Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1611.07090 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Diatomic molecule as a testbed for combining DMFT with electronic structure methods such as GW and DFT

Juho Lee, Kristjan Haule

Published Apr 3, 2017• 24 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We implemented a combination of DMFT and $GW$ in its fully self-consistent way, one shot $GW$ approximation, and quasiparticle self-consistent scheme, and studied how well these combined methods perform on a ${\mathrm{H}}_{2}$ molecule as compared to more established methods such as LDA+DMFT. We found that most flavors of $GW+\mathrm{DMFT}$ break down in a strongly correlated regime due to causality violation. Among $GW+\mathrm{DMFT}$ methods, only the self-consistent quasiparticle $GW+\mathrm{DMFT}$ with static double-counting, and a method with causal double-counting, correctly recover the atomic limit at large H-atom separation. While some flavors of $GW+\mathrm{DMFT}$ improve the single-electron spectra as compared to LDA+DMFT, the total energy is best predicted by LDA+DMFT, for which the exact double-counting is known, and is static.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.95.155104

Related papers

Dynamical mean field theory for diatomic molecules and the exact double counting

Juho Lee, Kristjan Haule

Dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) combined with the local density approximation (LDA) is widely used in solids to predict properties of correlated systems. In this study, a parameter-free version of the LDA+DMFT framework is implemented and tested on one of the simplest strongly correlated systems, the ${\text{H}}_{2}$ molecule. Specifically, we propose a method to calculate the exact intersection of LDA and DMFT that leads to highly accurate subtraction of the doubly counted correlation in both methods. When the exact-double-counting treatment and a good projector to the correlated subspace are used, LDA+DMFT yields a very accurate total energy and excitation spectrum of ${\text{H}}_{2}$. We also discuss how this double-counting scheme can be extended to solid state calculations.

arXiv:1403.2474•Physical Review B•Apr 27, 2015•13 citations

Methodological study of computational approaches to address the problem of strong correlations

Juho Lee

The main focus of this thesis is the detailed investigation of computational methods to tackle strongly correlated materials in which a rich variety of exotic phenomena are found. A many-body problem with sizable electronic correlations can no longer be explained by independent-particle approximations such as density functional theory (DFT) or tight-binding approaches. The influence of an electron to the others is too strong for each electron to be treated as an independent quasiparticle and consequently those standard band-structure methods fail even at a qualitative level. One of the most powerful approaches for strong correlations is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT), which has enlightened the understanding of the Mott transition based on the Hubbard model. For realistic applications, the dynamical mean-field theory is combined with various independent-particles approaches. The most widely used one is the DMFT combined with the DFT in the local density approximation (LDA), so-called LDA+DMFT. In this approach, the electrons in the weakly correlated orbitals are calculated by LDA while others in the strongly correlated orbitals are treated by DMFT. Recently, the method combining DMFT with Hedin's $GW$ approximation was also developed, in which the momentum-dependent self-energy is also added. In this thesis, we discuss the application of those methodologies based on DMFT. First, we apply the dynamical mean-field theory to solve the 3-dimensional Hubbard model in Chap. 3. In this application, we model the interface between the thermodynamically coexisting metal and Mott insulator. We show how to model the required slab geometry and extract the electronic spectra. We construct an effective Landau free energy and compute the variation of its parameters across the phase diagram. Finally, using a linear mixture of the density and double-occupancy, we identify a natural Ising order parameter which unifies the treatment of the bandwidth and filling controlled Mott transitions. Secondly, we study the double-counting problem, a subtle issue that arises in LDA+DMFT. We propose a highly precise double-counting functional, in which the intersection of LDA and DMFT is calculated exactly, and implement a parameter-free version of the LDA+DMFT that is tested on one of the simplest strongly correlated systems, the H2 molecule. We show that the exact double-counting treatment along with a good DMFT projector leads to very accurate and total energy and excitation spectrum of H$_2$ molecule. Finally, we implement various versions of $GW$+DMFT, in its fully self-consistent way, one shot GW approximation, and quasiparticle self-consistent scheme, and studied how well these combined methods perform on H$_2$ molecule as compared to more established methods such as LDA+DMFT. We found that most flavors of GW+DMFT break down in strongly correlated regime due to causality violation. Among GW+DMFT methods, only the self-consistent quasiparticle GW+DMFT with static double-counting, and a new method with causal double-counting, correctly recover the atomic limit at large H-atom separation. While some flavors of GW+DMFT improve the single-electron spectra of LDA+DMFT, the total energy is best predicted by LDA+DMFT, for which the exact double-counting is known, and is static.

•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations

Implementation of parameter-free LDA+DMFT and GW+DMFT for diatomic molecules using exact double-counting correction

Juho Lee, Kristjan Haule

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 5, 2015•0 citations

Testing self-energy embedding theory in combination with GW

Lan Nguyen Tran, Avijit Shee, Jia Zhao Li +2 more

We present a theoretical framework and implementation details for self-energy embedding theory (SEET) with the GW approximation for the treatment of weakly correlated degrees of freedom and configuration interactions solver for handing the strongly correlated degrees. On a series of molecular examples, for which the exact results are known within a given basis, we demonstrate that SEET(CI/GW) is a systematically improvable and well controlled method capable of giving accurate results and well behaved causal self-energies and Green's functions. We compare the theoretical framework of SEET(CI/GW) to that of GW+DMFT and comment on differences between these to approaches that aim to treat both strongly and weakly correlated simultaneously.

arXiv:1706.05774•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 5, 2017•35 citations

First-Principles Approach to the Electronic Structure of Strongly Correlated Systems: Combining the GW Approximation and Dynamical Mean-Field Theory

Silke Biermann, F. Aryasetiawan, Antoine Georges

We propose a dynamical mean-field approach for calculating the electronic structure of strongly correlated materials from first principles. The scheme combines the GW method with dynamical mean-field theory, which enables one to treat strong interaction effects. It avoids the conceptual problems inherent to conventional "LDA+DMFT," such as Hubbard interaction parameters and double-counting terms. We apply a simplified version of the approach to the electronic structure of nickel and find encouraging results.

arXiv:cond-mat/0207419•Physical Review Letters•Feb 27, 2003•398 citations

Strong electron correlation from partition density functional theory

Yi Shi, Yuming Shi, Adam Wasserman

Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional in Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT) typically lead to unacceptably large errors when applied to strongly correlated electronic systems. Partition-DFT (PDFT) is a formally exact reformulation of KS-DFT in which the ground-state density and energy of a system are obtained through self-consistent calculations on isolated fragments, with a partition energy representing inter-fragment interactions. Here, we show how typical errors of the local density approximation (LDA) in KS-DFT can be largely suppressed through a simple approximation, the multi-fragment overlap approximation (MFOA), for the partition energy in PDFT. Our method is illustrated on simple models of one-dimensional strongly correlated linear hydrogen chains. The MFOA, when used in combination with the LDA for the fragments, improves LDA dissociation curves of hydrogen chains and produces results that are comparable to those of spin-unrestricted LDA, but without breaking the spin symmetry. MFOA also induces a correction to the LDA electron density that partially captures the correct density dimerization in strongly correlated hydrogen chains. Moreover, with an additional correction to the partition energy that is specific to the one-dimensional LDA, the approximation is shown to produce dissociation energies in quantitative agreement with calculations based on the density matrix renormalization group method.

arXiv:2309.04571•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 12, 2023•3 citations
We implemented a combination of DMFT and GWGWGW in its fully self-consistent way, one shot GWGWGW approximation, and quasiparticle self-consistent scheme, and studied how well these combined methods perform on a H2{\mathrm{H}}_{2}H2​ molecule as compared to more established methods such as LDA+DMFT. We found that most flavors of GW+DMFTGW+\mathrm{DMFT}GW+DMFT break down in a strongly correlated regime due to causality violation. Among GW+DMFTGW+\mathrm{DMFT}GW+DMFT methods, only the self-consistent quasiparticle GW+DMFTGW+\mathrm{DMFT}GW+DMFT with static double-counting, and a method with causal double-counting, correctly recover the atomic limit at large H-atom separation. While some flavors of GW+DMFTGW+\mathrm{DMFT}GW+DMFT improve the single-electron spectra as compared to LDA+DMFT, the total energy is best predicted by LDA+DMFT, for which the exact double-counting is known, and is static.
Dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) combined with the local density approximation (LDA) is widely used in solids to predict properties of correlated systems. In this study, a parameter-free version of the LDA+DMFT framework is implemented and tested on one of the simplest strongly correlated systems, the H2{\text{H}}_{2}H2​ molecule. Specifically, we propose a method to calculate the exact intersection of LDA and DMFT that leads to highly accurate subtraction of the doubly counted correlation in both methods. When the exact-double-counting treatment and a good projector to the correlated subspace are used, LDA+DMFT yields a very accurate total energy and excitation spectrum of H2{\text{H}}_{2}H2​. We also discuss how this double-counting scheme can be extended to solid state calculations.
The main focus of this thesis is the detailed investigation of computational methods to tackle strongly correlated materials in which a rich variety of exotic phenomena are found. A many-body problem with sizable electronic correlations can no longer be explained by independent-particle approximations such as density functional theory (DFT) or tight-binding approaches. The influence of an electron to the others is too strong for each electron to be treated as an independent quasiparticle and consequently those standard band-structure methods fail even at a qualitative level. One of the most powerful approaches for strong correlations is the dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT), which has enlightened the understanding of the Mott transition based on the Hubbard model. For realistic applications, the dynamical mean-field theory is combined with various independent-particles approaches. The most widely used one is the DMFT combined with the DFT in the local density approximation (LDA), so-called LDA+DMFT. In this approach, the electrons in the weakly correlated orbitals are calculated by LDA while others in the strongly correlated orbitals are treated by DMFT. Recently, the method combining DMFT with Hedin's GWGWGW approximation was also developed, in which the momentum-dependent self-energy is also added. In this thesis, we discuss the application of those methodologies based on DMFT. First, we apply the dynamical mean-field theory to solve the 3-dimensional Hubbard model in Chap. 3. In this application, we model the interface between the thermodynamically coexisting metal and Mott insulator. We show how to model the required slab geometry and extract the electronic spectra. We construct an effective Landau free energy and compute the variation of its parameters across the phase diagram. Finally, using a linear mixture of the density and double-occupancy, we identify a natural Ising order parameter which unifies the treatment of the bandwidth and filling controlled Mott transitions. Secondly, we study the double-counting problem, a subtle issue that arises in LDA+DMFT. We propose a highly precise double-counting functional, in which the intersection of LDA and DMFT is calculated exactly, and implement a parameter-free version of the LDA+DMFT that is tested on one of the simplest strongly correlated systems, the H2 molecule. We show that the exact double-counting treatment along with a good DMFT projector leads to very accurate and total energy and excitation spectrum of H2_22​ molecule. Finally, we implement various versions of GWGWGW+DMFT, in its fully self-consistent way, one shot GW approximation, and quasiparticle self-consistent scheme, and studied how well these combined methods perform on H2_22​ molecule as compared to more established methods such as LDA+DMFT. We found that most flavors of GW+DMFT break down in strongly correlated regime due to causality violation. Among GW+DMFT methods, only the self-consistent quasiparticle GW+DMFT with static double-counting, and a new method with causal double-counting, correctly recover the atomic limit at large H-atom separation. While some flavors of GW+DMFT improve the single-electron spectra of LDA+DMFT, the total energy is best predicted by LDA+DMFT, for which the exact double-counting is known, and is static.
We present a theoretical framework and implementation details for self-energy embedding theory (SEET) with the GW approximation for the treatment of weakly correlated degrees of freedom and configuration interactions solver for handing the strongly correlated degrees. On a series of molecular examples, for which the exact results are known within a given basis, we demonstrate that SEET(CI/GW) is a systematically improvable and well controlled method capable of giving accurate results and well behaved causal self-energies and Green's functions. We compare the theoretical framework of SEET(CI/GW) to that of GW+DMFT and comment on differences between these to approaches that aim to treat both strongly and weakly correlated simultaneously.
We propose a dynamical mean-field approach for calculating the electronic structure of strongly correlated materials from first principles. The scheme combines the GW method with dynamical mean-field theory, which enables one to treat strong interaction effects. It avoids the conceptual problems inherent to conventional "LDA+DMFT," such as Hubbard interaction parameters and double-counting terms. We apply a simplified version of the approach to the electronic structure of nickel and find encouraging results.
Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional in Kohn-Sham density functional theory (KS-DFT) typically lead to unacceptably large errors when applied to strongly correlated electronic systems. Partition-DFT (PDFT) is a formally exact reformulation of KS-DFT in which the ground-state density and energy of a system are obtained through self-consistent calculations on isolated fragments, with a partition energy representing inter-fragment interactions. Here, we show how typical errors of the local density approximation (LDA) in KS-DFT can be largely suppressed through a simple approximation, the multi-fragment overlap approximation (MFOA), for the partition energy in PDFT. Our method is illustrated on simple models of one-dimensional strongly correlated linear hydrogen chains. The MFOA, when used in combination with the LDA for the fragments, improves LDA dissociation curves of hydrogen chains and produces results that are comparable to those of spin-unrestricted LDA, but without breaking the spin symmetry. MFOA also induces a correction to the LDA electron density that partially captures the correct density dimerization in strongly correlated hydrogen chains. Moreover, with an additional correction to the partition energy that is specific to the one-dimensional LDA, the approximation is shown to produce dissociation energies in quantitative agreement with calculations based on the density matrix renormalization group method.