Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1608.03820 · Cryptography

Recursive Cheating Strategies for the Relativistic FQ Bit Commitment Protocol

Rémi Bricout, André Chailloux

Published Aug 24, 2017• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we study relativistic bit commitment, which uses timing and location constraints to achieve information theoretic security. Using those constraints, we consider a relativistic bit commitment scheme introduced by Lunghi et al. This protocol was shown secure against classical adversaries as long as the number of rounds performed in the protocol is not too large. In this work, we study classical attacks on this scheme. We use the correspondence between this protocol and the CHSHQ game—which is a variant of the CHSH game—to derive cheating strategies for this protocol. Our attack matches the existing security bound for some range of parameters and shows that the scaling of the security in the number of rounds is essentially optimal.

DOI
10.3390/cryptography1020014

Related papers

Arbitrarily Long Relativistic Bit Commitment

Kaushik Chakraborty, André Chailloux, Anthony Leverrier

We consider the recent relativistic bit commitment protocol introduced by Lunghi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 030502 (2015)] and present a new security analysis against classical attacks. In particular, while the initial complexity of the protocol scales double exponentially with the commitment time, our analysis shows that the correct dependence is only linear. This has dramatic implications in terms of implementation: in particular, the commitment time can easily be made arbitrarily long, by only requiring both parties to communicate classically and perform efficient classical computation.

arXiv:1507.00239•Physical Review Letters•Dec 17, 2015•29 citations

Practical Relativistic Bit Commitment

Tommaso Lunghi, Jędrzej Kaniewski, Félix Bussières +4 more

Bit commitment is a fundamental cryptographic primitive in which Alice wishes to commit a secret bit to Bob. Perfectly secure bit commitment between two mistrustful parties is impossible through an asynchronous exchange of quantum information. Perfect security is, however, possible when Alice and Bob each split into several agents exchanging classical information at times and locations suitably chosen to satisfy specific relativistic constraints. In this Letter we first revisit a previously proposed scheme [C. Crépeau et al., Lect. Notes Comput. Sci. 7073, 407 (2011)] that realizes bit commitment using only classical communication. We prove that the protocol is secure against quantum adversaries for a duration limited by the light-speed communication time between the locations of the agents. We then propose a novel multiround scheme based on finite-field arithmetic that extends the commitment time beyond this limit, and we prove its security against classical attacks. Finally, we present an implementation of these protocols using dedicated hardware and we demonstrate a 2 ms-long bit commitment over a distance of 131 km. By positioning the agents on antipodal points on the surface of Earth, the commitment time could possibly be extended to 212 ms.

arXiv:1411.4917•Physical Review Letters•Jul 13, 2015•56 citations

Relativistic quantum cryptography

Jędrzej Kaniewski

In this thesis we explore the benefits of relativistic constraints for cryptography. We first revisit non-communicating models and its applications in the context of interactive proofs and cryptography. We propose bit commitment protocols whose security hinges on communication constraints and investigate its limitations. We explain how some non-communicating models can be justified by special relativity and study the limitations of such models. In particular, we present a framework for analysing security of multiround relativistic protocols. The second part of the thesis is dedicated to analysing specific protocols. We start by considering a recently proposed two-round quantum bit commitment protocol. We propose a fault-tolerant variant of the protocol, present a complete security analysis and report on an experimental implementation performed in collaboration with an experimental group at the University of Geneva. We also propose a new, multiround classical bit commitment protocol and prove its security against classical adversaries. This demonstrates that in the classical world an arbitrarily long commitment can be achieved even if the agents are restricted to occupy a finite region of space. Moreover, the protocol is easy to implement and we report on an experiment performed in collaboration with the Geneva group.

arXiv:1512.00602•Dec 2, 2015•7 citations

Device-independent relativistic quantum bit commitment

Emily Adlam, Adrian Kent

We examine the possibility of device-independent relativistic quantum bit commitment, introducing three relativistic quantum bit commitment schemes that offer device-independent security against hypothetical postquantum adversaries subject only to the no-signaling principle. We discuss the potential threat of location attacks, in which the behavior of untrusted devices used in relativistic quantum cryptography depends on their space-time location and show that our protocols are secure against both location attacks and memory attacks. The protocols are compared to a relativistic classical bit commitment scheme with similar features and we note some advantages for the quantum schemes.

arXiv:1504.00944•Physical Review A•Aug 7, 2015•39 citations

Secure Classical Bit Commitment over Finite Channels

Adrian Kent

If mistrustful parties A and B control two or more appropriately located sites, special relativity can be used to guarantee that a pair of messages exchanged by A and B are independent. Using this fact, an unconditionally secure relativistic bit commitment protocol, RBC1, was recently defined. Security is maintained in RBC1 by exchanging a sequence of messages whose transmission rate increases exponentially in time. We define here a variant, RBC2, which requires a constant transmission rate and can in practice be securely maintained for long periods. We also introduce a zero-knowledge proof protocol which allows A to convince B of the value of any function of $N$ relativistic bit commitments without giving any further information. Applying this to the XOR of two bit commitments made by RBC1 or RBC2, we define two further relativistic bit commitment protocols, RBC3 and RBC4. These two protocols are permanently unconditionally secure against classical attack and require only a constant transmission rate. We conjecture that they are also unconditionally secure against quantum attack.

•Jun 29, 1999•6 citations

Robust relativistic bit commitment

Kaushik Chakraborty, André Chailloux, Anthony Leverrier

Relativistic cryptography exploits the fact that no information can travel faster than the speed of light in order to obtain security guarantees that cannot be achieved from the laws of quantum mechanics alone. Recently, Lunghi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 030502 (2015)] presented a bit-commitment scheme where each party uses two agents that exchange classical information in a synchronized fashion, and that is both hiding and binding. A caveat is that the commitment time is intrinsically limited by the spatial configuration of the players, and increasing this time requires the agents to exchange messages during the whole duration of the protocol. While such a solution remains computationally attractive, its practicality is severely limited in realistic settings since all communication must remain perfectly synchronized at all times. In this work, we introduce a robust protocol for relativistic bit commitment that tolerates failures of the classical communication network. This is done by adding a third agent to both parties. Our scheme provides a quadratic improvement in terms of expected sustain time compared with the original protocol, while retaining the same level of security.

arXiv:1608.03398•Physical Review A•Dec 12, 2016•2 citations
In this paper, we study relativistic bit commitment, which uses timing and location constraints to achieve information theoretic security. Using those constraints, we consider a relativistic bit commitment scheme introduced by Lunghi et al. This protocol was shown secure against classical adversaries as long as the number of rounds performed in the protocol is not too large. In this work, we study classical attacks on this scheme. We use the correspondence between this protocol and the CHSHQ game—which is a variant of the CHSH game—to derive cheating strategies for this protocol. Our attack matches the existing security bound for some range of parameters and shows that the scaling of the security in the number of rounds is essentially optimal.
We consider the recent relativistic bit commitment protocol introduced by Lunghi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 030502 (2015)] and present a new security analysis against classical attacks. In particular, while the initial complexity of the protocol scales double exponentially with the commitment time, our analysis shows that the correct dependence is only linear. This has dramatic implications in terms of implementation: in particular, the commitment time can easily be made arbitrarily long, by only requiring both parties to communicate classically and perform efficient classical computation.
Bit commitment is a fundamental cryptographic primitive in which Alice wishes to commit a secret bit to Bob. Perfectly secure bit commitment between two mistrustful parties is impossible through an asynchronous exchange of quantum information. Perfect security is, however, possible when Alice and Bob each split into several agents exchanging classical information at times and locations suitably chosen to satisfy specific relativistic constraints. In this Letter we first revisit a previously proposed scheme [C. Crépeau et al., Lect. Notes Comput. Sci. 7073, 407 (2011)] that realizes bit commitment using only classical communication. We prove that the protocol is secure against quantum adversaries for a duration limited by the light-speed communication time between the locations of the agents. We then propose a novel multiround scheme based on finite-field arithmetic that extends the commitment time beyond this limit, and we prove its security against classical attacks. Finally, we present an implementation of these protocols using dedicated hardware and we demonstrate a 2 ms-long bit commitment over a distance of 131 km. By positioning the agents on antipodal points on the surface of Earth, the commitment time could possibly be extended to 212 ms.
In this thesis we explore the benefits of relativistic constraints for cryptography. We first revisit non-communicating models and its applications in the context of interactive proofs and cryptography. We propose bit commitment protocols whose security hinges on communication constraints and investigate its limitations. We explain how some non-communicating models can be justified by special relativity and study the limitations of such models. In particular, we present a framework for analysing security of multiround relativistic protocols. The second part of the thesis is dedicated to analysing specific protocols. We start by considering a recently proposed two-round quantum bit commitment protocol. We propose a fault-tolerant variant of the protocol, present a complete security analysis and report on an experimental implementation performed in collaboration with an experimental group at the University of Geneva. We also propose a new, multiround classical bit commitment protocol and prove its security against classical adversaries. This demonstrates that in the classical world an arbitrarily long commitment can be achieved even if the agents are restricted to occupy a finite region of space. Moreover, the protocol is easy to implement and we report on an experiment performed in collaboration with the Geneva group.
We examine the possibility of device-independent relativistic quantum bit commitment, introducing three relativistic quantum bit commitment schemes that offer device-independent security against hypothetical postquantum adversaries subject only to the no-signaling principle. We discuss the potential threat of location attacks, in which the behavior of untrusted devices used in relativistic quantum cryptography depends on their space-time location and show that our protocols are secure against both location attacks and memory attacks. The protocols are compared to a relativistic classical bit commitment scheme with similar features and we note some advantages for the quantum schemes.
If mistrustful parties A and B control two or more appropriately located sites, special relativity can be used to guarantee that a pair of messages exchanged by A and B are independent. Using this fact, an unconditionally secure relativistic bit commitment protocol, RBC1, was recently defined. Security is maintained in RBC1 by exchanging a sequence of messages whose transmission rate increases exponentially in time. We define here a variant, RBC2, which requires a constant transmission rate and can in practice be securely maintained for long periods. We also introduce a zero-knowledge proof protocol which allows A to convince B of the value of any function of NNN relativistic bit commitments without giving any further information. Applying this to the XOR of two bit commitments made by RBC1 or RBC2, we define two further relativistic bit commitment protocols, RBC3 and RBC4. These two protocols are permanently unconditionally secure against classical attack and require only a constant transmission rate. We conjecture that they are also unconditionally secure against quantum attack.
Relativistic cryptography exploits the fact that no information can travel faster than the speed of light in order to obtain security guarantees that cannot be achieved from the laws of quantum mechanics alone. Recently, Lunghi et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 030502 (2015)] presented a bit-commitment scheme where each party uses two agents that exchange classical information in a synchronized fashion, and that is both hiding and binding. A caveat is that the commitment time is intrinsically limited by the spatial configuration of the players, and increasing this time requires the agents to exchange messages during the whole duration of the protocol. While such a solution remains computationally attractive, its practicality is severely limited in realistic settings since all communication must remain perfectly synchronized at all times. In this work, we introduce a robust protocol for relativistic bit commitment that tolerates failures of the classical communication network. This is done by adding a third agent to both parties. Our scheme provides a quadratic improvement in terms of expected sustain time compared with the original protocol, while retaining the same level of security.