Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1611.07455 · Physical Review A

Reexamination of strong subadditivity: A quantum-correlation approach

Razieh Taghiabadi, Seyed Javad Akhtarshenas, Mohsen Sarbishaei

Published Mar 13, 2017• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The strong subadditivity inequality of von Neumann entropy relates the entropy of subsystems of a tripartite state ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC}$ to that of the composite system. Here, we define ${\mathbit{T}}^{(a)}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC})$ as the extent to which ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC}$ fails to satisfy the strong subadditivity inequality $S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B})+S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{C})\ensuremath{\le}S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB})+S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AC})$ with equality and investigate its properties. In particular, by introducing auxiliary subsystem $E$, we consider any purification $|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{ABCE}\ensuremath{\rangle}$ of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC}$ and formulate ${\mathbit{T}}^{(a)}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC})$ as the extent to which the bipartite quantum correlations of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}$ and ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AC}$, measured by entanglement of formation and quantum discord, change under the transformation $B\ensuremath{\rightarrow}BE$ and $C\ensuremath{\rightarrow}CE$. Invariance of quantum correlations of ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}$ and ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AC}$ under such transformation is shown to be a necessary and sufficient condition for vanishing ${\mathbit{T}}^{(a)}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC})$. Our approach allows one to characterize, intuitively, the structure of states for which the strong subadditivity is saturated. Moreover, along with providing a conservation law for quantum correlations of states for which the strong subadditivity inequality is satisfied with equality, we find that such states coincide with those that the Koashi-Winter monogamy relation is saturated.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.032315

Related papers

Additivity relations in quantum correlations

Seung-Ho Yang, Hyunseok Jeong, Wonmin Son

Does the sum of correlations in subsystems constitute the correlation in the total system? Such a concept can be expressed by an additivity relationship of correlations. From a strong subadditivity condition of von Neumann entropy, four different additivity relations in total correlation are derived and quantified. Based upon the classification of the additivity in total correlation, we identify the corresponding additive relationships in entanglement. It is also discussed that similar relationships are satisfied for quantum discord of pure states, but it is not always true for mixed states.

arXiv:1305.3609•Physical Review A•May 13, 2013•5 citations

Inequalities for quantum entropy: A review with conditions for equality

Mary Beth Ruskai

This article presents self-contained proofs of the strong subadditivity inequality for von Neumann’s quantum entropy, S(ρ), and some related inequalities for the quantum relative entropy, most notably its convexity and its monotonicity under stochastic maps. Moreover, the approach presented here, which is based on Klein’s inequality and Lieb’s theorem that the function A→Tr eK+log A is concave, allows one to obtain conditions for equality. In the case of strong subadditivity, which states that S(ρ123)+S(ρ2)⩽S(ρ12)+S(ρ23) where the subscripts denote subsystems of a composite system, equality holds if and only if log ρ123=log ρ12−log ρ2+log ρ23. Using the fact that the Holevo bound on the accessible information in a quantum ensemble can be obtained as a consequence of the monotonicity of relative entropy, we show that equality can be attained for that bound only when the states in the ensemble commute. The article concludes with an Appendix giving a short description of Epstein’s elegant proof of Lieb’s theorem.

arXiv:quant-ph/0205064•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Sep 1, 2002•202 citations

On mutual information in multipartite quantum states and equality in strong subadditivity of entropy

Fedor Herbut

The challenge of equality in the strong subadditivity inequality of entropy is approached via a general additivity of correlation information in terms of nonoverlapping clusters of subsystems in multipartite states (density operators). A family of tripartite states satisfying equality is derived.

arXiv:quant-ph/0311193•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 24, 2004•28 citations

Notes on the equality in SSA of entropy on CAR algebra

József Pitrik, V. P. Belavkin

We prove a necessary an sufficient condition for the states which satisfy strong subadditivity of von Neumann entropy with equality on CAR algebra and we show an example when the equality holds but the state is not separable.

arXiv:math-ph/0602035•Feb 13, 2006•1 citation

Addendum Entropy and information causality in general probabilistic theories

Howard Barnum, Jonathan Barrett, Lisa Orloff Clark +5 more

In this addendum to our paper (2010 New J. Phys. 12 033024), we point out that an elementary consequence of the strong subadditivity inequality allows us to strengthen one of the main conclusions of that paper. In this addendum to our paper [1], we point out that an elementary consequence of the strong subadditivity inequality allows us to strengthen one of the main conclusions of that paper. In [1], we defined notions of measurement and mixing entropy for a broad class of probabilistic theories (which includes finite-dimensional quantum theory). We defined a theory to be monoentropic if for every state of a system in the theory, the mixing entropy (denoted S) is equal to the measurement entropy (denoted H ). This broad class of theories has a notion of composite system, and of the ‘marginal state’ of a subsystem given a state for the composite system, so that the strong subadditivity inequality may be formulated for real-valued functions of states, including the measurement and mixing entropies. We proved the following theorem. Theorem 1 (theorem 4 of [1]). Suppose that a theory has the following properties: (1) it is monoentropic, meaning that measurement entropy equals mixing entropy for all systems, (2) its measurement entropy is strongly subadditive and (3) its measurement entropy satisfies the Holevo bound. Then the theory satisfies information causality. It follows that any theory satisfying these conditions cannot violate Tsirel’son’s bound. In [1] we noted that monoentropicity was only used to establish the technical condition of positivity of conditional information, H(A|C), defined as H(AC)− H(C), when A is classical. This condition does not hold for all theories in the broad class we consider. Shortly after submitting the final version of [1], but too late for inclusion therein, we noticed that it does, however, hold for all theories satisfying strong subadditivity, enabling us to strengthen our theorem as follows. Theorem 2. Suppose that a theory’s measurement entropy is strongly subadditive and satisfies the Holevo bound. Then the theory satisfies information causality. It follows that any theory satisfying these conditions cannot violate Tsirel’son’s bound. As noted in our earlier paper, one can replace the two premises of this theorem with the single premise that the measurement entropy satisfies the data processing inequality. To see that H(A|C)> 0 for classical A follows from strong subadditivity, we recall (from e.g. lemma 1 of [1]), that strong subadditivity is equivalent to the positivity of conditional mutual information, I (A : B|C)> 0. Letting A and B be perfectly correlated classical systems in this inequality, we have I (A : B|C)= H(A|C)+ H(B|C)− H(AB|C) = H(AC)− H(C)+ H(BC) − H(C)− H(ABC)+ H(C) = H(AC)+ H(BC)− H(ABC)− H(C). New Journal of Physics 14 (2012) 129401 (http://www.njp.org/)

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

A Condition for the Nullity of Quantum Discord

Animesh Datta

The positivity of quantum discord is shown to be equivalent to the strong subadditivity of von-Neumann entropy. This leads us to a necessary and sufficient condition characterizing the set of states with zero quantum discord. This also gives us a mathematical definition of pointer states, as they are the states with zero discord. Finally, we suggest that strong subadditivity of entropy might delineate the boundaries of the set of quantum correlations.

arXiv:1003.5256•Mar 27, 2010•91 citations
The strong subadditivity inequality of von Neumann entropy relates the entropy of subsystems of a tripartite state \ensuremathρABC{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC}\ensuremathρABC​ to that of the composite system. Here, we define \mathbitT(a)(\ensuremathρABC){\mathbit{T}}^{(a)}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC})\mathbitT(a)(\ensuremathρABC​) as the extent to which \ensuremathρABC{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC}\ensuremathρABC​ fails to satisfy the strong subadditivity inequality S(\ensuremathρB)+S(\ensuremathρC)\ensuremath≤S(\ensuremathρAB)+S(\ensuremathρAC)S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{B})+S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{C})\ensuremath{\le}S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB})+S({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AC})S(\ensuremathρB​)+S(\ensuremathρC​)\ensuremath≤S(\ensuremathρAB​)+S(\ensuremathρAC​) with equality and investigate its properties. In particular, by introducing auxiliary subsystem EEE, we consider any purification ∣\ensuremathψABCE\ensuremath⟩|{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{ABCE}\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathψABCE​\ensuremath⟩ of \ensuremathρABC{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC}\ensuremathρABC​ and formulate \mathbitT(a)(\ensuremathρABC){\mathbit{T}}^{(a)}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC})\mathbitT(a)(\ensuremathρABC​) as the extent to which the bipartite quantum correlations of \ensuremathρAB{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}\ensuremathρAB​ and \ensuremathρAC{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AC}\ensuremathρAC​, measured by entanglement of formation and quantum discord, change under the transformation B\ensuremath→BEB\ensuremath{\rightarrow}BEB\ensuremath→BE and C\ensuremath→CEC\ensuremath{\rightarrow}CEC\ensuremath→CE. Invariance of quantum correlations of \ensuremathρAB{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AB}\ensuremathρAB​ and \ensuremathρAC{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{AC}\ensuremathρAC​ under such transformation is shown to be a necessary and sufficient condition for vanishing \mathbitT(a)(\ensuremathρABC){\mathbit{T}}^{(a)}({\ensuremath{\rho}}_{ABC})\mathbitT(a)(\ensuremathρABC​). Our approach allows one to characterize, intuitively, the structure of states for which the strong subadditivity is saturated. Moreover, along with providing a conservation law for quantum correlations of states for which the strong subadditivity inequality is satisfied with equality, we find that such states coincide with those that the Koashi-Winter monogamy relation is saturated.
Does the sum of correlations in subsystems constitute the correlation in the total system? Such a concept can be expressed by an additivity relationship of correlations. From a strong subadditivity condition of von Neumann entropy, four different additivity relations in total correlation are derived and quantified. Based upon the classification of the additivity in total correlation, we identify the corresponding additive relationships in entanglement. It is also discussed that similar relationships are satisfied for quantum discord of pure states, but it is not always true for mixed states.
This article presents self-contained proofs of the strong subadditivity inequality for von Neumann’s quantum entropy, S(ρ), and some related inequalities for the quantum relative entropy, most notably its convexity and its monotonicity under stochastic maps. Moreover, the approach presented here, which is based on Klein’s inequality and Lieb’s theorem that the function A→Tr eK+log A is concave, allows one to obtain conditions for equality. In the case of strong subadditivity, which states that S(ρ123)+S(ρ2)⩽S(ρ12)+S(ρ23) where the subscripts denote subsystems of a composite system, equality holds if and only if log ρ123=log ρ12−log ρ2+log ρ23. Using the fact that the Holevo bound on the accessible information in a quantum ensemble can be obtained as a consequence of the monotonicity of relative entropy, we show that equality can be attained for that bound only when the states in the ensemble commute. The article concludes with an Appendix giving a short description of Epstein’s elegant proof of Lieb’s theorem.
In this addendum to our paper (2010 New J. Phys. 12 033024), we point out that an elementary consequence of the strong subadditivity inequality allows us to strengthen one of the main conclusions of that paper. In this addendum to our paper [1], we point out that an elementary consequence of the strong subadditivity inequality allows us to strengthen one of the main conclusions of that paper. In [1], we defined notions of measurement and mixing entropy for a broad class of probabilistic theories (which includes finite-dimensional quantum theory). We defined a theory to be monoentropic if for every state of a system in the theory, the mixing entropy (denoted S) is equal to the measurement entropy (denoted H ). This broad class of theories has a notion of composite system, and of the ‘marginal state’ of a subsystem given a state for the composite system, so that the strong subadditivity inequality may be formulated for real-valued functions of states, including the measurement and mixing entropies. We proved the following theorem. Theorem 1 (theorem 4 of [1]). Suppose that a theory has the following properties: (1) it is monoentropic, meaning that measurement entropy equals mixing entropy for all systems, (2) its measurement entropy is strongly subadditive and (3) its measurement entropy satisfies the Holevo bound. Then the theory satisfies information causality. It follows that any theory satisfying these conditions cannot violate Tsirel’son’s bound. In [1] we noted that monoentropicity was only used to establish the technical condition of positivity of conditional information, H(A|C), defined as H(AC)− H(C), when A is classical. This condition does not hold for all theories in the broad class we consider. Shortly after submitting the final version of [1], but too late for inclusion therein, we noticed that it does, however, hold for all theories satisfying strong subadditivity, enabling us to strengthen our theorem as follows. Theorem 2. Suppose that a theory’s measurement entropy is strongly subadditive and satisfies the Holevo bound. Then the theory satisfies information causality. It follows that any theory satisfying these conditions cannot violate Tsirel’son’s bound. As noted in our earlier paper, one can replace the two premises of this theorem with the single premise that the measurement entropy satisfies the data processing inequality. To see that H(A|C)> 0 for classical A follows from strong subadditivity, we recall (from e.g. lemma 1 of [1]), that strong subadditivity is equivalent to the positivity of conditional mutual information, I (A : B|C)> 0. Letting A and B be perfectly correlated classical systems in this inequality, we have I (A : B|C)= H(A|C)+ H(B|C)− H(AB|C) = H(AC)− H(C)+ H(BC) − H(C)− H(ABC)+ H(C) = H(AC)+ H(BC)− H(ABC)− H(C). New Journal of Physics 14 (2012) 129401 (http://www.njp.org/)