Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1604.05629

Projective Limits of State Spaces: Quantum Field Theory without a Vacuum

Suzanne Lanéry

Published Apr 19, 2016• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Instead of formulating the states of a Quantum Field Theory (QFT) as density matrices over a single large Hilbert space, it has been proposed by Kijowski [Kijowski, 1977] to construct them as consistent families of partial density matrices, the latter being defined over small 'building block' Hilbert spaces. In this picture, each small Hilbert space can be physically interpreted as extracting from the full theory specific degrees of freedom. This allows to reduce the quantization of a classical field theory to the quantization of finite-dimensional sub-systems, thus sidestepping some of the common ambiguities (specifically, the issues revolving around the choice of a 'vacuum state'), while obtaining robust and well-controlled quantum states spaces. The present letter provides a self-contained introduction to this formalism, detailing its motivations as well as its relations to other approaches to QFT (such as conventional Fock-like Hilbert spaces, path-integral quantization, and the algebraic formulation). At the same time, it can serve as a reading guide to the series of more in-depth articles [arXiv:1411.3589, arXiv:1411.3590, arXiv:1411.3591, arXiv:1510.01926].

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1604.05629

Related papers

The modal interpretation of algebraic quantum field theory

Rob Clifton

Abstract The modal interpretation is actually a family of interpretations sharing the feature that a system’s density operator constrains the possibilities for assigning definite values to its observables (Healey 1989, Dieks & Vermaas 1998). We start with a brief review of the basic idea behind these interpretations from an algebraic point of view (Zimba & Clifton 1998, Halvorson & Clifton 1999). Consider a ‘universe’ comprised of a quantum system U, with finitely many degrees of freedom, represented by a Hilbert space Hu = ®i Hi. At any given time, U will occupy a pure vector state x E Hu that determines a reduced density operator Ds on the Hilbert space Hi of any subsystem S U. Let B(Hs) de­

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 23, 2009•0 citations

Algebraic approach to quantum theory: a finite-dimensional guide

Cédric Bény, Richter, Florian

This document is meant as a pedagogical introduction to the modern language used to talk about quantum theory, especially in the field of quantum information. It assumes that the reader has taken a first traditional course on quantum mechanics, and is familiar with the concept of Hilbert space and elementary linear algebra. As in the popular textbook on quantum information by Nielsen and Chuang, we introduce the generalised concept of states (density matrices), observables (POVMs) and transformations (channels), but we also characterise these structures from an algebraic standpoint, which provides many useful technical tools, and clarity as to their generality. This approach also makes it manifest that quantum theory is a direct generalisation of probability theory, and provides a unifying formalism for both fields. The focus on finite-dimensional systems allows for a self-contained presentation which avoids many of the technicalities inherent to the more general $C^*$-algebraic approach, while being appropriate for the quantum information literature.

arXiv:1505.03106•May 12, 2015•24 citations

Path integrals and the discrete Weyl representation

Wayne Nicholas Polyzou

This paper uses Schwinger's representation of quantum systems of a finite number of degrees of freedom to formulate discrete path integral representations of the dynamics. The representation starts with an observable with a finite number of distinct eigenvalues. Using that observable Schwinger constructs complementary pairs of finite dimensional unitary operators that are finite dimensional analogs of the irreducible Weyl algebra. These can be decomposed into products of irreducible sub-algebras that reduce to q-bit gates for the case of $2^N$ degrees of freedom. In the limit of a large number of discrete degrees of freedom these representations can be used to model quantum systems with continuous degrees of freedom. This limit recovers the continuum Weyl algebra. Path integrals can be formulated in the discrete case. They have the advantage that the number of paths for a finite number of time slices is finite. In this work the path integral is interpreted as the expectation value of a potential functional with respect to a complex probability distribution on the space of paths. An application to scattering from a short-range potential is given. Multi-resolution wavelet bases are used exactly represent a local $\phi^4(x)$ quantum field theory as a theory with an infinite number of discrete local modes. The discrete path integral is illustrated by computing time evolution when this theory is truncated to two coupled modes.

•Aug 27, 2021•0 citations

The Algebraic Approach to Quantum Field Theory

Simon W. Saunders

Abstract The fundamental entity in the algebraic approach to quantum theory is an abstract C*-algebra 𝒜 together with its set of states ℱ, that is, the set of all positive linear functionals on 𝒜. I shall call such a pair an (abstract) quantum system. The theory of C*-algebras and their representations provides the most powerful abstract approach to quantum theory; unlike the propositional lattice approach it also has direct applications in mainstream physics, and in a certain sense is even forced upon us in quantum field theory (OFT) (sec sections (2.11), (2.16)-(2.18)). Mathematically, the subject is a complex of analysis and algebra; it is a rather wild area involving high degrees of infinity. Philosophically it is most strongly associated with opera tionalism; in part this rellects the predilections of its originators, and in part the continuing philosophical appeal of positivism within the mathematics community. (I do not know why this is so.)

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jul 5, 1990•3 citations

Localization for Dirac fermions

Aleksander M. Kubicki, Westman, Hans, Juan León

This work is devoted to incorporating into QFT the notion that particles and hence the particle states should be localizable in space. It focuses on the case of the Dirac field in 1+1 dimensional flat spacetime, generalizing a recently developed formalism for scalar fields. This is achieved exploiting again the non-uniqueness of quantization process. Instead of elementary excitations carrying definite amounts of energy and momentum, we construct the elementary excitations of the field localized (at some instant) in a definite region of space. This construction not only leads to a natural notion of localized quanta, but also provides a local algebra of operators. Once constructed, the new representation is confronted to the standard global (Fock) construction. In spite of being unitarily inequivalent representations, the localized operators are well defined in the conventional Fock space. By using them we dig up the issues of localization in QFT showing how the globality of the vacuum state is responsible for the lack of a "common sense localization" notion for particles in the standard Fock representation of QFT and propose a method to meet its requirements.

arXiv:1606.03286•Jun 10, 2016•4 citations

Interpreting Quantum Field Theory

Laura Ruetsche

The availability of unitarily inequivalent representations of the canonical commutation relations constituting a quantization of a classical field theory raises questions about how to formulate and pursue quantum field theory. In a minimally technical way, I explain how these questions arise and how advocates of the Hilbert space and of the algebraic approaches to quantum theory might answer them. Where these answers differ, I sketch considerations for and against each approach, as well as considerations which might temper their apparent rivalry.

Philosophy of Science•Jun 1, 2002•72 citations
Instead of formulating the states of a Quantum Field Theory (QFT) as density matrices over a single large Hilbert space, it has been proposed by Kijowski [Kijowski, 1977] to construct them as consistent families of partial density matrices, the latter being defined over small 'building block' Hilbert spaces. In this picture, each small Hilbert space can be physically interpreted as extracting from the full theory specific degrees of freedom. This allows to reduce the quantization of a classical field theory to the quantization of finite-dimensional sub-systems, thus sidestepping some of the common ambiguities (specifically, the issues revolving around the choice of a 'vacuum state'), while obtaining robust and well-controlled quantum states spaces. The present letter provides a self-contained introduction to this formalism, detailing its motivations as well as its relations to other approaches to QFT (such as conventional Fock-like Hilbert spaces, path-integral quantization, and the algebraic formulation). At the same time, it can serve as a reading guide to the series of more in-depth articles [arXiv:1411.3589, arXiv:1411.3590, arXiv:1411.3591, arXiv:1510.01926].
Abstract The modal interpretation is actually a family of interpretations sharing the feature that a system’s density operator constrains the possibilities for assigning definite values to its observables (Healey 1989, Dieks & Vermaas 1998). We start with a brief review of the basic idea behind these interpretations from an algebraic point of view (Zimba & Clifton 1998, Halvorson & Clifton 1999). Consider a ‘universe’ comprised of a quantum system U, with finitely many degrees of freedom, represented by a Hilbert space Hu = ®i Hi. At any given time, U will occupy a pure vector state x E Hu that determines a reduced density operator Ds on the Hilbert space Hi of any subsystem S U. Let B(Hs) de­
This document is meant as a pedagogical introduction to the modern language used to talk about quantum theory, especially in the field of quantum information. It assumes that the reader has taken a first traditional course on quantum mechanics, and is familiar with the concept of Hilbert space and elementary linear algebra. As in the popular textbook on quantum information by Nielsen and Chuang, we introduce the generalised concept of states (density matrices), observables (POVMs) and transformations (channels), but we also characterise these structures from an algebraic standpoint, which provides many useful technical tools, and clarity as to their generality. This approach also makes it manifest that quantum theory is a direct generalisation of probability theory, and provides a unifying formalism for both fields. The focus on finite-dimensional systems allows for a self-contained presentation which avoids many of the technicalities inherent to the more general C∗C^*C∗-algebraic approach, while being appropriate for the quantum information literature.
This paper uses Schwinger's representation of quantum systems of a finite number of degrees of freedom to formulate discrete path integral representations of the dynamics. The representation starts with an observable with a finite number of distinct eigenvalues. Using that observable Schwinger constructs complementary pairs of finite dimensional unitary operators that are finite dimensional analogs of the irreducible Weyl algebra. These can be decomposed into products of irreducible sub-algebras that reduce to q-bit gates for the case of 2N2^N2N degrees of freedom. In the limit of a large number of discrete degrees of freedom these representations can be used to model quantum systems with continuous degrees of freedom. This limit recovers the continuum Weyl algebra. Path integrals can be formulated in the discrete case. They have the advantage that the number of paths for a finite number of time slices is finite. In this work the path integral is interpreted as the expectation value of a potential functional with respect to a complex probability distribution on the space of paths. An application to scattering from a short-range potential is given. Multi-resolution wavelet bases are used exactly represent a local ϕ4(x)\phi^4(x)ϕ4(x) quantum field theory as a theory with an infinite number of discrete local modes. The discrete path integral is illustrated by computing time evolution when this theory is truncated to two coupled modes.
Abstract The fundamental entity in the algebraic approach to quantum theory is an abstract C*-algebra 𝒜 together with its set of states ℱ, that is, the set of all positive linear functionals on 𝒜. I shall call such a pair an (abstract) quantum system. The theory of C*-algebras and their representations provides the most powerful abstract approach to quantum theory; unlike the propositional lattice approach it also has direct applications in mainstream physics, and in a certain sense is even forced upon us in quantum field theory (OFT) (sec sections (2.11), (2.16)-(2.18)). Mathematically, the subject is a complex of analysis and algebra; it is a rather wild area involving high degrees of infinity. Philosophically it is most strongly associated with opera tionalism; in part this rellects the predilections of its originators, and in part the continuing philosophical appeal of positivism within the mathematics community. (I do not know why this is so.)
This work is devoted to incorporating into QFT the notion that particles and hence the particle states should be localizable in space. It focuses on the case of the Dirac field in 1+1 dimensional flat spacetime, generalizing a recently developed formalism for scalar fields. This is achieved exploiting again the non-uniqueness of quantization process. Instead of elementary excitations carrying definite amounts of energy and momentum, we construct the elementary excitations of the field localized (at some instant) in a definite region of space. This construction not only leads to a natural notion of localized quanta, but also provides a local algebra of operators. Once constructed, the new representation is confronted to the standard global (Fock) construction. In spite of being unitarily inequivalent representations, the localized operators are well defined in the conventional Fock space. By using them we dig up the issues of localization in QFT showing how the globality of the vacuum state is responsible for the lack of a "common sense localization" notion for particles in the standard Fock representation of QFT and propose a method to meet its requirements.
The availability of unitarily inequivalent representations of the canonical commutation relations constituting a quantization of a classical field theory raises questions about how to formulate and pursue quantum field theory. In a minimally technical way, I explain how these questions arise and how advocates of the Hilbert space and of the algebraic approaches to quantum theory might answer them. Where these answers differ, I sketch considerations for and against each approach, as well as considerations which might temper their apparent rivalry.