Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1606.09331 · Quantum

Composites and Categories of Euclidean Jordan Algebras

Howard Barnum, Matthew A. Graydon, Alexander Wilce

Published Nov 8, 2020• 61 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider possible non-signaling composites of probabilistic models based on euclidean Jordan algebras (EJAs), satisfying some reasonable additional constraints motivated by the desire to construct dagger-compact categories of such models. We show that no such composite has the exceptional Jordan algebra as a direct summand, nor does any such composite exist if one factor has an exceptional summand, unless the other factor is a direct sum of one-dimensional Jordan algebras (representing essentially a classical system). Moreover, we show that any composite of simple, non-exceptional EJAs is a direct summand of their universal tensor product, sharply limiting the possibilities.These results warrant our focussing on concrete Jordan algebras of hermitian matrices, i.e., euclidean Jordan algebras with a preferred embedding in a complex matrix algebra. We show that these can be organized in a natural way as a symmetric monoidal category, albeit one that is not compact closed. We then construct a related category InvQM of embedded euclidean Jordan algebras, having fewer objects but more morphisms, that is not only compact closed but dagger-compact. This category unifies finite-dimensional real, complex and quaternionic mixed-state quantum mechanics, except that the composite of two complex quantum systems comes with an extra classical bit.Our notion of composite requires neither tomographic locality, nor preservation of purity under tensor product. The categories we construct include examples in which both of these conditions fail. {In such cases, the information capacity (the maximum number of mutually distinguishable states) of a composite is greater than the product of the capacities of its constituents.}

DOI
10.22331/q-2020-11-08-359

Related papers

Some Nearly Quantum Theories

Howard Barnum, Matthew A. Graydon, Alexander Wilce

We consider possible non-signaling composites of probabilistic models based on euclidean Jordan algebras. Subject to some reasonable constraints, we show that no such composite exists having the exceptional Jordan algebra as a direct summand. We then construct several dagger compact categories of such Jordan-algebraic models. One of these neatly unifies real, complex and quaternionic mixed-state quantum mechanics, with the exception of the quaternionic "bit". Another is similar, except in that (i) it excludes the quaternionic bit, and (ii) the composite of two complex quantum systems comes with an extra classical bit. In both of these categories, states are morphisms from systems to the tensor unit, which helps give the categorical structure a clear operational interpretation. A no-go result shows that the first of these categories, at least, cannot be extended to include spin factors other than the (real, complex, and quaternionic) quantum bits, while preserving the representation of states as morphisms. The same is true for attempts to extend the second category to even-dimensional spin-factors. Interesting phenomena exhibited by some composites in these categories include failure of local tomography, supermultiplicativity of the maximal number of mutually distinguishable states, and mixed states whose marginals are pure.

arXiv:1507.06278•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Nov 4, 2015•20 citations

Composite systems and the role of the complex numbers in quantum mechanics

Gerd Niestegge

An axiomatic approach to the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, based upon a certain concept of conditional probability, has been proposed in two recent papers by the author. It leads to Jordan operator algebras and thus comes rather close to the standard Hilbert space model of quantum mechanics, but still includes the so-called exceptional Jordan algebras, for which a Hilbert space representation does not exist. This approach is now extended by defining a mathematical model of composite systems. Such a model is required for the study of the joint distribution of two quantum observables. A very general type of observables (not only the real-valued observables corresponding to the self-adjoint operators) is considered. The joint distribution is defined, using the concept of conditional probability, and exhibits a certain dependence on the succession of the observations which is different from the classical case and unknown so far in quantum mechanics. Finally, it turns out that, at least in the finite-dimensional case, a really satisfying model of the composite system exists only if each single system is modeled by a complex Jordan matrix algebra (or a direct sum), and the model then becomes the tensor product. This provides some reasoning why the exceptional Jordan algebras can be ruled out, why quantum mechanics needs the complex numbers and the complex Hilbert space, and why the tensor product is the right choice for the model of a composite system.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Nov 12, 2004•15 citations

Pure Maps between Euclidean Jordan Algebras

Abraham Westerbaan, Bas Westerbaan, John van de Wetering

We propose a definition of purity for positive linear maps between Euclidean Jordan Algebras (EJA) that generalizes the notion of purity for quantum systems. We show that this definition of purity is closed under composition and taking adjoints and thus that the pure maps form a dagger category (which sets it apart from other possible definitions.) In fact, from the results presented in this paper, it follows that the category of EJAs with positive contractive linear maps is a dagger-effectus, a type of structure originally defined to study von Neumann algebras in an abstract categorical setting. In combination with previous work this characterizes EJAs as the most general systems allowed in a generalized probabilistic theory that is simultaneously a dagger-effectus. Using the dagger structure we get a notion of dagger-positive maps of the form f = g*g. We give a complete characterization of the pure dagger-positive maps and show that these correspond precisely to the Jordan algebraic version of the sequential product that maps (a,b) to sqrt(a) b sqrt(a). The notion of dagger-positivity therefore characterizes the sequential product.

arXiv:1805.11496•Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Jan 31, 2019•4 citations

A Royal Road to Quantum Theory (or Thereabouts), Extended Abstract

Alexander Wilce

A representation of finite-dimensional probabilistic models in terms of formally real Jordan algebras is obtained, in a strikingly easy way, from simple assumptions. This provides a framework in which real, complex and quaternionic quantum mechanics can be treated on an equal footing, and allows some (but not too much) room for other alternatives. This is based on earlier work (arXiv:1206:2897), but the development here is further simplified, and also extended in several ways. I also discuss the possibilities for organizing probabilistic models, subject to the assumptions discussed here, into symmetric monoidal categories, showing that such a category will automatically have a dagger-compact structure. (Recent joint work with Howard Barnum and Matthew Graydon (arXiv:1507.06278) exhibits several categories of this kind.)

Electronic Proceedings in Theoretical Computer Science•Jan 1, 2017•5 citations

FCD-QM 1-B: Recursive No-Hypersignaling Constraints on Euclidean Jordan Theories

Geoffrey Marcellin

This paper extends the results of Hyperbolic Degree Bounds Signaling Dimension in Generalized Probabilistic Theories (Zenodo DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.22946778), which established that the signaling dimension of every canonical finite-dimensional Euclidean Jordan algebra (EJA) equals its Jordan rank. We investigate the consequences of this single-system identity under recursive composition. Combining the injectivity of local effect-space tensor products in standard non-signaling composites with the no-hypersignaling (NH) principle, we prove that the normalized linear-dimension ratio η_lin(S) = dim(S)/sign.dim(S)² is supermultiplicative. Consequently, any local excess above unity is amplified under repeated composition. For canonical EJA composites satisfying the structural axioms of Barnum, Graydon, and Wilce, product Jordan frames and NH enforce multiplicativity of composite rank. Together with established EJA classification results, this yields the conditional recursive constraint dim(J) ≤ rank(J)². Within this framework, quaternionic matrix Jordan systems and spin factors V_n with n ≥ 4 are excluded, while real matrix systems remain subcritical and complex matrix systems exactly saturate the bound. We also obtain finite-copy exclusion criteria and identify exact NH violations in specified EJA composition rules, including doubled complex and quaternionic composites. The analysis does not assume local tomography. Its conclusions are conditional on NH and the stated composition axioms; they do not establish unique selection of complex quantum theory. This work provides a compositional continuation of the preceding hyperbolic-signaling result, connecting classical simulation requirements to structural constraints on Jordan probabilistic theories.

•Oct 11, 2026•0 citations

A Royal Road to Quantum Theory (or Thereabouts), Extended Abstract

Alexander Wilce

A representation of finite-dimensional probabilistic models in terms of formally real Jordan algebras is obtained, in a strikingly easy way, from simple assumptions. This provides a framework in which real, complex and quaternionic quantum mechanics can be treated on an equal footing, and allows some (but not too much) room for other alternatives. This is based on earlier work (arXiv:1206:2897), but the development here is further simplified, and also extended in several ways. I also discuss the possibilities for organizing probabilistic models, subject to the assumptions discussed here, into symmetric monoidal categories, showing that such a category will automatically have a dagger-compact structure. (Recent joint work with Howard Barnum and Matthew Graydon (arXiv:1507.06278) exhibits several categories of this kind.)

arXiv:1701.00664•Jan 3, 2017•38 citations
We consider possible non-signaling composites of probabilistic models based on euclidean Jordan algebras (EJAs), satisfying some reasonable additional constraints motivated by the desire to construct dagger-compact categories of such models. We show that no such composite has the exceptional Jordan algebra as a direct summand, nor does any such composite exist if one factor has an exceptional summand, unless the other factor is a direct sum of one-dimensional Jordan algebras (representing essentially a classical system). Moreover, we show that any composite of simple, non-exceptional EJAs is a direct summand of their universal tensor product, sharply limiting the possibilities.These results warrant our focussing on concrete Jordan algebras of hermitian matrices, i.e., euclidean Jordan algebras with a preferred embedding in a complex matrix algebra. We show that these can be organized in a natural way as a symmetric monoidal category, albeit one that is not compact closed. We then construct a related category InvQM of embedded euclidean Jordan algebras, having fewer objects but more morphisms, that is not only compact closed but dagger-compact. This category unifies finite-dimensional real, complex and quaternionic mixed-state quantum mechanics, except that the composite of two complex quantum systems comes with an extra classical bit.Our notion of composite requires neither tomographic locality, nor preservation of purity under tensor product. The categories we construct include examples in which both of these conditions fail. {In such cases, the information capacity (the maximum number of mutually distinguishable states) of a composite is greater than the product of the capacities of its constituents.}
We consider possible non-signaling composites of probabilistic models based on euclidean Jordan algebras. Subject to some reasonable constraints, we show that no such composite exists having the exceptional Jordan algebra as a direct summand. We then construct several dagger compact categories of such Jordan-algebraic models. One of these neatly unifies real, complex and quaternionic mixed-state quantum mechanics, with the exception of the quaternionic "bit". Another is similar, except in that (i) it excludes the quaternionic bit, and (ii) the composite of two complex quantum systems comes with an extra classical bit. In both of these categories, states are morphisms from systems to the tensor unit, which helps give the categorical structure a clear operational interpretation. A no-go result shows that the first of these categories, at least, cannot be extended to include spin factors other than the (real, complex, and quaternionic) quantum bits, while preserving the representation of states as morphisms. The same is true for attempts to extend the second category to even-dimensional spin-factors. Interesting phenomena exhibited by some composites in these categories include failure of local tomography, supermultiplicativity of the maximal number of mutually distinguishable states, and mixed states whose marginals are pure.
An axiomatic approach to the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics, based upon a certain concept of conditional probability, has been proposed in two recent papers by the author. It leads to Jordan operator algebras and thus comes rather close to the standard Hilbert space model of quantum mechanics, but still includes the so-called exceptional Jordan algebras, for which a Hilbert space representation does not exist. This approach is now extended by defining a mathematical model of composite systems. Such a model is required for the study of the joint distribution of two quantum observables. A very general type of observables (not only the real-valued observables corresponding to the self-adjoint operators) is considered. The joint distribution is defined, using the concept of conditional probability, and exhibits a certain dependence on the succession of the observations which is different from the classical case and unknown so far in quantum mechanics. Finally, it turns out that, at least in the finite-dimensional case, a really satisfying model of the composite system exists only if each single system is modeled by a complex Jordan matrix algebra (or a direct sum), and the model then becomes the tensor product. This provides some reasoning why the exceptional Jordan algebras can be ruled out, why quantum mechanics needs the complex numbers and the complex Hilbert space, and why the tensor product is the right choice for the model of a composite system.
We propose a definition of purity for positive linear maps between Euclidean Jordan Algebras (EJA) that generalizes the notion of purity for quantum systems. We show that this definition of purity is closed under composition and taking adjoints and thus that the pure maps form a dagger category (which sets it apart from other possible definitions.) In fact, from the results presented in this paper, it follows that the category of EJAs with positive contractive linear maps is a dagger-effectus, a type of structure originally defined to study von Neumann algebras in an abstract categorical setting. In combination with previous work this characterizes EJAs as the most general systems allowed in a generalized probabilistic theory that is simultaneously a dagger-effectus. Using the dagger structure we get a notion of dagger-positive maps of the form f = g*g. We give a complete characterization of the pure dagger-positive maps and show that these correspond precisely to the Jordan algebraic version of the sequential product that maps (a,b) to sqrt(a) b sqrt(a). The notion of dagger-positivity therefore characterizes the sequential product.
A representation of finite-dimensional probabilistic models in terms of formally real Jordan algebras is obtained, in a strikingly easy way, from simple assumptions. This provides a framework in which real, complex and quaternionic quantum mechanics can be treated on an equal footing, and allows some (but not too much) room for other alternatives. This is based on earlier work (arXiv:1206:2897), but the development here is further simplified, and also extended in several ways. I also discuss the possibilities for organizing probabilistic models, subject to the assumptions discussed here, into symmetric monoidal categories, showing that such a category will automatically have a dagger-compact structure. (Recent joint work with Howard Barnum and Matthew Graydon (arXiv:1507.06278) exhibits several categories of this kind.)
This paper extends the results of Hyperbolic Degree Bounds Signaling Dimension in Generalized Probabilistic Theories (Zenodo DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.22946778), which established that the signaling dimension of every canonical finite-dimensional Euclidean Jordan algebra (EJA) equals its Jordan rank. We investigate the consequences of this single-system identity under recursive composition. Combining the injectivity of local effect-space tensor products in standard non-signaling composites with the no-hypersignaling (NH) principle, we prove that the normalized linear-dimension ratio η_lin(S) = dim(S)/sign.dim(S)² is supermultiplicative. Consequently, any local excess above unity is amplified under repeated composition. For canonical EJA composites satisfying the structural axioms of Barnum, Graydon, and Wilce, product Jordan frames and NH enforce multiplicativity of composite rank. Together with established EJA classification results, this yields the conditional recursive constraint dim(J) ≤ rank(J)². Within this framework, quaternionic matrix Jordan systems and spin factors V_n with n ≥ 4 are excluded, while real matrix systems remain subcritical and complex matrix systems exactly saturate the bound. We also obtain finite-copy exclusion criteria and identify exact NH violations in specified EJA composition rules, including doubled complex and quaternionic composites. The analysis does not assume local tomography. Its conclusions are conditional on NH and the stated composition axioms; they do not establish unique selection of complex quantum theory. This work provides a compositional continuation of the preceding hyperbolic-signaling result, connecting classical simulation requirements to structural constraints on Jordan probabilistic theories.
A representation of finite-dimensional probabilistic models in terms of formally real Jordan algebras is obtained, in a strikingly easy way, from simple assumptions. This provides a framework in which real, complex and quaternionic quantum mechanics can be treated on an equal footing, and allows some (but not too much) room for other alternatives. This is based on earlier work (arXiv:1206:2897), but the development here is further simplified, and also extended in several ways. I also discuss the possibilities for organizing probabilistic models, subject to the assumptions discussed here, into symmetric monoidal categories, showing that such a category will automatically have a dagger-compact structure. (Recent joint work with Howard Barnum and Matthew Graydon (arXiv:1507.06278) exhibits several categories of this kind.)