Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.09688 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

The reachable set of single-mode quadratic Hamiltonians

Uther Shackerley-Bennett, Alexander Pitchford, Marco G. Genoni, Alessio Serafini, Daniel Klaus Burgarth

Published Feb 22, 2017• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract Open-loop controllability in quantum mechanics refers to finding conditions on time-varying Hamiltonians such that a full group of unitary transformations can be enacted with them. For compact groups controllability is well understood and is dealt with using the Lie algebra rank criterion. Gaussian systems, however, evolve under Hamiltonians generating the non-compact symplectic group, rendering the rank criterion necessary but no longer sufficient. In this setting it is possible to satisfy the rank criterion without the ability to enact all symplectic transformations. We refer to such systems as ‘unstable’ and explore the set of symplectic transformations that remain reachable. We provide a partial analytical characterisation for the reachable set of a single-mode unstable system. From this it is proven that no orthogonal-symplectic operations (‘energy-preserving’ or ‘passive’ in the literature) may be reached with such controls. We then apply numerical optimal control algorithms to demonstrate a complete characterisation of the set in specific cases. These results suggest approaches to the long-standing open problem of controllability in n modes.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8121/aa6243

Related papers

Criteria for reachability of quantum states

S G Schirmer, A. I. Solomon, J V Leahy

Abstract. We address the question of which quantum states can be inter-converted under the action of a time-dependent Hamiltonian. In particular, we consider the problem as applied to mixed states, and investigate the difference between pure and mixed-state controllability introduced in previous work. We provide a complete characterization of the eigenvalue spectrum for which the state is controllable under the action of the symplectic group. We also address the problem of which states can be prepared if the dynamical Lie group is not sufficiently large to allow the system to be controllable. Criteria for reachability of quantum states 2 1.

•Oct 11, 2002•33 citations

On the controllability of systems on compact Lie groups and quantum mechanical systems

Domenico D’Alessandro

We develop some general results on the properties of the reachable sets for right invariant bilinear systems with state varying on compact Lie groups. The main results consist of a characterization of the set of states reachable in arbitrary time from the identity of the group. This, under suitable assumptions, is proved to be a Lie subgroup of the underlying Lie group. We apply these results to the analysis of the controllability of particles with spin. For these systems we also obtain estimates of the time after which every state is reachable from the identity. The results are motivated by the problem of controlling a two-level quantum system in implementations of quantum computers.

IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC)•Nov 11, 2002•6 citations

The control of Gaussian quantum states

Uther Shackerley-Bennett

The rise of quantum technology has put control at the centre of advancements in quantum mechanics. The union of quantum mechanics with mathematical control theory is a meeting that is leading to a much deeper insight into our interaction with the bizarre properties of quantum theory. Often, the study of discrete variable systems is the focus for making this union. Here, we look at how control theory may be applied to the continuous variable theory of Gaussian states. Special emphasis is given to control of the covariance matrix of these states, as it is here that we find the entanglement and entropic properties of the state. We begin by exploring some initial results for the geometry of Gaussian states, revealing different manifold structures dependent on symplectic eigenvalue degeneracy. In this geometrical setting a proposal for an extension of Williamson's theorem is put forward and partially completed. It is often interesting to look at restricted sets of Hamiltonians and ask what transformations can be performed with concatenations of their corresponding unitaries. Controllable systems are those for which the entire group of interest is possible to enact. We explore an uncontrollable system in a single mode and give a physical analysis as to why it behaves this way. This leads to ideas to move forwards for a necessary and sufficient condition for control on the symplectic group that has been conjectured since 1972. Later, we transfer to the question of open dynamics. We focus on a particular and ubiquitous channel known as 'lossy' or 'the attenuation channel'. An equation is derived describing the evolution for the symplectic invariants of a Gaussian state undergoing such dynamics. The equation of the former chapter is used to explore the evolution of entropy and entanglement. Optimal protocols are developed for the manipulation of these properties undergoing lossy dynamics.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Criteria for reachability of quantum states

S G Schirmer, A. I. Solomon, J V Leahy

We address the question of which quantum states can be inter-converted under the action of a time-dependent Hamiltonian. In particular, we consider the problem as applied to mixed states, and investigate the difference between pure- and mixed-state controllabilities introduced in previous work. We provide a complete characterization of the eigenvalue spectrum for which the state is controllable under the action of the symplectic group. We also address the problem of which states can be prepared if the dynamical Lie group is not sufficiently large to allow the system to be controllable.

arXiv:quant-ph/0110171•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 24, 2002•48 citations

ON THE CONTROLLABILITY OF SYSTEMS ON COMPACT LIE GROUPS AND QUANTUM MECHANICAL SYSTEMS

Domenico D ' Alessandro

In this paper, we develop some general results on the properties of the reachable sets for right invariant bilinear systems with state varying on compact Lie groups. The main results consist of a characterization of the set of states reachable in arbitrary time from the identity of the group. This, under suitable assumptions, is proved to be a Lie subgroup of the underlying Lie group. We apply these results to the analysis of the controllability of particles with spin. For these systems we also obtain estimates of the time after which every state is reachable from the identity. The results are motivated by the problem of controlling a two-level quantum system in implementations of quantum computers.

•Jan 1, 2000•4 citations

Quantifying State Space Accessibility through Operator Commutation Relations

Revista, Zen, PHYSICS, 10

The ability to navigate and control the state space of a quantum system is fundamental to quantum computing, quantum information processing, and advanced spectroscopy. This paper explores a rigorous mathematical framework for quantifying state space accessibility by leveraging the theory of operator commutation relations, particularly within the context of Lie algebras. We demonstrate that the span of iterated commutators of system Hamiltonians and control operators forms a dynamical Lie algebra, whose dimension and structure directly dictate the reachable states and unitary transformations. For closed quantum systems, the Lie algebra rank condition provides a powerful criterion for complete controllability, asserting that if the dynamical Lie algebra spans the entire space of anti-Hermitian operators, then any state can be reached from any other, and any unitary operation can be implemented. For open quantum systems, while environmental interactions introduce decoherence and dissipation, the Lie algebraic approach can still offer insights into the attainable subspaces and the limits of control, often involving Lie semigroups and Lie wedges. We present methods to analyze the accessibility of both pure and mixed states, illustrating how the algebraic properties encoded in commutation relations provide a precise measure of the manipulability of quantum systems. The implications extend to the design of robust quantum control protocols, optimized state preparation, and the development of error-resilient quantum technologies.

•Nov 28, 2025•0 citations
Abstract Open-loop controllability in quantum mechanics refers to finding conditions on time-varying Hamiltonians such that a full group of unitary transformations can be enacted with them. For compact groups controllability is well understood and is dealt with using the Lie algebra rank criterion. Gaussian systems, however, evolve under Hamiltonians generating the non-compact symplectic group, rendering the rank criterion necessary but no longer sufficient. In this setting it is possible to satisfy the rank criterion without the ability to enact all symplectic transformations. We refer to such systems as ‘unstable’ and explore the set of symplectic transformations that remain reachable. We provide a partial analytical characterisation for the reachable set of a single-mode unstable system. From this it is proven that no orthogonal-symplectic operations (‘energy-preserving’ or ‘passive’ in the literature) may be reached with such controls. We then apply numerical optimal control algorithms to demonstrate a complete characterisation of the set in specific cases. These results suggest approaches to the long-standing open problem of controllability in n modes.
Abstract. We address the question of which quantum states can be inter-converted under the action of a time-dependent Hamiltonian. In particular, we consider the problem as applied to mixed states, and investigate the difference between pure and mixed-state controllability introduced in previous work. We provide a complete characterization of the eigenvalue spectrum for which the state is controllable under the action of the symplectic group. We also address the problem of which states can be prepared if the dynamical Lie group is not sufficiently large to allow the system to be controllable. Criteria for reachability of quantum states 2 1.
We develop some general results on the properties of the reachable sets for right invariant bilinear systems with state varying on compact Lie groups. The main results consist of a characterization of the set of states reachable in arbitrary time from the identity of the group. This, under suitable assumptions, is proved to be a Lie subgroup of the underlying Lie group. We apply these results to the analysis of the controllability of particles with spin. For these systems we also obtain estimates of the time after which every state is reachable from the identity. The results are motivated by the problem of controlling a two-level quantum system in implementations of quantum computers.
The rise of quantum technology has put control at the centre of advancements in quantum mechanics. The union of quantum mechanics with mathematical control theory is a meeting that is leading to a much deeper insight into our interaction with the bizarre properties of quantum theory. Often, the study of discrete variable systems is the focus for making this union. Here, we look at how control theory may be applied to the continuous variable theory of Gaussian states. Special emphasis is given to control of the covariance matrix of these states, as it is here that we find the entanglement and entropic properties of the state. We begin by exploring some initial results for the geometry of Gaussian states, revealing different manifold structures dependent on symplectic eigenvalue degeneracy. In this geometrical setting a proposal for an extension of Williamson's theorem is put forward and partially completed. It is often interesting to look at restricted sets of Hamiltonians and ask what transformations can be performed with concatenations of their corresponding unitaries. Controllable systems are those for which the entire group of interest is possible to enact. We explore an uncontrollable system in a single mode and give a physical analysis as to why it behaves this way. This leads to ideas to move forwards for a necessary and sufficient condition for control on the symplectic group that has been conjectured since 1972. Later, we transfer to the question of open dynamics. We focus on a particular and ubiquitous channel known as 'lossy' or 'the attenuation channel'. An equation is derived describing the evolution for the symplectic invariants of a Gaussian state undergoing such dynamics. The equation of the former chapter is used to explore the evolution of entropy and entanglement. Optimal protocols are developed for the manipulation of these properties undergoing lossy dynamics.
We address the question of which quantum states can be inter-converted under the action of a time-dependent Hamiltonian. In particular, we consider the problem as applied to mixed states, and investigate the difference between pure- and mixed-state controllabilities introduced in previous work. We provide a complete characterization of the eigenvalue spectrum for which the state is controllable under the action of the symplectic group. We also address the problem of which states can be prepared if the dynamical Lie group is not sufficiently large to allow the system to be controllable.
In this paper, we develop some general results on the properties of the reachable sets for right invariant bilinear systems with state varying on compact Lie groups. The main results consist of a characterization of the set of states reachable in arbitrary time from the identity of the group. This, under suitable assumptions, is proved to be a Lie subgroup of the underlying Lie group. We apply these results to the analysis of the controllability of particles with spin. For these systems we also obtain estimates of the time after which every state is reachable from the identity. The results are motivated by the problem of controlling a two-level quantum system in implementations of quantum computers.
The ability to navigate and control the state space of a quantum system is fundamental to quantum computing, quantum information processing, and advanced spectroscopy. This paper explores a rigorous mathematical framework for quantifying state space accessibility by leveraging the theory of operator commutation relations, particularly within the context of Lie algebras. We demonstrate that the span of iterated commutators of system Hamiltonians and control operators forms a dynamical Lie algebra, whose dimension and structure directly dictate the reachable states and unitary transformations. For closed quantum systems, the Lie algebra rank condition provides a powerful criterion for complete controllability, asserting that if the dynamical Lie algebra spans the entire space of anti-Hermitian operators, then any state can be reached from any other, and any unitary operation can be implemented. For open quantum systems, while environmental interactions introduce decoherence and dissipation, the Lie algebraic approach can still offer insights into the attainable subspaces and the limits of control, often involving Lie semigroups and Lie wedges. We present methods to analyze the accessibility of both pure and mixed states, illustrating how the algebraic properties encoded in commutation relations provide a precise measure of the manipulability of quantum systems. The implications extend to the design of robust quantum control protocols, optimized state preparation, and the development of error-resilient quantum technologies.