Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1604.07158

Comment on the paper "Quasi-particle approach for lattice Hamiltonians with large coordination numbers" by P. Navez, F. Queisser and R. Schützhold - J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 47 225004 (2014)

Demetra Psiachos

Published Apr 25, 2016• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

This comment regards a central aspect of the referred-to paper, the issue of convergence of the large coordination-number expansion. Perturbation expansions of expressions containing a large number of parameters are generally invalid due to the non-analyticity of the expanded expressions. I refer to recent work where these issues are analyzed and discussed in detail in relation to a benchmark example of a cluster model. As discussed therein, methods which are uncontrollable and for which their convergence is not foreseeable are not only useless but can mislead, particularly if models derived from them are used to interpret experiments.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1604.07158

Related papers

Quasi-particle approach for lattice Hamiltonians with large coordination numbers

Patrick Navez, Friedemann Queißer, Ralf Schützhold

In many condensed-matter systems, it is very useful to introduce a quasi-particle approach, which is based on some sort of linearization around a suitable background state. In order to be a systematic and controlled approximation, this linearization should be justified by an expansion into powers of some small control parameter. Here, we present a method for general lattice Hamiltonians with large coordination numbers Z >> 1, which is based on an expansion into powers of 1/Z. In order to demonstrate the generality of our method, we apply it to various spin systems, as well as the Bose and Fermi Hubbard model.

arXiv:1303.4112•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•May 19, 2014•18 citations

Quantum physics with non-Hermitian operators

Carl M. Bender, Andreas Fring, Uwe Günther +1 more

The main motivation behind the call for this special issue was to gather recent results, developments and open problems in quantum physics with non-Hermitian operators. There have been previous special issues in this journal [1, 2] and elsewhere on this subject. The intention of this issue is to reflect the current state of this rapidly-developing field. It has therefore been open to all contributions containing new results on non-Hermitian theories that are explicitly -symmetric and/or pseudo-Hermitian or quasi-Hermitian. In the last decade these types of systems have proved to be viable self-consistent physical theories with well defined unitary time-evolution and real spectra. As the large number of responses demonstrates, this is a rapidly evolving field of research. A consensus has been reached regarding most of the fundamental problems, and the general ideas and techniques are now readily being employed in many areas of physics. Nonetheless, this issue still contains some treatments of a more general nature regarding the spectral analysis of these models, in particular, the physics of the exceptional points, the breaking of the -symmetry, an interpretation of negative energies and the consistent implementation of the WKB analysis. This issue also contains a treatment of a scattering theory associated with these types of systems, weak measurements, coherent states, decoherence, unbounded metric operators and the inclusion of domain issues to obtain well defined self-adjoint theories. Contributions in the form of applications of the general ideas include: studies of classical shock-waves and tunnelling, supersymmetric models, spin chain models, models with ring structure, random matrix models, the Pauli equation, the nonlinear Schrödinger equation, quasi-exactly solvable models, integrable models such as the Calogero model, Bose–Einstein condensates, thermodynamics, nonlinear oligomers, quantum catastrophes, the Landau–Zener problem and pseudo-Fermions. Applications close to experimental realization are proposed in optics, including short light pulse models, waveguides and laser systems, and also in electronics. We hope that this issue will become a valuable reference and inspiration for the broader scientific community working in mathematical and theoretical physics. References [1] Fring A, Jones H F and Znojil M (ed) 2008 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 41 240301 [2] Geyer H, Heiss D and Znojil M (ed) 2006 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 39 9963

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Oct 23, 2012•62 citations

Comment on “Improved many-body expansions from eigenvector continuation”

Péter R. Śurján, Ágnes Szabados

In a recent paper [Phys. Rev. C 101, 041302(R) (2020)] Demol et al. published an interesting method to improve results from finite-order perturbation theory. Their applications on nuclear many-body problems show that the numerical results are very accurate, capable of converting divergent series to fast-converging sequences. We argue that one reason for this impressive accuracy is connected to those of related methods which proved to be useful in many-electron theory.

Physical Review C•Jun 28, 2021•0 citations

Comment on the paper “Ground state instability in systems of strongly interacting fermions”

VICTOR A. KHODEL

Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics Letters•Feb 1, 1999•0 citations

Comment on ‘Little-known non-orthogonality of hydrogenic radial wavefunctions: an ℓ -dependent operator perspective’

Gregory L. Bason, Bruce Cameron Reed

Abstract Following the recent discussion of Mankame (2026 Eur. J. Phys. 47 025405), we consider the orthogonality of the radial parts of the hydrogen atom wavefunctions, R n , ℓ ( r ) . As Mankame showed, these functions are not in general orthogonal. By this we mean that the overlap integral of the product of two of them weighted by the square of the radial coordinate may be non-zero if the two angular momentum quantum numbers differ. Orthogonality does hold in the case where the two angular momentum quantum numbers are the same, providing that the principal quantum numbers differ. Here we offer an alternate proof of this result, describe some analytic examples to complement Mankame’s numerical ones, and point out some further references on this issue.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 20, 2026•0 citations

Comment on ‘‘A quantum mechanical representation in phase space’’ [J. Chem. Phys. 98, 3103 (1993)]

Xu‐Guang Hu, Qian-Shu Li

In this comment questions about the improper eigenfunctions in J. Chem. Phys. 98, 3103 (1993) are addressed and the other suitable eigenfunctions are suggested at the same time.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 15, 1994•6 citations
This comment regards a central aspect of the referred-to paper, the issue of convergence of the large coordination-number expansion. Perturbation expansions of expressions containing a large number of parameters are generally invalid due to the non-analyticity of the expanded expressions. I refer to recent work where these issues are analyzed and discussed in detail in relation to a benchmark example of a cluster model. As discussed therein, methods which are uncontrollable and for which their convergence is not foreseeable are not only useless but can mislead, particularly if models derived from them are used to interpret experiments.
In many condensed-matter systems, it is very useful to introduce a quasi-particle approach, which is based on some sort of linearization around a suitable background state. In order to be a systematic and controlled approximation, this linearization should be justified by an expansion into powers of some small control parameter. Here, we present a method for general lattice Hamiltonians with large coordination numbers Z >> 1, which is based on an expansion into powers of 1/Z. In order to demonstrate the generality of our method, we apply it to various spin systems, as well as the Bose and Fermi Hubbard model.
The main motivation behind the call for this special issue was to gather recent results, developments and open problems in quantum physics with non-Hermitian operators. There have been previous special issues in this journal [1, 2] and elsewhere on this subject. The intention of this issue is to reflect the current state of this rapidly-developing field. It has therefore been open to all contributions containing new results on non-Hermitian theories that are explicitly -symmetric and/or pseudo-Hermitian or quasi-Hermitian. In the last decade these types of systems have proved to be viable self-consistent physical theories with well defined unitary time-evolution and real spectra. As the large number of responses demonstrates, this is a rapidly evolving field of research. A consensus has been reached regarding most of the fundamental problems, and the general ideas and techniques are now readily being employed in many areas of physics. Nonetheless, this issue still contains some treatments of a more general nature regarding the spectral analysis of these models, in particular, the physics of the exceptional points, the breaking of the -symmetry, an interpretation of negative energies and the consistent implementation of the WKB analysis. This issue also contains a treatment of a scattering theory associated with these types of systems, weak measurements, coherent states, decoherence, unbounded metric operators and the inclusion of domain issues to obtain well defined self-adjoint theories. Contributions in the form of applications of the general ideas include: studies of classical shock-waves and tunnelling, supersymmetric models, spin chain models, models with ring structure, random matrix models, the Pauli equation, the nonlinear Schrödinger equation, quasi-exactly solvable models, integrable models such as the Calogero model, Bose–Einstein condensates, thermodynamics, nonlinear oligomers, quantum catastrophes, the Landau–Zener problem and pseudo-Fermions. Applications close to experimental realization are proposed in optics, including short light pulse models, waveguides and laser systems, and also in electronics. We hope that this issue will become a valuable reference and inspiration for the broader scientific community working in mathematical and theoretical physics. References [1] Fring A, Jones H F and Znojil M (ed) 2008 J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 41 240301 [2] Geyer H, Heiss D and Znojil M (ed) 2006 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 39 9963
Abstract Following the recent discussion of Mankame (2026 Eur. J. Phys. 47 025405), we consider the orthogonality of the radial parts of the hydrogen atom wavefunctions, R n , ℓ ( r ) . As Mankame showed, these functions are not in general orthogonal. By this we mean that the overlap integral of the product of two of them weighted by the square of the radial coordinate may be non-zero if the two angular momentum quantum numbers differ. Orthogonality does hold in the case where the two angular momentum quantum numbers are the same, providing that the principal quantum numbers differ. Here we offer an alternate proof of this result, describe some analytic examples to complement Mankame’s numerical ones, and point out some further references on this issue.