Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1607.02364 · Physics Essays

Delayed choice, complementarity, entanglement and measurement

Hervé Zwirn C

Published Sep 15, 2017• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

It is well known that Wheeler proposed several delayed choice experiments in order to show the impossibility to speak of the way a quantum system behaves before being detected. In a double-slit experiment, when do photons decide to travel by one way or by two ways? Delayed choice experiments seem to indicate that, strangely, it is possible to change the decision of the photons until the very last moment before they are detected. This led Wheeler to his famous sentence: No elementary quantum phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is a registered phenomenon, brought to a close by an irreversible act of amplification. Nevertheless some authors wrote that backward in time effects were needed to explain these results. I will show that in delayed choice experiments involving only one particle, a simple explanation is possible without invoking any backward in time effect. Delayed choice experiments involving entangled particles such as the so called quantum eraser can also be explained without invoking any backward in time effect but I will argue that these experiments cannot be accounted for so simply because they rise the whole problem of knowing what a measurement and a collapse are. A previously presented interpretation, Convivial Solipsism, is a natural framework for giving a simple explanation of these delayed choice experiments with entangled particles. In this paper, I show how Convivial Solipsism helps clarifying the puzzling questions raised by the collapse of the wave function of entangled systems.

DOI
10.4006/0836-1398-30.3.281

Related papers

Quantum entanglement, Wheeler’s delayed choice experiment and its explanation on the basis of quantization of fields

Alexey V. Melkikh

The result of Wheeler's delayed choice experiment is a natural consequence of the entanglement of moving photons and particles (atoms, molecules) of the slit through which they move. The inclusion of quantum fields (taking into account that speed of virtual particles is not limited) self-consistently explains why interaction's propagation velocity after closing one slit is larger than the speed of light.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2017•2 citations

Revelation method of unmeasured phenomenon in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment

XinHua Liu, ChuangRui Liu, HanRui Liu

Abstract Wheeler proposed the "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment. Perhaps the quantum delayed eraser experiments revealed Wheeler's unmeasurable phenomenon. However, all quantum delayed eraser experiments involve non-locality between entangled photon pairs, causing the timing relationship between events on the idler path and events on the signal path to not necessarily represent the timing relationship between the correspond events on the signal path. In the quantum delayed eraser experiments, the time distinguishing the path passing through the double-slit on the signal path is when they pass through the slits. Therefore, the quantum delayed eraser experiments do not adhere to the condition in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment, which need the distinction of the photons passing through the double-slit is done after the formation of the fringe pattern. The results of the quantum delayed eraser experiments do not exhibit the unmeasured phenomenon of Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment. This paper proposes a method that eliminates the non-locality effects of entangled photons without using entangled photon pairs. By dividing the route of photons passing through the double-slit into two routes and verifying the fringe pattern based on the number of photons on the two routes, Wheeler's notion of an unmeasured phenomenon becomes measurable, thus providing a revelation method of the unmeasured phenomenon in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment.

•May 16, 2024•0 citations

Revelation method of unmeasured phenomena in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment

XinHua Liu, ChuangRui Liu, HanRui Liu

Abstract Wheeler proposed the "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment. Some scholars believe that the quantum delayed eraser experiments reveals Wheeler's unmeasurable phenomenon. However, all quantum delayed eraser experiments involve non-locality between entangled photon pairs, causing the timing relationship between events on the idler path and events on the signal path to not necessarily represent the timing relationship between the correspond events on the signal path. In the quantum delayed eraser experiments, the time distinguishing the path passing through the double-slit on the signal path is when they pass through the slits. Therefore, the quantum delayed eraser experimentsdoes not adhere to the condition in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment, which need the distinction of the photons passing through the double-slit is done after the formation of the fringe pattern. The results of the quantum delayed eraser experimentsdo not exhibit the unmeasured phenomenon of Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment.This paper proposes a method that eliminates the non-locality effects of entangled photons without using entangled photon pairs. By dividing the route of photons passing through the double-slit into two routes and verifying the fringe pattern based on the number of photons on the two routes, Wheeler's notion of an unmeasured phenomenon becomes measurable, thus providing a revelation method of the unmeasured phenomenon in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment.

•May 8, 2024•0 citations

A coherence interpretation of nonlocal realism in the delayed-choice quantum eraser

Byoung Seung HAM

The delayed-choice thought experiment proposed by Wheeler has been demonstrated over the last several decades for the wave-particle duality of a single photon. The delayed-choice quantum eraser proposed by Scully and Druhl has also been intensively studied for the violation of the cause-effect relation of a single photon as well as a pair of entangled photons in an interferometric system. Here, a coherence interpretation is conducted for the nonlocal realism of the space-like separated photons observed in Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1 (2000). As a result, coherence solutions of the observed nonlocal fringes are deterministically derived from coincidence detection-caused selective measurements, where the resulting product-basis superposition becomes the origin of the otherwise quantum mystery of the nonlocal fringes. For this, a fixed sum-phase relation between entangled photons is a prerequisite, which cannot be explained by conventional particle nature-based quantum mechanics.

arXiv:2302.13474•Feb 27, 2023•8 citations

Delayed-choice experiments and the Bohm approach

Basil J. Hiley, R E Callaghan

The delayed-choice experiments of the type introduced by Wheeler and extended by Englert, Scully, Süssmann and Walther (ESSW) (1992 Z. Naturf. a 47 1175–86), and others, have formed a rich area for investigating the puzzling behaviour of particles undergoing quantum interference. The surprise provided by the original delayed-choice experiment led Wheeler to the conclusion that 'no phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon', a radical explanation which implied that 'the past has no existence except as it is recorded in the present'. However Bohm et al (1985 Nature 315 294–97) have shown that the Bohm interpretation (BI) gives a straightforward account of the behaviour of the particle without resorting to such a radical explanation. The subsequent modifications of this experiment led both Aharonov and Vaidman (1996 Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal ed J T Cushing, A Fine and S Goldstein (Dordrecht: Kluwer) pp 141–54) and ESSW to conclude that the resulting Bohm-type trajectories in these new situations produce unacceptable properties. For example, if a cavity is placed in one arm of the interferometer, it will be excited by a particle travelling down the other arm. In other words, it is the particle that does not go through the cavity that gives up its energy! If this analysis is correct, this behaviour would be truly bizarre and could only be explained by an extreme non-local transfer of energy that is even stronger than that required in an Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR)-type process. In this paper, we show that this conclusion is not correct and that if the BI is used correctly, it gives a local explanation, which actually corresponds exactly to the standard quantum mechanics explanation offered by ESSW.

arXiv:1602.06100•Physica Scripta•Aug 9, 2006•40 citations

A delayed choice experiment enabled by entanglement

Florian Kaiser, T. Coudreau, P. Milman +2 more

Bohr's complementarity notion is at the heart of quantum physics, and suggests that in a quantum experiment, the observed phenomena are inherently linked to the type of measurement that is performed. For example, sending single photons to an open or closed Mach-Zehnder interferometer leads to the observation of particle or wave behaviours. In 1984, Wheeler proposed a 'Gedanken' experiment in which the experimentalist chooses the interferometer configuration, at will, only after the photon has already passed the input beam-splitter (BSin) of the device. This experiment was realized using a diamond-based single photon source, and it was shown that Bohr's complementarity notion was still obeyed, as expected. It was recently proposed theoretically to take Wheeler's experiment one step further by employing a 'quantum beam-splitter' (QBS) at the interferometer output. In this case, the output beam-splitter (BSout) is placed in a coherent superposition of being absent and present, which also allows to further delay the choice of the measurement type. The type of measurement is determined only after having measured the state of the QBS, which can be (in principle) infinitely delayed. We demonstrate the realization of such an experiment by exploiting entanglement. In particular, we take advantage of pairs of polarization entangled photons. The behaviour of one of the paired photons, called the test photon, is analysed by sending it to a Mach-Zehnder interferometer having an entanglement-enabled QBS at its output. This device is made of a polarization dependent beam-splitter followed by polarization state erasers. The other photon, called the corroborative photon, allows determining the actual state of the QBS, and consequently, which test photon behaviour (wave, particle, or both) is measured. By manipulating the corroborative photon, we demonstrate a continuous morphing from wave to particle behaviour, which refutes too simple views of single photons behaving exclusively as waves or particles. The measurements on the test photon and the interferometer configuration are performed in a strictly delayed manner. The state of the QBS is measured only after the test photon already left the interferometer, and is detected, which means that it is destroyed before the type of measurement it under- goes is determined. We find that even in this configuration, Bohr's complementarity notion, and its extension, are perfectly obeyed. The space-like separation between the measurements invalidates local-hidden variable models associated with pre-existing information about the measurement out- comes. In other words, when the test photon is detected, no information is available about the type of measurement that was performed. This assertion is confirmed by the violation of the Bell's inequalities with more than 10 standard deviations. The presence of entanglement shows furthermore that genuine quantum behaviour for the test photons has been observed. As a conclusion, we have demonstrated the experimental realization of the quantum version of Wheeler's experiment. Trying to explain our observations in classical terms causes severe contradictions, but the results are in perfect agreement with quantum physics, in which the measurement timing order does not matter. The beauty in such experiments is that space and time do not seem to play any role.

•Nov 28, 2012•1 citation
It is well known that Wheeler proposed several delayed choice experiments in order to show the impossibility to speak of the way a quantum system behaves before being detected. In a double-slit experiment, when do photons decide to travel by one way or by two ways? Delayed choice experiments seem to indicate that, strangely, it is possible to change the decision of the photons until the very last moment before they are detected. This led Wheeler to his famous sentence: No elementary quantum phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is a registered phenomenon, brought to a close by an irreversible act of amplification. Nevertheless some authors wrote that backward in time effects were needed to explain these results. I will show that in delayed choice experiments involving only one particle, a simple explanation is possible without invoking any backward in time effect. Delayed choice experiments involving entangled particles such as the so called quantum eraser can also be explained without invoking any backward in time effect but I will argue that these experiments cannot be accounted for so simply because they rise the whole problem of knowing what a measurement and a collapse are. A previously presented interpretation, Convivial Solipsism, is a natural framework for giving a simple explanation of these delayed choice experiments with entangled particles. In this paper, I show how Convivial Solipsism helps clarifying the puzzling questions raised by the collapse of the wave function of entangled systems.
Abstract Wheeler proposed the "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment. Perhaps the quantum delayed eraser experiments revealed Wheeler's unmeasurable phenomenon. However, all quantum delayed eraser experiments involve non-locality between entangled photon pairs, causing the timing relationship between events on the idler path and events on the signal path to not necessarily represent the timing relationship between the correspond events on the signal path. In the quantum delayed eraser experiments, the time distinguishing the path passing through the double-slit on the signal path is when they pass through the slits. Therefore, the quantum delayed eraser experiments do not adhere to the condition in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment, which need the distinction of the photons passing through the double-slit is done after the formation of the fringe pattern. The results of the quantum delayed eraser experiments do not exhibit the unmeasured phenomenon of Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment. This paper proposes a method that eliminates the non-locality effects of entangled photons without using entangled photon pairs. By dividing the route of photons passing through the double-slit into two routes and verifying the fringe pattern based on the number of photons on the two routes, Wheeler's notion of an unmeasured phenomenon becomes measurable, thus providing a revelation method of the unmeasured phenomenon in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment.
Abstract Wheeler proposed the "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment. Some scholars believe that the quantum delayed eraser experiments reveals Wheeler's unmeasurable phenomenon. However, all quantum delayed eraser experiments involve non-locality between entangled photon pairs, causing the timing relationship between events on the idler path and events on the signal path to not necessarily represent the timing relationship between the correspond events on the signal path. In the quantum delayed eraser experiments, the time distinguishing the path passing through the double-slit on the signal path is when they pass through the slits. Therefore, the quantum delayed eraser experimentsdoes not adhere to the condition in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment, which need the distinction of the photons passing through the double-slit is done after the formation of the fringe pattern. The results of the quantum delayed eraser experimentsdo not exhibit the unmeasured phenomenon of Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment.This paper proposes a method that eliminates the non-locality effects of entangled photons without using entangled photon pairs. By dividing the route of photons passing through the double-slit into two routes and verifying the fringe pattern based on the number of photons on the two routes, Wheeler's notion of an unmeasured phenomenon becomes measurable, thus providing a revelation method of the unmeasured phenomenon in Wheeler's "Delayed-Choice" Double-Slit Experiment.
The delayed-choice thought experiment proposed by Wheeler has been demonstrated over the last several decades for the wave-particle duality of a single photon. The delayed-choice quantum eraser proposed by Scully and Druhl has also been intensively studied for the violation of the cause-effect relation of a single photon as well as a pair of entangled photons in an interferometric system. Here, a coherence interpretation is conducted for the nonlocal realism of the space-like separated photons observed in Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 1 (2000). As a result, coherence solutions of the observed nonlocal fringes are deterministically derived from coincidence detection-caused selective measurements, where the resulting product-basis superposition becomes the origin of the otherwise quantum mystery of the nonlocal fringes. For this, a fixed sum-phase relation between entangled photons is a prerequisite, which cannot be explained by conventional particle nature-based quantum mechanics.
The delayed-choice experiments of the type introduced by Wheeler and extended by Englert, Scully, Süssmann and Walther (ESSW) (1992 Z. Naturf. a 47 1175–86), and others, have formed a rich area for investigating the puzzling behaviour of particles undergoing quantum interference. The surprise provided by the original delayed-choice experiment led Wheeler to the conclusion that 'no phenomenon is a phenomenon until it is an observed phenomenon', a radical explanation which implied that 'the past has no existence except as it is recorded in the present'. However Bohm et al (1985 Nature 315 294–97) have shown that the Bohm interpretation (BI) gives a straightforward account of the behaviour of the particle without resorting to such a radical explanation. The subsequent modifications of this experiment led both Aharonov and Vaidman (1996 Bohmian Mechanics and Quantum Theory: An Appraisal ed J T Cushing, A Fine and S Goldstein (Dordrecht: Kluwer) pp 141–54) and ESSW to conclude that the resulting Bohm-type trajectories in these new situations produce unacceptable properties. For example, if a cavity is placed in one arm of the interferometer, it will be excited by a particle travelling down the other arm. In other words, it is the particle that does not go through the cavity that gives up its energy! If this analysis is correct, this behaviour would be truly bizarre and could only be explained by an extreme non-local transfer of energy that is even stronger than that required in an Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (EPR)-type process. In this paper, we show that this conclusion is not correct and that if the BI is used correctly, it gives a local explanation, which actually corresponds exactly to the standard quantum mechanics explanation offered by ESSW.
Bohr's complementarity notion is at the heart of quantum physics, and suggests that in a quantum experiment, the observed phenomena are inherently linked to the type of measurement that is performed. For example, sending single photons to an open or closed Mach-Zehnder interferometer leads to the observation of particle or wave behaviours. In 1984, Wheeler proposed a 'Gedanken' experiment in which the experimentalist chooses the interferometer configuration, at will, only after the photon has already passed the input beam-splitter (BSin) of the device. This experiment was realized using a diamond-based single photon source, and it was shown that Bohr's complementarity notion was still obeyed, as expected. It was recently proposed theoretically to take Wheeler's experiment one step further by employing a 'quantum beam-splitter' (QBS) at the interferometer output. In this case, the output beam-splitter (BSout) is placed in a coherent superposition of being absent and present, which also allows to further delay the choice of the measurement type. The type of measurement is determined only after having measured the state of the QBS, which can be (in principle) infinitely delayed. We demonstrate the realization of such an experiment by exploiting entanglement. In particular, we take advantage of pairs of polarization entangled photons. The behaviour of one of the paired photons, called the test photon, is analysed by sending it to a Mach-Zehnder interferometer having an entanglement-enabled QBS at its output. This device is made of a polarization dependent beam-splitter followed by polarization state erasers. The other photon, called the corroborative photon, allows determining the actual state of the QBS, and consequently, which test photon behaviour (wave, particle, or both) is measured. By manipulating the corroborative photon, we demonstrate a continuous morphing from wave to particle behaviour, which refutes too simple views of single photons behaving exclusively as waves or particles. The measurements on the test photon and the interferometer configuration are performed in a strictly delayed manner. The state of the QBS is measured only after the test photon already left the interferometer, and is detected, which means that it is destroyed before the type of measurement it under- goes is determined. We find that even in this configuration, Bohr's complementarity notion, and its extension, are perfectly obeyed. The space-like separation between the measurements invalidates local-hidden variable models associated with pre-existing information about the measurement out- comes. In other words, when the test photon is detected, no information is available about the type of measurement that was performed. This assertion is confirmed by the violation of the Bell's inequalities with more than 10 standard deviations. The presence of entanglement shows furthermore that genuine quantum behaviour for the test photons has been observed. As a conclusion, we have demonstrated the experimental realization of the quantum version of Wheeler's experiment. Trying to explain our observations in classical terms causes severe contradictions, but the results are in perfect agreement with quantum physics, in which the measurement timing order does not matter. The beauty in such experiments is that space and time do not seem to play any role.