Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.03566 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Ferromagnetism beyond Lieb's theorem

Natanael C. Costa, Tiago Mendes-Santos, Thereza Paiva, Raimundo R. dos Santos, Richard T. Scalettar

Published Oct 6, 2016• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The noninteracting electronic structures of tight-binding models on bipartite lattices with unequal numbers of sites in the two sublattices have a number of unique features, including the presence of spatially localized eigenstates and flat bands. When a uniform on-site Hubbard interaction $U$ is turned on, Lieb proved rigorously that at half-filling ($\ensuremath{\rho}=1$) the ground state has a nonzero spin. In this paper we consider a ``${\mathrm{CuO}}_{2}$ lattice'' (also known as ``Lieb lattice,'' or as a decorated square lattice), in which ``$d$ orbitals'' occupy the vertices of the squares, while ``$p$ orbitals'' lie halfway between two $d$ orbitals; both $d$ and $p$ orbitals can accommodate only up to two electrons. We use exact determinant quantum Monte Carlo (DQMC) simulations to quantify the nature of magnetic order through the behavior of correlation functions and sublattice magnetizations in the different orbitals as a function of $U$ and temperature; we have also calculated the projected density of states, and the compressibility. We study both the homogeneous (H) case, ${U}_{d}={U}_{p}$, originally considered by Lieb, and the inhomogeneous (IH) case, ${U}_{d}\ensuremath{\ne}{U}_{p}$. For the H case at half-filling, we found that the global magnetization rises sharply at weak coupling, and then stabilizes towards the strong-coupling (Heisenberg) value, as a result of the interplay between the ferromagnetism of like sites and the antiferromagnetism between unlike sites; we verified that the system is an insulator for all $U$. For the IH system at half-filling, we argue that the case ${U}_{p}\ensuremath{\ne}{U}_{d}$ falls under Lieb's theorem, provided they are positive definite, so we used DQMC to probe the cases ${U}_{p}=0,{U}_{d}=U$ and ${U}_{p}=U,{U}_{d}=0$. We found that the different environments of $d$ and $p$ sites lead to a ferromagnetic insulator when ${U}_{d}=0$; by contrast, ${U}_{p}=0$ leads to to a metal without any magnetic ordering. In addition, we have also established that at density $\ensuremath{\rho}=1/3$, strong antiferromagnetic correlations set in, caused by the presence of one fermion on each $d$ site.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.94.155107

Related papers

Superconducting transitions in flat-band systems

Vladimir Iglovikov, F. Hébert, Benoît Grémaud +2 more

The physics of strongly correlated quantum particles within a flat band was originally explored as a route to itinerant ferromagnetism and, indeed, a celebrated theorem by Lieb rigorously establishes that the ground state of the repulsive Hubbard model on a bipartite lattice with an unequal number of sites in each sublattice must have nonzero spin $S$ at half filling. Recently, there has been interest in Lieb geometries due to the possibility of topological insulator, nematic, and Bose-Einstein condensed (BEC) phases. In this paper, we extend the understanding of the attractive Hubbard model on the Lieb lattice by using determinant quantum Monte Carlo to study real space charge and pair correlation functions not addressed by the Lieb theorems. Specifically, our results show unusual charge and charge transfer signatures within the flat band, and a reduction in pairing order at $\ensuremath{\rho}=2/3$ and $\ensuremath{\rho}=4/3$, the points at which the flat band is first occupied and then completely filled. We compare our results to the case of flat bands in the Kagome lattice and demonstrate that the behavior observed in the two cases is rather different.

arXiv:1404.5482•Physical Review B•Sep 11, 2014•115 citations

A DMRG study of the half-filled Hubbard model on a Bethe lattice: a signature of the Mott-Hubbard transition

Marie-Bernadette Lepetit, Maixent Cousy

The half-filled Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice with coordination number $z=3$ is studied using the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method. Ground-state properties such as the energy $E$, average local magnetization $ $, its fluctuations $ - ^2$ and various spin correlation functions $ - $ are determined as a function of the Coulomb interaction strength $U/t$. The calculated local magnetic moments $ $ increase monotonically with increasing Coulomb repulsion $U/t$ forming an antiferromagnetic spin-density-wave state which matches the two sublattices of the bipartite Bethe lattice. At large $U/t$, $ $ is strongly reduced with respect to the saturation value 1/2 due to exchange fluctuations between nearest neighbors (NN) spins ($| |\simeq 0.35$ for $U/t\to +\infty$). $ - ^2$ shows a maximum for $U/t=2.4$--2.9 which results from the interplay between the usual increase of $ $ with increasing $U/t$ and the formation of important permanent moments $ $ at large $U/t$. NN sites show antiferromagnetic spin correlations which increase with increasing Coulomb repulsion. In contrast next NN sites are very weakly correlated over the whole range of $U/t$. The accuracy of the DMRG results is discussed by comparison with tight-binding exact results, independent DMRG calculations for the Heisenberg model and simple first-order perturbation estimates.

•Jan 22, 1998•0 citations

Magnetism in the two-dimensional Hubbard model (abstract)

J. E. Hirsch, Hsueh‐Ju Lin

The Hubbard model has been widely used to describe magnetism due to itinerant electrons. However, except for the one-dimensional case, no exact solution of the model exists. We have studied the two-dimensional Hubbard model on a square lattice using a Monte Carlo simulation technique. Simulations were performed on lattices of up to 8×8 in spatial size. We will discuss results for thermodynamic properties and correlation functions as a function of temperature and interaction strength. For the half-filled band case, our results indicate that the system exhibits long-range antiferromagnetic order in the ground state for any nonzero interaction, although substantially reduced from the classical Néel state due to both charge and spin fluctuations. For the non-half-filled band case, our results suggest that no long-range magnetic order exists. We also don’t find any indication of short-ranged ferromagnetic correlations in the parameter range studied. We have also studied the predictions of various approximate treatments for this model, particularly the static approximation and the coherent potential approximation (CPA). By comparison with the Monte Carlo results, we discuss the validity of these schemes. Finally, we discuss the effect of changing the band structure on the magnetic properties of the system.

Journal of Applied Physics•Apr 15, 1985•0 citations

Dynamical resilience to disorder: The dilute Hubbard model on the Lieb lattice

L. Oliveira-Lima, Natanael C. Costa, J.P. de Lima +2 more

In itinerant systems, electron-electron interactions may lead to the formation of local magnetic moments and their effective exchange coupling, which in turn gives rise to long-range magnetic order. Therefore, when moment formation is weakened, such as in the single-band Hubbard model on a square lattice with the on-site repulsion being randomly switched off on a fraction $x$ of sites, magnetic order is suppressed beyond some critical ${x}_{c}$, which was found to lie below the classical percolation threshold ${x}_{c}^{\text{(perc,sq)}}$. Here we study dilute magnetism in flat band systems, namely, in the Hubbard model on a ``Lieb'' lattice. Interestingly, we show that magnetic order persists to $x$ almost twice as large as the classical percolation threshold for the lattice, thus emphasizing the central role of electron itinerancy to the magnetic response. The analysis of the orbital-resolved order parameters reveals that the contribution of the fourfold coordinated ``$d$'' sites to magnetism is dramatically affected by dilution, while the localized ``$p$'' states of the flat band provide the dominant contribution to long-range correlations. We also examine the transport properties, which suggest the existence of an insulator-to-metal transition in the same range of the critical magnetic dilution.

arXiv:1912.04918•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 9, 2020•12 citations

Two theorems on the Hubbard model

Élliott H. Lieb

In the attractive Hubbard Model (and some extended versions of it), the ground state is proved to have spin angular momentum S=0 for every (even) electron filling. In the repulsive case, and with a bipartite lattice and a half-filled band, the ground state has S=(1/2\ensuremath{\parallel}B\ensuremath{\Vert}-\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Vert}, where \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert} (\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}) is the number of sites in the B (A) sublattice. In both cases the ground state is unique. The second theorem confirms an old, unproved conjecture in the \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}=\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert} case and yields, with \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\ne}\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}, the first provable example of itinerant-electron ferromagnetism. The theorems hold in all dimensions without even the necessity of a periodic lattice structure.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 6, 1989•2,244 citations

Evolution of magnetic correlation in an inhomogeneous square lattice

Xiao Zhang, Runyu Ma, Zenghui Fan +3 more

We explore the magnetic properties of a two-dimensional Hubbard model on an inhomogeneous square lattice, which provides a platform for tuning the bandwidth of the flat band. In its limit, this inhomogeneous square lattice turns into a Lieb lattice, and it exhibits abundant properties due to the flat band structure at the Fermi level. By using the determinant quantum Monte Carlo simulation, we calculate the spin susceptibility, double occupancy, magnetization, spin structure factor, and effective pairing interaction of the system. It is found that the antiferromagnetic correlation is suppressed by the inhomogeneous strength and that the ferromagnetic correlation is enhanced. Both the antiferromagnetic correlation and ferromagnetic correlation are enhanced as the interaction increases. It is also found that the effective $d$-wave pairing interaction is suppressed by the increasing inhomogeneity. In addition, we also study the thermodynamic properties of the inhomogeneous square lattice, and the calculation of specific heat provides good support for our point. Our intensive numerical results provide a rich magnetic phase diagram over both the inhomogeneity and interaction.

arXiv:2306.03510•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 14, 2023•0 citations
The noninteracting electronic structures of tight-binding models on bipartite lattices with unequal numbers of sites in the two sublattices have a number of unique features, including the presence of spatially localized eigenstates and flat bands. When a uniform on-site Hubbard interaction UUU is turned on, Lieb proved rigorously that at half-filling (\ensuremathρ=1\ensuremath{\rho}=1\ensuremathρ=1) the ground state has a nonzero spin. In this paper we consider a ${\mathrm{CuO}}_{2}$ lattice'' (also known as Lieb lattice,'' or as a decorated square lattice), in which $d$ orbitals'' occupy the vertices of the squares, while ppp orbitals'' lie halfway between two ddd orbitals; both ddd and ppp orbitals can accommodate only up to two electrons. We use exact determinant quantum Monte Carlo (DQMC) simulations to quantify the nature of magnetic order through the behavior of correlation functions and sublattice magnetizations in the different orbitals as a function of UUU and temperature; we have also calculated the projected density of states, and the compressibility. We study both the homogeneous (H) case, Ud=Up{U}_{d}={U}_{p}Ud​=Up​, originally considered by Lieb, and the inhomogeneous (IH) case, Ud\ensuremath≠Up{U}_{d}\ensuremath{\ne}{U}_{p}Ud​\ensuremath=Up​. For the H case at half-filling, we found that the global magnetization rises sharply at weak coupling, and then stabilizes towards the strong-coupling (Heisenberg) value, as a result of the interplay between the ferromagnetism of like sites and the antiferromagnetism between unlike sites; we verified that the system is an insulator for all UUU. For the IH system at half-filling, we argue that the case Up\ensuremath≠Ud{U}_{p}\ensuremath{\ne}{U}_{d}Up​\ensuremath=Ud​ falls under Lieb's theorem, provided they are positive definite, so we used DQMC to probe the cases Up=0,Ud=U{U}_{p}=0,{U}_{d}=UUp​=0,Ud​=U and Up=U,Ud=0{U}_{p}=U,{U}_{d}=0Up​=U,Ud​=0. We found that the different environments of ddd and ppp sites lead to a ferromagnetic insulator when Ud=0{U}_{d}=0Ud​=0; by contrast, Up=0{U}_{p}=0Up​=0 leads to to a metal without any magnetic ordering. In addition, we have also established that at density \ensuremathρ=1/3\ensuremath{\rho}=1/3\ensuremathρ=1/3, strong antiferromagnetic correlations set in, caused by the presence of one fermion on each ddd site.
The physics of strongly correlated quantum particles within a flat band was originally explored as a route to itinerant ferromagnetism and, indeed, a celebrated theorem by Lieb rigorously establishes that the ground state of the repulsive Hubbard model on a bipartite lattice with an unequal number of sites in each sublattice must have nonzero spin SSS at half filling. Recently, there has been interest in Lieb geometries due to the possibility of topological insulator, nematic, and Bose-Einstein condensed (BEC) phases. In this paper, we extend the understanding of the attractive Hubbard model on the Lieb lattice by using determinant quantum Monte Carlo to study real space charge and pair correlation functions not addressed by the Lieb theorems. Specifically, our results show unusual charge and charge transfer signatures within the flat band, and a reduction in pairing order at $\ensuremath{\rho}=2/3$ and $\ensuremath{\rho}=4/3$, the points at which the flat band is first occupied and then completely filled. We compare our results to the case of flat bands in the Kagome lattice and demonstrate that the behavior observed in the two cases is rather different.
The half-filled Hubbard model on the Bethe lattice with coordination number z=3z=3z=3 is studied using the density-matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method. Ground-state properties such as the energy EEE, average local magnetization $ $, its fluctuations $ - ^2$ and various spin correlation functions $ - $ are determined as a function of the Coulomb interaction strength U/tU/tU/t. The calculated local magnetic moments $ $ increase monotonically with increasing Coulomb repulsion U/tU/tU/t forming an antiferromagnetic spin-density-wave state which matches the two sublattices of the bipartite Bethe lattice. At large U/tU/tU/t, $ $ is strongly reduced with respect to the saturation value 1/2 due to exchange fluctuations between nearest neighbors (NN) spins (∣∣≃0.35| |\simeq 0.35∣∣≃0.35 for U/t→+∞U/t\to +\inftyU/t→+∞). $ - ^2$ shows a maximum for U/t=2.4U/t=2.4U/t=2.4--2.9 which results from the interplay between the usual increase of $ $ with increasing U/tU/tU/t and the formation of important permanent moments $ $ at large U/tU/tU/t. NN sites show antiferromagnetic spin correlations which increase with increasing Coulomb repulsion. In contrast next NN sites are very weakly correlated over the whole range of U/tU/tU/t. The accuracy of the DMRG results is discussed by comparison with tight-binding exact results, independent DMRG calculations for the Heisenberg model and simple first-order perturbation estimates.
The Hubbard model has been widely used to describe magnetism due to itinerant electrons. However, except for the one-dimensional case, no exact solution of the model exists. We have studied the two-dimensional Hubbard model on a square lattice using a Monte Carlo simulation technique. Simulations were performed on lattices of up to 8×8 in spatial size. We will discuss results for thermodynamic properties and correlation functions as a function of temperature and interaction strength. For the half-filled band case, our results indicate that the system exhibits long-range antiferromagnetic order in the ground state for any nonzero interaction, although substantially reduced from the classical Néel state due to both charge and spin fluctuations. For the non-half-filled band case, our results suggest that no long-range magnetic order exists. We also don’t find any indication of short-ranged ferromagnetic correlations in the parameter range studied. We have also studied the predictions of various approximate treatments for this model, particularly the static approximation and the coherent potential approximation (CPA). By comparison with the Monte Carlo results, we discuss the validity of these schemes. Finally, we discuss the effect of changing the band structure on the magnetic properties of the system.
In itinerant systems, electron-electron interactions may lead to the formation of local magnetic moments and their effective exchange coupling, which in turn gives rise to long-range magnetic order. Therefore, when moment formation is weakened, such as in the single-band Hubbard model on a square lattice with the on-site repulsion being randomly switched off on a fraction xxx of sites, magnetic order is suppressed beyond some critical xc{x}_{c}xc​, which was found to lie below the classical percolation threshold xc(perc,sq){x}_{c}^{\text{(perc,sq)}}xc(perc,sq)​. Here we study dilute magnetism in flat band systems, namely, in the Hubbard model on a ``Lieb'' lattice. Interestingly, we show that magnetic order persists to xxx almost twice as large as the classical percolation threshold for the lattice, thus emphasizing the central role of electron itinerancy to the magnetic response. The analysis of the orbital-resolved order parameters reveals that the contribution of the fourfold coordinated ``ddd'' sites to magnetism is dramatically affected by dilution, while the localized ``ppp'' states of the flat band provide the dominant contribution to long-range correlations. We also examine the transport properties, which suggest the existence of an insulator-to-metal transition in the same range of the critical magnetic dilution.
In the attractive Hubbard Model (and some extended versions of it), the ground state is proved to have spin angular momentum S=0 for every (even) electron filling. In the repulsive case, and with a bipartite lattice and a half-filled band, the ground state has S=(1/2\ensuremath{\parallel}B\ensuremath{\Vert}-\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Vert}, where \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert} (\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}) is the number of sites in the B (A) sublattice. In both cases the ground state is unique. The second theorem confirms an old, unproved conjecture in the \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}=\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert} case and yields, with \ensuremath{\Vert}B\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\ne}\ensuremath{\Vert}A\ensuremath{\Vert}, the first provable example of itinerant-electron ferromagnetism. The theorems hold in all dimensions without even the necessity of a periodic lattice structure.
We explore the magnetic properties of a two-dimensional Hubbard model on an inhomogeneous square lattice, which provides a platform for tuning the bandwidth of the flat band. In its limit, this inhomogeneous square lattice turns into a Lieb lattice, and it exhibits abundant properties due to the flat band structure at the Fermi level. By using the determinant quantum Monte Carlo simulation, we calculate the spin susceptibility, double occupancy, magnetization, spin structure factor, and effective pairing interaction of the system. It is found that the antiferromagnetic correlation is suppressed by the inhomogeneous strength and that the ferromagnetic correlation is enhanced. Both the antiferromagnetic correlation and ferromagnetic correlation are enhanced as the interaction increases. It is also found that the effective ddd-wave pairing interaction is suppressed by the increasing inhomogeneity. In addition, we also study the thermodynamic properties of the inhomogeneous square lattice, and the calculation of specific heat provides good support for our point. Our intensive numerical results provide a rich magnetic phase diagram over both the inhomogeneity and interaction.