Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1606.07458 · Journal of High Energy Physics

Closure of the operator product expansion in the non-unitary bootstrap

Ilya Esterlis, A. Liam Fitzpatrick, David M. Ramirez

Published Nov 1, 2016• 73 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We use the numerical conformal bootstrap in two dimensions to search for finite, closed sub-algebras of the operator product expansion (OPE), without assuming unitarity. We find the minimal models as special cases, as well as additional lines of solutions that can be understood in the Coulomb gas formalism. All the solutions we find that contain the vacuum in the operator algebra are cases where the external operators of the bootstrap equation are degenerate operators, and we argue that this follows analytically from the expressions in arXiv:1202.4698 for the crossing matrices of Virasoro conformal blocks. Our numerical analysis is a special case of the “Gliozzi” bootstrap method, and provides a simpler setting in which to study technical challenges with the method. In the supplementary material, we provide a Mathematica notebook that automates the calculation of the crossing matrices and OPE coefficients for degenerate operators using the formulae of Dotsenko and Fateev.

DOI
10.1007/jhep11(2016)030

Related papers

Bootstrapping non-unitary CFTs

Huang, Yu-tin, Lee, Shao-Cheng, Liao, Henry +1 more

We introduce a non-unitary-compatible numerical bootstrap strategy based on the statistical stability of OPE data inferred from crossing at multiple cross-ratios. For a trial spectrum, crossing determines OPE coefficients whose residual cross-ratio dependence directly measures the truncation error. This defines a scalar objective on the space of spectra, allowing bootstrap searches without imposing unitarity. Applied to two-dimensional Virasoro blocks, the method reproduces known A-series minimal models, including non-unitary examples, and yields candidate truncated solutions for c>1 with crossing violation comparable to that of minimal models. More generally, our framework provides a practical route to solving bootstrap constraints beyond the convex, unitary setting.

arXiv:2512.07706•Dec 8, 2025•2 citations

Bootstrapping Conformal Field Theories with the Extremal Functional Method

Sheer El-Showk, Miguel F. Paulos

The existence of a positive linear functional acting on the space of (differences between) conformal blocks has been shown to rule out regions in the parameter space of conformal field theories (CFTs). We argue that at the boundary of the allowed region the extremal functional contains, in principle, enough information to determine the dimensions and operator product expansion (OPE) coefficients of an infinite number of operators appearing in the correlator under analysis. Based on this idea we develop the extremal functional method (EFM), a numerical procedure for deriving the spectrum and OPE coefficients of CFTs lying on the boundary (of solution space). We test the EFM by using it to rederive the low lying spectrum and OPE coefficients of the two-dimensional Ising model based solely on the dimension of a single scalar quasiprimary--no Virasoro algebra required. Our work serves as a benchmark for applications to more interesting, less known CFTs in the near future.

arXiv:1211.2810•Physical Review Letters•Dec 9, 2013•269 citations

Conformal bootstrap in two-dimensional conformal field theories with non-diagonal spectrums

Santiago Migliaccio

In this thesis we study two-dimensional conformal field theories with Virasoro algebra symmetry, following the conformal bootstrap approach. Under the assumption that degenerate fields exist, we provide an extension of the analytic conformal bootstrap method to theories with non-diagonal spectrums. We write the equations that determine structure constants, and find explicit solutions in terms of special functions. We validate this results by numerically computing four-point functions in diagonal and non-diagonal minimal models, and verifying that crossing symmetry is satisfied. In addition, we build a proposal for a family of non-diagonal, non-rational conformal field theories for any central charges such that $\Re{c} < 13$. This proposal is motivated by taking limits of the spectrum of D-series minimal models. We perform numerical computations of four-point functions in these theories, and find that they satisfy crossing symmetry. These theories may be understood as non-diagonal extensions of Liouville theory.

arXiv:1901.10922•Jan 30, 2019•1 citation

OPE convergence in non-relativistic conformal field theories

Walter D. Goldberger, Zuhair U. Khandker, Siddharth G. Prabhu

Motivated by applications to the study of ultracold atomic gases near the unitarity limit, we investigate the structure of the operator product expansion (OPE) in non-relativistic conformal field theories (NRCFTs). The main tool used in our analysis is the representation theory of charged (i.e. non-zero particle number) operators in the NR-CFT, in particular the mapping between operators and states in a non-relativistic “radial quantization” Hilbert space. Our results include: a determination of the OPE coefficients of descendant operators in terms of those of the underlying primary state, a demonstration of convergence of the (imaginary time) OPE in certain kinematic limits, and an estimate of the decay rate of the OPE tail inside matrix elements which, as in relativistic CFTs, depends exponentially on operator dimensions. To illustrate our results we consider several examples, including a strongly interacting field theory of bosons tuned to the unitarity limit, as well as a class of holographic models. Given the similarity with known statements about the OPE in SO(2, d) invariant field theories, our results suggest the existence of a bootstrap approach to constraining NRCFTs, with applications to bound state spectra and interactions. We briefly comment on a possible implementation of this non-relativistic conformal bootstrap program.

arXiv:1412.8507•Journal of High Energy Physics•Dec 1, 2015•57 citations

What crossing symmetry forbids just above $c=1$

優 中山

What does a unitary two-dimensional conformal field theory look like just above $c=1$? Using the numerical conformal bootstrap, we study the four-point function of a scalar Virasoro primary $ϕ$ such that no primary lighter than $ϕ$ appears in its operator product expansion with itself. Slightly above $c=1$, crossing symmetry excludes the interval $0.17\lesssimΔ_ϕ\lesssim1$, although the compact boson realizes every such $Δ_ϕ$ at $c=1$. Combining this exclusion with results from the modular bootstrap, we show that the lightest primary of a compact unitary conformal field theory at $c=1.0005$ or $1.001$ has dimension $Δ_{\rm gap}<0.17$. Further from $c=1$, the largest excluded central charge at fixed $Δ_ϕ$ has two sharp minima near $Δ_ϕ=1/2$ and $4/7$. At these values it lies within $2\times10^{-7}$ of $c=8/7$, where the $\mathbb{Z}_5$ parafermion and its charge-conjugation orbifold have scalars of exactly these dimensions.

arXiv:2611.03217•Nov 2, 2026•1 citation

Virasoro OPE and conformal blocks from the inverse Shapovalov form

Jean-François Fortin, Lorenzo Quintavalle, Witold Skiba

We derive expressions for the Virasoro OPE and four-point conformal blocks on the sphere via the resolution of identity recently determined in [J.-F. Fortin et al., Phys. Rev. D 111, 085010 (2025)]. Even though the resolution of the identity depends on Virasoro singular vectors, our expression for the blocks does not depend on their precise form, but just on their well-known conformal weights. We verify that our expression is compatible with—but differs from—Zamolodchikov’s h h -recursion relation and we also examine the impact of various large central charge limits in our formula. A Mathematica notebook with a simple implementation of our expression for the Virasoro conformal blocks is provided as an ancillary file.

arXiv:2509.09765•SciPost Physics•May 20, 2026•1 citation
We use the numerical conformal bootstrap in two dimensions to search for finite, closed sub-algebras of the operator product expansion (OPE), without assuming unitarity. We find the minimal models as special cases, as well as additional lines of solutions that can be understood in the Coulomb gas formalism. All the solutions we find that contain the vacuum in the operator algebra are cases where the external operators of the bootstrap equation are degenerate operators, and we argue that this follows analytically from the expressions in arXiv:1202.4698 for the crossing matrices of Virasoro conformal blocks. Our numerical analysis is a special case of the “Gliozzi” bootstrap method, and provides a simpler setting in which to study technical challenges with the method. In the supplementary material, we provide a Mathematica notebook that automates the calculation of the crossing matrices and OPE coefficients for degenerate operators using the formulae of Dotsenko and Fateev.
We introduce a non-unitary-compatible numerical bootstrap strategy based on the statistical stability of OPE data inferred from crossing at multiple cross-ratios. For a trial spectrum, crossing determines OPE coefficients whose residual cross-ratio dependence directly measures the truncation error. This defines a scalar objective on the space of spectra, allowing bootstrap searches without imposing unitarity. Applied to two-dimensional Virasoro blocks, the method reproduces known A-series minimal models, including non-unitary examples, and yields candidate truncated solutions for c>1 with crossing violation comparable to that of minimal models. More generally, our framework provides a practical route to solving bootstrap constraints beyond the convex, unitary setting.
The existence of a positive linear functional acting on the space of (differences between) conformal blocks has been shown to rule out regions in the parameter space of conformal field theories (CFTs). We argue that at the boundary of the allowed region the extremal functional contains, in principle, enough information to determine the dimensions and operator product expansion (OPE) coefficients of an infinite number of operators appearing in the correlator under analysis. Based on this idea we develop the extremal functional method (EFM), a numerical procedure for deriving the spectrum and OPE coefficients of CFTs lying on the boundary (of solution space). We test the EFM by using it to rederive the low lying spectrum and OPE coefficients of the two-dimensional Ising model based solely on the dimension of a single scalar quasiprimary--no Virasoro algebra required. Our work serves as a benchmark for applications to more interesting, less known CFTs in the near future.
In this thesis we study two-dimensional conformal field theories with Virasoro algebra symmetry, following the conformal bootstrap approach. Under the assumption that degenerate fields exist, we provide an extension of the analytic conformal bootstrap method to theories with non-diagonal spectrums. We write the equations that determine structure constants, and find explicit solutions in terms of special functions. We validate this results by numerically computing four-point functions in diagonal and non-diagonal minimal models, and verifying that crossing symmetry is satisfied. In addition, we build a proposal for a family of non-diagonal, non-rational conformal field theories for any central charges such that ℜc<13\Re{c} < 13ℜc<13. This proposal is motivated by taking limits of the spectrum of D-series minimal models. We perform numerical computations of four-point functions in these theories, and find that they satisfy crossing symmetry. These theories may be understood as non-diagonal extensions of Liouville theory.
Motivated by applications to the study of ultracold atomic gases near the unitarity limit, we investigate the structure of the operator product expansion (OPE) in non-relativistic conformal field theories (NRCFTs). The main tool used in our analysis is the representation theory of charged (i.e. non-zero particle number) operators in the NR-CFT, in particular the mapping between operators and states in a non-relativistic “radial quantization” Hilbert space. Our results include: a determination of the OPE coefficients of descendant operators in terms of those of the underlying primary state, a demonstration of convergence of the (imaginary time) OPE in certain kinematic limits, and an estimate of the decay rate of the OPE tail inside matrix elements which, as in relativistic CFTs, depends exponentially on operator dimensions. To illustrate our results we consider several examples, including a strongly interacting field theory of bosons tuned to the unitarity limit, as well as a class of holographic models. Given the similarity with known statements about the OPE in SO(2, d) invariant field theories, our results suggest the existence of a bootstrap approach to constraining NRCFTs, with applications to bound state spectra and interactions. We briefly comment on a possible implementation of this non-relativistic conformal bootstrap program.
What crossing symmetry forbids just above c=1c=1c=1
What does a unitary two-dimensional conformal field theory look like just above c=1c=1c=1? Using the numerical conformal bootstrap, we study the four-point function of a scalar Virasoro primary ϕϕϕ such that no primary lighter than ϕϕϕ appears in its operator product expansion with itself. Slightly above c=1c=1c=1, crossing symmetry excludes the interval 0.17≲Δϕ≲10.17\lesssimΔ_ϕ\lesssim10.17≲Δϕ​≲1, although the compact boson realizes every such ΔϕΔ_ϕΔϕ​ at c=1c=1c=1. Combining this exclusion with results from the modular bootstrap, we show that the lightest primary of a compact unitary conformal field theory at c=1.0005c=1.0005c=1.0005 or 1.0011.0011.001 has dimension Δgap<0.17Δ_{\rm gap}<0.17Δgap​<0.17. Further from c=1c=1c=1, the largest excluded central charge at fixed ΔϕΔ_ϕΔϕ​ has two sharp minima near Δϕ=1/2Δ_ϕ=1/2Δϕ​=1/2 and 4/74/74/7. At these values it lies within 2×10−72\times10^{-7}2×10−7 of c=8/7c=8/7c=8/7, where the Z5\mathbb{Z}_5Z5​ parafermion and its charge-conjugation orbifold have scalars of exactly these dimensions.
We derive expressions for the Virasoro OPE and four-point conformal blocks on the sphere via the resolution of identity recently determined in [J.-F. Fortin et al., Phys. Rev. D 111, 085010 (2025)]. Even though the resolution of the identity depends on Virasoro singular vectors, our expression for the blocks does not depend on their precise form, but just on their well-known conformal weights. We verify that our expression is compatible with—but differs from—Zamolodchikov’s h h -recursion relation and we also examine the impact of various large central charge limits in our formula. A Mathematica notebook with a simple implementation of our expression for the Virasoro conformal blocks is provided as an ancillary file.