and so must radically challenge our understanding of how information behaves. To summarise, we use the framework of process theories to gain a better understanding of quantum theory, its sub-theories, and its potential super-theories.
A thoroughgoing and consistent application of quantum theory shows that the connection between classical and quantum physics is very different from what can be found in standard textbooks. In the last two decades it has been shown that the elements of classical physics emerge through an irreversible quantum process called ‘decoherence’. According to decoherence theories, quantum objects acquire classical properties only through interactions with their natural environment as a consequence of the holistic features of quantum theory. In view of the interpretation problem of quantum theory, only two directions out of the host of proposals suggested in the course of time appear to remain consistent solutions. Whatever solution is preferred, the message of decoherence remains the same: classical notions are not needed as the starting point for physics. Instead, these emerge through the dynamical process of decoherence from the quantum substrate.
Mixing and decoherence are both manifestations of classicality within quantum theory, each of which admit a very general category-theoretic construction. We show under which conditions these two 'roads to classicality' coincide. This is indeed the case for (finite-dimensional) quantum theory, where each construction yields the category of C*-algebras and completely positive maps. We present counterexamples where the property fails which includes relational and modal theories. Finally, we provide a new interpretation for our category-theoretic generalisation of decoherence in terms of 'leaking information'.
A reconstruction of quantum theory refers to both a mathematical and a conceptual paradigm that allows one to derive the usual formulation of quantum theory from a set of primitive assumptions. The motivation for doing so is a discomfort with the usual formulation of quantum theory, a discomfort that started with its originator John von Neumann. We present a reconstruction of finite-dimensional quantum theory where all of the postulates are stated in diagrammatic terms, making them intuitive. Equivalently, they are stated in category-theoretic terms, making them mathematically appealing. Again equivalently, they are stated in process-theoretic terms, establishing that the conceptual backbone of quantum theory concerns the manner in which systems and processes compose. Aside from the diagrammatic form, the key novel aspect of this reconstruction is the introduction of a new postulate, symmetric purification. Unlike the ordinary purification postulate, symmetric purification applies equally well to classical theory as well as quantum theory. Therefore we first reconstruct the full process theoretic description of quantum theory, consisting of composite classical-quantum systems and their interactions, before restricting ourselves to just the ‘fully quantum’ systems as the final step. We propose two novel alternative manners of doing so, ‘no-leaking’ (roughly that information gain causes disturbance) and ‘purity of cups’ (roughly the existence of entangled states). Interestingly, these turn out to be equivalent in any process theory with cups & caps. Additionally, we show how the standard purification postulate can be seen as an immediate consequence of the symmetric purification postulate and purity of cups. Other tangential results concern the specific frameworks of generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs) and process theories (a.k.a. CQM). Firstly, we provide a diagrammatic presentation of GPTs, which, henceforth, can be subsumed under process theories. Secondly, we argue that the ‘sharp dagger’ is indeed the right choice of a dagger structure as this sharpness is vital to the reconstruction.
At present there is a consensus about the fact that the emergence of the classical world from the underlying quantum reality involves the physical phenomenon of decoherence, which is usually studied in the version proposed by Zurek and his collaborators. According to this version, decoherence is a process resulting from the interaction between a quantum system and its environment (environment-induced decoherence, EID); this process singles out the observables that receive definite classical values. The aim of this paper is to propose a top-down approach to decoherence, which takes the perspective of the whole closed system, and considers whether each set of degrees of freedom decoheres or not. This approach is more general than the orthodox open-system perspective and dissolves some of its conceptual problems. Although decoherence becomes relative to the way in which the closed system is decomposed, the quantum-to-classical transition defines unequivocally the realm of classicality by identifying the observables with classical-like behavior.