Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1612.00619 · Journal of Mathematical Physics

Decay of superconducting correlations for gauged electrons in dimensions D ≤ 4

Yasuhiro Tada, Tohru Koma

Published Mar 1, 2018• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We study lattice superconductors coupled to gauge fields, such as an attractive Hubbard model in electromagnetic fields, with a standard gauge fixing. We prove upper bounds for a two-point Cooper pair correlation at finite temperatures in spatial dimensions D ≤ 4. The upper bounds decay exponentially in three dimensions and by power law in four dimensions. These imply the absence of the superconducting long-range order for the Cooper pair amplitude as a consequence of fluctuations of the gauge fields. Since our results hold for the gauge fixing Hamiltonian, they cannot be obtained as a corollary of Elitzur’s theorem.

DOI
10.1063/1.5029282

Related papers

Decay of superconducting and magnetic correlations in one- and two-dimensional Hubbard models

Tohru Koma, Hal Tasaki

In a general class of one- and two-dimensional Hubbard models, we prove upper bounds for the two-point correlation functions at finite temperatures for electrons, electron pairs, and spin. The upper bounds decay exponentially in one dimension, and with power laws in two dimensions. The bounds rule out the possibility of the corresponding condensation of superconducting electron pairs, and of the corresponding magnetic ordering. Our method is general enough to cover other models such as the t-J model.

arXiv:cond-mat/9709068•Physical Review Letters•May 25, 1992•72 citations

$π$ Flux Phase and Superconductivity for Lattice Fermions Coupled to Classical Gauge Fields

Tohru Koma

We study superconducting lattice fermions coupled to classical gauge fields. Namely, without the gauge fields, the lattice fermions show superconducting long-range order. In the previous paper, the existence of the long-range order was proved by the present author. This paper is the continuing part of the previous one. More precisely, the interactions between fermions were assumed to be a Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer-type pairing which is a nearest-neighbour two-body interaction on the hypercubic lattice $\mathbb{Z}^d$ with the dimension $d\ge 3$. In the present paper, we deal with the corresponding gauged model by introducing classical U(1) gauge fields. We prove that a certain configuration of gauge fields which yields the $π$ flux for all the plaquettes in the lattice minimizes the ground-state energy of the fermion system. Since this configuration of the gauge fields exactly coincides with the hopping amplitudes of the Hamiltonian of the previous paper, the ground state of the whole system shows superconducting long-range order. Any configuration of gauge fields which is gauge-equivalent to this special configuration of the gauge fields also yields another ground state. However, if the Cooper pair correlations are averaged over the gauge-equivalent class, then they are vanishing except for the on-site correlation because the Cooper pair correlations are not necessarily gauge invariant. On the other hand, the string Cooper pair correlations which are gauge invariant always show the same long-range order for any configuration of gauge fields in the gauge-equivalent class.

arXiv:2205.00835•May 2, 2022•3 citations

Superconducting fluctuations in the Hubbard model with an attractive on-site interaction in one dimension

P. Schlottmann, Kong-Ju-Bock Lee

The low-temperature thermodynamics of the one-dimensional Hubbard model with attractive on-site interaction of the electrons is discussed within the framework of the Bethe ansatz for the wave function. At low T the dominant states consist of spin-paired electrons (Cooper-pair-like) and excitations of such pairs (without breaking up the singlet bound states). A critical field Hc (energy required to depair a Cooper pair) is obtained at T=0 (note that the superconducting Tc =0), which disappears for T≠0. There is no magnetic response at T=0 for H<Hc . The one-electron correlation function falls off exponentially with distance, while the singlet pair–singlet pair correlation decreases with a power law. The specific heat is linear in temperature, which is possibly a consequence of the dimension. The elementary excitations of the system are discussed. The excitation spectrum shows some analogies to that of resonant valence bonds in two dimensions.

Journal of Applied Physics•May 1, 1990•1 citation

Magnetic and pairing correlations in correlated electron systems

Gang Su

Magnetic and superconducting pairing correlation functions in a general class of Hubbard models, the t - J model and a single-band Hubbard model with additional bond - charge interaction are investigated. Some rigorous upper bounds of the corresponding correlation functions are obtained. It is found that the decay of the spin - spin correlation function with temperature in the general Hubbard models cannot be slower than the inverse square law at low temperatures and the inverse law at high temperatures, while the on-site pairing correlation function cannot be slower than the inverse law. An upper bound for the average energy of the t - J model is found. The upper bounds for the spin - spin and the electron pairing correlation functions in the t - J model as well as in the Hubbard model with bond - charge interaction are also obtained. These bounds are expected to provide certain standards for approximate methods. In some special cases, these bounds rule out the possibility of corresponding magnetic and pairing long-range order.

arXiv:cond-mat/9601005•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Jul 29, 1996•0 citations

Quantum Charge-4e Superconductivity and Possible Deconfined Pseudocriticality in the Attractive SU(4) Hubbard Model

Zhou‐Quan Wan, Huan Jiang, Xuan Zou +2 more

Unlike conventional charge-2e superconductors, a charge-4e superconductor exhibits long-range coherence of electron quartets rather than Cooper pairs. Clear zero-temperature realizations of charge-4e superconductivity remain rare. Here, we investigate the zero-temperature phase diagram of the attractive SU(4) Hubbard model with numerically exact, large-scale quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations overcoming major technical hurdles. We identify both charge-2e and charge-4e superconducting phases. Upon increasing interaction, charge-2e long-range order vanishes, while charge-4e correlations remain robust and converge with system size, establishing a quartet-condensed phase. Interestingly, across the charge-2e--charge-4e transition, single electrons remain gapped, while charge-2e correlations exhibit an effective anomalous dimension substantially exceeding the conventional O(6) Landau theory prediction. These features motivate a fractionalized framework in which the physical charge-2e order parameter is a composite field coupled to an emergent non-Abelian gauge structure. We formulate an Sp(4) gauge-Higgs theory associating the charge-2e and charge-4e states with Higgs and confined phases, respectively. A one-loop analysis of an SU($N_f$) generalization exhibits a fixed-point collision, motivating deconfined pseudocriticality as a possible interpretation of the observed scaling. Our results establish charge-4e superconductivity as a bona fide zero-temperature phase, provide a simple model for future studies in a numerically exact framework, and suggest an unconventional route to superconducting criticality.

arXiv:2604.14289•Apr 15, 2026•8 citations

Superconducting phase coherence and pairing gap in the three-dimensional attractive Hubbard model

T. K. Kopeć

We consider a lattice version of the ``negative-$U''$ Hubbard model in three dimensions, to study the crossover from a superconducting phase transition (dominated by phase fluctuation) to a regime where the amplitude of the superconducting order parameter controls the critical temperature. Starting from a fermionic Hamiltonian, we give a microscopic derivation of the effective action in terms of the relevant physical fields: the modulus and phase of the superconducting order parameter. Furthermore, by employing to the resulting coarse--grained quantum $\mathrm{XY}$ model the phase fluctuation algebra between number and phase operators (given by the Euclidean group ${E}_{2}),$ we map the ``phase-only'' action onto a solvable quantum spherical model. We establish the self--consistent theory (involving both fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom), and calculate the superconducting phase coherence transition temperature ${T}_{c}$ as a function of the coupling strength $|U|,$ exhibiting a maximum where the behavior crosses over from BCS to Bose-Einstein (BE) condensation. We examine a pseudogap in the normal state which emerges naturally as a precursor of superconductivity at the second characteristic temperature ${T}_{g}$ due to a state with bound pairs but without long--range phase coherence. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the reduced gaps of the model $2{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{0}{/k}_{B}{T}_{g}\ensuremath{\sim}4$ is almost independent on the pairing strength $|U|/t,$ whereas $2{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{0}{/k}_{B}{T}_{c}$ increases with increasing $|U|$---in striking analogy with the phenomenology of the high--temperature cuprate superconductors when interpreted in terms of the BCS-BC crossover scenario.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 2002•11 citations
We study lattice superconductors coupled to gauge fields, such as an attractive Hubbard model in electromagnetic fields, with a standard gauge fixing. We prove upper bounds for a two-point Cooper pair correlation at finite temperatures in spatial dimensions D ≤ 4. The upper bounds decay exponentially in three dimensions and by power law in four dimensions. These imply the absence of the superconducting long-range order for the Cooper pair amplitude as a consequence of fluctuations of the gauge fields. Since our results hold for the gauge fixing Hamiltonian, they cannot be obtained as a corollary of Elitzur’s theorem.
In a general class of one- and two-dimensional Hubbard models, we prove upper bounds for the two-point correlation functions at finite temperatures for electrons, electron pairs, and spin. The upper bounds decay exponentially in one dimension, and with power laws in two dimensions. The bounds rule out the possibility of the corresponding condensation of superconducting electron pairs, and of the corresponding magnetic ordering. Our method is general enough to cover other models such as the t-J model.
πππ Flux Phase and Superconductivity for Lattice Fermions Coupled to Classical Gauge Fields
We study superconducting lattice fermions coupled to classical gauge fields. Namely, without the gauge fields, the lattice fermions show superconducting long-range order. In the previous paper, the existence of the long-range order was proved by the present author. This paper is the continuing part of the previous one. More precisely, the interactions between fermions were assumed to be a Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer-type pairing which is a nearest-neighbour two-body interaction on the hypercubic lattice Zd\mathbb{Z}^dZd with the dimension d≥3d\ge 3d≥3. In the present paper, we deal with the corresponding gauged model by introducing classical U(1) gauge fields. We prove that a certain configuration of gauge fields which yields the πππ flux for all the plaquettes in the lattice minimizes the ground-state energy of the fermion system. Since this configuration of the gauge fields exactly coincides with the hopping amplitudes of the Hamiltonian of the previous paper, the ground state of the whole system shows superconducting long-range order. Any configuration of gauge fields which is gauge-equivalent to this special configuration of the gauge fields also yields another ground state. However, if the Cooper pair correlations are averaged over the gauge-equivalent class, then they are vanishing except for the on-site correlation because the Cooper pair correlations are not necessarily gauge invariant. On the other hand, the string Cooper pair correlations which are gauge invariant always show the same long-range order for any configuration of gauge fields in the gauge-equivalent class.
The low-temperature thermodynamics of the one-dimensional Hubbard model with attractive on-site interaction of the electrons is discussed within the framework of the Bethe ansatz for the wave function. At low T the dominant states consist of spin-paired electrons (Cooper-pair-like) and excitations of such pairs (without breaking up the singlet bound states). A critical field Hc (energy required to depair a Cooper pair) is obtained at T=0 (note that the superconducting Tc =0), which disappears for T≠0. There is no magnetic response at T=0 for H<Hc . The one-electron correlation function falls off exponentially with distance, while the singlet pair–singlet pair correlation decreases with a power law. The specific heat is linear in temperature, which is possibly a consequence of the dimension. The elementary excitations of the system are discussed. The excitation spectrum shows some analogies to that of resonant valence bonds in two dimensions.
Magnetic and superconducting pairing correlation functions in a general class of Hubbard models, the t - J model and a single-band Hubbard model with additional bond - charge interaction are investigated. Some rigorous upper bounds of the corresponding correlation functions are obtained. It is found that the decay of the spin - spin correlation function with temperature in the general Hubbard models cannot be slower than the inverse square law at low temperatures and the inverse law at high temperatures, while the on-site pairing correlation function cannot be slower than the inverse law. An upper bound for the average energy of the t - J model is found. The upper bounds for the spin - spin and the electron pairing correlation functions in the t - J model as well as in the Hubbard model with bond - charge interaction are also obtained. These bounds are expected to provide certain standards for approximate methods. In some special cases, these bounds rule out the possibility of corresponding magnetic and pairing long-range order.
Unlike conventional charge-2e superconductors, a charge-4e superconductor exhibits long-range coherence of electron quartets rather than Cooper pairs. Clear zero-temperature realizations of charge-4e superconductivity remain rare. Here, we investigate the zero-temperature phase diagram of the attractive SU(4) Hubbard model with numerically exact, large-scale quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations overcoming major technical hurdles. We identify both charge-2e and charge-4e superconducting phases. Upon increasing interaction, charge-2e long-range order vanishes, while charge-4e correlations remain robust and converge with system size, establishing a quartet-condensed phase. Interestingly, across the charge-2e--charge-4e transition, single electrons remain gapped, while charge-2e correlations exhibit an effective anomalous dimension substantially exceeding the conventional O(6) Landau theory prediction. These features motivate a fractionalized framework in which the physical charge-2e order parameter is a composite field coupled to an emergent non-Abelian gauge structure. We formulate an Sp(4) gauge-Higgs theory associating the charge-2e and charge-4e states with Higgs and confined phases, respectively. A one-loop analysis of an SU(NfN_fNf​) generalization exhibits a fixed-point collision, motivating deconfined pseudocriticality as a possible interpretation of the observed scaling. Our results establish charge-4e superconductivity as a bona fide zero-temperature phase, provide a simple model for future studies in a numerically exact framework, and suggest an unconventional route to superconducting criticality.
We consider a lattice version of the ``negative-U′′U''U′′ Hubbard model in three dimensions, to study the crossover from a superconducting phase transition (dominated by phase fluctuation) to a regime where the amplitude of the superconducting order parameter controls the critical temperature. Starting from a fermionic Hamiltonian, we give a microscopic derivation of the effective action in terms of the relevant physical fields: the modulus and phase of the superconducting order parameter. Furthermore, by employing to the resulting coarse--grained quantum XY\mathrm{XY}XY model the phase fluctuation algebra between number and phase operators (given by the Euclidean group E2),{E}_{2}),E2​), we map the ``phase-only'' action onto a solvable quantum spherical model. We establish the self--consistent theory (involving both fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom), and calculate the superconducting phase coherence transition temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ as a function of the coupling strength ∣U∣,|U|,∣U∣, exhibiting a maximum where the behavior crosses over from BCS to Bose-Einstein (BE) condensation. We examine a pseudogap in the normal state which emerges naturally as a precursor of superconductivity at the second characteristic temperature Tg{T}_{g}Tg​ due to a state with bound pairs but without long--range phase coherence. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the reduced gaps of the model $2{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{0}{/k}_{B}{T}_{g}\ensuremath{\sim}4$ is almost independent on the pairing strength ∣U∣/t,|U|/t,∣U∣/t, whereas $2{\ensuremath{\Delta}}_{0}{/k}_{B}{T}_{c}$ increases with increasing ∣U∣|U|∣U∣---in striking analogy with the phenomenology of the high--temperature cuprate superconductors when interpreted in terms of the BCS-BC crossover scenario.