Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.09251

Kelvin Waves and Dynamic Knots on Vortex-Membrane

Su-Peng Kou

Published Oct 21, 2016• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum mechanics is a successful theory that describes the behavior of photons, electrons, and other atomic- and molecular-scale objects. However, it is far from being well understood. In this paper, a new theory - knot physics for entangled vortex-membranes is developed to explore the underline physics of quantum mechanics. From point view of information, three dimensional quantum Dirac model is developed to effectively describe the fluctuations of local deformation of vortex-membranes: The elementary excitations are knots with information unit; The physics quality to describe local deformation is knot density that is defined by the density of zeros between two projected vortex-membranes; The Biot-Savart equation for Kelvin waves becomes Schrodinger equation for probability waves of knots; the classical functions for perturbative Kelvin waves become wave functions for knots; The probability of quantum mechanics comes from dynamic projection for inner observers owing to "fast clock" effect; The angular frequency for leapfrogging motion plays the role of the mass of knots; etc. This work would help people to understand the mystery of quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1610.09251

Related papers

Emergent Quantum Dynamics of Vortex-Line under Linear Local Induction Approximation*

Gui-Hao Jia, Yu Xu, Xiao Kong +3 more

Using the linear local induction approximation, we investigate the self-induced motion of a vortex-line that corresponds to the motion of a particle in quantum mechanics. Provided Kelvin waves, the effective Schrödinger equation, physical quantity operators, and the corresponding path-integral formula can be obtained. In particular, the effective Planck constant defined by parameters of vortex-line motion shows the mathematical relation between the two fields. The vortexline–particle mapping may help in understanding particle motion in quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1810.01358•Chinese Physics Letters•Dec 1, 2019•0 citations

QUANTUM-LIKE PROPERTIES OF KNOTS AND LINKS

Andrzej Stasiak

Knot theory was boosted in its development when in 1860ties Kelvin proposed that knots made out of vortex lines of ether constitute elementary particles of matter. Tait and other associates of Kelvin started to catalogue various types of knots with a hope to create a periodic table of knots which would correspond to periodic tables of chemical elements. However, development of atomic physics, first with classical and then with quantum models of atoms failed to show a connection between knots and atoms. More recently, though, the superstring theory revived the idea that knots can be relevant to understanding elementary particles. Studying ideal geometric configuration of knots we noticed that their writhe is quantized into units of 4/7 and 10/7 whereby the total writhe of a knot is determined by a simple arithmetic sum of four elementary types of crossings which need to be "removed" to convert a standard minimal crossing diagram of a given knot into a diagram of a trivial knot without nugatory crossings. There are parallel and antiparallel crossings of positive and negative sign. Interestingly parallel and antiparallel crossings of the same sign show frequently superposition of states. This resembles the quantum properties of elementary particles and their known superposition principle. A model of physical knotted systems is discussed which can change energy states by adopting discrete shapes with associated discrete energies whereby the writhe difference between any two discrete shapes is n*constant.

Knots in Hellas•Sep 1, 2000•2 citations

Motion of vortex lines in quantum mechanics

Cezary Śliwa, Iwo Białynicki‐Birula, Zofia Białynicka-Birula +1 more

In quantum theory, vortex lines arise in the hydrodynamic interpretation of the wave equation. In this interpretation, which is originally due to Madelung, the flow of the probability density for a single particle is described in terms of the hydrodynamic variables. For the sake of simplicity, the standard time-dependent Schrödinger equation, and the related vortex lines embedded in the probability fluid of the quantum particle, are considered here. A vortex line in this case is simply the curve defined by equating the wave function to zero. The linearity of the Schrödinger equation enables us to obtain a large family of exact time-dependent analytic solutions for the wave functions with vortex lines. Moreover, the method is general enough to allow for various initial configurations of the vortex lines. Although the equation of motion of the quantum mechanical probability fluid is different in its literal form from the equations describing the real physical fluid, we believe that the evolution of the vorticity in the quantum and in the real fluid share the same qualitative features that can be described in terms of the topology of the vortex lines configurations. The general phenomena such as the switch-over, creation and annihilation of vortices can be observed in the quantum mechanical fluid. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Kluwer Academic Publishers eBooks•Dec 16, 2005•0 citations

Long-Lived Quantum Vortex Knots

V. P. Ruban

The dynamics of the simplest torus quantum vortex knots in a superfluid at zero temperature has been simulated with a regularized Biot–Savart law (the torus radii R 0 and r 0 for the initial vortex configuration are much larger than the width of the vortex core ). The evolution times of knots until their significant deformation have been calculated with a small step in the parameter B 0 = r 0 / R 0 for different values of the parameter Λ = log( R 0 /ξ). It has been found that regions of quasi-stability appear at Λ ≳ 3 in the range B 0 ≲ 0.2, which correspond to long knot lifetimes and very large traveling distances up to several hundred R 0 . This result is new and quite surprising because previously it was believed that the maximum lifetime of torus knots until reconnection does not exceed several typical periods. The opening of quasi-stable “windows” at increasing Λ is due to narrowing of main parametric resonances of the dynamic system in the parameter B 0 .

arXiv:1801.04822•Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Mar 1, 2018•7 citations

Reconstructing Quantum Mechanics: A Vortex-Based Replacement for Schrödinger’s Equation

Nader Butto

This article proposes a deterministic and geometrically grounded reformulation of quantum mechanics based on vortex dynamics in a structured, superfluid-like vacuum. Modeling the electron as a self-sustaining irrotational vortex with both internal rotation and external translation, the framework derives fundamental quantum phenomena—including de Broglie wavelength, Compton wavelength, spin, and quantization—directly from physical principles of motion and vacuum geometry. A generalized wave function is introduced, embedding both translational and rotational phase components, leading to a modified Schrödinger-like equation that naturally incorporates internal angular momentum. Interference, tunneling, and entanglement are reinterpreted as emergent behaviors of coherent vortex trajectories, eliminating the need for wavefunction collapse or intrinsic randomness. The Born rule is shown to arise from deterministic mechanisms such as phase averaging, internal oscillations, and ergodic dynamics. This vortex model aligns with classical, quantum, and relativistic principles, resolves key interpretational paradoxes, and offers a unified, causal framework for understanding quantum phenomena as structured motion within a physically real vacuum.

Journal of High Energy Physics Gravitation and Cosmology•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Non-Hamiltonian Kelvin wave generation on vortices in Bose-Einstein condensates

Strong, Scott A., Lincoln D. Carr

Ultra-cold quantum turbulence is expected to decay through a cascade of Kelvin waves. These helical excitations couple vorticity to the quantum fluid causing long wavelength phonon fluctuations in a Bose-Einstein condensate. This interaction is hypothesized to be the route to relaxation for turbulent tangles in quantum hydrodynamics. The local induction approximation is the lowest order approximation to the Biot-Savart velocity field induced by a vortex line and, because of its integrability, is thought to prohibit energy transfer by Kelvin waves. Using the Biot-Savart description, we derive a generalization to the local induction approximation which predicts that regions of large curvature can reconfigure themselves as Kelvin wave packets. While this generalization preserves the arclength metric, a quantity conserved under the Eulerian flow of vortex lines, it also introduces a non-Hamiltonian structure on the geometric properties of the vortex line. It is this non-Hamiltonian evolution of curvature and torsion which provides a resolution to the missing Kelvin wave motion. In this work, we derive corrections to the local induction approximation in powers of curvature and state them for utilization in vortex filament methods. Using the Hasimoto transformation, we arrive at a nonlinear integro-differential equation which reduces to a modified nonlinear Schrödinger type evolution of the curvature and torsion on the vortex line. We show that this modification seeks to disperse localized curvature profiles. At the same time, the non-Hamiltonian break in integrability bolsters the deforming curvature profile and simulations show that this dynamic results in Kelvin wave propagation along the dispersive vortex medium.

arXiv:1803.00147•Mar 1, 2018•2 citations
Quantum mechanics is a successful theory that describes the behavior of photons, electrons, and other atomic- and molecular-scale objects. However, it is far from being well understood. In this paper, a new theory - knot physics for entangled vortex-membranes is developed to explore the underline physics of quantum mechanics. From point view of information, three dimensional quantum Dirac model is developed to effectively describe the fluctuations of local deformation of vortex-membranes: The elementary excitations are knots with information unit; The physics quality to describe local deformation is knot density that is defined by the density of zeros between two projected vortex-membranes; The Biot-Savart equation for Kelvin waves becomes Schrodinger equation for probability waves of knots; the classical functions for perturbative Kelvin waves become wave functions for knots; The probability of quantum mechanics comes from dynamic projection for inner observers owing to "fast clock" effect; The angular frequency for leapfrogging motion plays the role of the mass of knots; etc. This work would help people to understand the mystery of quantum mechanics.
Using the linear local induction approximation, we investigate the self-induced motion of a vortex-line that corresponds to the motion of a particle in quantum mechanics. Provided Kelvin waves, the effective Schrödinger equation, physical quantity operators, and the corresponding path-integral formula can be obtained. In particular, the effective Planck constant defined by parameters of vortex-line motion shows the mathematical relation between the two fields. The vortexline–particle mapping may help in understanding particle motion in quantum mechanics.
Knot theory was boosted in its development when in 1860ties Kelvin proposed that knots made out of vortex lines of ether constitute elementary particles of matter. Tait and other associates of Kelvin started to catalogue various types of knots with a hope to create a periodic table of knots which would correspond to periodic tables of chemical elements. However, development of atomic physics, first with classical and then with quantum models of atoms failed to show a connection between knots and atoms. More recently, though, the superstring theory revived the idea that knots can be relevant to understanding elementary particles. Studying ideal geometric configuration of knots we noticed that their writhe is quantized into units of 4/7 and 10/7 whereby the total writhe of a knot is determined by a simple arithmetic sum of four elementary types of crossings which need to be "removed" to convert a standard minimal crossing diagram of a given knot into a diagram of a trivial knot without nugatory crossings. There are parallel and antiparallel crossings of positive and negative sign. Interestingly parallel and antiparallel crossings of the same sign show frequently superposition of states. This resembles the quantum properties of elementary particles and their known superposition principle. A model of physical knotted systems is discussed which can change energy states by adopting discrete shapes with associated discrete energies whereby the writhe difference between any two discrete shapes is n*constant.
In quantum theory, vortex lines arise in the hydrodynamic interpretation of the wave equation. In this interpretation, which is originally due to Madelung, the flow of the probability density for a single particle is described in terms of the hydrodynamic variables. For the sake of simplicity, the standard time-dependent Schrödinger equation, and the related vortex lines embedded in the probability fluid of the quantum particle, are considered here. A vortex line in this case is simply the curve defined by equating the wave function to zero. The linearity of the Schrödinger equation enables us to obtain a large family of exact time-dependent analytic solutions for the wave functions with vortex lines. Moreover, the method is general enough to allow for various initial configurations of the vortex lines. Although the equation of motion of the quantum mechanical probability fluid is different in its literal form from the equations describing the real physical fluid, we believe that the evolution of the vorticity in the quantum and in the real fluid share the same qualitative features that can be described in terms of the topology of the vortex lines configurations. The general phenomena such as the switch-over, creation and annihilation of vortices can be observed in the quantum mechanical fluid. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
The dynamics of the simplest torus quantum vortex knots in a superfluid at zero temperature has been simulated with a regularized Biot–Savart law (the torus radii R 0 and r 0 for the initial vortex configuration are much larger than the width of the vortex core ). The evolution times of knots until their significant deformation have been calculated with a small step in the parameter B 0 = r 0 / R 0 for different values of the parameter Λ = log( R 0 /ξ). It has been found that regions of quasi-stability appear at Λ ≳ 3 in the range B 0 ≲ 0.2, which correspond to long knot lifetimes and very large traveling distances up to several hundred R 0 . This result is new and quite surprising because previously it was believed that the maximum lifetime of torus knots until reconnection does not exceed several typical periods. The opening of quasi-stable “windows” at increasing Λ is due to narrowing of main parametric resonances of the dynamic system in the parameter B 0 .
This article proposes a deterministic and geometrically grounded reformulation of quantum mechanics based on vortex dynamics in a structured, superfluid-like vacuum. Modeling the electron as a self-sustaining irrotational vortex with both internal rotation and external translation, the framework derives fundamental quantum phenomena—including de Broglie wavelength, Compton wavelength, spin, and quantization—directly from physical principles of motion and vacuum geometry. A generalized wave function is introduced, embedding both translational and rotational phase components, leading to a modified Schrödinger-like equation that naturally incorporates internal angular momentum. Interference, tunneling, and entanglement are reinterpreted as emergent behaviors of coherent vortex trajectories, eliminating the need for wavefunction collapse or intrinsic randomness. The Born rule is shown to arise from deterministic mechanisms such as phase averaging, internal oscillations, and ergodic dynamics. This vortex model aligns with classical, quantum, and relativistic principles, resolves key interpretational paradoxes, and offers a unified, causal framework for understanding quantum phenomena as structured motion within a physically real vacuum.
Ultra-cold quantum turbulence is expected to decay through a cascade of Kelvin waves. These helical excitations couple vorticity to the quantum fluid causing long wavelength phonon fluctuations in a Bose-Einstein condensate. This interaction is hypothesized to be the route to relaxation for turbulent tangles in quantum hydrodynamics. The local induction approximation is the lowest order approximation to the Biot-Savart velocity field induced by a vortex line and, because of its integrability, is thought to prohibit energy transfer by Kelvin waves. Using the Biot-Savart description, we derive a generalization to the local induction approximation which predicts that regions of large curvature can reconfigure themselves as Kelvin wave packets. While this generalization preserves the arclength metric, a quantity conserved under the Eulerian flow of vortex lines, it also introduces a non-Hamiltonian structure on the geometric properties of the vortex line. It is this non-Hamiltonian evolution of curvature and torsion which provides a resolution to the missing Kelvin wave motion. In this work, we derive corrections to the local induction approximation in powers of curvature and state them for utilization in vortex filament methods. Using the Hasimoto transformation, we arrive at a nonlinear integro-differential equation which reduces to a modified nonlinear Schrödinger type evolution of the curvature and torsion on the vortex line. We show that this modification seeks to disperse localized curvature profiles. At the same time, the non-Hamiltonian break in integrability bolsters the deforming curvature profile and simulations show that this dynamic results in Kelvin wave propagation along the dispersive vortex medium.