Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1607.08193 · Physical Review A

Loss-tolerant quantum secure positioning with weak laser sources

Charles Ci Wen Lim, Feihu Xu, George Siopsis, Eric Chitambar, Philip G. Evans, Bing Qi

Published Sep 14, 2016• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum position verification (QPV) is the art of verifying the geographical location of an untrusted party. Recently, it has been shown that the widely studied Bennett Brassard 1984 (BB84) QPV protocol is insecure after the 3 dB loss point assuming local operations and classical communication (LOCC) adversaries. Here, we propose a time-reversed entanglement swapping QPV protocol (based on measurement-device-independent quantum cryptography) that is highly robust against quantum channel loss. First, assuming ideal qubit sources, we show that the protocol is secure against LOCC adversaries for any quantum channel loss, thereby overcoming the 3 dB loss limit. Then, we analyze the security of the protocol in a more practical setting involving weak laser sources and linear optics. In this setting, we find that the security only degrades by an additive constant and the protocol is able to verify positions up to 47 dB channel loss.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.94.032315

Related papers

Loss-tolerant position-based quantum cryptography

Bing Qi, George Siopsis

Position-based quantum cryptography (PBQC) allows a party to use its geographical location as its only credential to implement various cryptographic protocols. Such a protocol may lead to important applications in practice. Although it has been shown that any PBQC protocol is breakable if the adversaries pre-share an arbitrarily large entangled state, the security of PBQC in the bounded-quantum-storage model is still an open question. In this paper, we study the performance of various PBQC protocols over a lossy channel under the assumption that no entanglement is pre-shared between adversaries. By introducing the decoy state idea, we show that an extended Bennett-Brassard-1984--type PBQC protocol implemented with a weak coherent source and realistic single-photon detectors can tolerate an overall loss (including both the channel loss and the detection efficiency) of 13 dB if the intrinsic quantum bit error rate is 1%. We also study a few continuous variable PBQC protocols and show that they suffer from a 3-dB loss limitation.

arXiv:1502.02020•Physical Review A•Apr 28, 2015•31 citations

Quantum position verification: loss-tolerant protocols and fundamental limits

Philip Verduyn Lunel

In this thesis we explore position-based quantum cryptography zooming in on the task of position verification. In position verification, the idea is to use an individual's geographical location as a cryptographic credential. In practice, such protocols can authenticate that a message originated from a specific location or ensure that messages can only be read at a certain location. In a position-verification protocol, the limitations imposed by the speed of light, as described by special relativity, are used to verify that a party is at their claimed location. It has been shown that any QPV protocol can be broken by attackers that use an amount of entanglement exponential in the input size. However, from a practical point of view, not all is lost. We can still hope for QPV protocols that are secure in practice. This raises the problem of designing protocols that are secure in a practical setting. An important problem that arises is that of signal loss. Signal loss can be detrimental as it allows attackers to only answer on a subset of rounds. We investigate several questions related to the practical implementation of such protocols. We propose a new experimentally feasible protocol, which is fully loss-tolerant against attackers restricted to classical communication. Furthermore, we consider the role of allowing quantum communication with no pre-shared entanglement for attackers and show that this setting is strictly stronger than the classical one, indicating that allowing for quantum communication may break security. Conversely, we then show that any protocol secure against classical communication can be transformed into a protocol secure against quantum communication. Finally, we invert the picture, and consider the task of non-local quantum computation (NLQC), which corresponds to the operations of the attackers in a QPV protocol. We connect NLQC to the wider context of information-theoretic cryptography by relating it to a number of other cryptographic primitives.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations

Arbitrarily Loss-Tolerant Quantum Position Verification in a Single Execution

Llorenç Escolà-Farràs, Boris Škorić, Florian Speelman

Quantum position verification (QPV) aims to certify the location of an untrusted prover, but faces two major obstacles: fundamentally, entanglement-based attacks and, experimentally, photon loss. A commitment-based modification introduced in Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 260801 addresses both in sequentially repeated protocols. Its security analysis, however, relies on the sequential structure and does not extend to parallel repetition. We use a different proof approach to establish security of the commitment modification for a parallel BB84-based QPV protocol. Against bounded-entanglement adversaries, the acceptance probability decays exponentially in the minimum number $k$ of successfully committed qubits. The protocol tolerates arbitrary transmission loss and noise rates up to 3.7%, while allowing arbitrarily slow quantum communication. This yields a fully loss-tolerant, single-execution QPV protocol secure against bounded-entanglement attacks, removing transmission loss as a fundamental limitation on verification distance. We also revisit sequential repetition, correcting the treatment of conditioning on commitment and replacing the earlier conditional guarantee with an unconditional security bound, without the finite-size correction to the correctness gap. The resulting bound provides improved quantitative security parameters for experimental implementations.

quant-pharXiv:2606.25037•Jun 25, 2026•2 citations

Loss-Tolerant Quantum Position Verification for Metropolitan Area Networks

Wen Yu Kon, Niccolò Bigagli, Andrew Conrad +13 more

A spacetime seal, a cryptographic guarantee that a digital event has occurred at an approved location and time, can augment a digital signature with location attestation for legal, financial, and regulatory use cases. In adversarial settings any purely classical realization of such a seal can be spoofed. Quantum position verification (QPV) offers a physics-based solution, exploiting the no-cloning theorem and the no-signaling principle to certify a party's spacetime coordinates. While the feasibility of QPV has been recently shown via entanglement- and coherent light-based protocols, achieving loss tolerance for these schemes substantially increases implementation complexity at metropolitan scales. Here, we introduce and experimentally demonstrate a loss-tolerant QPV (LT-QPV) protocol whose security is independent of channel loss. We prove finite-size security against quantum polynomial-time entangled adversaries in the quantum random oracle model instantiated with cryptographically secure hash functions. Implemented entirely with commercial off-the-shelf components, our system certifies position within 22 minutes of net data collection time against a restricted adversary, with a clear path to real-time certification (<1s) with upgraded hardware. Our architecture, requiring only a single quantum verifier node alongside classical infrastructure, is naturally compatible with metropolitan-area quantum networks, establishing the foundations for scalable, physics-backed spacetime certification as a deployable service.

quant-pharXiv:2609.23234•Sep 22, 2026•1 citation

Towards practical and error-robust quantum position verification

Rene Allerstorfer, Harry Buhrman, Florian Speelman +1 more

Loss of inputs can be detrimental to the security of quantum position verification (QPV) protocols, as it may allow attackers to not answer on all played rounds, but only on those they perform well on. In this work, we study \textit{loss-tolerant} QPV protocols. We propose a new fully loss-tolerant protocol QPV$_{\textsf{SWAP}}$, based on the SWAP test, with several desirable properties. The task of the protocol, which could be implemented using only a single beam splitter and two detectors, is to estimate the overlap between two input states. By formulating possible attacks as a semi-definite program (SDP), we prove full loss tolerance against unentangled attackers restricted to local operations and classical communication, and show that the attack probability decays exponentially under parallel repetition of rounds. We show that the protocol remains secure even if unentangled attackers are allowed to quantum communicate, making our protocol the first fully loss-tolerant protocol with this property. A detailed analysis under experimental conditions is conducted, showing that QPV$_{\textsf{SWAP}}$ remains fairly robust against equipment errors. We identify a necessary condition for security with errors and simulate one instance of our protocol with currently realistic experimental parameters, gathering that an attack success probability of $\leq10^{-6}$ can be achieved by collecting just a few hundred conclusive protocol rounds.

arXiv:2106.12911•Jun 24, 2021•19 citations

Position-based quantum cryptography: from theory towards practice

Rene Allerstorfer

This thesis deals with position-based quantum cryptography (PBQC), a type of quantum cryptography. More concretely, we focus on the design and study of quantum position verification (QPV) protocols, which act as a building block for PBQC. We prioritise the development of QPV protocols that are loss-tolerant, error-robust, and feasible with current or near-future technology, concentrating on photon-based protocols and linear-optical equipment. We also theoretically study different attack settings on QPV in the context of state discrimination, dealing with the interplay between non-locality and interaction. We introduce a new QPV protocol based on the SWAP test and Hong-Ou-Mandel interference and study it in detail regarding attacks and practical feasibility. We further provide a solution to a major practical issue of QPV -- signal loss. A minor modification of the standard structure of QPV, namely introducing a small time delay and a commitment to play from the honest prover, allows us to provably make the transmission loss between the verifiers and the honest party irrelevant for security for a class of QPV protocols. Moreover, we generalise and study QPV protocols in the continuous-variable setting. Exploring theoretical aspects of QPV attacks, we focus on the difference between quantum and classical communication. We show new bounds on existing protocols, construct protocols that can be attacked with quantum communication but not locally, show a separation between quantum and classical communication attacks on QPV, and derive a necessary condition on the attack error based on the structure of the QPV input ensemble.

•Jan 1, 2024•0 citations
Quantum position verification (QPV) is the art of verifying the geographical location of an untrusted party. Recently, it has been shown that the widely studied Bennett Brassard 1984 (BB84) QPV protocol is insecure after the 3 dB loss point assuming local operations and classical communication (LOCC) adversaries. Here, we propose a time-reversed entanglement swapping QPV protocol (based on measurement-device-independent quantum cryptography) that is highly robust against quantum channel loss. First, assuming ideal qubit sources, we show that the protocol is secure against LOCC adversaries for any quantum channel loss, thereby overcoming the 3 dB loss limit. Then, we analyze the security of the protocol in a more practical setting involving weak laser sources and linear optics. In this setting, we find that the security only degrades by an additive constant and the protocol is able to verify positions up to 47 dB channel loss.
Position-based quantum cryptography (PBQC) allows a party to use its geographical location as its only credential to implement various cryptographic protocols. Such a protocol may lead to important applications in practice. Although it has been shown that any PBQC protocol is breakable if the adversaries pre-share an arbitrarily large entangled state, the security of PBQC in the bounded-quantum-storage model is still an open question. In this paper, we study the performance of various PBQC protocols over a lossy channel under the assumption that no entanglement is pre-shared between adversaries. By introducing the decoy state idea, we show that an extended Bennett-Brassard-1984--type PBQC protocol implemented with a weak coherent source and realistic single-photon detectors can tolerate an overall loss (including both the channel loss and the detection efficiency) of 13 dB if the intrinsic quantum bit error rate is 1%. We also study a few continuous variable PBQC protocols and show that they suffer from a 3-dB loss limitation.
In this thesis we explore position-based quantum cryptography zooming in on the task of position verification. In position verification, the idea is to use an individual's geographical location as a cryptographic credential. In practice, such protocols can authenticate that a message originated from a specific location or ensure that messages can only be read at a certain location. In a position-verification protocol, the limitations imposed by the speed of light, as described by special relativity, are used to verify that a party is at their claimed location. It has been shown that any QPV protocol can be broken by attackers that use an amount of entanglement exponential in the input size. However, from a practical point of view, not all is lost. We can still hope for QPV protocols that are secure in practice. This raises the problem of designing protocols that are secure in a practical setting. An important problem that arises is that of signal loss. Signal loss can be detrimental as it allows attackers to only answer on a subset of rounds. We investigate several questions related to the practical implementation of such protocols. We propose a new experimentally feasible protocol, which is fully loss-tolerant against attackers restricted to classical communication. Furthermore, we consider the role of allowing quantum communication with no pre-shared entanglement for attackers and show that this setting is strictly stronger than the classical one, indicating that allowing for quantum communication may break security. Conversely, we then show that any protocol secure against classical communication can be transformed into a protocol secure against quantum communication. Finally, we invert the picture, and consider the task of non-local quantum computation (NLQC), which corresponds to the operations of the attackers in a QPV protocol. We connect NLQC to the wider context of information-theoretic cryptography by relating it to a number of other cryptographic primitives.
Quantum position verification (QPV) aims to certify the location of an untrusted prover, but faces two major obstacles: fundamentally, entanglement-based attacks and, experimentally, photon loss. A commitment-based modification introduced in Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 260801 addresses both in sequentially repeated protocols. Its security analysis, however, relies on the sequential structure and does not extend to parallel repetition. We use a different proof approach to establish security of the commitment modification for a parallel BB84-based QPV protocol. Against bounded-entanglement adversaries, the acceptance probability decays exponentially in the minimum number kkk of successfully committed qubits. The protocol tolerates arbitrary transmission loss and noise rates up to 3.7%, while allowing arbitrarily slow quantum communication. This yields a fully loss-tolerant, single-execution QPV protocol secure against bounded-entanglement attacks, removing transmission loss as a fundamental limitation on verification distance. We also revisit sequential repetition, correcting the treatment of conditioning on commitment and replacing the earlier conditional guarantee with an unconditional security bound, without the finite-size correction to the correctness gap. The resulting bound provides improved quantitative security parameters for experimental implementations.
A spacetime seal, a cryptographic guarantee that a digital event has occurred at an approved location and time, can augment a digital signature with location attestation for legal, financial, and regulatory use cases. In adversarial settings any purely classical realization of such a seal can be spoofed. Quantum position verification (QPV) offers a physics-based solution, exploiting the no-cloning theorem and the no-signaling principle to certify a party's spacetime coordinates. While the feasibility of QPV has been recently shown via entanglement- and coherent light-based protocols, achieving loss tolerance for these schemes substantially increases implementation complexity at metropolitan scales. Here, we introduce and experimentally demonstrate a loss-tolerant QPV (LT-QPV) protocol whose security is independent of channel loss. We prove finite-size security against quantum polynomial-time entangled adversaries in the quantum random oracle model instantiated with cryptographically secure hash functions. Implemented entirely with commercial off-the-shelf components, our system certifies position within 22 minutes of net data collection time against a restricted adversary, with a clear path to real-time certification (<1s) with upgraded hardware. Our architecture, requiring only a single quantum verifier node alongside classical infrastructure, is naturally compatible with metropolitan-area quantum networks, establishing the foundations for scalable, physics-backed spacetime certification as a deployable service.
Loss of inputs can be detrimental to the security of quantum position verification (QPV) protocols, as it may allow attackers to not answer on all played rounds, but only on those they perform well on. In this work, we study \textit{loss-tolerant} QPV protocols. We propose a new fully loss-tolerant protocol QPVSWAP_{\textsf{SWAP}}SWAP​, based on the SWAP test, with several desirable properties. The task of the protocol, which could be implemented using only a single beam splitter and two detectors, is to estimate the overlap between two input states. By formulating possible attacks as a semi-definite program (SDP), we prove full loss tolerance against unentangled attackers restricted to local operations and classical communication, and show that the attack probability decays exponentially under parallel repetition of rounds. We show that the protocol remains secure even if unentangled attackers are allowed to quantum communicate, making our protocol the first fully loss-tolerant protocol with this property. A detailed analysis under experimental conditions is conducted, showing that QPVSWAP_{\textsf{SWAP}}SWAP​ remains fairly robust against equipment errors. We identify a necessary condition for security with errors and simulate one instance of our protocol with currently realistic experimental parameters, gathering that an attack success probability of ≤10−6\leq10^{-6}≤10−6 can be achieved by collecting just a few hundred conclusive protocol rounds.
This thesis deals with position-based quantum cryptography (PBQC), a type of quantum cryptography. More concretely, we focus on the design and study of quantum position verification (QPV) protocols, which act as a building block for PBQC. We prioritise the development of QPV protocols that are loss-tolerant, error-robust, and feasible with current or near-future technology, concentrating on photon-based protocols and linear-optical equipment. We also theoretically study different attack settings on QPV in the context of state discrimination, dealing with the interplay between non-locality and interaction. We introduce a new QPV protocol based on the SWAP test and Hong-Ou-Mandel interference and study it in detail regarding attacks and practical feasibility. We further provide a solution to a major practical issue of QPV -- signal loss. A minor modification of the standard structure of QPV, namely introducing a small time delay and a commitment to play from the honest prover, allows us to provably make the transmission loss between the verifiers and the honest party irrelevant for security for a class of QPV protocols. Moreover, we generalise and study QPV protocols in the continuous-variable setting. Exploring theoretical aspects of QPV attacks, we focus on the difference between quantum and classical communication. We show new bounds on existing protocols, construct protocols that can be attacked with quantum communication but not locally, show a separation between quantum and classical communication attacks on QPV, and derive a necessary condition on the attack error based on the structure of the QPV input ensemble.