Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1604.06719 · Nature Communications

Correspondence: Enhancing a phase measurement by sequentially probing a solid-state system

Paul A. Knott, William J. Munro, Jacob Dunningham

Published May 9, 2016• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In a recent paper, Liu et al . 1 claim to perform the first room temperature entanglement-enhanced phase measurement in a solid-state system. We argue here that this claim is incorrect: their measurement is not enhanced because of the entanglement in their system, instead the enhancement comes from the fact that the phase shift is applied twice to their state.

DOI
10.1038/ncomms11520

Related papers

Correspondence: Reply to ‘Enhancing a phase measurement by sequentially probing a solid-state system’

Gang‐Qin Liu, Zhang Yu-Ran, Yanchun Chang +3 more

Knott et al . 1 argue in their comment on our recently published study 2 that the enhancement of phase sensitivity is obtained by applying a phase shift twice, and thus not from the entanglement. We clarify that the entanglement between the two non-identical qubits is the crucial and decisive factor in the achieved enhancement, and the experimental technique used to encode the phases to qubits does not affect this conclusion.

Nature Communications•May 9, 2016•1 citation

Quantum-Enhanced Phase Imaging

Andy Nicholas Black, Long Duc Nguyen, James E. Evans +1 more

We report on a phase-shifting holography scheme that uses position-momentum entangled photons to achieve twice the contrast of classical phase-shifting holography while only measuring the marginal of the two-photon joint-position distribution.

Frontiers in Optics•Jan 1, 2022•0 citations

Demonstration of entanglement-enhanced phase estimation in solid

Gang‐Qin Liu, Yu-Ran Zhang, Yanchun Chang +3 more

Precise parameter estimation plays a central role in science and technology. The statistical error in estimation can be decreased by repeating measurement, leading to that the resultant uncertainty of the estimated parameter is proportional to the square root of the number of repetitions in accordance with the central limit theorem. Quantum parameter estimation, an emerging field of quantum technology, aims to use quantum resources to yield higher statistical precision than classical approaches. Here we report the first room-temperature implementation of entanglement-enhanced phase estimation in a solid-state system: the nitrogen-vacancy centre in pure diamond. We demonstrate a super-resolving phase measurement with two entangled qubits of different physical realizations: an nitrogen-vacancy centre electron spin and a proximal (13)C nuclear spin. The experimental data shows clearly the uncertainty reduction when entanglement resource is used, confirming the theoretical expectation. Our results represent an elemental demonstration of enhancement of quantum metrology against classical procedure.

arXiv:1408.0480•Nature Communications•Apr 2, 2015•40 citations

Single-gate, multipartite entanglement on a room-temperature quantum register

Joseph Minnella, Mathieu Ouellet, Amelia R. Klein +1 more

Multipartite entanglement is an essential aspect of quantum systems, needed to execute quantum algorithms, implement error correction and achieve quantum-enhanced sensing. In solid-state quantum registers such as nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond, entangled states are typically created using sequential, pairwise gates between the central electron and individual nuclear qubits. This sequential approach is slow and suffers from crosstalk errors. Here we demonstrate a parallelized multi-qubit entangling gate to generate a four-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state using a room-temperature nitrogen-vacancy centre in only 14.8 μs-ten times faster than that using sequences of two-qubit gates and close to the fundamental limit set by the hyperfine coupling frequencies. Parallel three-qubit gates are also realized with all-nuclear-qubit subsets. The entangled states are verified by measuring multiple quantum coherences. The four-qubit parallel gate has a fidelity of 0.92(4), whereas the sequential four-qubit gate fidelity is only 0.69(3). The approach is generalizable to other solid-state platforms, and it lays the foundation for scalable generation and control of entanglement in practical devices.

arXiv:2508.08465•Nature Nanotechnology•Sep 14, 2026•3 citations

Entanglement-Enhanced Measurement of a Completely Unknown Phase

Dominic William Berry, Guo‐Yong Xiang, Brendon L. Higgins +2 more

We demonstrate a method for achieving phase measurements with accuracy beyond the standard quantum limit using entangled states. A sophisticated feedback scheme means that no initial estimate of the phase is required.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics•Jan 1, 2010•0 citations

Long-Range Coupling Affects Entanglement Dynamics

Shenglong Xu

Three new studies predict the measurement-induced phase-transition behavior for quantum systems that have long-range coupling between their qubits.

Physics•Jan 5, 2022•8 citations
In a recent paper, Liu et al . 1 claim to perform the first room temperature entanglement-enhanced phase measurement in a solid-state system. We argue here that this claim is incorrect: their measurement is not enhanced because of the entanglement in their system, instead the enhancement comes from the fact that the phase shift is applied twice to their state.
Precise parameter estimation plays a central role in science and technology. The statistical error in estimation can be decreased by repeating measurement, leading to that the resultant uncertainty of the estimated parameter is proportional to the square root of the number of repetitions in accordance with the central limit theorem. Quantum parameter estimation, an emerging field of quantum technology, aims to use quantum resources to yield higher statistical precision than classical approaches. Here we report the first room-temperature implementation of entanglement-enhanced phase estimation in a solid-state system: the nitrogen-vacancy centre in pure diamond. We demonstrate a super-resolving phase measurement with two entangled qubits of different physical realizations: an nitrogen-vacancy centre electron spin and a proximal (13)C nuclear spin. The experimental data shows clearly the uncertainty reduction when entanglement resource is used, confirming the theoretical expectation. Our results represent an elemental demonstration of enhancement of quantum metrology against classical procedure.
Multipartite entanglement is an essential aspect of quantum systems, needed to execute quantum algorithms, implement error correction and achieve quantum-enhanced sensing. In solid-state quantum registers such as nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond, entangled states are typically created using sequential, pairwise gates between the central electron and individual nuclear qubits. This sequential approach is slow and suffers from crosstalk errors. Here we demonstrate a parallelized multi-qubit entangling gate to generate a four-qubit Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger state using a room-temperature nitrogen-vacancy centre in only 14.8 μs-ten times faster than that using sequences of two-qubit gates and close to the fundamental limit set by the hyperfine coupling frequencies. Parallel three-qubit gates are also realized with all-nuclear-qubit subsets. The entangled states are verified by measuring multiple quantum coherences. The four-qubit parallel gate has a fidelity of 0.92(4), whereas the sequential four-qubit gate fidelity is only 0.69(3). The approach is generalizable to other solid-state platforms, and it lays the foundation for scalable generation and control of entanglement in practical devices.