Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.09905 · Physical Review A

Test of a hypothesis of realism in quantum theory using a Bayesian approach

N. Nikitin, K. S. Toms

Published May 5, 2017• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper we propose a time-independent equality and time-dependent inequality, suitable for an experimental test of the hypothesis of realism. The derivation of these relations is based on the concept of conditional probability and on Bayes' theorem in the framework of Kolmogorov's axiomatics of probability theory. The equality obtained is intrinsically different from the well-known Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) equality and its variants, because violation of the proposed equality might be tested in experiments with only two microsystems in a maximally entangled Bell state $|{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rangle}$, while a test of the GHZ equality requires at least three quantum systems in a special state $|{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}}^{\mathrm{GHZ}}\ensuremath{\rangle}$. The obtained inequality differs from Bell's, Wigner's, and Leggett-Garg inequalities, because it deals with spin $s=1/2$ projections onto only two nonparallel directions at two different moments of time, while a test of the Bell and Wigner inequalities requires at least three nonparallel directions, and a test of the Leggett-Garg inequalities requires at least three distinct moments of time. Hence, the proposed inequality seems to open an additional experimental possibility to avoid the ``contextuality loophole.'' Violation of the proposed equality and inequality is illustrated with the behavior of a pair of anticorrelated spins in an external magnetic field and also with the oscillations of flavor-entangled pairs of neutral pseudoscalar mesons.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.052103

Related papers

Wigner inequalities for testing the hypothesis of realism and concepts of macroscopic and local realism

N. Nikitin, K. S. Toms

We propose a Wigner-like inequality suitable for testing the hypothesis of realism. We show that this inequality is identical neither to the well-known Wigner inequality nor to the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form. The obtained inequality is suitable for testing realism not only in quantum mechanical systems, but also in quantum field systems. Also we propose a mathematically consistent derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form, which was recently presented in the literature, for three and $n$ distinct moments of time. Contrary to these works, our rigor derivation uses Kolmogorov axiomatics of probability theory. We pay special attention to the construction and studies of the spaces of elementary outcomes. Based on the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form for $n$ distinct moments of time we prove that any unitary evolution of a quantum system contradicts the concept of macroscopic realism. We show that application of the concept of macroscopic realism to any quantum system leads to ``freezing'' of the system in the initial state. It is shown that for a particle with an infinite number of observables the probability to find a pair of the observables in some defined state is zero, even if the operators of these observables commute. This fact might serve as an additional logical argument for the contradiction between quantum theory and classical realism.

arXiv:1808.03119•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2019•8 citations

Investigation of properties of time-dependent bell inequalities in Wigner’s form for nonstationary and open quantum systems

N. Nikitin, V.P. Sotnikov, K. S. Toms

A radically new class of Bell inequalities in Wigner’s form was obtained on the basis of Kolmorov’s axiomatization of probability theory and the hypothesis of locality. These inequalities take explicitly into account the dependence on time (time-dependent Bell inequalities in Wigner’s form). By using these inequalities, one can propose a means for experimentally testing Bohr’ complementarity principle in the relativistic region. The inequalities in question open broad possibilities for studying correlations of nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum systems in external fields. The violation of the time-dependent inequalities in quantum mechanics was studied by considering the behavior of a pair of anticorrelated spins in a constant external magnetic field and oscillations of neutral pseudoscalar mesons. The decay of a pseudoscalar particle to a fermion–antifermion pair is considered within quantum field theory. In order to test experimentally the inequalities proposed in the present study, it is not necessary to perform dedicated noninvasive measurements required in the Leggett–Garg approach, for example.

Physics of Atomic Nuclei•Oct 1, 2015•2 citations

Time-dependent Bell inequalities in a Wigner form

N. Nikitin, V. P. Sotnikov, K. S. Toms

We propose time-dependent Bell inequalities in a Wigner form, which expand the possibilities of experimental verification of Bohr’s principle of complementarity in the relativistic domain and for nonstationary quantum-mechanical systems. Derivation of the proposed inequalities is based entirely on the Kolmogorov axiomatics of probability theory and the locality hypothesis. Violation of the obtained inequalities is considered in the framework of quantum theory based on the example of oscillations of neutral B mesons.

Moscow University Physics Bulletin•Nov 1, 2014•0 citations

Bell’s theorem with and without inequalities for the three-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger andWstates

Adán Cabello

A proof of Bell's theorem without inequalities valid for both inequivalent classes of three-qubit entangled states under local operations assisted by classical communication, namely Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and $W,$ is described. This proof leads to a Bell inequality that allows more conclusive tests of Bell's theorem for three-qubit systems. Another Bell inequality involving both tri- and bipartite correlations is introduced which illustrates the different violations of local realism exhibited by the GHZ and $W$ states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107146•Physical Review A•Feb 5, 2002•216 citations

Test of the Hypothesis of Realism Using a Modified Version of Wigner Inequality

N. Nikitin, K. S. Toms

In the current work we present a modified Wigner inequality for test of the hypothesis of realism. This modified Wigner inequality is suitable for test of realism not only in systems that obey the laws of non-relativistic quantum mechanics, but also in systems that obey the laws of quantum field theory. We show how this inequality can be violated in systems of neutral pseudoscalar mesons.

EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

Time-dependent Bell inequalities in a Wigner form

N. Nikitin, V. Sotnikov, K. S. Toms

We derive a class of time-dependent Bell inequalities in Wigner form under the assumption of locality in the framework of Kolmogorov's probability theory. We consider violation of the obtained inequalities for three cases: spin correlations in an external magnetic field, oscillations of neutral pseudoscalar mesons, and decays of a pseudoscalar into a fermion-antifermion pair.

arXiv:1408.6023•Physical Review A•Oct 31, 2014•7 citations
In this paper we propose a time-independent equality and time-dependent inequality, suitable for an experimental test of the hypothesis of realism. The derivation of these relations is based on the concept of conditional probability and on Bayes' theorem in the framework of Kolmogorov's axiomatics of probability theory. The equality obtained is intrinsically different from the well-known Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) equality and its variants, because violation of the proposed equality might be tested in experiments with only two microsystems in a maximally entangled Bell state ∣\ensuremathΨ\ensuremath−\ensuremath⟩|{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}}^{\ensuremath{-}}\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathΨ\ensuremath−\ensuremath⟩, while a test of the GHZ equality requires at least three quantum systems in a special state ∣\ensuremathΨGHZ\ensuremath⟩|{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Psi}}}^{\mathrm{GHZ}}\ensuremath{\rangle}∣\ensuremathΨGHZ\ensuremath⟩. The obtained inequality differs from Bell's, Wigner's, and Leggett-Garg inequalities, because it deals with spin s=1/2s=1/2s=1/2 projections onto only two nonparallel directions at two different moments of time, while a test of the Bell and Wigner inequalities requires at least three nonparallel directions, and a test of the Leggett-Garg inequalities requires at least three distinct moments of time. Hence, the proposed inequality seems to open an additional experimental possibility to avoid the ``contextuality loophole.'' Violation of the proposed equality and inequality is illustrated with the behavior of a pair of anticorrelated spins in an external magnetic field and also with the oscillations of flavor-entangled pairs of neutral pseudoscalar mesons.
We propose a Wigner-like inequality suitable for testing the hypothesis of realism. We show that this inequality is identical neither to the well-known Wigner inequality nor to the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form. The obtained inequality is suitable for testing realism not only in quantum mechanical systems, but also in quantum field systems. Also we propose a mathematically consistent derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form, which was recently presented in the literature, for three and nnn distinct moments of time. Contrary to these works, our rigor derivation uses Kolmogorov axiomatics of probability theory. We pay special attention to the construction and studies of the spaces of elementary outcomes. Based on the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form for nnn distinct moments of time we prove that any unitary evolution of a quantum system contradicts the concept of macroscopic realism. We show that application of the concept of macroscopic realism to any quantum system leads to ``freezing'' of the system in the initial state. It is shown that for a particle with an infinite number of observables the probability to find a pair of the observables in some defined state is zero, even if the operators of these observables commute. This fact might serve as an additional logical argument for the contradiction between quantum theory and classical realism.
A radically new class of Bell inequalities in Wigner’s form was obtained on the basis of Kolmorov’s axiomatization of probability theory and the hypothesis of locality. These inequalities take explicitly into account the dependence on time (time-dependent Bell inequalities in Wigner’s form). By using these inequalities, one can propose a means for experimentally testing Bohr’ complementarity principle in the relativistic region. The inequalities in question open broad possibilities for studying correlations of nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum systems in external fields. The violation of the time-dependent inequalities in quantum mechanics was studied by considering the behavior of a pair of anticorrelated spins in a constant external magnetic field and oscillations of neutral pseudoscalar mesons. The decay of a pseudoscalar particle to a fermion–antifermion pair is considered within quantum field theory. In order to test experimentally the inequalities proposed in the present study, it is not necessary to perform dedicated noninvasive measurements required in the Leggett–Garg approach, for example.
We propose time-dependent Bell inequalities in a Wigner form, which expand the possibilities of experimental verification of Bohr’s principle of complementarity in the relativistic domain and for nonstationary quantum-mechanical systems. Derivation of the proposed inequalities is based entirely on the Kolmogorov axiomatics of probability theory and the locality hypothesis. Violation of the obtained inequalities is considered in the framework of quantum theory based on the example of oscillations of neutral B mesons.
A proof of Bell's theorem without inequalities valid for both inequivalent classes of three-qubit entangled states under local operations assisted by classical communication, namely Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) and W,W,W, is described. This proof leads to a Bell inequality that allows more conclusive tests of Bell's theorem for three-qubit systems. Another Bell inequality involving both tri- and bipartite correlations is introduced which illustrates the different violations of local realism exhibited by the GHZ and WWW states.