Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1611.09445 · Physical Review A

Infrared problem in quantum acoustodynamics

Dennis P. Clougherty, Sanghita Sengupta

Published May 12, 2017• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum electrodynamics (QED) provides a highly accurate description of phenomena involving the interaction of atoms with light. We argue that the quantum theory describing the interaction of cold atoms with a vibrating membrane---quantum acoustodynamics (QAD)---shares many issues and features with QED. Specifically, the adsorption of an atom on a vibrating membrane can be viewed as the counterpart to QED radiative electron capture. A calculation of the adsorption rate to lowest order in the atom-phonon coupling is finite; however, higher-order contributions suffer from an infrared problem mimicking the case of radiative capture in QED. Terms in the perturbation series for the adsorption rate diverge as a result of massless particles in the model (flexural phonons of the membrane in QAD and photons in QED). We treat this infrared problem in QAD explicitly to obtain finite results by regularizing with a low-frequency cutoff that corresponds to the inverse size of the membrane. Using a coherent-state basis for the soft-phonon final state, we then sum the dominant contributions to derive a new formula for the multiphonon adsorption rate of atoms on the membrane that gives results that are finite, nonperturbative in the atom-phonon coupling, and consistent with the Kinoshita-Lee-Nauenberg theorem. For micromembranes, we predict a reduction with increasing membrane size for the low-energy adsorption rate. We discuss the relevance of this to the adsorption of a cold gas of atomic hydrogen on suspended graphene.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.052110

Related papers

Infrared dynamics of cold atoms on hot graphene membranes

Sanghita Sengupta, Valeri N. Kotov, Dennis P. Clougherty

We study the infrared dynamics of low-energy atoms interacting with a sample of suspended graphene at finite temperature. The dynamics exhibits severe infrared divergences order by order in perturbation theory as a result of the singular nature of low-energy flexural phonon emission. Our model can be viewed as a two-channel generalization of the independent boson model with asymmetric atom-phonon coupling. This allows us to take advantage of the exact nonperturbative solution of the independent boson model in the stronger channel while treating the weaker one perturbatively. In the low-energy limit, the exact solution can be viewed as a resummation (exponentiation) of the most divergent diagrams in the perturbative expansion. As a result of this procedure, we obtain the atom's Green function which we use to calculate the atom damping rate, a quantity equal to the quantum sticking rate. A characteristic feature of our results is that the Green's function retains a weak, infrared cutoff dependence that reflects the reduced dimensionality of the problem. As a consequence, we predict a measurable dependence of the sticking rate on graphene sample size. We provide detailed predictions for the sticking rate of atomic hydrogen as a function of temperature and sample size. The resummation yields an enhanced sticking rate relative to the conventional Fermi golden rule result (equivalent to the one-loop atom self-energy), as higher-order processes increase damping at finite temperature.

arXiv:1603.03476•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 21, 2016•8 citations

Infrared Problem in Cold Atom Quantum Physisorption on 2D Materials

Sanghita Sengupta, Dennis P. Clougherty

Results from four different approximations to the phonon-assisted quantum adsorption rate for cold atoms on a 2D material are compared and contrasted: (1) a loop expansion (LE) based on the atom-phonon coupling, (2) non-crossing approximation (NCA), (3) independent boson model approximation (IBMA), and (4) a leading-order soft-phonon resummation method (SPR). The SPR method treats the adsorbed atom as a surface polaron where the phonon cloud accompanying the bound atom is a phonon coherent state. We conclude that, of the four approximations considered, only the SPR method gives a divergence-free result in the large membrane regime at finite temperature. The other three methods give an adsorption rate that diverges in the limit of an infinite surface.

arXiv:1809.08990•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Dec 1, 2018•3 citations

Variational approach to atom-membrane dynamics

Dennis P. Clougherty

Using the Dirac–Frenkel variational principle, a time-dependent description of the dynamics of a two-level system coupled to a bosonic bath is formulated. The method is applied to the case of a gas of cold atoms adsorbing to an elastic membrane at a finite temperature via phonon creation. The time-dependence of the system state is analytically calculated using Laplace transform methods, and a closed-form expression for the transition rate is obtained. Atoms in the gas transition to the adsorbed state through a resonance that has contributions from a distribution of vibrational modes of the membrane. The resonance can decay with the creation of a phonon to complete the adsorption process. The adsorption rate at low membrane temperatures agrees with the golden rule estimate to the lowest order in the coupling constant for values greater than a critical coupling strength. Below this critical coupling strength, the adsorption rate is exponentially suppressed by a phonon reduction factor whose exponent diverges with increasing adsorbent size. The rate changes discontinuously with coupling strength for low temperature membranes, and the magnitude of the discontinuity decreases with increasing temperature. These variational results suggest the quantum adsorption model may contain a first-order quantum phase transition.

arXiv:2408.16759•APL Quantum•Dec 1, 2024•3 citations

Quantum sticking of atoms on membranes

Dennis P. Clougherty

A continuum model for low-energy physisorption on a membrane under tension is proposed and studied with variational mean-field theory. A discontinuous change in the energy-dependent sticking coefficient is predicted under certain conditions. This singularity is a result of the bosonic orthogonality catastrophe of the vibrational states of the membrane. The energy-dependent sticking coefficient is predicted to have exponential scaling in $1/E$ at energies above the singularity. The application of this model to the quantum sticking of cold hydrogen to suspended graphene is discussed. The model predicts that a beam of atomic hydrogen can be completely reflected by suspended graphene at ultralow energies.

arXiv:1312.5754•Physical Review B•Dec 5, 2014•14 citations

Purcell-enhanced quantum adsorption

Dennis P. Clougherty

Cold atoms can adsorb to a surface with the emission of a single phonon when the binding energy is sufficiently small. The effects of phonon damping and adsorbent size on the adsorption rate in this quantum regime are studied using the multimode Rabi model. It is demonstrated that the adsorption rate can be either enhanced or suppressed relative to the Fermi golden rule rate, in analogy to cavity effects in the spontaneous emission rate in QED. A mesoscopic-sized adsorbent behaves as an acoustic cavity that enhances the adsorption rate when tuned to the adsorption transition frequency and suppresses the rate when detuned. This acoustic cavity effect occurs in the regime where the frequency spacing between vibrational modes exceeds the phonon linewidth.

arXiv:2504.10410•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 10, 2025•1 citation

The Hydrogen Atom as Pure Vibration: A Classical Field Model with a Q-Ball Nucleus and Quantised Electron Waves

Mykola Yaremenko

We construct a mathematically complete model of the hydrogen atom in which no point particles appear. The nucleus is a stable, gauged Q‑ball soliton of a complex scalar field; the electron is a charged scalar field vibration; and the electromagnetic interaction is carried by a massless vector field. Imposing finite total energy for stationary electron waves leads directly to a quantised frequency spectrum that exactly matches the Bohr levels. The sign of the Coulomb force is corrected, giving attraction. The electron self‑interaction is treated rigorously: a classical mass renormalisation is performed, and the finite residual corresponds to a classical Lamb‑shift‑like correction. Spontaneous emission is derived as the deterministic radiation coming from the beat frequency of two stationary vibrations; the Larmor‑formula decay rate for the hydrogen 2P to 1S transition is computed and shown to coincide with the quantum electrodynamics result. Throughout, the model reproduces many quantum phenomena within a purely vibrational, classical field theory, while the Born rule is identified as the remaining conceptual frontier. A full bibliography of 28 references supports the work.

London journal of physics.•Jun 9, 2026•0 citations
Quantum electrodynamics (QED) provides a highly accurate description of phenomena involving the interaction of atoms with light. We argue that the quantum theory describing the interaction of cold atoms with a vibrating membrane---quantum acoustodynamics (QAD)---shares many issues and features with QED. Specifically, the adsorption of an atom on a vibrating membrane can be viewed as the counterpart to QED radiative electron capture. A calculation of the adsorption rate to lowest order in the atom-phonon coupling is finite; however, higher-order contributions suffer from an infrared problem mimicking the case of radiative capture in QED. Terms in the perturbation series for the adsorption rate diverge as a result of massless particles in the model (flexural phonons of the membrane in QAD and photons in QED). We treat this infrared problem in QAD explicitly to obtain finite results by regularizing with a low-frequency cutoff that corresponds to the inverse size of the membrane. Using a coherent-state basis for the soft-phonon final state, we then sum the dominant contributions to derive a new formula for the multiphonon adsorption rate of atoms on the membrane that gives results that are finite, nonperturbative in the atom-phonon coupling, and consistent with the Kinoshita-Lee-Nauenberg theorem. For micromembranes, we predict a reduction with increasing membrane size for the low-energy adsorption rate. We discuss the relevance of this to the adsorption of a cold gas of atomic hydrogen on suspended graphene.
We study the infrared dynamics of low-energy atoms interacting with a sample of suspended graphene at finite temperature. The dynamics exhibits severe infrared divergences order by order in perturbation theory as a result of the singular nature of low-energy flexural phonon emission. Our model can be viewed as a two-channel generalization of the independent boson model with asymmetric atom-phonon coupling. This allows us to take advantage of the exact nonperturbative solution of the independent boson model in the stronger channel while treating the weaker one perturbatively. In the low-energy limit, the exact solution can be viewed as a resummation (exponentiation) of the most divergent diagrams in the perturbative expansion. As a result of this procedure, we obtain the atom's Green function which we use to calculate the atom damping rate, a quantity equal to the quantum sticking rate. A characteristic feature of our results is that the Green's function retains a weak, infrared cutoff dependence that reflects the reduced dimensionality of the problem. As a consequence, we predict a measurable dependence of the sticking rate on graphene sample size. We provide detailed predictions for the sticking rate of atomic hydrogen as a function of temperature and sample size. The resummation yields an enhanced sticking rate relative to the conventional Fermi golden rule result (equivalent to the one-loop atom self-energy), as higher-order processes increase damping at finite temperature.
Results from four different approximations to the phonon-assisted quantum adsorption rate for cold atoms on a 2D material are compared and contrasted: (1) a loop expansion (LE) based on the atom-phonon coupling, (2) non-crossing approximation (NCA), (3) independent boson model approximation (IBMA), and (4) a leading-order soft-phonon resummation method (SPR). The SPR method treats the adsorbed atom as a surface polaron where the phonon cloud accompanying the bound atom is a phonon coherent state. We conclude that, of the four approximations considered, only the SPR method gives a divergence-free result in the large membrane regime at finite temperature. The other three methods give an adsorption rate that diverges in the limit of an infinite surface.
Using the Dirac–Frenkel variational principle, a time-dependent description of the dynamics of a two-level system coupled to a bosonic bath is formulated. The method is applied to the case of a gas of cold atoms adsorbing to an elastic membrane at a finite temperature via phonon creation. The time-dependence of the system state is analytically calculated using Laplace transform methods, and a closed-form expression for the transition rate is obtained. Atoms in the gas transition to the adsorbed state through a resonance that has contributions from a distribution of vibrational modes of the membrane. The resonance can decay with the creation of a phonon to complete the adsorption process. The adsorption rate at low membrane temperatures agrees with the golden rule estimate to the lowest order in the coupling constant for values greater than a critical coupling strength. Below this critical coupling strength, the adsorption rate is exponentially suppressed by a phonon reduction factor whose exponent diverges with increasing adsorbent size. The rate changes discontinuously with coupling strength for low temperature membranes, and the magnitude of the discontinuity decreases with increasing temperature. These variational results suggest the quantum adsorption model may contain a first-order quantum phase transition.
A continuum model for low-energy physisorption on a membrane under tension is proposed and studied with variational mean-field theory. A discontinuous change in the energy-dependent sticking coefficient is predicted under certain conditions. This singularity is a result of the bosonic orthogonality catastrophe of the vibrational states of the membrane. The energy-dependent sticking coefficient is predicted to have exponential scaling in 1/E1/E1/E at energies above the singularity. The application of this model to the quantum sticking of cold hydrogen to suspended graphene is discussed. The model predicts that a beam of atomic hydrogen can be completely reflected by suspended graphene at ultralow energies.
Cold atoms can adsorb to a surface with the emission of a single phonon when the binding energy is sufficiently small. The effects of phonon damping and adsorbent size on the adsorption rate in this quantum regime are studied using the multimode Rabi model. It is demonstrated that the adsorption rate can be either enhanced or suppressed relative to the Fermi golden rule rate, in analogy to cavity effects in the spontaneous emission rate in QED. A mesoscopic-sized adsorbent behaves as an acoustic cavity that enhances the adsorption rate when tuned to the adsorption transition frequency and suppresses the rate when detuned. This acoustic cavity effect occurs in the regime where the frequency spacing between vibrational modes exceeds the phonon linewidth.
We construct a mathematically complete model of the hydrogen atom in which no point particles appear. The nucleus is a stable, gauged Q‑ball soliton of a complex scalar field; the electron is a charged scalar field vibration; and the electromagnetic interaction is carried by a massless vector field. Imposing finite total energy for stationary electron waves leads directly to a quantised frequency spectrum that exactly matches the Bohr levels. The sign of the Coulomb force is corrected, giving attraction. The electron self‑interaction is treated rigorously: a classical mass renormalisation is performed, and the finite residual corresponds to a classical Lamb‑shift‑like correction. Spontaneous emission is derived as the deterministic radiation coming from the beat frequency of two stationary vibrations; the Larmor‑formula decay rate for the hydrogen 2P to 1S transition is computed and shown to coincide with the quantum electrodynamics result. Throughout, the model reproduces many quantum phenomena within a purely vibrational, classical field theory, while the Born rule is identified as the remaining conceptual frontier. A full bibliography of 28 references supports the work.