Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.07130 · Quanta

Quantum Trajectories: Dirac, Moyal and Bohm

Basil J. Hiley, Maurice A. de Gosson, Glen Dennis

Published Jun 5, 2019• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We recall Dirac's early proposals to develop a description of quantum phenomena in terms of a non-commutative algebra in which he suggested a way to construct what he called quantum trajectories. Generalising these ideas, we show how they are related to weak values and explore their use in the experimental construction of quantum trajectories. We discuss covering spaces which play an essential role in accounting for the wave properties of quantum particles. We briefly point out how new mathematical techniques take us beyond Hilbert space and into a deeper structure which connects with the algebras originally introduced by Born, Heisenberg and Jordan. This enables us to bring out the geometric aspects of quantum phenomena. Quanta 2019; 8: 11–23.

DOI
10.12743/quanta.v8i1.84

Related papers

Dirac, Bohm and the Algebraic Approach

Basil J. Hiley, Glen Dennis

In this paper we show how Dirac, in 1947, anticipated the Bohm approach using an argument based on what is now called the Heisenberg picture. From a detailed examination of these ideas, we show that the role played by the Dirac standard ket is equivalent to the introduction and use of the idempotent in the orthogonal and symplectic Clifford algebras. This formalism is then used to show that the so-called `Bohm trajectories' are the average of an ensemble of individual stochastic Feynman paths. Since the Bohm approach can be simply reduced to classical mechanics, the algebraic formalism presented here provides a natural way to relate quantum mechanics to classical mechanics without the need for decoherence. We show that this approach suggests an underlying fractal space-time of the type discussed by Nottale.

arXiv:1901.01979•Jan 5, 2019•3 citations

Foundations of Quantum Theory in the Light of Bohmian Non-commutative Dynamics

Basil J. Hiley

In this paper we discuss the notion of a ‘particle’ and its ‘trajectory’ in the Bohm approach to quantum theory in the context of a non-commutative dynamics which has classical mechanics as a commutative sub-algebra. We study the von Neumann-Moyal algebra and show that the key equations used in the Bohm approach are already contained within this structure. They appear as projections from the non-commutative phase space into space-time. This structure leads us to a more radical view of quantum processes involving individual particles.

•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

The role of geometric and dynamical phases in the Dirac–Bohm picture

Basil J. Hiley, Glen Dennis, Maurice A. de Gosson

In this paper we explore a different but unitarily equivalent picture to the standard Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures, namely the Dirac–Bohm picture introduced by Hiley and Dennis. This is not merely another interpretation as it allows us to examine the unfolding quantum process in terms of the algebraic structure of the dynamical variables, which in turn allows us to explore the geometric implications of quantum phenomena. Furthermore this enables us to exploit the double valued nature of the orthogonal and symplectic symmetry groups and show how they profoundly affect the nature of the conjugate momentum by enabling the introduction of classes of vector potentials into Hamiltonian systems. This throws more light on the significance of gauge invariance both in classical and quantum mechanics. The connection with geometric aspects of quantum phenomena allows us to introduce Clifford algebras in a natural way so that it is possible to extend the Dirac–Bohm approach to include spin and relativity, offering new geometric insights into quantum phenomena. In particular the bi-vector aspects allow us to introduce the Gromov non-squeezing theorem in a new way, ultimately offering the possibility of relating our work to the non-commutative geometry of M-theory.

Annals of Physics•Jan 24, 2022•3 citations

PHASE SPACE DESCRIPTION OF QUANTUM MECHANICS AND NON-COMMUTATIVE GEOMETRY: WINGNER–MOYAL AND BOHM IN A WIDER CONTEXT

Basil J. Hiley

In this paper we approach the question of the existence of a (x, p) phase space in a new way. Rather than abandoning all hope of constructing such a phase-space for quantum phenomena, we take aspects from both the Wigner-Moyal and Bohm approaches and show that although there is no unique phase space, we can form ‘shadow’ phase spaces. We then argue that this is a consequence of the non-commutative geometry defined by the operator algebra.

Beyond the Quantum•Sep 1, 2007•3 citations

The Moyal-Dirac controversy revisited

Basil J. Hiley

In this paper we revisit the controversy that arose between Paul Dirac and Joe Moyal.Our motivation is provided by the fact that the algebraic aspects of both their approaches are becoming more appreciated as interest in the development of non-commutative geometry's attempt to "geometrise" quantum mechanics grows.Both were seeking to understand the role of non-commutativity, Moyal from a consideration of the differences between classical and quantum statistics, while Dirac was exploring its implications for the dynamics.The disagreement arose essentially over which should be given priority, the dynamics or the statistics.We will provide the background to show that both are essential aspects of the same overall mathematical structure. IntroductionN this paper I want to focus on the controversy that arose between Paul Dirac and Joe Moyal as a consequence of their different proposals for developing a phase space approach to quantum theory.This controversy gets to the heart of the fundamental problems in the description of quantum phenomena.Interestingly Dirac and Moyal were both "outsiders" in the sense that they started out as engineers, more so Moyal because of the way he entered academia, a story beautifully told in a biography penned by his wife Ann Moyal (2006).! We pick up the story when Moyal was working in the Meteorological branch of the Ministére de |'Air in Paris at the outbreak of World War IJ.In the ensuing chaos, he managed to escape to England and was eventually given a job at the de Havilland Aircraft Company where he became the Assistant Director of the wartime Vibrations Department.After the war Moyal wanted to work in quantum physics when fortunately an opportunity arose for him to enter academia by becoming an assistant lecturer in the Department of Mathematical Physics at Queen's University Belfast.It was there in 1949 that he published his classic paper which is the focus of his disagreement with Dirac.This disagreement involves the question as how best to develop a (p, x,t) phase space formulation for quantum phenomena, the well-recognised difficulty arising from the non-commutativity of the quantum observables for momentum and position.In other words, if we replace the classical variables, (p,x), by operators, or rather 1. See also Moyal (2017).[Ed.]

Journal and proceedings of the Royal Society of New South Wales•Dec 1, 2021•1 citation

Non-dynamical quantum trajectories

Timothy M. Coffey

Commonly held opinion is that particle trajectory descriptions are incompatible with quantum mechanics. Louis de Broglie (1926) first proposed a way to include trajectories in quantum mechanics, but the idea was abandoned until David Bohm (1952) re-invented and improved the theory. Bohm interprets the particle trajectories as physically real; for example, an electron actually is a particle moving on a well defined trajectory with a position and momentum at all times. By design, Bohm's trajectories never make predictions that differ from standard quantum mechanics, and their existence cannot be experimentally verified. \n \n \n \nThree new methods to obtain Bohm's particle trajectories are presented. The methods are non-dynamical, and utilize none of Bohm's equations of motion; in fact, two of the methods have no equations for a particle's trajectory. Instead, all three methods use only the evolving probability density ρ=ψ*ψ to extract the trajectories. The first two methods rest upon probability conservation and density sampling, while the third method employs the informational or geometrical construction of centroidal Voronoi tessellations. In one-dimension all three methods are proved to be equivalent to Bohm's particle trajectories. For higher dimensional configuration spaces, the first two methods can be used in limited situations, but the last method can be applied in all cases. Typically, the resulting higher dimensional non-dynamical trajectories are also identical to Bohm. \n \n \n \nTogether the three methods point to a new interpretation of Bohm's particle trajectories, namely, the Bohm trajectories are simply a kinematic portrayal of the evolution of the probability density. In addition, the new methods can be used to measure Schrödinger's wave function and Planck's constant.

•Dec 1, 2010•0 citations
We recall Dirac's early proposals to develop a description of quantum phenomena in terms of a non-commutative algebra in which he suggested a way to construct what he called quantum trajectories. Generalising these ideas, we show how they are related to weak values and explore their use in the experimental construction of quantum trajectories. We discuss covering spaces which play an essential role in accounting for the wave properties of quantum particles. We briefly point out how new mathematical techniques take us beyond Hilbert space and into a deeper structure which connects with the algebras originally introduced by Born, Heisenberg and Jordan. This enables us to bring out the geometric aspects of quantum phenomena. Quanta 2019; 8: 11–23.
In this paper we show how Dirac, in 1947, anticipated the Bohm approach using an argument based on what is now called the Heisenberg picture. From a detailed examination of these ideas, we show that the role played by the Dirac standard ket is equivalent to the introduction and use of the idempotent in the orthogonal and symplectic Clifford algebras. This formalism is then used to show that the so-called `Bohm trajectories' are the average of an ensemble of individual stochastic Feynman paths. Since the Bohm approach can be simply reduced to classical mechanics, the algebraic formalism presented here provides a natural way to relate quantum mechanics to classical mechanics without the need for decoherence. We show that this approach suggests an underlying fractal space-time of the type discussed by Nottale.
In this paper we discuss the notion of a ‘particle’ and its ‘trajectory’ in the Bohm approach to quantum theory in the context of a non-commutative dynamics which has classical mechanics as a commutative sub-algebra. We study the von Neumann-Moyal algebra and show that the key equations used in the Bohm approach are already contained within this structure. They appear as projections from the non-commutative phase space into space-time. This structure leads us to a more radical view of quantum processes involving individual particles.
In this paper we explore a different but unitarily equivalent picture to the standard Schrödinger and Heisenberg pictures, namely the Dirac–Bohm picture introduced by Hiley and Dennis. This is not merely another interpretation as it allows us to examine the unfolding quantum process in terms of the algebraic structure of the dynamical variables, which in turn allows us to explore the geometric implications of quantum phenomena. Furthermore this enables us to exploit the double valued nature of the orthogonal and symplectic symmetry groups and show how they profoundly affect the nature of the conjugate momentum by enabling the introduction of classes of vector potentials into Hamiltonian systems. This throws more light on the significance of gauge invariance both in classical and quantum mechanics. The connection with geometric aspects of quantum phenomena allows us to introduce Clifford algebras in a natural way so that it is possible to extend the Dirac–Bohm approach to include spin and relativity, offering new geometric insights into quantum phenomena. In particular the bi-vector aspects allow us to introduce the Gromov non-squeezing theorem in a new way, ultimately offering the possibility of relating our work to the non-commutative geometry of M-theory.
In this paper we revisit the controversy that arose between Paul Dirac and Joe Moyal.Our motivation is provided by the fact that the algebraic aspects of both their approaches are becoming more appreciated as interest in the development of non-commutative geometry's attempt to "geometrise" quantum mechanics grows.Both were seeking to understand the role of non-commutativity, Moyal from a consideration of the differences between classical and quantum statistics, while Dirac was exploring its implications for the dynamics.The disagreement arose essentially over which should be given priority, the dynamics or the statistics.We will provide the background to show that both are essential aspects of the same overall mathematical structure. IntroductionN this paper I want to focus on the controversy that arose between Paul Dirac and Joe Moyal as a consequence of their different proposals for developing a phase space approach to quantum theory.This controversy gets to the heart of the fundamental problems in the description of quantum phenomena.Interestingly Dirac and Moyal were both "outsiders" in the sense that they started out as engineers, more so Moyal because of the way he entered academia, a story beautifully told in a biography penned by his wife Ann Moyal (2006).! We pick up the story when Moyal was working in the Meteorological branch of the Ministére de |'Air in Paris at the outbreak of World War IJ.In the ensuing chaos, he managed to escape to England and was eventually given a job at the de Havilland Aircraft Company where he became the Assistant Director of the wartime Vibrations Department.After the war Moyal wanted to work in quantum physics when fortunately an opportunity arose for him to enter academia by becoming an assistant lecturer in the Department of Mathematical Physics at Queen's University Belfast.It was there in 1949 that he published his classic paper which is the focus of his disagreement with Dirac.This disagreement involves the question as how best to develop a (p, x,t) phase space formulation for quantum phenomena, the well-recognised difficulty arising from the non-commutativity of the quantum observables for momentum and position.In other words, if we replace the classical variables, (p,x), by operators, or rather 1. See also Moyal (2017).[Ed.]
Commonly held opinion is that particle trajectory descriptions are incompatible with quantum mechanics. Louis de Broglie (1926) first proposed a way to include trajectories in quantum mechanics, but the idea was abandoned until David Bohm (1952) re-invented and improved the theory. Bohm interprets the particle trajectories as physically real; for example, an electron actually is a particle moving on a well defined trajectory with a position and momentum at all times. By design, Bohm's trajectories never make predictions that differ from standard quantum mechanics, and their existence cannot be experimentally verified. \n \n \n \nThree new methods to obtain Bohm's particle trajectories are presented. The methods are non-dynamical, and utilize none of Bohm's equations of motion; in fact, two of the methods have no equations for a particle's trajectory. Instead, all three methods use only the evolving probability density ρ=ψ*ψ to extract the trajectories. The first two methods rest upon probability conservation and density sampling, while the third method employs the informational or geometrical construction of centroidal Voronoi tessellations. In one-dimension all three methods are proved to be equivalent to Bohm's particle trajectories. For higher dimensional configuration spaces, the first two methods can be used in limited situations, but the last method can be applied in all cases. Typically, the resulting higher dimensional non-dynamical trajectories are also identical to Bohm. \n \n \n \nTogether the three methods point to a new interpretation of Bohm's particle trajectories, namely, the Bohm trajectories are simply a kinematic portrayal of the evolution of the probability density. In addition, the new methods can be used to measure Schrödinger's wave function and Planck's constant.