Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1609.07931

The BCS theory of superconductivity revisited: quasiparticle imbalance in equilibrium and multiple solutions of the energy gap equation

Dragoş-Victor Anghel

Published Sep 26, 2016• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We examine the equilibrium solutions of the BCS theory of superconductivity in the low temperature allowing the attraction band to be asymmetric with respect to the chemical potential of the system $\mu_R$. If we denote by $\mu$ the middle of the attraction band, we observe that the superconducting phase is formed only if $|\mu_R-\mu| < 2\Delta_0$, where $\Delta_0$ is the energy gap at zero temperature in the BCS theory. If $|\mu_R-\mu| < 2\Delta_0$, the system of equations which give the energy gap has two solutions for each value of $\mu_R-\mu$: one with $\Delta(T=0) = \Delta_0$ and another one, with $\Delta(T=0) < \Delta_0$ ($\Delta(T=0)$ is the energy gap at 0~K). If $0<|\mu_R-\mu| < 2\Delta_0$, a quasiparticle imbalance appears in equilibrium. In the standard BCS limit, which is $\mu_R \to \mu$, beside the solution $\Delta(T=0) = \Delta_0$, we find another one, with $\Delta(T=0) = \Delta_0/3$ and nonzero quasiparticle population. The formalism takes into account in a consistent way the variation of the total number of particles with the population of the quasiparticle states.

Related papers

Superconductivity versus bound-state formation in a two-band superconductor with small Fermi energy: Applications to Fe pnictides/chalcogenides and doped SrTiO3

Andrey V. Chubukov, Ilya Eremin, Dmitri V. Efremov

We analyze the interplay between superconductivity and the formation of bound pairs of fermions (BCS-BEC crossover) in a 2D model of interacting fermions with small Fermi energy ${E}_{F}$ and weak attractive interaction, which extends to energies well above ${E}_{F}$. The 2D case is special because a two-particle bound state forms at arbitrary weak interaction, and already at weak coupling, one has to distinguish between the bound-state formation and superconductivity. We briefly review the situation in the one-band model and then consider two different two-band models: one with one hole band and one electron band and another with two hole or two electron bands. In each case, we obtain the bound-state energy $2{E}_{0}$ for two fermions in a vacuum and solve the set of coupled equations for the pairing gaps and the chemical potentials to obtain the onset temperature of the pairing ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}$ and the quasiparticle dispersion at $T=0$. We then compute the superfluid stiffness ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{s}(T=0)$ and obtain the actual ${T}_{c}$. For definiteness, we set ${E}_{F}$ in one band to be near zero and consider different ratios of ${E}_{0}$ and ${E}_{F}$ in the other band. We show that at ${E}_{F}\ensuremath{\gg}{E}_{0}$, the behavior of both two-band models is BCS-like in the sense that ${T}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}\ensuremath{\ll}{E}_{F}$ and $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}{T}_{c}$. At ${E}_{F}\ensuremath{\ll}{E}_{0}$, the two models behave differently: in the model with two hole/two electron bands, ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}\ensuremath{\sim}{E}_{0}/ln\frac{{E}_{0}}{{E}_{F}}, \mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}{({E}_{0}{E}_{F})}^{1/2}$, and ${T}_{c}\ensuremath{\sim}{E}_{F}$, like in the one-band model. In between ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}$ and ${T}_{c}$, the system displays a preformed pair behavior. In the model with one hole and one electron bands, ${T}_{c}$ remains of order ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}$, and both remain finite at ${E}_{F}=0$ and of the order of ${E}_{0}$. The preformed pair behavior still does exist in this model because ${T}_{c}$ is numerically smaller than ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}$. For both models, we reexpress ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}$ in terms of the fully renormalized two-particle scattering amplitude by extending to the two-band case (the method pioneered by Gorkov and Melik-Barkhudarov back in 1961). We apply our results for the model with a hole and an electron band to Fe pnictides and Fe chalcogenides in which a superconducting gap has been detected on the bands that do not cross the Fermi level, and to FeSe, in which the superconducting gap is comparable to the Fermi energy. We apply the results for the model with two electron bands to Nb-doped ${\mathrm{SrTiO}}_{3}$ and argue that our theory explains the rapid increase of ${T}_{c}$ when both bands start crossing the Fermi level.

arXiv:1601.01678•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 25, 2016•91 citations

BCS superconductivity near the band edge: Exact results for one and several bands

Davide Valentinis, D. van der Marel, Christophe Berthod

We revisit the problem of a BCS superconductor in the regime where the Fermi energy is smaller than the Debye energy. This regime is relevant for low-density superconductors such as ${\mathrm{SrTiO}}_{3}$ that are not in the BEC limit, as well as in the problem of ``shape resonances'' associated with the confinement of a three-dimensional superconductor. While the problem is not new, exact results were lacking in the low-density limit. In two dimensions, we find that the initial rise of the pairing temperature ${T}_{c}$ at low density $n$ is nonanalytic and faster than any power of $n$. In three dimensions, we also find that ${T}_{c}$ is nonanalytic, but starts with zero slope at weak coupling and infinite slope at strong coupling. Self-consistent treatment of the chemical potential and energy dependence of the density of states are crucial ingredients to obtain these results. We also present exact results for multiband systems and confirm our analytical expressions by numerical simulations.

arXiv:1601.04521•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jul 14, 2016•27 citations

BEC, BCS and BCS-Bose Crossover Theories in Superconductors and Superfluids

MANUEL DE LLANO, Francisco J. Sevilla, M. A. Solís +1 more

For the Cooper/BCS model interaction in superconductors (SCs) it is shown: a) how BCS-Bose crossover picture transition temperatures Tc, defined self-consistently by both the gap and fermion-number equations, require unphysically large couplings to differ significantly from the Tc of ordinary BCS theory defined without the number equation since here the chemical potential is assumed equal to the Fermi energy; how although ignoring either hole- or electron-Cooper-pairs in the recent "complete boson-fermion model": b) one obtains the precise BCS gap equation for all temperatures T, but c) only half the zero-temperature BCS condensation energy emerges. Results (b) and (c) are also expected to hold for neutral-fermion superfluids (SFs)--such as liquid $^3$He, neutron matter and trapped ultra-cold fermion atomic gases--where the pair-forming two-fermion interaction of course differs from the Cooper/BCS one for SCs.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412418•Dec 16, 2004•0 citations

Stability conditions and Fermi surface topologies in a superconductor

Elena Gubankova, Andreas Schmitt, Frank A. Wilczek

Candidate homogeneous, isotropic superfluid or superconducting states of paired fermion species with different chemical potentials, can lead to quasiparticle excitation energies that vanish at either 0, 1, or 2 spheres in momentum space. With no zeros, we have a conventional BCS superconductor. The other two cases, ``gapless'' superconductors, appear in mean- field theory for sufficiently large mismatches and/or sufficiently large coupling strengths. Here we examine several stability criteria for those candidate phases. Positivity of number susceptibility appears to provide the most powerful constraint, and renders all the two-zero states that we have examined mechanically unstable. Our results should apply directly to ultracold fermionic atom systems.

arXiv:cond-mat/0603603•Physical Review B•Aug 11, 2006•52 citations

Spectral properties of the boson-fermion model in the superconducting state

T. Kostyrko, J. Ranninger

The spectral properties of a mixture of bosons hybridized with fermion pairs are studied in the superconducting state. Such a model exhibits two limiting behaviors. One is reminiscent of a BCS system, provided that the total concentration n of particles is below a certain critical concentration ${\mathit{n}}_{\mathit{c}}$, in which case bosons exist only in thermally excited states. The other limit for n\ensuremath{\geqslant}${\mathit{n}}_{\mathit{c}}$ describes a situation largely controlled by the condensation of the bosons. The variation of the single-boson as well as collective excitations as a function of n and for the entire temperature regime from T=0 K to ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ will be discussed, both with and without long-range Coulomb interaction between the charge carriers. The method for calculation applied here is based on the dielectric formalism and the use of Ward identities, currently used in the theory of the interacting Bose gas, which allows us to derive the density and current correlation functions consistent with local charge-current conservation laws. In the absence of a Coulomb interaction the behavior of the system is characterized by the existence of a sound-wave-like branch in the Bose single-particle and collective excitation spectrum. In the BCS regime the sound velocity is proportional to the Fermi velocity while in the Bose regime it is proportional to the strength of the boson-fermion hybridization and decreases with the superfluid density as we approach ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$. In the presence of a long-range Coulomb interaction and in the Bose regime one observes, besides the usual optical plasmon mode at high frequency and corresponding to in-phase density oscillation of the two subsytems, an out-of-phase collective mode in the two particle continuum just above the gap. Moreover, upon approaching ${\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}$ a relatively well-defined quasiparticle feature starts to emerge within the gap and is seen in both the Bose single-particle excitation and the density oscillation spectrum. In the BCS regime, due to the very small number of occupied bosonic states, the low-energy quasiparticle features are absent. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 1, 1996•48 citations

A First-Order Phase Transition in Spin-Imbalanced BCS Theory of Superconductivity

Marius Lemm, Barbara Roos

We study a translation-invariant BCS functional of superconductivity for a system of spin-$1/2$ fermions with spin-dependent chemical potentials, $μ_+\neqμ_-$. Numerical work of Caldas and Mota and analytical work of Freiji, Hainzl, and Seiringer has suggested an unusual first-order phase transition in spin-imbalanced BCS models, in which the normal state becomes globally unstable while remaining locally stable. Here, we prove that a first-order phase transition occurs in such spin-imbalanced BCS functionals. For each sufficiently small fixed spin imbalance and sufficiently low temperature, there is a coexistence coupling $λ_{\mathrm{fo}}$ strictly below the linear-stability threshold $λ_{\mathrm{lin}}$ of the normal state at which the Cooper pair density exhibits a nonzero jump and the minimized energy has a kink. The methodological insight is a coercivity estimate obtained by decomposing the BCS energy minimization into two parts, where the ``inner'' problem minimizes over the one-particle density matrices at fixed pairing and can be exactly solved by a Legendre--Fenchel transform.

arXiv:2610.38961•Oct 28, 2026•0 citations
We examine the equilibrium solutions of the BCS theory of superconductivity in the low temperature allowing the attraction band to be asymmetric with respect to the chemical potential of the system μR\mu_RμR​. If we denote by μ\muμ the middle of the attraction band, we observe that the superconducting phase is formed only if ∣μR−μ∣<2Δ0|\mu_R-\mu| < 2\Delta_0∣μR​−μ∣<2Δ0​, where Δ0\Delta_0Δ0​ is the energy gap at zero temperature in the BCS theory. If ∣μR−μ∣<2Δ0|\mu_R-\mu| < 2\Delta_0∣μR​−μ∣<2Δ0​, the system of equations which give the energy gap has two solutions for each value of μR−μ\mu_R-\muμR​−μ: one with Δ(T=0)=Δ0\Delta(T=0) = \Delta_0Δ(T=0)=Δ0​ and another one, with Δ(T=0)<Δ0\Delta(T=0) < \Delta_0Δ(T=0)<Δ0​ (Δ(T=0)\Delta(T=0)Δ(T=0) is the energy gap at 0~K). If 0<∣μR−μ∣<2Δ00<|\mu_R-\mu| < 2\Delta_00<∣μR​−μ∣<2Δ0​, a quasiparticle imbalance appears in equilibrium. In the standard BCS limit, which is μR→μ\mu_R \to \muμR​→μ, beside the solution Δ(T=0)=Δ0\Delta(T=0) = \Delta_0Δ(T=0)=Δ0​, we find another one, with Δ(T=0)=Δ0/3\Delta(T=0) = \Delta_0/3Δ(T=0)=Δ0​/3 and nonzero quasiparticle population. The formalism takes into account in a consistent way the variation of the total number of particles with the population of the quasiparticle states.
We analyze the interplay between superconductivity and the formation of bound pairs of fermions (BCS-BEC crossover) in a 2D model of interacting fermions with small Fermi energy EF{E}_{F}EF​ and weak attractive interaction, which extends to energies well above EF{E}_{F}EF​. The 2D case is special because a two-particle bound state forms at arbitrary weak interaction, and already at weak coupling, one has to distinguish between the bound-state formation and superconductivity. We briefly review the situation in the one-band model and then consider two different two-band models: one with one hole band and one electron band and another with two hole or two electron bands. In each case, we obtain the bound-state energy 2E02{E}_{0}2E0​ for two fermions in a vacuum and solve the set of coupled equations for the pairing gaps and the chemical potentials to obtain the onset temperature of the pairing Tins{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}Tins​ and the quasiparticle dispersion at T=0T=0T=0. We then compute the superfluid stiffness ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{s}(T=0)$ and obtain the actual Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. For definiteness, we set EF{E}_{F}EF​ in one band to be near zero and consider different ratios of E0{E}_{0}E0​ and EF{E}_{F}EF​ in the other band. We show that at ${E}_{F}\ensuremath{\gg}{E}_{0}$, the behavior of both two-band models is BCS-like in the sense that ${T}_{c}\ensuremath{\approx}{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}\ensuremath{\ll}{E}_{F}$ and $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}{T}_{c}$. At ${E}_{F}\ensuremath{\ll}{E}_{0}$, the two models behave differently: in the model with two hole/two electron bands, ${T}_{\mathrm{ins}}\ensuremath{\sim}{E}_{0}/ln\frac{{E}_{0}}{{E}_{F}}, \mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}{({E}_{0}{E}_{F})}^{1/2}$, and ${T}_{c}\ensuremath{\sim}{E}_{F}$, like in the one-band model. In between Tins{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}Tins​ and Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, the system displays a preformed pair behavior. In the model with one hole and one electron bands, Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ remains of order Tins{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}Tins​, and both remain finite at EF=0{E}_{F}=0EF​=0 and of the order of E0{E}_{0}E0​. The preformed pair behavior still does exist in this model because Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is numerically smaller than Tins{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}Tins​. For both models, we reexpress Tins{T}_{\mathrm{ins}}Tins​ in terms of the fully renormalized two-particle scattering amplitude by extending to the two-band case (the method pioneered by Gorkov and Melik-Barkhudarov back in 1961). We apply our results for the model with a hole and an electron band to Fe pnictides and Fe chalcogenides in which a superconducting gap has been detected on the bands that do not cross the Fermi level, and to FeSe, in which the superconducting gap is comparable to the Fermi energy. We apply the results for the model with two electron bands to Nb-doped SrTiO3{\mathrm{SrTiO}}_{3}SrTiO3​ and argue that our theory explains the rapid increase of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ when both bands start crossing the Fermi level.
We revisit the problem of a BCS superconductor in the regime where the Fermi energy is smaller than the Debye energy. This regime is relevant for low-density superconductors such as SrTiO3{\mathrm{SrTiO}}_{3}SrTiO3​ that are not in the BEC limit, as well as in the problem of ``shape resonances'' associated with the confinement of a three-dimensional superconductor. While the problem is not new, exact results were lacking in the low-density limit. In two dimensions, we find that the initial rise of the pairing temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ at low density nnn is nonanalytic and faster than any power of nnn. In three dimensions, we also find that Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is nonanalytic, but starts with zero slope at weak coupling and infinite slope at strong coupling. Self-consistent treatment of the chemical potential and energy dependence of the density of states are crucial ingredients to obtain these results. We also present exact results for multiband systems and confirm our analytical expressions by numerical simulations.
For the Cooper/BCS model interaction in superconductors (SCs) it is shown: a) how BCS-Bose crossover picture transition temperatures Tc, defined self-consistently by both the gap and fermion-number equations, require unphysically large couplings to differ significantly from the Tc of ordinary BCS theory defined without the number equation since here the chemical potential is assumed equal to the Fermi energy; how although ignoring either hole- or electron-Cooper-pairs in the recent "complete boson-fermion model": b) one obtains the precise BCS gap equation for all temperatures T, but c) only half the zero-temperature BCS condensation energy emerges. Results (b) and (c) are also expected to hold for neutral-fermion superfluids (SFs)--such as liquid 3^33He, neutron matter and trapped ultra-cold fermion atomic gases--where the pair-forming two-fermion interaction of course differs from the Cooper/BCS one for SCs.
Candidate homogeneous, isotropic superfluid or superconducting states of paired fermion species with different chemical potentials, can lead to quasiparticle excitation energies that vanish at either 0, 1, or 2 spheres in momentum space. With no zeros, we have a conventional BCS superconductor. The other two cases, ``gapless'' superconductors, appear in mean- field theory for sufficiently large mismatches and/or sufficiently large coupling strengths. Here we examine several stability criteria for those candidate phases. Positivity of number susceptibility appears to provide the most powerful constraint, and renders all the two-zero states that we have examined mechanically unstable. Our results should apply directly to ultracold fermionic atom systems.
The spectral properties of a mixture of bosons hybridized with fermion pairs are studied in the superconducting state. Such a model exhibits two limiting behaviors. One is reminiscent of a BCS system, provided that the total concentration n of particles is below a certain critical concentration nc{\mathit{n}}_{\mathit{c}}nc​, in which case bosons exist only in thermally excited states. The other limit for n\ensuremath{\geqslant}nc{\mathit{n}}_{\mathit{c}}nc​ describes a situation largely controlled by the condensation of the bosons. The variation of the single-boson as well as collective excitations as a function of n and for the entire temperature regime from T=0 K to Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ will be discussed, both with and without long-range Coulomb interaction between the charge carriers. The method for calculation applied here is based on the dielectric formalism and the use of Ward identities, currently used in the theory of the interacting Bose gas, which allows us to derive the density and current correlation functions consistent with local charge-current conservation laws. In the absence of a Coulomb interaction the behavior of the system is characterized by the existence of a sound-wave-like branch in the Bose single-particle and collective excitation spectrum. In the BCS regime the sound velocity is proportional to the Fermi velocity while in the Bose regime it is proportional to the strength of the boson-fermion hybridization and decreases with the superfluid density as we approach Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​. In the presence of a long-range Coulomb interaction and in the Bose regime one observes, besides the usual optical plasmon mode at high frequency and corresponding to in-phase density oscillation of the two subsytems, an out-of-phase collective mode in the two particle continuum just above the gap. Moreover, upon approaching Tc{\mathit{T}}_{\mathit{c}}Tc​ a relatively well-defined quasiparticle feature starts to emerge within the gap and is seen in both the Bose single-particle excitation and the density oscillation spectrum. In the BCS regime, due to the very small number of occupied bosonic states, the low-energy quasiparticle features are absent. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
We study a translation-invariant BCS functional of superconductivity for a system of spin-1/21/21/2 fermions with spin-dependent chemical potentials, μ+≠μ−μ_+\neqμ_-μ+​=μ−​. Numerical work of Caldas and Mota and analytical work of Freiji, Hainzl, and Seiringer has suggested an unusual first-order phase transition in spin-imbalanced BCS models, in which the normal state becomes globally unstable while remaining locally stable. Here, we prove that a first-order phase transition occurs in such spin-imbalanced BCS functionals. For each sufficiently small fixed spin imbalance and sufficiently low temperature, there is a coexistence coupling λfoλ_{\mathrm{fo}}λfo​ strictly below the linear-stability threshold λlinλ_{\mathrm{lin}}λlin​ of the normal state at which the Cooper pair density exhibits a nonzero jump and the minimized energy has a kink. The methodological insight is a coercivity estimate obtained by decomposing the BCS energy minimization into two parts, where the ``inner'' problem minimizes over the one-particle density matrices at fixed pairing and can be exactly solved by a Legendre--Fenchel transform.