Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1610.00608 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Boson condensation and instability in the tensor network representation of string-net states

Sujeet K. Shukla, Mehmet Şahinoglu, Frank Pollmann, Xie Chen

Published Sep 7, 2018• 21 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The tensor network representation of many-body quantum states, given by local tensors, provides a promising numerical tool for the study of strongly correlated topological phases in two dimensions. However, the representation may be vulnerable to instabilities caused by small variations in the local tensors. For example, the topological order in the tensor network representations of the toric code ground state has been shown in Chen, Zeng, Gu, Chuang, and Wen, Phys. Rev. B 82, 165119 (2010) to be unstable if the variations break certain ${Z}_{2}$ symmetry of the tensor. In this work, we ask whether other types of topological orders suffer from similar kinds of instability and if so, what is the underlying physical mechanism and whether we can protect the order by enforcing certain symmetries on the tensor. We answer these questions by showing that the tensor network representations of all string-net models are indeed unstable, but the matrix product operator (MPO) symmetries of the tensors identified in \ifmmode \mbox{\c{S}}\else \c{S}\fi{}ahino\ifmmode \breve{g}\else \u{g}\fi{}lu, Williamson, Bultinck, Mari\"en, Haegeman, Schuch, and Verstraete, arXiv:1409.2150 can help to protect the order. In particular, we show that a subset of variations that break the MPO symmetries lead to instability by inducing the condensation of bosonic quasiparticles, which destroys the topological order in the wave function. Therefore such variations must be forbidden for the encoded topological order to be reliably extracted from the local tensors. On the other hand, if a tensor network based variational algorithm is used to simulate the phase transition due to boson condensation, such variation directions may prove important to access the continuous transition correctly.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.98.125112

Related papers

Tensor Network Representation of Many-Body Quantum States and Unitary Operators

Sujeet K. Shukla

Understanding many-body quantum systems is one of the most challenging problems in contemporary condensed-matter physics. Tensor network representation of quantum states and operators are taking central stage in this pursuit and beyond. They prove to be a powerful numerical and conceptual tool, and indeed a new language altogether. This thesis investigates various aspects of these representations by focusing on two specific problems: the first half of the thesis is devoted to examining how 'stable' a tensor network representation is for two-dimensional quantum states with topological order, and the second half explores the representability of various unitary loop operators with tensor networks. In the numerical usage of the tensor networks, the tensor is varied as to find the representation of the ground states of the given Hamiltonian. In chapter two and three of this thesis we show that such a numerical program for topological phases can be 'ill-posed'. We show that tensor network can be an unstable representation for a topological phase: even an infinitesimal variation in the representation results in the loss of topological order, completely or partially. We diagnose this problem by identifying the exact causes of this instability, and find that it is only tensor variations in certain directions that result in instability, because they result in the condensation of bosonic quasi-particles of the phase. Such unstable variations are characterized by two properties: (1) they can replace a tensor in the tensor network without making the network collapse, and (2) their presence in the network represents the presence of a non-trivial topological charge. We prove that the general tensor representation of all string-net models suffer with such instabilities. We propose an exact mathematical operator to project out all such unstable variations and show its efficacy for a few models by direct calculations. Such an operator can be useful in numerical programs involving such tensor representations. We also point out that such variations play a crucial role in simulating topological phase transitions and their presence can be vital in an accurate simulation. In chapter four and five of this thesis we focus on the representability of unitary loop operators by tensor networks. Such operators not only provide an important tool in the study of dynamical process in one-dimensional systems, but also in understanding and classification of symmetry protected topological phases in two dimensions. To characterize all such operators, we find a necessary and sufficient condition for any loop tensor network operator of a given length to represent a unitary operator. In particular, it is shown that all unitary operators that map local operators to local operators (locality-preserving) can always be represented by a tensor network. Locality-preserving unitary loop operators are classified by a rational index called the GNVW index defined in Ref. [1] which measures how much information 'flows' along the loop. We define Rank-Ratio index for tensor network operators and show that it is completely equivalent to the GNVW index. Therefore, GNVW index of a unitary operator can be easily extracted from its tensor network representation. We find that, other than representing locality-preserving unitary maps, tensor networks can also represent unitary operators that map local operators to global (non-local) operators. These tensor network operators are found to have a long-ranged order similar to tensors that represent topological tensor network states in two dimensions.

•Sep 25, 2017•0 citations

Tensor-product representations for string-net condensed states

Zheng‐Cheng Gu, Michael Levin, Brian G. Swingle +1 more

We show that general string-net condensed states have a natural representation in terms of tensor product states (TPSs). These TPSs are built from local tensors. They can describe both states with short-range entanglement (such as the symmetry-breaking states) and states with long-range entanglement (such as string-net condensed states with topological/quantum order). The tensor product representation provides a kind of ``mean-field'' description for topologically ordered states and could be a powerful way to study quantum phase transitions between such states. As an attempt in this direction, we show that the constructed TPSs are fixed points under a certain wave-function renormalization-group transformation for quantum states.

arXiv:0809.2821•Physical Review B•Feb 23, 2009•170 citations

Tensor product representation of a topological ordered phase: Necessary symmetry conditions

Xie Chen, Bei Zeng, Zheng‐Cheng Gu +2 more

The tensor product representation of quantum states leads to a promising variational approach to study quantum phase and quantum phase transitions, especially topological ordered phases which are impossible to handle with conventional methods due to their long-range entanglement. However, an important issue arises when we use tensor product states (TPSs) as variational states to find the ground state of a Hamiltonian: can arbitrary variations in the tensors that represent ground state of a Hamiltonian be induced by local perturbations to the Hamiltonian? Starting from a tensor product state which is the exact ground state of a Hamiltonian with ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ topological order, we show that, surprisingly, not all variations in the tensors correspond to the variation in the ground state caused by local perturbations of the Hamiltonian. Even in the absence of any symmetry requirement of the perturbed Hamiltonian, one necessary condition for the variations in the tensors to be physical is that they respect certain ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$ symmetry. We support this claim by calculating explicitly the change in topological entanglement entropy with different variations in the tensors. This finding will provide important guidance to numerical variational study of topological phase and phase transitions. It is also a crucial step in using TPS to study universal properties of a quantum phase and its topological order.

arXiv:1003.1774•Physical Review B•Oct 20, 2010•57 citations

Tensor Network methods in many-body physics

András Molnár

Strongly correlated systems exhibit phenomena -- such as high-T_c superconductivity or the fractional quantum Hall effect -- that are not explicable by classical and semi-classical methods. Moreover, due to the exponential scaling of the associated Hilbert space, solving the proposed model Hamiltonians by brute-force numerical methods is bound to fail. Thus, it is important to develop novel numerical and analytical methods that can explain the physics in this regime. Tensor Network states are quantum many-body states that help to overcome some of these difficulties by defining a family of states that depend only on a small number of parameters. Their use is twofold: they are used as variational ansatzes in numerical algorithms as well as providing a framework to represent a large class of exactly solvable models that are believed to represent all possible phases of matter. The present thesis investigates mathematical properties of these states thus deepening the understanding of how and why Tensor Networks are suitable for the description of quantum many-body systems. It is believed that tensor networks can represent ground states of local Hamiltonians, but how good is this representation? This question is of fundamental importance as variational algorithms based on tensor networks can only perform well if any ground state can be approximated efficiently in such a way. While any state can be written as a tensor network state, the number of parameters needed for the description might be too large. This is not the case for one-dimensional systems: only a few parameters are required to have a good approximation of their ground states; that, in turn, allows for numerical algorithms based on tensor networks performing well. The situation in two dimensions is somewhat more complicated, but it is known that ground states of local Hamiltonians can be expressed as tensor networks with sub-exponentially many parameters. In the present thesis, we improve on these existing bounds strengthening the claim that the language of tensor networks is suitable to describe many-body systems. Another central question is how symmetries of the system such as translational invariance, time-reversal symmetry or local unitary symmetry can be reflected in tensor networks. This question is important as systems appearing in nature might intrinsically possess certain symmetries; on one hand, understanding these symmetries simplifies the description of these systems. On the other hand, the presence of symmetries leads to the appearance of novel phases -- symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order, -- and tensor networks provide the right language to classify these phases. In one dimension and for certain classes of two-dimensional tensor networks (states generated by so-called injective tensors) it is well understood how symmetries of the state can be described. A general framework, however, has yet to be developed. In the present thesis, we contribute to the development of the theory in two ways. We first investigate the question for injective tensors, and generalize the existing proof for any geometry including the hyperbolic geometry used in the AdS/CFT correspondence. Second, we introduce a class of tensor network states that include previously known examples of states exhibiting SPT order. We show how symmetries are reflected in these states thus deepening the understanding of SPT order in two dimensions.

•Jan 1, 2019•0 citations

On the stability of topological order in tensor network states

Dominic J. Williamson, Clement Delcamp, Frank Verstraete +1 more

We construct a tensor network representation of the three-dimensional (3D) toric code ground state that is stable to a generating set of uniform local tensor perturbations, including those that do not map to local operators on the physical Hilbert space. The stability is established by mapping the phase diagram of the perturbed tensor network to that of the 3D Ising gauge theory, which has a nonzero finite temperature transition. More generally, we find that the stability of a topological tensor network state is determined by the form of its virtual symmetries and the topological excitations created by virtual operators that break those symmetries. In particular, a dual representation of the 3D toric code ground state, as well as representations of the $X$-cube and cubic code ground states, for which pointlike excitations are created by such operators, are found to be unstable.

arXiv:2012.15346•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 27, 2021•22 citations

Many-body entanglement : topological orders, tensor networks and superconductivity

Jimmy Fangzhou Liu

In this thesis, we discuss the characterization and application of quantum many-body entanglements. We try to establish a non-local "order parameter" description of different patterns of many-body entanglement, which are also named topological orders. In 2+ 1D, we show that this could be achieved by calculating the non-Abelian geometric phase (S, T)-matrices from the fixed-point wave functions, obtained in the string-net approach by Levin and Wen and the local unitary transformation approach by Chen, Gu and Wen. In doing so, (S, T)-matrices act as our non-local "order parameter" and give a full characterization of 2+ 1D exact topological orders (topological orders that have a gappable edge). For a generic non-fixed-point wave function, however, obtaining the (S, T)-matrices is numerically formidable. To go around this problem, we introduce a new tensor-network method that works on any generic wave function, and obtain the "environment matrix" as a less powerful "order parameter" description. The "environment matrix" can characterize topological orders described by any gauge theory as well as ID symmetry protected topological (SPT) orders. As an application of both the concept of many-body entanglement and the new tensor-network method developed earlier, in the last chapter of the thesis, we propose a non-BCS mechanism for superconductivity, in which the driving force is not traditional pair-attraction, but statistical confusion of charge carrier induced by strong many-body entanglement. This may open new doors for identifying and constructing new superconducting states.

•Jan 1, 2015•0 citations
The tensor network representation of many-body quantum states, given by local tensors, provides a promising numerical tool for the study of strongly correlated topological phases in two dimensions. However, the representation may be vulnerable to instabilities caused by small variations in the local tensors. For example, the topological order in the tensor network representations of the toric code ground state has been shown in Chen, Zeng, Gu, Chuang, and Wen, Phys. Rev. B 82, 165119 (2010) to be unstable if the variations break certain Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ symmetry of the tensor. In this work, we ask whether other types of topological orders suffer from similar kinds of instability and if so, what is the underlying physical mechanism and whether we can protect the order by enforcing certain symmetries on the tensor. We answer these questions by showing that the tensor network representations of all string-net models are indeed unstable, but the matrix product operator (MPO) symmetries of the tensors identified in \ifmmode \mbox{\c{S}}\else \c{S}\fi{}ahino\ifmmode \breve{g}\else \u{g}\fi{}lu, Williamson, Bultinck, Mari"en, Haegeman, Schuch, and Verstraete, arXiv:1409.2150 can help to protect the order. In particular, we show that a subset of variations that break the MPO symmetries lead to instability by inducing the condensation of bosonic quasiparticles, which destroys the topological order in the wave function. Therefore such variations must be forbidden for the encoded topological order to be reliably extracted from the local tensors. On the other hand, if a tensor network based variational algorithm is used to simulate the phase transition due to boson condensation, such variation directions may prove important to access the continuous transition correctly.
Understanding many-body quantum systems is one of the most challenging problems in contemporary condensed-matter physics. Tensor network representation of quantum states and operators are taking central stage in this pursuit and beyond. They prove to be a powerful numerical and conceptual tool, and indeed a new language altogether. This thesis investigates various aspects of these representations by focusing on two specific problems: the first half of the thesis is devoted to examining how 'stable' a tensor network representation is for two-dimensional quantum states with topological order, and the second half explores the representability of various unitary loop operators with tensor networks. In the numerical usage of the tensor networks, the tensor is varied as to find the representation of the ground states of the given Hamiltonian. In chapter two and three of this thesis we show that such a numerical program for topological phases can be 'ill-posed'. We show that tensor network can be an unstable representation for a topological phase: even an infinitesimal variation in the representation results in the loss of topological order, completely or partially. We diagnose this problem by identifying the exact causes of this instability, and find that it is only tensor variations in certain directions that result in instability, because they result in the condensation of bosonic quasi-particles of the phase. Such unstable variations are characterized by two properties: (1) they can replace a tensor in the tensor network without making the network collapse, and (2) their presence in the network represents the presence of a non-trivial topological charge. We prove that the general tensor representation of all string-net models suffer with such instabilities. We propose an exact mathematical operator to project out all such unstable variations and show its efficacy for a few models by direct calculations. Such an operator can be useful in numerical programs involving such tensor representations. We also point out that such variations play a crucial role in simulating topological phase transitions and their presence can be vital in an accurate simulation. In chapter four and five of this thesis we focus on the representability of unitary loop operators by tensor networks. Such operators not only provide an important tool in the study of dynamical process in one-dimensional systems, but also in understanding and classification of symmetry protected topological phases in two dimensions. To characterize all such operators, we find a necessary and sufficient condition for any loop tensor network operator of a given length to represent a unitary operator. In particular, it is shown that all unitary operators that map local operators to local operators (locality-preserving) can always be represented by a tensor network. Locality-preserving unitary loop operators are classified by a rational index called the GNVW index defined in Ref. [1] which measures how much information 'flows' along the loop. We define Rank-Ratio index for tensor network operators and show that it is completely equivalent to the GNVW index. Therefore, GNVW index of a unitary operator can be easily extracted from its tensor network representation. We find that, other than representing locality-preserving unitary maps, tensor networks can also represent unitary operators that map local operators to global (non-local) operators. These tensor network operators are found to have a long-ranged order similar to tensors that represent topological tensor network states in two dimensions.
We show that general string-net condensed states have a natural representation in terms of tensor product states (TPSs). These TPSs are built from local tensors. They can describe both states with short-range entanglement (such as the symmetry-breaking states) and states with long-range entanglement (such as string-net condensed states with topological/quantum order). The tensor product representation provides a kind of ``mean-field'' description for topologically ordered states and could be a powerful way to study quantum phase transitions between such states. As an attempt in this direction, we show that the constructed TPSs are fixed points under a certain wave-function renormalization-group transformation for quantum states.
The tensor product representation of quantum states leads to a promising variational approach to study quantum phase and quantum phase transitions, especially topological ordered phases which are impossible to handle with conventional methods due to their long-range entanglement. However, an important issue arises when we use tensor product states (TPSs) as variational states to find the ground state of a Hamiltonian: can arbitrary variations in the tensors that represent ground state of a Hamiltonian be induced by local perturbations to the Hamiltonian? Starting from a tensor product state which is the exact ground state of a Hamiltonian with Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ topological order, we show that, surprisingly, not all variations in the tensors correspond to the variation in the ground state caused by local perturbations of the Hamiltonian. Even in the absence of any symmetry requirement of the perturbed Hamiltonian, one necessary condition for the variations in the tensors to be physical is that they respect certain Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​ symmetry. We support this claim by calculating explicitly the change in topological entanglement entropy with different variations in the tensors. This finding will provide important guidance to numerical variational study of topological phase and phase transitions. It is also a crucial step in using TPS to study universal properties of a quantum phase and its topological order.
Strongly correlated systems exhibit phenomena -- such as high-T_c superconductivity or the fractional quantum Hall effect -- that are not explicable by classical and semi-classical methods. Moreover, due to the exponential scaling of the associated Hilbert space, solving the proposed model Hamiltonians by brute-force numerical methods is bound to fail. Thus, it is important to develop novel numerical and analytical methods that can explain the physics in this regime. Tensor Network states are quantum many-body states that help to overcome some of these difficulties by defining a family of states that depend only on a small number of parameters. Their use is twofold: they are used as variational ansatzes in numerical algorithms as well as providing a framework to represent a large class of exactly solvable models that are believed to represent all possible phases of matter. The present thesis investigates mathematical properties of these states thus deepening the understanding of how and why Tensor Networks are suitable for the description of quantum many-body systems. It is believed that tensor networks can represent ground states of local Hamiltonians, but how good is this representation? This question is of fundamental importance as variational algorithms based on tensor networks can only perform well if any ground state can be approximated efficiently in such a way. While any state can be written as a tensor network state, the number of parameters needed for the description might be too large. This is not the case for one-dimensional systems: only a few parameters are required to have a good approximation of their ground states; that, in turn, allows for numerical algorithms based on tensor networks performing well. The situation in two dimensions is somewhat more complicated, but it is known that ground states of local Hamiltonians can be expressed as tensor networks with sub-exponentially many parameters. In the present thesis, we improve on these existing bounds strengthening the claim that the language of tensor networks is suitable to describe many-body systems. Another central question is how symmetries of the system such as translational invariance, time-reversal symmetry or local unitary symmetry can be reflected in tensor networks. This question is important as systems appearing in nature might intrinsically possess certain symmetries; on one hand, understanding these symmetries simplifies the description of these systems. On the other hand, the presence of symmetries leads to the appearance of novel phases -- symmetry-protected topological (SPT) order, -- and tensor networks provide the right language to classify these phases. In one dimension and for certain classes of two-dimensional tensor networks (states generated by so-called injective tensors) it is well understood how symmetries of the state can be described. A general framework, however, has yet to be developed. In the present thesis, we contribute to the development of the theory in two ways. We first investigate the question for injective tensors, and generalize the existing proof for any geometry including the hyperbolic geometry used in the AdS/CFT correspondence. Second, we introduce a class of tensor network states that include previously known examples of states exhibiting SPT order. We show how symmetries are reflected in these states thus deepening the understanding of SPT order in two dimensions.
We construct a tensor network representation of the three-dimensional (3D) toric code ground state that is stable to a generating set of uniform local tensor perturbations, including those that do not map to local operators on the physical Hilbert space. The stability is established by mapping the phase diagram of the perturbed tensor network to that of the 3D Ising gauge theory, which has a nonzero finite temperature transition. More generally, we find that the stability of a topological tensor network state is determined by the form of its virtual symmetries and the topological excitations created by virtual operators that break those symmetries. In particular, a dual representation of the 3D toric code ground state, as well as representations of the XXX-cube and cubic code ground states, for which pointlike excitations are created by such operators, are found to be unstable.
In this thesis, we discuss the characterization and application of quantum many-body entanglements. We try to establish a non-local "order parameter" description of different patterns of many-body entanglement, which are also named topological orders. In 2+ 1D, we show that this could be achieved by calculating the non-Abelian geometric phase (S, T)-matrices from the fixed-point wave functions, obtained in the string-net approach by Levin and Wen and the local unitary transformation approach by Chen, Gu and Wen. In doing so, (S, T)-matrices act as our non-local "order parameter" and give a full characterization of 2+ 1D exact topological orders (topological orders that have a gappable edge). For a generic non-fixed-point wave function, however, obtaining the (S, T)-matrices is numerically formidable. To go around this problem, we introduce a new tensor-network method that works on any generic wave function, and obtain the "environment matrix" as a less powerful "order parameter" description. The "environment matrix" can characterize topological orders described by any gauge theory as well as ID symmetry protected topological (SPT) orders. As an application of both the concept of many-body entanglement and the new tensor-network method developed earlier, in the last chapter of the thesis, we propose a non-BCS mechanism for superconductivity, in which the driving force is not traditional pair-attraction, but statistical confusion of charge carrier induced by strong many-body entanglement. This may open new doors for identifying and constructing new superconducting states.