Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1608.02677 · Physical Review A

Hybrid quantum systems with trapped charged particles

Shlomi Kotler, Raymond W. Simmonds, Dietrich G. Leibfried, David J. Wineland

Published Feb 21, 2017• 45 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Trapped charged particles have been at the forefront of quantum information processing (QIP) for a few decades now, with deterministic two-qubit logic gates reaching record fidelities of $99.9%$ and single-qubit operations of much higher fidelity. In a hybrid system involving trapped charges, quantum degrees of freedom of macroscopic objects such as bulk acoustic resonators, superconducting circuits, or nanomechanical membranes, couple to the trapped charges and ideally inherit the coherent properties of the charges. The hybrid system therefore implements a ``quantum transducer,'' where the quantum reality (i.e., superpositions and entanglement) of small objects is extended to include the larger object. Although a hybrid quantum system with trapped charges could be valuable both for fundamental research and for QIP applications, no such system exists today. Here we study theoretically the possibilities of coupling the quantum-mechanical motion of a trapped charged particle (e.g., an ion or electron) to the quantum degrees of freedom of superconducting devices, nanomechanical resonators, and quartz bulk acoustic wave resonators. For each case, we estimate the coupling rate between the charged particle and its macroscopic counterpart and compare it to the decoherence rate, i.e., the rate at which quantum superposition decays. A hybrid system can only be considered quantum if the coupling rate significantly exceeds all decoherence rates. Our approach is to examine specific examples by using parameters that are experimentally attainable in the foreseeable future. We conclude that hybrid quantum systems involving a single atomic ion are unfavorable compared with the use of a single electron because the coupling rates between the ion and its counterpart are slower than the expected decoherence rates. A system based on trapped electrons, on the other hand, might have coupling rates that significantly exceed decoherence rates. Moreover, it might have appealing properties such as fast entangling gates, long coherence, and flexible topology that is fully electronic in nature. Realizing such a system, however, is technologically challenging because it requires accommodating both a trapping technology and superconducting circuitry in a compatible manner. We review some of the challenges involved, such as the required trap parameters, electron sources, electrical circuitry, and cooling schemes in order to promote further investigations towards the realization of such a hybrid system.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.95.022327

Related papers

Feasibility study on ground-state cooling and single-phonon readout of trapped electrons using hybrid quantum systems

Alto Osada, Kento Taniguchi, Masato Shigefuji +1 more

Qubits of long coherence time and fast quantum operations are long-sought objectives toward the realization of high-fidelity quantum operations and their applications to quantum technologies. An electron levitated in a vacuum by a Paul trap is expected to be a good candidate, for its light mass and hence the high secular frequency which allows for faster gate operations than those in trapped ions. Controlling the motional state of the trapped electron is a crucial issue, for it mediates an interaction between electron spins, intrinsic qubits embedded in electrons, and its decoherence results in degraded fidelity of two-qubit gates. In addition, an efficient readout of the motional state is important, regarding the possibility of detecting spin state by using it. Despite such importance, how to achieve the motional ground state and how to efficiently detect it are not reported so far. Here we propose methods addressing these issues by utilizing hybrid quantum systems involving an electron-superconducting circuit and electron-ion coupled systems and analyze the feasibility of our schemes. In both systems, we show that ground-state cooling and single-phonon readout of the motional state of the trapped electron are possible. Our work sheds light on a way to precisely control the motional states of the trapped electrons, that provides an interesting playground for the development of quantum technologies.

arXiv:2204.07957•Physical Review Research•Sep 29, 2022•13 citations

Quantum gates, sensors, and systems with trapped ions

Shannon X. Wang

Quantum information science promises a host of new and useful applications in communication, simulation, and computational algorithms. Trapped atomic ions are one of the leading physical systems with potential to implement a large-scale quantum information system, but many challenges still remain. This thesis describes some experimental approaches to address several such challenges broadly organized under three themes: gates, sensors, and systems. Quantum logic gates are the fundamental building blocks for quantum algorithms. Although they have been demonstrated with trapped ions previously, scalability requires miniaturizing ion traps by using a surface-electrode geometry. Using a single ion in a surface-electrode trap, we perform a two-qubit entangling gate and fully characterize it via quantum process tomography, as an initial validation of surface-electrode ion traps for quantum information processing. Good logic gates are often good sensors for fast fluctuations and energy changes in their environment. Trapped ions are sensitive to fluctuating and static charges, leading to motional state decoherence (heating) and instabilities, problems exacerbated by the surface-electrode geometry. We investigate the material dependence of heating, specifically with aluminum and superconducting traps, to elucidate the physical origin of these fluctuating charges. Static charging is hypothesized to be caused by the trapping and cooling lasers due to the photoelectric effect. We perform systematic experiments with aluminum, gold, and copper traps with lasers at various wavelengths to validate this hypothesis. Realizing quantum processors at the system level requires models and tools for predicting system performance, demonstration of good classical and quantum control, and techniques for integrating different quantum systems. We develop a modeling system for trapped ion quantum computing experiments and simulate the effect of physical and technical noise sources on practical realizations of quantum algorithms in a trapped ion system. We experimentally demonstrate several such algorithms, including the quantum Fourier transform, order-finding, and Shor's algorithm on up to 5 ions. These experiments highlight several unique advantages of ion trap systems and help identify needs for further development. Finally, we explore the integration of ion traps with optical elements including mirrors and photon detectors as key elements in creating future hybrid quantum systems.

•Jan 1, 2012•7 citations

A new experimental apparatus for atom-ion quantum mixtures

Amelia Detti

Hybrid quantum systems represent one of the most promising routes in the progress of experimental quantum physics and in the development of quantum technologies. In a hybrid quantum system two (or more) different quantum systems interact in the same experimental setup. Therefore, these composite systems benefit from both the properties of each single system and from the presence of an interaction term, leading to the emergence of new variables that can be experimentally manipulated. \nA promising hybrid quantum system is the one realized by the com- bination of an ultracold atomic gas and trapped ions. Ultracold atoms and trapped ions are two of the most studied physical systems for the implementation of several quantum technologies, like e.g. quantum simulation, quantum computa- tion, and quantum metrology. When trapped together, atoms and ions interact via an interaction potential that scales asymptotically with R^(−4), where R is the inter- particle distance, due to the electrostatic (attractive) force between the ion’s electric monopole and the atom’s induced dipole. Interestingly, this potential has a typical range on the order of hundreds of nm, i.e. approx. two orders of magnitude longer than the range of atom-atom interactions. Several studies have proposed to use this interaction to realize new quantum simulations, study few-body physics, and control atom-ion chemical reactions. \nElastic collisions between ions and atoms can be exploited to sympathetically cool the ions and try to reach the so-far elusive s-wave scattering regime, in which atom- ion collisions can lead to a quantum coherent evolution of the composite system. However, the ultracold atom-ion mixtures realized so far were not brought to the s-wave scattering regime because of the so-called “micromotion”, a driven motion affecting the dynamics of the ions trapped in Paul traps. Atom-ion collisions in the presence of micromotion cause a coupling of energy from the oscillating field of the Paul trap to the colliding particles, which can be heated up in the collision. In order to realize an atom-ion experiment in which the system could reach the s-wave scattering regime, the choice of the atomic species and the ion trapping strategy are crucial. \nWe decided to build a new experimental apparatus for the realization of an ultracold atom-ion quantum hybrid system made of a quantum gas of fermionic Lithium and trapped Barium ions. The choice for the elements ensures that atoms and ions in their electronic ground state will not undergo charge- exchange collisions, i.e. inelastic processes for which an electron is “exchanged” be- tween the two colliding particles. Additionally, the large mass ratio ensures an efficient cooling of the ion in the ultracold gas. \nFor what regards the ion trapping strategy, in order to remove the limitations set by micromotion, we conceived a new trap. This is formed by the superposition of an electric quadrupole static potential and an optical lattice along the untrapping direction of the electric quadrupole. The ions are moved into this electro-optical trap (EOT) from a standard Paul trap, in which the ions are first trapped after their production through photoionization. \nIn this thesis, I will describe how this new experimental apparatus for the real- ization of an ultracold atom-ion quantum hybrid system was conceived, designed and assembled. I will first describe the motivations for investigating atom-ion interactions in the ultracold regime. Then, I will describe the experimental techniques to trap and cool Barium ions and Lithium atoms, and how we plan to make them interact. The largest part of the thesis will be dedicated to the description of the parts of the experimental setup that I designed and realized, like the Lithium optical setup, the Barium imaging system and the electrical setup of the ion trap, including a compact RF drive based on interdependent resonant circuits that I developed for operating the Paul trap. The last chapter of the thesis is dedicated to this innovative drive.

•Jan 1, 2020•0 citations

Issues using equivalent circuit elements to describe trapped ions

Noah Van Horne, Manas Mukherjee

Trapped charged particles, and in particular trapped ions, are among the leading candidates for quantum computing technologies. However, our ability to interconnect arrays of ions in different traps is a significant hurdle in scaling trapped ion quantum computing. One approach to overcome this problem is using a solid state conducting wire to mediate the Coulomb interaction between particles in different traps. Additionally, there is strong interest in interfacing trapped ion qubits with solid state superconducting qubits to develop hybrid systems which benefit from the complementary strengths of the two technologies. For studies related to these fields, a trapped charged particle inducing charge on a conductor has long been modeled using equivalent circuit elements. The equivalent circuit element approach is popular partly due to the appeal of a model for analyzing systems using simple electronic components. As a result, a body of theoretical work is founded on this approach. However, careful consideration of the model leads to inconsistencies. Here, we identify the origin of the inconsistencies and their implications. Our result removes a potential road-block for future studies aiming to use conductors to connect independent arrays of ions, or to interface charged particles with solid-state qubit technologies. In addition, for the specific case of two trapped ions interacting via a conducting coupling system, we introduce an alternative way to use linear relationships, which reproduces results from other works that are not based on the circuit element model. This method is useful in trouble-shooting real experimental designs and assessing the accuracy of different theoretical models.

•Aug 17, 2020•0 citations

Coupling two charge qubits via a superconducting resonator operating in the resonant and dispersive regimes

Chengxian Zhang, Guo Xuan Chan, Xin Wang +1 more

A key challenge for semiconductor quantum-dot charge qubits is the realization of long-range qubit coupling and performing high-fidelity gates based on it. Here, we describe a different type of charge qubit formed by an electron confined in a triple-quantum-dot system, enabling single and two-qubit gates working in the dipolar and quadrupolar detuning sweet spots. We further present the form for the long-range dipolar coupling between the charge qubit and the superconducting resonator. Based on the hybrid system composed of the qubits and the resonator, we present two types of entangling gates: the dynamical iswap gate and holonomic entangling gate, which are operating in the dispersive and resonant regimes, respectively. We find that the fidelity for the iswap gate can reach a fidelity higher than 99% for the noise level typical in experiments. Meanwhile, the fidelity for the holonomic gate can surpass 98% if the anharmonicity in the resonator is large enough. Our proposal offers an alternative, useful way to build up high-fidelity quantum computation for charge qubits in the semiconductor quantum dot.

arXiv:2012.14129•Physical Review A•Sep 12, 2022•9 citations

Silicon based quantum dot hybrid qubits

Dohun Kim

The charge and spin degrees of freedom of an electron constitute natural bases for constructing quantum two level systems, or qubits, in semiconductor quantum dots. The quantum dot charge qubit offers a simple architecture and high-speed operation, but generally suffers from fast dephasing due to strong coupling of the environment to the electron’s charge. On the other hand, quantum dot spin qubits have demonstrated long coherence times, but their manipulation is often slower than desired for important future applications. This talk will present experimental progress of a ‘hybrid’ qubit, formed by three electrons in a Si/SiGe double quantum dot, which combines desirable characteristics (speed and coherence) in the past found separately in qubits based on either charge or spin degrees of freedom. Using resonant microwaves, we first discuss qubit operations near the ‘sweet spot’ for charge qubit operation. Along with fast ( >GHz) manipulation rates for any rotation axis on the Bloch sphere, we implement two independent tomographic characterization schemes in the charge qubit regime: traditional quantum process tomography (QPT) and gate set tomography (GST). We also present resonant qubit operations of the hybrid qubit performed on the same device, DC pulsed gate operations of which were recently demonstrated. We demonstrate three-axis control and the implementation of dynamic decoupling pulse sequences. Performing QPT on the hybrid qubit, we show that AC gating yields π rotation process fidelities higher than 93% for X-axis and 96% for Z-axis rotations, which demonstrates efficient quantum control of semiconductor qubits using resonant microwaves. We discuss a path forward for achieving fidelities better than the threshold for quantum error correction using surface codes.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 3, 2015•0 citations
Trapped charged particles have been at the forefront of quantum information processing (QIP) for a few decades now, with deterministic two-qubit logic gates reaching record fidelities of 99.999.9%99.9 and single-qubit operations of much higher fidelity. In a hybrid system involving trapped charges, quantum degrees of freedom of macroscopic objects such as bulk acoustic resonators, superconducting circuits, or nanomechanical membranes, couple to the trapped charges and ideally inherit the coherent properties of the charges. The hybrid system therefore implements a ``quantum transducer,'' where the quantum reality (i.e., superpositions and entanglement) of small objects is extended to include the larger object. Although a hybrid quantum system with trapped charges could be valuable both for fundamental research and for QIP applications, no such system exists today. Here we study theoretically the possibilities of coupling the quantum-mechanical motion of a trapped charged particle (e.g., an ion or electron) to the quantum degrees of freedom of superconducting devices, nanomechanical resonators, and quartz bulk acoustic wave resonators. For each case, we estimate the coupling rate between the charged particle and its macroscopic counterpart and compare it to the decoherence rate, i.e., the rate at which quantum superposition decays. A hybrid system can only be considered quantum if the coupling rate significantly exceeds all decoherence rates. Our approach is to examine specific examples by using parameters that are experimentally attainable in the foreseeable future. We conclude that hybrid quantum systems involving a single atomic ion are unfavorable compared with the use of a single electron because the coupling rates between the ion and its counterpart are slower than the expected decoherence rates. A system based on trapped electrons, on the other hand, might have coupling rates that significantly exceed decoherence rates. Moreover, it might have appealing properties such as fast entangling gates, long coherence, and flexible topology that is fully electronic in nature. Realizing such a system, however, is technologically challenging because it requires accommodating both a trapping technology and superconducting circuitry in a compatible manner. We review some of the challenges involved, such as the required trap parameters, electron sources, electrical circuitry, and cooling schemes in order to promote further investigations towards the realization of such a hybrid system.
Qubits of long coherence time and fast quantum operations are long-sought objectives toward the realization of high-fidelity quantum operations and their applications to quantum technologies. An electron levitated in a vacuum by a Paul trap is expected to be a good candidate, for its light mass and hence the high secular frequency which allows for faster gate operations than those in trapped ions. Controlling the motional state of the trapped electron is a crucial issue, for it mediates an interaction between electron spins, intrinsic qubits embedded in electrons, and its decoherence results in degraded fidelity of two-qubit gates. In addition, an efficient readout of the motional state is important, regarding the possibility of detecting spin state by using it. Despite such importance, how to achieve the motional ground state and how to efficiently detect it are not reported so far. Here we propose methods addressing these issues by utilizing hybrid quantum systems involving an electron-superconducting circuit and electron-ion coupled systems and analyze the feasibility of our schemes. In both systems, we show that ground-state cooling and single-phonon readout of the motional state of the trapped electron are possible. Our work sheds light on a way to precisely control the motional states of the trapped electrons, that provides an interesting playground for the development of quantum technologies.
Quantum information science promises a host of new and useful applications in communication, simulation, and computational algorithms. Trapped atomic ions are one of the leading physical systems with potential to implement a large-scale quantum information system, but many challenges still remain. This thesis describes some experimental approaches to address several such challenges broadly organized under three themes: gates, sensors, and systems. Quantum logic gates are the fundamental building blocks for quantum algorithms. Although they have been demonstrated with trapped ions previously, scalability requires miniaturizing ion traps by using a surface-electrode geometry. Using a single ion in a surface-electrode trap, we perform a two-qubit entangling gate and fully characterize it via quantum process tomography, as an initial validation of surface-electrode ion traps for quantum information processing. Good logic gates are often good sensors for fast fluctuations and energy changes in their environment. Trapped ions are sensitive to fluctuating and static charges, leading to motional state decoherence (heating) and instabilities, problems exacerbated by the surface-electrode geometry. We investigate the material dependence of heating, specifically with aluminum and superconducting traps, to elucidate the physical origin of these fluctuating charges. Static charging is hypothesized to be caused by the trapping and cooling lasers due to the photoelectric effect. We perform systematic experiments with aluminum, gold, and copper traps with lasers at various wavelengths to validate this hypothesis. Realizing quantum processors at the system level requires models and tools for predicting system performance, demonstration of good classical and quantum control, and techniques for integrating different quantum systems. We develop a modeling system for trapped ion quantum computing experiments and simulate the effect of physical and technical noise sources on practical realizations of quantum algorithms in a trapped ion system. We experimentally demonstrate several such algorithms, including the quantum Fourier transform, order-finding, and Shor's algorithm on up to 5 ions. These experiments highlight several unique advantages of ion trap systems and help identify needs for further development. Finally, we explore the integration of ion traps with optical elements including mirrors and photon detectors as key elements in creating future hybrid quantum systems.
Hybrid quantum systems represent one of the most promising routes in the progress of experimental quantum physics and in the development of quantum technologies. In a hybrid quantum system two (or more) different quantum systems interact in the same experimental setup. Therefore, these composite systems benefit from both the properties of each single system and from the presence of an interaction term, leading to the emergence of new variables that can be experimentally manipulated. \nA promising hybrid quantum system is the one realized by the com- bination of an ultracold atomic gas and trapped ions. Ultracold atoms and trapped ions are two of the most studied physical systems for the implementation of several quantum technologies, like e.g. quantum simulation, quantum computa- tion, and quantum metrology. When trapped together, atoms and ions interact via an interaction potential that scales asymptotically with R^(−4), where R is the inter- particle distance, due to the electrostatic (attractive) force between the ion’s electric monopole and the atom’s induced dipole. Interestingly, this potential has a typical range on the order of hundreds of nm, i.e. approx. two orders of magnitude longer than the range of atom-atom interactions. Several studies have proposed to use this interaction to realize new quantum simulations, study few-body physics, and control atom-ion chemical reactions. \nElastic collisions between ions and atoms can be exploited to sympathetically cool the ions and try to reach the so-far elusive s-wave scattering regime, in which atom- ion collisions can lead to a quantum coherent evolution of the composite system. However, the ultracold atom-ion mixtures realized so far were not brought to the s-wave scattering regime because of the so-called “micromotion”, a driven motion affecting the dynamics of the ions trapped in Paul traps. Atom-ion collisions in the presence of micromotion cause a coupling of energy from the oscillating field of the Paul trap to the colliding particles, which can be heated up in the collision. In order to realize an atom-ion experiment in which the system could reach the s-wave scattering regime, the choice of the atomic species and the ion trapping strategy are crucial. \nWe decided to build a new experimental apparatus for the realization of an ultracold atom-ion quantum hybrid system made of a quantum gas of fermionic Lithium and trapped Barium ions. The choice for the elements ensures that atoms and ions in their electronic ground state will not undergo charge- exchange collisions, i.e. inelastic processes for which an electron is “exchanged” be- tween the two colliding particles. Additionally, the large mass ratio ensures an efficient cooling of the ion in the ultracold gas. \nFor what regards the ion trapping strategy, in order to remove the limitations set by micromotion, we conceived a new trap. This is formed by the superposition of an electric quadrupole static potential and an optical lattice along the untrapping direction of the electric quadrupole. The ions are moved into this electro-optical trap (EOT) from a standard Paul trap, in which the ions are first trapped after their production through photoionization. \nIn this thesis, I will describe how this new experimental apparatus for the real- ization of an ultracold atom-ion quantum hybrid system was conceived, designed and assembled. I will first describe the motivations for investigating atom-ion interactions in the ultracold regime. Then, I will describe the experimental techniques to trap and cool Barium ions and Lithium atoms, and how we plan to make them interact. The largest part of the thesis will be dedicated to the description of the parts of the experimental setup that I designed and realized, like the Lithium optical setup, the Barium imaging system and the electrical setup of the ion trap, including a compact RF drive based on interdependent resonant circuits that I developed for operating the Paul trap. The last chapter of the thesis is dedicated to this innovative drive.
Trapped charged particles, and in particular trapped ions, are among the leading candidates for quantum computing technologies. However, our ability to interconnect arrays of ions in different traps is a significant hurdle in scaling trapped ion quantum computing. One approach to overcome this problem is using a solid state conducting wire to mediate the Coulomb interaction between particles in different traps. Additionally, there is strong interest in interfacing trapped ion qubits with solid state superconducting qubits to develop hybrid systems which benefit from the complementary strengths of the two technologies. For studies related to these fields, a trapped charged particle inducing charge on a conductor has long been modeled using equivalent circuit elements. The equivalent circuit element approach is popular partly due to the appeal of a model for analyzing systems using simple electronic components. As a result, a body of theoretical work is founded on this approach. However, careful consideration of the model leads to inconsistencies. Here, we identify the origin of the inconsistencies and their implications. Our result removes a potential road-block for future studies aiming to use conductors to connect independent arrays of ions, or to interface charged particles with solid-state qubit technologies. In addition, for the specific case of two trapped ions interacting via a conducting coupling system, we introduce an alternative way to use linear relationships, which reproduces results from other works that are not based on the circuit element model. This method is useful in trouble-shooting real experimental designs and assessing the accuracy of different theoretical models.
A key challenge for semiconductor quantum-dot charge qubits is the realization of long-range qubit coupling and performing high-fidelity gates based on it. Here, we describe a different type of charge qubit formed by an electron confined in a triple-quantum-dot system, enabling single and two-qubit gates working in the dipolar and quadrupolar detuning sweet spots. We further present the form for the long-range dipolar coupling between the charge qubit and the superconducting resonator. Based on the hybrid system composed of the qubits and the resonator, we present two types of entangling gates: the dynamical iswap gate and holonomic entangling gate, which are operating in the dispersive and resonant regimes, respectively. We find that the fidelity for the iswap gate can reach a fidelity higher than 99% for the noise level typical in experiments. Meanwhile, the fidelity for the holonomic gate can surpass 98% if the anharmonicity in the resonator is large enough. Our proposal offers an alternative, useful way to build up high-fidelity quantum computation for charge qubits in the semiconductor quantum dot.
The charge and spin degrees of freedom of an electron constitute natural bases for constructing quantum two level systems, or qubits, in semiconductor quantum dots. The quantum dot charge qubit offers a simple architecture and high-speed operation, but generally suffers from fast dephasing due to strong coupling of the environment to the electron’s charge. On the other hand, quantum dot spin qubits have demonstrated long coherence times, but their manipulation is often slower than desired for important future applications. This talk will present experimental progress of a ‘hybrid’ qubit, formed by three electrons in a Si/SiGe double quantum dot, which combines desirable characteristics (speed and coherence) in the past found separately in qubits based on either charge or spin degrees of freedom. Using resonant microwaves, we first discuss qubit operations near the ‘sweet spot’ for charge qubit operation. Along with fast ( >GHz) manipulation rates for any rotation axis on the Bloch sphere, we implement two independent tomographic characterization schemes in the charge qubit regime: traditional quantum process tomography (QPT) and gate set tomography (GST). We also present resonant qubit operations of the hybrid qubit performed on the same device, DC pulsed gate operations of which were recently demonstrated. We demonstrate three-axis control and the implementation of dynamic decoupling pulse sequences. Performing QPT on the hybrid qubit, we show that AC gating yields π rotation process fidelities higher than 93% for X-axis and 96% for Z-axis rotations, which demonstrates efficient quantum control of semiconductor qubits using resonant microwaves. We discuss a path forward for achieving fidelities better than the threshold for quantum error correction using surface codes.