Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1611.07937 · Physical Review A

Simultaneous measurement of two noncommuting quantum variables: Solution of a dynamical model

Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

Published May 30, 2017• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The possibility of performing simultaneous measurements in quantum mechanics is investigated in the context of the Curie-Weiss model for a projective measurement. Concretely, we consider a spin--$\frac{1}{2}$ system simultaneously interacting with two magnets, which act as measuring apparatuses of two different spin components. We work out the dynamics of this process and determine the final state of the measuring apparatuses, from which we can find the probabilities of the four possible outcomes of the measurements. The measurement is found to be nonideal, as (i) the joint statistics do not coincide with the one obtained by separately measuring each spin component, and (ii) the density matrix of the spin does not collapse in either of the measured observables. However, we give an operational interpretation of the process as a generalized quantum measurement, and show that it is fully informative: The expected value of the measured spin components can be found with arbitrary precision for sufficiently many runs of the experiment.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.052129

Related papers

Curie-Weiss model of the quantum measurement process

ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN, Roger Balian, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

A Hamiltonian model is solved, which satisfies all requirements for a realistic ideal quantum measurement. The system S is a spin-½, whose z -component is measured through coupling with an apparatus A = M + B, consisting of a magnet M formed by a set of N >> 1 spins with quartic infinite-range Ising interactions, and a phonon bath B at temperature T . Initially A is in a metastable paramagnetic phase. The process involves several time-scales. Without being much affected, A first acts on S, whose state collapses in a very brief time. The mechanism differs from the usual decoherence. Soon after its irreversibility is achieved. Finally, the field induced by S on M, which may take two opposite values with probabilities given by Born's rule, drives A into its up or down ferromagnetic phase. The overall final state involves the expected correlations between the result registered in M and the state of S. The measurement is thus accounted for by standard quantum-statistical mechanics and its specific features arise from the macroscopic size of the apparatus.

arXiv:cond-mat/0203460•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Feb 1, 2003•55 citations

Dynamics of ideal quantum measurement of a spin 1 with a Curie-Weiss magnet

Theodorus Maria Nieuwenhuizen

Quantum measurement is a dynamical process of an apparatus coupled to a test system. Ideal measurement of the $z$-component of a spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ ($s_z=\pm\frac{1}{2}$) has been modeled by the Curie-Weiss model for quantum measurement. Recently, the model was generalized to higher spin and the thermodynamics was solved. Here the dynamics is considered. To this end, the dynamics for spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ case are cast in general notation. The dynamics of the measurement of the $z$-component of a spin-1 ($s_z=0,\pm 1$) are solved in detail and evaluated numerically. Energy costs of the measurement, which are macroscopic, are evaluated. Generalization to higher spin is straightforward.

quant-pharXiv:2603.07153•Frontiers in Quantum Science and Technology•Mar 10, 2026•1 citation

Measurement of noncommuting spin components using spin-orbit interaction

D. Sokolovski, Eugene Ya. Sherman

We propose a possible experiment aimed at a joint measurement of two noncommuting spin-1/2 components and analyze its physical meaning. We demonstrate that switching of a strong spin-orbit interaction, e.g., in a solid-state or a cold-atom system, for a short time interval simulates a simultaneous von Neumann measurement of the operators ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{x}$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{y}$. With the spin dynamics mapped onto the quantum coordinate-space motion, such an experiment determines averages of ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{x}$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{y}$ over the duration of the measurement, however short the latter may be. These time averages, unlike the instantaneous values of ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{x}$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{y}$, may be evaluated simultaneously to an arbitrary accuracy.

arXiv:1105.5359•Physical Review A•Sep 22, 2011•11 citations

The quantum measurement process: an exactly solvable model

ARMEN E. ALLAHVERDYAN, Roger Balian, Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen

An exactly solvable model for a quantum measurement is discussed, that integrates quantum measurements with classical measurements. The z-component of a spin-1/2 test spin is measured with an apparatus, that itself consists of magnet of N spin-1/2 particles, coupled to a bath. The initial state of the magnet is a metastable paramagnet, while the bath starts in a thermal, gibbsian state. Conditions are such that the act of measurement drives the magnet in the up or down ferromagnetic state, according to the sign of s_z of the test spin. The quantum measurement goes in two steps. On a timescale 1/\sqrt{N} the collapse takes place due to a unitary evolution of test spin and apparatus spins; on a larger but still short timescale this collapse is made definite by the bath. Then the system is in a `classical' state, having a diagonal density matrix. The registration of that state is basically a classical process, that can already be understood from classical statistical mechanics.

arXiv:cond-mat/0309188•Sep 8, 2003•6 citations

Operations, disturbance, and simultaneous measurability

Masanao Ozawa

Quantum mechanics predicts the joint probability distributions of the outcomes of simultaneous measurements of commuting observables, but the current formulation lacks the operational definition of simultaneous measurements. In order to provide foundations of joint statistics of local general measurements on entangled systems in a general theoretical framework, the question is answered as to under what condition the outputs of two measuring apparatuses satisfy the joint probability formula for simultaneous measurements of their observables. For this purpose, all the possible state changes caused by measurements of an observable are characterized, and the notion of disturbance in measurement is formalized in terms of operations derived by the measuring interaction.

arXiv:quant-ph/0005054•Physical Review A•Feb 1, 2001•37 citations

Lectures on dynamical models for quantum measurements

Theo M. Nieuwenhuizen, Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Roger Balian

In textbooks, ideal quantum measurements are described in terms of the tested system only by the collapse postulate and Born's rule. This level of description offers a rather flexible position for the interpretation of quantum mechanics. Here we analyse an ideal measurement as a process of interaction between the tested system S and an apparatus A, so as to derive the properties postulated in textbooks. We thus consider within standard quantum mechanics the measurement of a quantum spin component ŝz by an apparatus A, being a magnet coupled to a bath. We first consider the evolution of the density operator of S + A describing a large set of runs of the measurement process. The approach describes the disappearance of the off-diagonal terms ("truncation") of the density matrix as a physical effect due to A, while the registration of the outcome has classical features due to the large size of the pointer variable, the magnetization. A quantum ambiguity implies that the density matrix at the final time can be decomposed on many bases, not only the one of the measurement. This quantum oddity prevents to connect individual outcomes to measurements, a difficulty known as the "measurement problem". It is shown that it is circumvented by the apparatus as well, since the evolution in a small time interval erases all decompositions, except the one on the measurement basis. Once one can derive the outcome of individual events from quantum theory, the so-called collapse of the wavefunction or the reduction of the state appears as the result of a selection of runs among the original large set. Hence nothing more than standard quantum mechanics is needed to explain features of measurements. The employed statistical formulation is advocated for the teaching of quantum theory.

arXiv:1406.5178•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Jun 23, 2014•5 citations
The possibility of performing simultaneous measurements in quantum mechanics is investigated in the context of the Curie-Weiss model for a projective measurement. Concretely, we consider a spin--12\frac{1}{2}21​ system simultaneously interacting with two magnets, which act as measuring apparatuses of two different spin components. We work out the dynamics of this process and determine the final state of the measuring apparatuses, from which we can find the probabilities of the four possible outcomes of the measurements. The measurement is found to be nonideal, as (i) the joint statistics do not coincide with the one obtained by separately measuring each spin component, and (ii) the density matrix of the spin does not collapse in either of the measured observables. However, we give an operational interpretation of the process as a generalized quantum measurement, and show that it is fully informative: The expected value of the measured spin components can be found with arbitrary precision for sufficiently many runs of the experiment.
A Hamiltonian model is solved, which satisfies all requirements for a realistic ideal quantum measurement. The system S is a spin-½, whose z -component is measured through coupling with an apparatus A = M + B, consisting of a magnet M formed by a set of N >> 1 spins with quartic infinite-range Ising interactions, and a phonon bath B at temperature T . Initially A is in a metastable paramagnetic phase. The process involves several time-scales. Without being much affected, A first acts on S, whose state collapses in a very brief time. The mechanism differs from the usual decoherence. Soon after its irreversibility is achieved. Finally, the field induced by S on M, which may take two opposite values with probabilities given by Born's rule, drives A into its up or down ferromagnetic phase. The overall final state involves the expected correlations between the result registered in M and the state of S. The measurement is thus accounted for by standard quantum-statistical mechanics and its specific features arise from the macroscopic size of the apparatus.
Quantum measurement is a dynamical process of an apparatus coupled to a test system. Ideal measurement of the zzz-component of a spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ (sz=±12s_z=\pm\frac{1}{2}sz​=±21​) has been modeled by the Curie-Weiss model for quantum measurement. Recently, the model was generalized to higher spin and the thermodynamics was solved. Here the dynamics is considered. To this end, the dynamics for spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ case are cast in general notation. The dynamics of the measurement of the zzz-component of a spin-1 (sz=0,±1s_z=0,\pm 1sz​=0,±1) are solved in detail and evaluated numerically. Energy costs of the measurement, which are macroscopic, are evaluated. Generalization to higher spin is straightforward.
We propose a possible experiment aimed at a joint measurement of two noncommuting spin-1/2 components and analyze its physical meaning. We demonstrate that switching of a strong spin-orbit interaction, e.g., in a solid-state or a cold-atom system, for a short time interval simulates a simultaneous von Neumann measurement of the operators ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{x}$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{y}$. With the spin dynamics mapped onto the quantum coordinate-space motion, such an experiment determines averages of ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{x}$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{y}$ over the duration of the measurement, however short the latter may be. These time averages, unlike the instantaneous values of ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{x}$ and ${\ensuremath{\sigma}}_{y}$, may be evaluated simultaneously to an arbitrary accuracy.
An exactly solvable model for a quantum measurement is discussed, that integrates quantum measurements with classical measurements. The z-component of a spin-1/2 test spin is measured with an apparatus, that itself consists of magnet of N spin-1/2 particles, coupled to a bath. The initial state of the magnet is a metastable paramagnet, while the bath starts in a thermal, gibbsian state. Conditions are such that the act of measurement drives the magnet in the up or down ferromagnetic state, according to the sign of s_z of the test spin. The quantum measurement goes in two steps. On a timescale 1/\sqrt{N} the collapse takes place due to a unitary evolution of test spin and apparatus spins; on a larger but still short timescale this collapse is made definite by the bath. Then the system is in a `classical' state, having a diagonal density matrix. The registration of that state is basically a classical process, that can already be understood from classical statistical mechanics.
Quantum mechanics predicts the joint probability distributions of the outcomes of simultaneous measurements of commuting observables, but the current formulation lacks the operational definition of simultaneous measurements. In order to provide foundations of joint statistics of local general measurements on entangled systems in a general theoretical framework, the question is answered as to under what condition the outputs of two measuring apparatuses satisfy the joint probability formula for simultaneous measurements of their observables. For this purpose, all the possible state changes caused by measurements of an observable are characterized, and the notion of disturbance in measurement is formalized in terms of operations derived by the measuring interaction.
In textbooks, ideal quantum measurements are described in terms of the tested system only by the collapse postulate and Born's rule. This level of description offers a rather flexible position for the interpretation of quantum mechanics. Here we analyse an ideal measurement as a process of interaction between the tested system S and an apparatus A, so as to derive the properties postulated in textbooks. We thus consider within standard quantum mechanics the measurement of a quantum spin component ŝz by an apparatus A, being a magnet coupled to a bath. We first consider the evolution of the density operator of S + A describing a large set of runs of the measurement process. The approach describes the disappearance of the off-diagonal terms ("truncation") of the density matrix as a physical effect due to A, while the registration of the outcome has classical features due to the large size of the pointer variable, the magnetization. A quantum ambiguity implies that the density matrix at the final time can be decomposed on many bases, not only the one of the measurement. This quantum oddity prevents to connect individual outcomes to measurements, a difficulty known as the "measurement problem". It is shown that it is circumvented by the apparatus as well, since the evolution in a small time interval erases all decompositions, except the one on the measurement basis. Once one can derive the outcome of individual events from quantum theory, the so-called collapse of the wavefunction or the reduction of the state appears as the result of a selection of runs among the original large set. Hence nothing more than standard quantum mechanics is needed to explain features of measurements. The employed statistical formulation is advocated for the teaching of quantum theory.