Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.09496 · Physical review. E

Upper and lower critical decay exponents of Ising ferromagnets with long-range interaction

俊樹 堀田, Hidemaro Suwa, Synge Todo

Published Jan 23, 2017• 54 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We investigate the universality class of the finite-temperature phase transition of the two-dimensional Ising model with the algebraically decaying ferromagnetic long-range interaction, J_{ij}=|r[over ⃗]_{i}-r[over ⃗]_{j}|^{-(d+σ)}, where d (=2) is the dimension of the system and σ is the decay exponent, by means of the order-N cluster-algorithm Monte Carlo method. In particular, we focus on the upper and lower critical decay exponents, the boundaries between the mean-field-universality, intermediate, and short-range-universality regimes. At the critical decay exponents, it is found that the standard Binder ratio of magnetization at the critical temperature exhibits extremely slow convergence as a function of the system size. We propose more effective physical quantities, namely the combined Binder ratio and the self-combined Binder ratio, both of which cancel the leading finite-size corrections of the conventional Binder ratio. Utilizing these techniques, we clearly demonstrate that in two dimensions, the lower and upper critical decay exponents are σ=1 and 7/4, respectively, contrary to the recent Monte Carlo and renormalization-group studies [M. Picco, arXiv:1207.1018; T. Blanchard et al., Europhys. Lett. 101, 56003 (2013)EULEEJ0295-507510.1209/0295-5075/101/56003].

DOI
10.1103/physreve.95.012143

Related papers

Relations between short-range and long-range Ising models

Maria Chiara Angelini, Giorgio Parisi A, Federico Ricci‐Tersenghi

We perform a numerical study of the long-range (LR) ferromagnetic Ising model with power law decaying interactions (J∝r{-d-σ}) on both a one-dimensional chain (d=1) and a square lattice (d=2). We use advanced cluster algorithms to avoid the critical slowing down. We first check the validity of the relation connecting the critical behavior of the LR model with parameters (d,σ) to that of a short-range (SR) model in an equivalent dimension D. We then study the critical behavior of the d=2 LR model close to the lower critical σ, uncovering that the spatial correlation function decays with two different power laws: The effect of the subdominant power law is much stronger than finite-size effects and actually makes the estimate of critical exponents very subtle. By including this subdominant power law, the numerical data are consistent with the standard renormalization group (RG) prediction by Sak [Phys. Rev. B 8, 281 (1973)], thus making not necessary (and unlikely, according to Occam's razor) the recent proposal by Picco [arXiv:1207.1018] of having a new set of RG fixed points in addition to the mean-field one and the SR one.

arXiv:1401.6805•Physical Review E•Jun 12, 2014•118 citations

Boundary between Long-Range and Short-Range Critical Behavior in Systems with Algebraic Interactions

Erik Luijten, Henk W. J. Blöte

We investigate phase transitions of two-dimensional Ising models with power-law interactions, using an efficient Monte Carlo algorithm. For slow decay, the transition is of the mean-field type; for fast decay, it belongs to the short-range Ising universality class. We focus on the intermediate range, where the critical exponents depend continuously on the power law. We find that the boundary with short-range critical behavior occurs for interactions depending on distance r as r(-15/4). This answers a long-standing controversy between mutually conflicting renormalization-group analyses.

arXiv:cond-mat/0112472•Physical Review Letters•Jun 20, 2002•124 citations

Phase transition in a general continuous Ising model with long-range interactions

E. Bayong, H. T. Diep, Trong Tuong Truong

Critical exponents for a one-dimensional general continuous Ising model with long-range ferromagnetic interactions decaying as 1/r1+σ are calculated using a histogram Monte Carlo technique. A continuous Ising model means that a spin can take any value between −1 and 1. The critical point behavior is investigated. It is found that the system exhibits a second-order phase transition with nonstandard critical exponents; the singularities in the specific heat and susceptibility depend on σ. For σ=1, there are extremely weak finite size effects: the first-order and the second-order cumulants of the order parameter yield ν=2.42(1). The susceptibility exponent γ=2.259(9). Results for σ=0.7 will be shown and discussed.

Journal of Applied Physics•Apr 15, 1999•6 citations

One-dimensional Ising models with long-range interactions

James L. Monroe

We consider Ising models with long-range ferromagnetic pair interactions decaying as for . We first find approximate values for the critical temperature. We use a cluster mean-field approach combined with finite-size scaling and Vanden Broeck and Schwartz transformations. For we find which can be compared with recent results of Luijten and Blöte who found , and which is two orders of magnitude more accurate than any previous results. Since we use a mean-field cluster approximation as part of our approach, the accuracy for larger values of decreases significantly. In addition to we obtain approximate values for the critical exponents , and using the coherent anomaly method. For we obtain , , and - all extremely close to the predictions of renormalization group calculations which say that these exponents should take on their classical values for this value of .

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Dec 11, 1998•14 citations

On Sak's criterion for statistical models with long-range interaction

Xiao, Tianning, Liu, Ziyu, Fan, Zhijie +1 more

Determining the threshold value $σ_*$ that separates the short-range (SR) and long-range (LR) universality classes in phase transitions remains a controversial issue. While Sak's criterion, $σ_* = 2 - η_{\mathrm{SR}}$, has been widely accepted, recent studies of two-dimensional (2D) models with long-range interactions have challenged it. In this work, we focus on the crossover between LR and SR criticality in several classical 2D statistical models, including the XY, Heisenberg, percolation, and Ising models, whose interactions decay as $1/r^{2+σ}$. Our previous simulations for the XY, Heisenberg, and percolation models consistently indicate a universal boundary at $σ_* = 2$. Here, we complete the picture by performing large-scale Monte Carlo simulations of the 2D LR-Ising model, reaching lattice sizes up to $L = 8192$. By analyzing the Fortuin-Kasteleyn critical polynomial $R_p$, the Binder ratio $Q_m$, and the anomalous dimension $η$, we obtain convergent and self-consistent evidence that the universality class already changes sharply at $σ= 2$. Taken together, these results establish a unified scenario for LR interacting systems: across all studied models, the crossover from LR to SR universality occurs at $σ_* = 2$.

arXiv:2512.04805•Dec 4, 2025•7 citations

Classical critical behavior of spin models with long-range interactions

Erik Luijten, Henk W. J. Blöte

We present the results of extensive Monte Carlo simulations of Ising models with algebraically decaying ferromagnetic interactions in the regime where classical critical behavior is expected for these systems. We corroborate the values for the exponents predicted by renormalization theory for systems in one, two, and three dimensions and accurately observe the predicted logarithmic corrections at the upper critical dimension. We give both theoretical and numerical evidence that above the upper critical dimension the decay of the critical spin-spin correlation function in finite systems consists of two different regimes. For one-dimensional systems our estimates for the critical couplings are more than two orders of magnitude more accurate than existing estimates. In two and three dimensions we are unaware of any other results for the critical couplings.

arXiv:cond-mat/9704016•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 1, 1997•213 citations
We investigate the universality class of the finite-temperature phase transition of the two-dimensional Ising model with the algebraically decaying ferromagnetic long-range interaction, J_{ij}=|r[over ⃗]{i}-r[over ⃗]{j}|^{-(d+σ)}, where d (=2) is the dimension of the system and σ is the decay exponent, by means of the order-N cluster-algorithm Monte Carlo method. In particular, we focus on the upper and lower critical decay exponents, the boundaries between the mean-field-universality, intermediate, and short-range-universality regimes. At the critical decay exponents, it is found that the standard Binder ratio of magnetization at the critical temperature exhibits extremely slow convergence as a function of the system size. We propose more effective physical quantities, namely the combined Binder ratio and the self-combined Binder ratio, both of which cancel the leading finite-size corrections of the conventional Binder ratio. Utilizing these techniques, we clearly demonstrate that in two dimensions, the lower and upper critical decay exponents are σ=1 and 7/4, respectively, contrary to the recent Monte Carlo and renormalization-group studies [M. Picco, arXiv:1207.1018; T. Blanchard et al., Europhys. Lett. 101, 56003 (2013)EULEEJ0295-507510.1209/0295-5075/101/56003].
We perform a numerical study of the long-range (LR) ferromagnetic Ising model with power law decaying interactions (J∝r{-d-σ}) on both a one-dimensional chain (d=1) and a square lattice (d=2). We use advanced cluster algorithms to avoid the critical slowing down. We first check the validity of the relation connecting the critical behavior of the LR model with parameters (d,σ) to that of a short-range (SR) model in an equivalent dimension D. We then study the critical behavior of the d=2 LR model close to the lower critical σ, uncovering that the spatial correlation function decays with two different power laws: The effect of the subdominant power law is much stronger than finite-size effects and actually makes the estimate of critical exponents very subtle. By including this subdominant power law, the numerical data are consistent with the standard renormalization group (RG) prediction by Sak [Phys. Rev. B 8, 281 (1973)], thus making not necessary (and unlikely, according to Occam's razor) the recent proposal by Picco [arXiv:1207.1018] of having a new set of RG fixed points in addition to the mean-field one and the SR one.
We investigate phase transitions of two-dimensional Ising models with power-law interactions, using an efficient Monte Carlo algorithm. For slow decay, the transition is of the mean-field type; for fast decay, it belongs to the short-range Ising universality class. We focus on the intermediate range, where the critical exponents depend continuously on the power law. We find that the boundary with short-range critical behavior occurs for interactions depending on distance r as r(-15/4). This answers a long-standing controversy between mutually conflicting renormalization-group analyses.
Critical exponents for a one-dimensional general continuous Ising model with long-range ferromagnetic interactions decaying as 1/r1+σ are calculated using a histogram Monte Carlo technique. A continuous Ising model means that a spin can take any value between −1 and 1. The critical point behavior is investigated. It is found that the system exhibits a second-order phase transition with nonstandard critical exponents; the singularities in the specific heat and susceptibility depend on σ. For σ=1, there are extremely weak finite size effects: the first-order and the second-order cumulants of the order parameter yield ν=2.42(1). The susceptibility exponent γ=2.259(9). Results for σ=0.7 will be shown and discussed.
We consider Ising models with long-range ferromagnetic pair interactions decaying as for . We first find approximate values for the critical temperature. We use a cluster mean-field approach combined with finite-size scaling and Vanden Broeck and Schwartz transformations. For we find which can be compared with recent results of Luijten and Blöte who found , and which is two orders of magnitude more accurate than any previous results. Since we use a mean-field cluster approximation as part of our approach, the accuracy for larger values of decreases significantly. In addition to we obtain approximate values for the critical exponents , and using the coherent anomaly method. For we obtain , , and - all extremely close to the predictions of renormalization group calculations which say that these exponents should take on their classical values for this value of .
Determining the threshold value σ∗σ_*σ∗​ that separates the short-range (SR) and long-range (LR) universality classes in phase transitions remains a controversial issue. While Sak's criterion, σ∗=2−ηSRσ_* = 2 - η_{\mathrm{SR}}σ∗​=2−ηSR​, has been widely accepted, recent studies of two-dimensional (2D) models with long-range interactions have challenged it. In this work, we focus on the crossover between LR and SR criticality in several classical 2D statistical models, including the XY, Heisenberg, percolation, and Ising models, whose interactions decay as 1/r2+σ1/r^{2+σ}1/r2+σ. Our previous simulations for the XY, Heisenberg, and percolation models consistently indicate a universal boundary at σ∗=2σ_* = 2σ∗​=2. Here, we complete the picture by performing large-scale Monte Carlo simulations of the 2D LR-Ising model, reaching lattice sizes up to L=8192L = 8192L=8192. By analyzing the Fortuin-Kasteleyn critical polynomial RpR_pRp​, the Binder ratio QmQ_mQm​, and the anomalous dimension ηηη, we obtain convergent and self-consistent evidence that the universality class already changes sharply at σ=2σ= 2σ=2. Taken together, these results establish a unified scenario for LR interacting systems: across all studied models, the crossover from LR to SR universality occurs at σ∗=2σ_* = 2σ∗​=2.
We present the results of extensive Monte Carlo simulations of Ising models with algebraically decaying ferromagnetic interactions in the regime where classical critical behavior is expected for these systems. We corroborate the values for the exponents predicted by renormalization theory for systems in one, two, and three dimensions and accurately observe the predicted logarithmic corrections at the upper critical dimension. We give both theoretical and numerical evidence that above the upper critical dimension the decay of the critical spin-spin correlation function in finite systems consists of two different regimes. For one-dimensional systems our estimates for the critical couplings are more than two orders of magnitude more accurate than existing estimates. In two and three dimensions we are unaware of any other results for the critical couplings.