Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1607.07388 · Philosophy of Science

Three Myths about Time Reversal in Quantum Theory

Bryan Wilson Roberts

Published Dec 14, 2016• 45 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many have suggested that the transformation standardly referred to as ‘time reversal’ in quantum theory is not deserving of the name. I argue on the contrary that the standard definition is perfectly appropriate and is indeed forced by basic considerations about the nature of time in the quantum formalism.
DOI
10.1086/690721

Related papers

Time Reversal Invariance in Quantum Mechanics

Reza Moulavi Ardakani

Symmetries have a crucial role in today's physics. In this thesis, we are mostly concerned with time reversal invariance (T-symmetry). A physical system is time reversal invariant if its underlying laws are not sensitive to the direction of time. There are various accounts of time reversal transformation resulting in different views on whether or not a given theory in physics is time reversal invariant. With a focus on quantum mechanics, I describe the standard account of time reversal and compare it with my alternative account, arguing why it deserves serious attention. Then, I review three known ways to T-violation in quantum mechanics, and explain two unique experiments made to detect it in the neutral K and B mesons.

arXiv:1802.10169•Feb 16, 2018•4 citations

Time-reversal invariance and irreversibility in time-asymmetric quantum mechanics

Mario A Castagnino, Manuel Gadella, Olímpia Lombardi

The aim of this paper is to analyze the concepts of time-reversal invariance and irreversibility in the so-called ’time-asymmetric quan-tum mechanics’. We begin with pointing out the difference between these two concepts. On this basis, we show that irreversibility is not as tightly linked to the semigroup evolution laws of the theory-which lead to its non time-reversal invariance- as usually suggested. In turn, we argue that the irreversible evolutions described by the theory are coarse-grained processes. 1 1

•Sep 1, 2005•0 citations

Time-Reversal Invariance and Ontology

Ward Struyve

Albert and Callender have challenged the received view that theories like classical electrodynamics and non-relativistic quantum mechanics are time reversal invariant. They claim that time reversal should correspond to the mere reversal of the temporal order of the instantaneous states, without any accompanying change of the instantaneous state as in the standard view. As such, Albert and Callender claim, these theories are not time reversal invariant. The view of Albert and Callender has been much criticized, with many philosophers arguing that time reversal may correspond to more than the reversal of the temporal order. In this paper, we will not so much engage with that aspect of the debate, but rather deflate the disagreement by exploiting the ontological underdetermination. Namely, it will be argued that with a suitable choice of ontology, these theories are in fact time reversal invariant in the sense of Albert and Callender, in agreement with the standard view.

arXiv:2307.07856•The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Jun 2, 2022•10 citations

Time-Symmetrized Quantum Theory

Lev Vaidman A

A brief review of the time-symmetrized quantum formalism originated by Aharonov, Bergmann and Lebowitz is presented. Symmetry of various measurements under the time reversal is analyzed. Time-symmetrized counterfactuals are introduced. It is argued that the time-symmetrized formalism demonstrates novel profound features of quantum theory and that recent criticism of the formalism is unfounded.

arXiv:quant-ph/9710036•Fortschritte der Physik•Nov 1, 1998•17 citations

Seeking for a Fundamental Quantum Arrow of Time: Time Reversal and the Symmetry-To-Reality Inference in Standard Quantum Mechanics

Cristian López

In this paper I shall shed some doubts on a widely-held claim: standard quantum mechanics is time-reversal invariant, and thereby, blind to the direction of time. Building bridges between physics and philosophy, I shall argue that such a claim features some puzzling assumptions that are frequently overlooked in the literature. In particular, I shall first argue that the claim involves some methodological and metaphysical commitments that should be evaluated more prudently from philosophy and from physics. Second, I shall point out that the common inference that goes from symmetry to metaphysical conclusions needs some correction and refinement to be acceptable for time symmetry and the debate around the arrow of time

Frontiers in Physics•Sep 19, 2018•4 citations

Aspects of the Problem of Retrodiction

Bernard d’Espagnat

The problem of retrodiction is associated with basic questions, but for this very reason it is, unfortunately, quite difficult, even in classical physics. In quantum physics it is even more subtle. In quantum mechanics, a consistent definition of what is called a "system" leads to problems that do not exist in classical physics, and correspondingly the answers to the questions raised are less straightforward. This chapter discusses the conditions under which it is possible to speak of an "independent time evolution" of a system S and to study what kinds of predictions can legitimately be made when these conditions are fulfilled. It describes retroactive computation to investigate whether or not the assumed knowledge in question is really consistent with the standard quantum mechanical formalism. The concept of retrodiction is related to the notions of time reversal and of irreversibility. Both these notions play a central role in physics.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations
Symmetries have a crucial role in today's physics. In this thesis, we are mostly concerned with time reversal invariance (T-symmetry). A physical system is time reversal invariant if its underlying laws are not sensitive to the direction of time. There are various accounts of time reversal transformation resulting in different views on whether or not a given theory in physics is time reversal invariant. With a focus on quantum mechanics, I describe the standard account of time reversal and compare it with my alternative account, arguing why it deserves serious attention. Then, I review three known ways to T-violation in quantum mechanics, and explain two unique experiments made to detect it in the neutral K and B mesons.
The aim of this paper is to analyze the concepts of time-reversal invariance and irreversibility in the so-called ’time-asymmetric quan-tum mechanics’. We begin with pointing out the difference between these two concepts. On this basis, we show that irreversibility is not as tightly linked to the semigroup evolution laws of the theory-which lead to its non time-reversal invariance- as usually suggested. In turn, we argue that the irreversible evolutions described by the theory are coarse-grained processes. 1 1
Albert and Callender have challenged the received view that theories like classical electrodynamics and non-relativistic quantum mechanics are time reversal invariant. They claim that time reversal should correspond to the mere reversal of the temporal order of the instantaneous states, without any accompanying change of the instantaneous state as in the standard view. As such, Albert and Callender claim, these theories are not time reversal invariant. The view of Albert and Callender has been much criticized, with many philosophers arguing that time reversal may correspond to more than the reversal of the temporal order. In this paper, we will not so much engage with that aspect of the debate, but rather deflate the disagreement by exploiting the ontological underdetermination. Namely, it will be argued that with a suitable choice of ontology, these theories are in fact time reversal invariant in the sense of Albert and Callender, in agreement with the standard view.
In this paper I shall shed some doubts on a widely-held claim: standard quantum mechanics is time-reversal invariant, and thereby, blind to the direction of time. Building bridges between physics and philosophy, I shall argue that such a claim features some puzzling assumptions that are frequently overlooked in the literature. In particular, I shall first argue that the claim involves some methodological and metaphysical commitments that should be evaluated more prudently from philosophy and from physics. Second, I shall point out that the common inference that goes from symmetry to metaphysical conclusions needs some correction and refinement to be acceptable for time symmetry and the debate around the arrow of time
The problem of retrodiction is associated with basic questions, but for this very reason it is, unfortunately, quite difficult, even in classical physics. In quantum physics it is even more subtle. In quantum mechanics, a consistent definition of what is called a "system" leads to problems that do not exist in classical physics, and correspondingly the answers to the questions raised are less straightforward. This chapter discusses the conditions under which it is possible to speak of an "independent time evolution" of a system S and to study what kinds of predictions can legitimately be made when these conditions are fulfilled. It describes retroactive computation to investigate whether or not the assumed knowledge in question is really consistent with the standard quantum mechanical formalism. The concept of retrodiction is related to the notions of time reversal and of irreversibility. Both these notions play a central role in physics.