Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1605.05690 · Physica A Statistical Mechanics and its Applications

The definition of the thermodynamic entropy in statistical mechanics

Robert H. Swendsen

Published Oct 16, 2016• 13 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1016/j.physa.2016.10.032

Related papers

Statistical mechanical proof of the second law of thermodynamics based on volume entropy

Michele Campisi

arXiv:0704.2567•Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics•Nov 26, 2007•38 citations

The thermodynamic meaning of negative entropy

Lídia del Rio, Johan Åberg, Renato Renner +2 more

arXiv:1009.1630•Nature•Jun 1, 2011•415 citations

Entropies of Statistical Mechanics and Disorder Versus the Entropy of Thermodynamics and Order

Elias P. Gyftopoulos

The prevailing beliefs in the scientific and engineering literature are that: (i) thermodynamics is explained and justified by statistical mechanics; (ii) entropy is a statistical measure of disorder; and (iii) for given values of energy, volume, and amounts of constituents, the largest value of entropy corresponds to both a thermodynamic equilibrium state and the ultimate disorder. In this paper, we provide: (i) a summary of the beliefs as stated by some eminent scientists; (ii) experimental evidence that casts serious doubt about the validity of the beliefs; (iii) an outline of a nonstatistical unified quantum theory of mechanics and thermodynamics; (iv) an outline of a nonquantal, nonstatistical exposition of thermodynamics, valid for all systems (both macroscopic and microscopic), and for all states (both thermodynamic equilibrium and not thermodynamic equilibrium); (v) the definition and analytical expression of the entropy of thermodynamics; (vi) the interpretation of entropy as both a measure of the quantum-theoretic spatial shape of a molecule, and an indicator of order; and (vii) nonstatistical answers to the questions that motivated the introduction of statistical mechanics.

Journal of Energy Resources Technology•Dec 13, 2000•12 citations

The ambiguity of “distinguishability” in statistical mechanics

Robert H. Swendsen

Differences of opinion concerning fundamental issues in statistical mechanics directly related to the thermodynamic entropy have persisted through more than a century of debate. One reason is the lack of consensus on the definitions of key terms, especially the terms “distinguishable,” “indistinguishable,” and “identical.” Several definitions occur in the literature, but are not always made explicit. The multiplicity of definitions has created confusion about the basic conditions under which entropy is to be defined. In this paper, I present an overview of definitions in current use for terms associated with distinguishability and relate them to various definitions that have been suggested for entropy. My hope is that consensus will be achievable if the definitions are clarified and agreed upon.

American Journal of Physics•May 20, 2015•16 citations

Statistical Definition of Entropy

Wolfgang Cassing

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2025•0 citations

Fluctuations, Thermodynamic Equilibrium and Entropy

Edwin C. Kemble

To eliminate exceptions to the second law due to fluctuation phenomena, etc., the following changes are necessary. First we must state the laws of thermodynamics in terms of Gibbsian ensembles rather than of individual systems. Second we must sharpen our conception of the experimental procedure required for producing states of thermodynamic equilibrium. It will not suffice to isolate the system and wait. We must have the positive stirring action of thermal contact with a thermostat. Using the new definition of thermal equilibrium we can place statistical mechanics on a more satisfactory footing by showing that the thermostat experimental procedure leads to the canonical ensemble and maximizes v. Neumann's microscopic entropy. (Details of this proof appear in succeeding paper). Difficulties with his macroscopic definition of entropy are avoided by showing that his original microscopic definition is satisfactory when used in conjunction with a proper operational definition of thermodynamic equilibrium. In conclusion the second law of thermodynamics is derived from quantum statistics on the basis of the microscopic definition of entropy.

Physical Review•Nov 15, 1939•18 citations
The prevailing beliefs in the scientific and engineering literature are that: (i) thermodynamics is explained and justified by statistical mechanics; (ii) entropy is a statistical measure of disorder; and (iii) for given values of energy, volume, and amounts of constituents, the largest value of entropy corresponds to both a thermodynamic equilibrium state and the ultimate disorder. In this paper, we provide: (i) a summary of the beliefs as stated by some eminent scientists; (ii) experimental evidence that casts serious doubt about the validity of the beliefs; (iii) an outline of a nonstatistical unified quantum theory of mechanics and thermodynamics; (iv) an outline of a nonquantal, nonstatistical exposition of thermodynamics, valid for all systems (both macroscopic and microscopic), and for all states (both thermodynamic equilibrium and not thermodynamic equilibrium); (v) the definition and analytical expression of the entropy of thermodynamics; (vi) the interpretation of entropy as both a measure of the quantum-theoretic spatial shape of a molecule, and an indicator of order; and (vii) nonstatistical answers to the questions that motivated the introduction of statistical mechanics.
Differences of opinion concerning fundamental issues in statistical mechanics directly related to the thermodynamic entropy have persisted through more than a century of debate. One reason is the lack of consensus on the definitions of key terms, especially the terms “distinguishable,” “indistinguishable,” and “identical.” Several definitions occur in the literature, but are not always made explicit. The multiplicity of definitions has created confusion about the basic conditions under which entropy is to be defined. In this paper, I present an overview of definitions in current use for terms associated with distinguishability and relate them to various definitions that have been suggested for entropy. My hope is that consensus will be achievable if the definitions are clarified and agreed upon.
To eliminate exceptions to the second law due to fluctuation phenomena, etc., the following changes are necessary. First we must state the laws of thermodynamics in terms of Gibbsian ensembles rather than of individual systems. Second we must sharpen our conception of the experimental procedure required for producing states of thermodynamic equilibrium. It will not suffice to isolate the system and wait. We must have the positive stirring action of thermal contact with a thermostat. Using the new definition of thermal equilibrium we can place statistical mechanics on a more satisfactory footing by showing that the thermostat experimental procedure leads to the canonical ensemble and maximizes v. Neumann's microscopic entropy. (Details of this proof appear in succeeding paper). Difficulties with his macroscopic definition of entropy are avoided by showing that his original microscopic definition is satisfactory when used in conjunction with a proper operational definition of thermodynamic equilibrium. In conclusion the second law of thermodynamics is derived from quantum statistics on the basis of the microscopic definition of entropy.