Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.09861

The D$_1$ enigma and its physical origin

Jan Olof Stenflo

Published Oct 31, 2016• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The D$_1$ enigma is an anomaly, which was first observed on the Sun as a symmetric polarization peak centered in the core of the sodium D$_1$ line that is expected to be intrinsically unpolarizable. To resolve this problem the underlying physics was later explored in the laboratory for D$_1$ scattering at potassium vapor. The experiment showed that the scattering phase matrix element $P_{21}$ is positive while $P_{22}$ is negative, although standard quantum scattering theory predicts that both should be zero. This experimental contradiction is currently the main manifestation of the D$_1$ enigma. Subsequent theoretical studies showed that such polarization effects may arise if scattering theory is extended to allow for interference effects due to level splittings of the ground state, in contrast to standard scattering theory, which only allows for interferences from level splittings of the intermediate state. Previous attempts to implement this idea had to rely on heuristic arguments to allow modeling of the experimental data. In the present paper we develop a formulation of the theory that can be self-consistently applied to quantum systems with any combination of electronic and nuclear spins. No statistical equilibrium or optical pumping is needed. The atom is assumed to be unpolarized at the beginning of each scattering event. The theory is capable of explaining both the phase matrix behavior of the laboratory data and the existence of a symmetric polarization peak in the core of the solar D$_1$ line. We also use it to predict the polarization structures that we expect to see in a next-generation laboratory experiment with the rubidium isotopes $^{87}$Rb and $^{85}$Rb.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1610.09861

Related papers

PHYSICS OF POLARIZED SCATTERING AT MULTI-LEVEL ATOMIC SYSTEMS

Jan Olof Stenflo

The symmetric peak observed in linear polarization in the core of the solar sodium D 1 line at 5896 Å has remained enigmatic since its discovery nearly two decades ago. One reason is that the theory of polarized scattering has not been experimentally tested for multi-level atomic systems in the relevant parameter domains, although the theory is continually being used for the interpretation of astrophysical observations. A laboratory experiment that was set up a decade ago to find out whether the D 1 enigma is a problem of solar physics or quantum physics revealed that the D 1 system has a rich polarization structure in situations where standard scattering theory predicts zero polarization, even when optical pumping of the m state populations of the hyperfine-split ground state is accounted for. Here we show that the laboratory results can be modeled in great quantitative detail if the theory is extended to include the coherences in both the initial and final states of the scattering process. Radiative couplings between the allowed dipole transitions generate coherences in the initial state. Corresponding coherences in the final state are then demanded by a phase closure selection rule. The experimental results for the well understood D 2 line are used to constrain the two free parameters of the experiment, collision rate and optical depth, to suppress the need for free parameters when fitting the D 1 results.

arXiv:1501.02259•The Astrophysical Journal•Mar 4, 2015•8 citations

Magnetic Field Dependence of Polarized Scattering on Potassium

C. Thalmann, Jan Olof Stenflo, Alex J. Feller +1 more

The polarization that is generated by scattering of light on atoms depends on the atomic quantum number structure. According to standard scattering theory the sodium D1 (5896 A) and potassium D1 (7699 A) lines should be intrinsically unpolarizable. Since however the existence of D1 scattering polarization in the solar spectrum has been well documented but resisted theoretical explanations, we have carried out a laboratory experiment to find out if this is a problem of solar physics or of quantum physics. We find that the polarization matrix for scattering of the Stokes vector in the potassium D1 line exhibits a rich structure that changes dramatically when the field strength is varied in the sub-gauss regime. In contrast, standard scattering theory predicts zero polarization, even when optical pumping of the magnetic sub-levels of the hyperfine structure multiplet is accounted for.

•Jun 1, 2009•0 citations

Coherence structure of D1 scattering

Jan Olof Stenflo

Abstract The extensive literature on the physics of polarized scattering may give the impression that we have a solid theoretical foundation for the interpretation of spectro-polarimetric data. This theoretical framework has however not been sufficiently tested by experiments under controlled conditions. While the solar atmosphere may be viewed as a physics laboratory, the observed solar polarization depends on too many environmental factors that are beyond our control. The existence of a symmetric polarization peak at the center of the solar Na D1 line has remained an enigma for two decades, in spite of persistent efforts to explain it with available quantum theory. A decade ago a laboratory experiment was set up to determine whether this was a problem for solar physics or quantum physics. The experiment revealed a rich polarization structure of D1 scattering, although available quantum theory predicted null results. It has now finally been possible to formulate a well-defined and self-consistent extension of the theory of quantum scattering that can reproduce in great quantitative detail the main polarization structures that were found in the laboratory experiment. Here we give a brief overview of the new physical ingredients that were missing before. The extended theory reveals that multi-level atomic systems have a far richer coherence structure than previously believed.

Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union•Dec 1, 2014•0 citations

THE POLARIZATION OF ALKALIATOM D-LINE EMMISSION THE CASE OF AXIAL RECOIL EXCITATION

Ernest Demaray, Roger J. Anderson

The complete and exact calculation of the observable polarization of alkali d-line emission, in the case of axial–recoil excitation, is presented and discussed. First, the formalism developed allows the differentiation of different symmetries and different angular momentum coupling schemes for the quasimolecular parent state. Second, the theory of Percival and Seaton is adapted to allow the computation of the effect of hyperfine precessional dephasing of the initial atomic state on the Zeeman Radiation Pattern of the final emission. Third, from scattering experiments performed in our laboratory we are able for the first time to introduce the effect of the distrubution of axes of quantization for the particular case of the excitation of rubidium in crossed beams with $N_{2}$. The dipole radiation distribution and natural isotope abudance effects are included in the final polorization fraction. The exact results are tabulated for sample calculations; nuclear spin I=3/2 (Na, K, Rb) and I=5/2 (Rb). And the second order nuclear quadrupole effects are demonstrated to be of less importance than accurate values of the relative lifetimes. Polarizations computed with this method are compared with recent measurements and calculations for rare gas alkali-ion scattering emission. The method is also used to discuss recently measured anisotropies in resonance enhanced photoionization electron distributions and photo-dissociation hot atom recoil.

•Jan 1, 1980•0 citations

Frequency Shifts in Spin-Exchange Optical Pumping Experiments

L. C. Balling, R. J. Hanson, F. M. Pipkin

A theory is derived to predict the density matrices describing two atoms after a spin-exchange collision from the density matrices before the collision and the scattering amplitude for binary collisions. This theory is then applied to a system of quasifree electrons interacting with optically pumped rubidium atoms. For calculating the change in the electron density matrix, the ${\mathrm{Rb}}^{85}$ and ${\mathrm{Rb}}^{87}$ are replaced by a fictitious rubidium isotope with no nuclear spin. Expressions are derived for the change in the light transmission when a radiofrequency field is present at the electron frequency. In addition to the linewidth for the electron signal, the spin-exchange theory predicts a frequency shift the magnitude of which depends upon the two-body scattering amplitude, the rubidium polarization and the rubidium density. Experiments performed to test various aspects of the theory are then reported. The measurements were made on a system of quasifree electrons interacting with rubidium atoms. Measurements of the electron linewidth as a function of temperature indicated that spin-exchange collisions dominated the electron relaxation. The predicted frequency shift was measured by observing the electron resonance frequency first with left circularly polarized light and then with right circularly polarized light. For electrons colliding with rubidium atoms the shift is negative when the rubidium polarization is positive and the ratio of the shift to the linewidth is $\frac{\ensuremath{\delta}{\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}}{\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\nu}}=\ensuremath{-}0.025\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.005$. From the measured values of the shift and the linewidth, a value is derived for the electron-rubidium spin-flip cross section. In one Appendix the replacement of the ${\mathrm{Rb}}^{85}$ and ${\mathrm{Rb}}^{87}$ by the fictitious rubidium isotope with no nuclear spin is justified. In a second Appendix the calculations for the simple electron-rubidium system are generalized and applied to more complicated systems. Results are reported for the change in the density matrix of hydrogen atoms when they collide with polarized electrons, the change in the density matrix of ${\mathrm{Rb}}^{87}$ atoms when they collide with polarized electrons, and the change in the density matrix of hydrogen atoms when they collide with hydrogen atoms.

Physical Review•Feb 3, 1964•132 citations

Optically excited Zeeman coherences in atomic ground states: Nuclear-spin effects

Dieter Suter

Optical experiments in alkali-metal atomic gases are usually interpreted in terms of the J=1/2 ground state, treating the electronic ground state as a degenerate two-level system. While this simplified level scheme has been quite successful in describing many experimental results, the nuclear spin can lead to significant modifications of the behavior. Apart from the obvious differences, such as the existence of hyperfine splitting, some more subtle effects are present that modify the dynamical as well as the equilibrium behavior of the system. An an example, the optical pumping process in the true atomic ground state is nonexponential and slower by at least an order of magnitude, compared to a hypothetical atom with nuclear spin zero. The limitations of the J=1/2 model are analyzed theoretically and experimentally for atomic sodium, and experimental methods are demonstrated that can help disentangle the contributions from different hyperfine components.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1992•26 citations
The D1_11​ enigma and its physical origin
The D1_11​ enigma is an anomaly, which was first observed on the Sun as a symmetric polarization peak centered in the core of the sodium D1_11​ line that is expected to be intrinsically unpolarizable. To resolve this problem the underlying physics was later explored in the laboratory for D1_11​ scattering at potassium vapor. The experiment showed that the scattering phase matrix element P21P_{21}P21​ is positive while P22P_{22}P22​ is negative, although standard quantum scattering theory predicts that both should be zero. This experimental contradiction is currently the main manifestation of the D1_11​ enigma. Subsequent theoretical studies showed that such polarization effects may arise if scattering theory is extended to allow for interference effects due to level splittings of the ground state, in contrast to standard scattering theory, which only allows for interferences from level splittings of the intermediate state. Previous attempts to implement this idea had to rely on heuristic arguments to allow modeling of the experimental data. In the present paper we develop a formulation of the theory that can be self-consistently applied to quantum systems with any combination of electronic and nuclear spins. No statistical equilibrium or optical pumping is needed. The atom is assumed to be unpolarized at the beginning of each scattering event. The theory is capable of explaining both the phase matrix behavior of the laboratory data and the existence of a symmetric polarization peak in the core of the solar D1_11​ line. We also use it to predict the polarization structures that we expect to see in a next-generation laboratory experiment with the rubidium isotopes 87^{87}87Rb and 85^{85}85Rb.
The symmetric peak observed in linear polarization in the core of the solar sodium D 1 line at 5896 Å has remained enigmatic since its discovery nearly two decades ago. One reason is that the theory of polarized scattering has not been experimentally tested for multi-level atomic systems in the relevant parameter domains, although the theory is continually being used for the interpretation of astrophysical observations. A laboratory experiment that was set up a decade ago to find out whether the D 1 enigma is a problem of solar physics or quantum physics revealed that the D 1 system has a rich polarization structure in situations where standard scattering theory predicts zero polarization, even when optical pumping of the m state populations of the hyperfine-split ground state is accounted for. Here we show that the laboratory results can be modeled in great quantitative detail if the theory is extended to include the coherences in both the initial and final states of the scattering process. Radiative couplings between the allowed dipole transitions generate coherences in the initial state. Corresponding coherences in the final state are then demanded by a phase closure selection rule. The experimental results for the well understood D 2 line are used to constrain the two free parameters of the experiment, collision rate and optical depth, to suppress the need for free parameters when fitting the D 1 results.
The polarization that is generated by scattering of light on atoms depends on the atomic quantum number structure. According to standard scattering theory the sodium D1 (5896 A) and potassium D1 (7699 A) lines should be intrinsically unpolarizable. Since however the existence of D1 scattering polarization in the solar spectrum has been well documented but resisted theoretical explanations, we have carried out a laboratory experiment to find out if this is a problem of solar physics or of quantum physics. We find that the polarization matrix for scattering of the Stokes vector in the potassium D1 line exhibits a rich structure that changes dramatically when the field strength is varied in the sub-gauss regime. In contrast, standard scattering theory predicts zero polarization, even when optical pumping of the magnetic sub-levels of the hyperfine structure multiplet is accounted for.
Abstract The extensive literature on the physics of polarized scattering may give the impression that we have a solid theoretical foundation for the interpretation of spectro-polarimetric data. This theoretical framework has however not been sufficiently tested by experiments under controlled conditions. While the solar atmosphere may be viewed as a physics laboratory, the observed solar polarization depends on too many environmental factors that are beyond our control. The existence of a symmetric polarization peak at the center of the solar Na D1 line has remained an enigma for two decades, in spite of persistent efforts to explain it with available quantum theory. A decade ago a laboratory experiment was set up to determine whether this was a problem for solar physics or quantum physics. The experiment revealed a rich polarization structure of D1 scattering, although available quantum theory predicted null results. It has now finally been possible to formulate a well-defined and self-consistent extension of the theory of quantum scattering that can reproduce in great quantitative detail the main polarization structures that were found in the laboratory experiment. Here we give a brief overview of the new physical ingredients that were missing before. The extended theory reveals that multi-level atomic systems have a far richer coherence structure than previously believed.
The complete and exact calculation of the observable polarization of alkali d-line emission, in the case of axial–recoil excitation, is presented and discussed. First, the formalism developed allows the differentiation of different symmetries and different angular momentum coupling schemes for the quasimolecular parent state. Second, the theory of Percival and Seaton is adapted to allow the computation of the effect of hyperfine precessional dephasing of the initial atomic state on the Zeeman Radiation Pattern of the final emission. Third, from scattering experiments performed in our laboratory we are able for the first time to introduce the effect of the distrubution of axes of quantization for the particular case of the excitation of rubidium in crossed beams with N2N_{2}N2​. The dipole radiation distribution and natural isotope abudance effects are included in the final polorization fraction. The exact results are tabulated for sample calculations; nuclear spin I=3/2 (Na, K, Rb) and I=5/2 (Rb). And the second order nuclear quadrupole effects are demonstrated to be of less importance than accurate values of the relative lifetimes. Polarizations computed with this method are compared with recent measurements and calculations for rare gas alkali-ion scattering emission. The method is also used to discuss recently measured anisotropies in resonance enhanced photoionization electron distributions and photo-dissociation hot atom recoil.
A theory is derived to predict the density matrices describing two atoms after a spin-exchange collision from the density matrices before the collision and the scattering amplitude for binary collisions. This theory is then applied to a system of quasifree electrons interacting with optically pumped rubidium atoms. For calculating the change in the electron density matrix, the Rb85{\mathrm{Rb}}^{85}Rb85 and Rb87{\mathrm{Rb}}^{87}Rb87 are replaced by a fictitious rubidium isotope with no nuclear spin. Expressions are derived for the change in the light transmission when a radiofrequency field is present at the electron frequency. In addition to the linewidth for the electron signal, the spin-exchange theory predicts a frequency shift the magnitude of which depends upon the two-body scattering amplitude, the rubidium polarization and the rubidium density. Experiments performed to test various aspects of the theory are then reported. The measurements were made on a system of quasifree electrons interacting with rubidium atoms. Measurements of the electron linewidth as a function of temperature indicated that spin-exchange collisions dominated the electron relaxation. The predicted frequency shift was measured by observing the electron resonance frequency first with left circularly polarized light and then with right circularly polarized light. For electrons colliding with rubidium atoms the shift is negative when the rubidium polarization is positive and the ratio of the shift to the linewidth is $\frac{\ensuremath{\delta}{\ensuremath{\nu}}_{0}}{\ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\nu}}=\ensuremath{-}0.025\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.005$. From the measured values of the shift and the linewidth, a value is derived for the electron-rubidium spin-flip cross section. In one Appendix the replacement of the Rb85{\mathrm{Rb}}^{85}Rb85 and Rb87{\mathrm{Rb}}^{87}Rb87 by the fictitious rubidium isotope with no nuclear spin is justified. In a second Appendix the calculations for the simple electron-rubidium system are generalized and applied to more complicated systems. Results are reported for the change in the density matrix of hydrogen atoms when they collide with polarized electrons, the change in the density matrix of Rb87{\mathrm{Rb}}^{87}Rb87 atoms when they collide with polarized electrons, and the change in the density matrix of hydrogen atoms when they collide with hydrogen atoms.
Optical experiments in alkali-metal atomic gases are usually interpreted in terms of the J=1/2 ground state, treating the electronic ground state as a degenerate two-level system. While this simplified level scheme has been quite successful in describing many experimental results, the nuclear spin can lead to significant modifications of the behavior. Apart from the obvious differences, such as the existence of hyperfine splitting, some more subtle effects are present that modify the dynamical as well as the equilibrium behavior of the system. An an example, the optical pumping process in the true atomic ground state is nonexponential and slower by at least an order of magnitude, compared to a hypothetical atom with nuclear spin zero. The limitations of the J=1/2 model are analyzed theoretically and experimentally for atomic sodium, and experimental methods are demonstrated that can help disentangle the contributions from different hyperfine components.