Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1603.00535 · Physical Review A

Maxwell boundary conditions imply non-Lindblad master equation

Motoaki Bamba, Nobuyuki Imoto

Published Sep 1, 2016• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

From the Hamiltonian connecting the inside and outside of a Fabry-P\'erot cavity, which is derived from the Maxwell boundary conditions at a mirror of the cavity, a master equation of a non-Lindblad form is derived when the cavity embeds matters, although we can transform it to the Lindblad form by performing the rotating-wave approximation to the connecting Hamiltonian. We calculate absorption spectra by these Lindblad and non-Lindblad master equations and also by the Maxwell boundary conditions in the framework of the classical electrodynamics, which we consider the most reliable approach. We found that, compared to the Lindblad master equation, the absorption spectra by the non-Lindblad one agree better with those by the Maxwell boundary conditions. Although the discrepancy is highlighted only in the ultrastrong light-matter interaction regime with a relatively large broadening, the master equation of the non-Lindblad form is preferable rather than of the Lindblad one for pursuing the consistency with the classical electrodynamics.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.94.033802

Related papers

Reply to “Comment on ‘System-environment coupling derived by Maxwell's boundary conditions from the weak to the ultrastrong light-matter-coupling regime’ ”

Motoaki Bamba, Tetsuo Ogawa

As mentioned by De Liberato [Phys. Rev. A 89, 017801 (2014)], when we suppose the metallic thin mirror and perform the renormalization to the approach starting from the frequently used system-environment-coupling Hamiltonian, we can certainly resolve the discrepancy of its result from that obtained by the reliable approach in the main discussion of our paper [Phys. Rev. A 88, 013814 (2013)]. Although the suggested approach is currently applicable to the specific situation after checking its validity by our reliable but cumbersome approach, we instead propose to start from the system-environment-coupling Hamiltonian determined properly by the mechanism of the confinement and loss of the cavity fields. This approach is applicable to any cavity structure, in principle, and we do not face the renormalization problem appearing in the Comment.

arXiv:1311.1564•Physical Review A•Jan 6, 2014•4 citations

Comment on “System-environment coupling derived by Maxwell's boundary conditions from the weak to the ultrastrong light-matter-coupling regime”

Simone De Liberato

In a recent paper, Bamba and Ogawa [Phys. Rev. A 88, 013814 (2013)] developed a microscopic model describing a photonic cavity coupled to an excitonlike resonance. One of the results they obtained studying such a model is that, in the ultrastrong coupling regime, dissipation rates calculated applying the rotating-wave approximation on the system-environment coupling qualitatively differ from the ones calculated using a microscopic theory based on the quantum electrodynamics for dielectric media. Here I show that this result is an artifact, caused by an inconsistent application of the rotating-wave approximation and by an unphysical parameter choice.

arXiv:1307.5615•Physical Review A•Jan 6, 2014•19 citations

Markovian and non-Markovian master equations versus an exactly solvable model of a qubit in a cavity

Zihan Xia, Juan Garcia-Nila, Daniel A. Lidar

Quantum master equations are commonly used to model the dynamics of open quantum systems, but their accuracy is rarely compared with the analytical solution of exactly solvable models. In this work, we perform such a comparison for the damped Jaynes-Cummings model of a qubit in a leaky cavity, for which an analytical solution is available in the one-excitation subspace. We consider the non-Markovian time-convolutionless master equation up to the second (Redfield) and fourth orders as well as three types of Markovian master equations: the coarse-grained, cumulant, and standard rotating-wave approximation (RWA) Lindblad equations. We compare the exact solution to these master equations for three different spectral densities: impulse, Ohmic, and triangular. We demonstrate that the coarse-grained master equation outperforms the standard RWA-based Lindblad master equation for weak coupling or high qubit frequency (relative to the spectral density high-frequency cutoff ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{c}$), where the Markovian approximation is valid. In the presence of non-Markovian effects characterized by oscillatory, nondecaying behavior, the time-convolutionless approximation closely matches the exact solution for short evolution times (in units of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{c}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$) even outside the regime of validity of the Markovian approximations. For long evolution times, all master equations perform poorly, as quantified in terms of the trace-norm distance from the exact solution. The fourth-order time-convolutionless master equation achieves the top performance in all cases. Our results highlight the need for reliable approximation methods to describe open-system quantum dynamics beyond the short-time limit.

arXiv:2403.09944•Physical Review Applied•Jul 11, 2024•15 citations

Breakdown signatures of the phenomenological Lindblad master equation in the strong optomechanical coupling regime

Ralf Betzholz, Bruno G Taketani, Juan Mauricio Torres

Abstract The Lindblad form of the master equation has proven to be one of the most convenient ways to describe the impact of an environment interacting with a quantum system of interest. For single systems the jump operators characterizing these interactions usually take simple forms with a clear interpretation. However, for coupled systems these operators take significantly different forms and the full dynamics cannot be described by jump operators acting on the individual subsystems only. In this work, we investigate the differences between a common phenomenological model for the master equation and the more rigorous dressed-state master equation for optomechanical systems. We provide an analytical method to obtain the absorption spectrum of the system for both models and show the breakdown of the phenomenological model in both the bad cavity and the ultra-strong coupling limit. We present a careful discussion of the indirect dephasing of the optical cavity in both models and its role in the differences of their predicted absorption spectra. Our work provides a simple experimental test to determine whether the simpler phenomenological model can be used to describe the system and is a step forward toward a better understanding of the role of the coupling between subsystems for open-quantum-system dynamics.

arXiv:2007.03108•Quantum Science and Technology•Oct 21, 2020•10 citations

System-environment coupling derived by Maxwell's boundary conditions from the weak to the ultrastrong light-matter-coupling regime

Motoaki Bamba, Tetsuo Ogawa

In the standard theory of cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED), coupling between photons inside and outside a cavity (cavity system and environment) is given conserving the total number of photons. However, when the cavity photons (ultrastrongly) interact with atoms or excitations in matters, the system-environment coupling must be determined from a more fundamental viewpoint. Based on the Maxwell's boundary conditions in the QED theory for dielectric media, we derive the quantum Langevin equation and input-output relation, in which the total number of polaritons (not photons) inside the cavity and photons outside is conserved.

arXiv:1301.3960•Physical Review A•Jul 9, 2013•26 citations

Theoretical Methods for Ultrastrong Light–Matter Interactions

Alexandre Le Boité

Abstract This article reviews theoretical methods developed in the last decade to understand cavity quantum electrodynamics in the ultrastrong‐coupling regime, where the strength of the light–matter interaction becomes comparable to the photon frequency. Along with profound modifications of fundamental quantum optical effects giving rise to a rich phenomenology, this regime introduces significant theoretical challenges. One of the most important is the break‐down of the rotating‐wave approximation which neglects all non‐resonant terms in light–matter interaction Hamiltonians. Consequently, a large part of the quantum optical theoretical framework has to be revisited in order to accurately account for all interaction terms in this regime. In this article, a broad overview of the recent progress is given, ranging from analytical estimates of ground‐state properties to proper derivations of master equations and computation of photodetection signals. For each aspect of the theory, the basic principles of the methods are illustrated on paradigmatic models such as quantum Rabi and spin‐boson models. The validity of effective Hamiltonians for the different experimental platforms is discussed in the last part of the article, addressing recent debates on fundamental issues related to gauge invariance in the ultrastrong‐coupling regime.

arXiv:2001.08715•Advanced Quantum Technologies•Jun 2, 2020•128 citations
From the Hamiltonian connecting the inside and outside of a Fabry-P'erot cavity, which is derived from the Maxwell boundary conditions at a mirror of the cavity, a master equation of a non-Lindblad form is derived when the cavity embeds matters, although we can transform it to the Lindblad form by performing the rotating-wave approximation to the connecting Hamiltonian. We calculate absorption spectra by these Lindblad and non-Lindblad master equations and also by the Maxwell boundary conditions in the framework of the classical electrodynamics, which we consider the most reliable approach. We found that, compared to the Lindblad master equation, the absorption spectra by the non-Lindblad one agree better with those by the Maxwell boundary conditions. Although the discrepancy is highlighted only in the ultrastrong light-matter interaction regime with a relatively large broadening, the master equation of the non-Lindblad form is preferable rather than of the Lindblad one for pursuing the consistency with the classical electrodynamics.
As mentioned by De Liberato [Phys. Rev. A 89, 017801 (2014)], when we suppose the metallic thin mirror and perform the renormalization to the approach starting from the frequently used system-environment-coupling Hamiltonian, we can certainly resolve the discrepancy of its result from that obtained by the reliable approach in the main discussion of our paper [Phys. Rev. A 88, 013814 (2013)]. Although the suggested approach is currently applicable to the specific situation after checking its validity by our reliable but cumbersome approach, we instead propose to start from the system-environment-coupling Hamiltonian determined properly by the mechanism of the confinement and loss of the cavity fields. This approach is applicable to any cavity structure, in principle, and we do not face the renormalization problem appearing in the Comment.
In a recent paper, Bamba and Ogawa [Phys. Rev. A 88, 013814 (2013)] developed a microscopic model describing a photonic cavity coupled to an excitonlike resonance. One of the results they obtained studying such a model is that, in the ultrastrong coupling regime, dissipation rates calculated applying the rotating-wave approximation on the system-environment coupling qualitatively differ from the ones calculated using a microscopic theory based on the quantum electrodynamics for dielectric media. Here I show that this result is an artifact, caused by an inconsistent application of the rotating-wave approximation and by an unphysical parameter choice.
Quantum master equations are commonly used to model the dynamics of open quantum systems, but their accuracy is rarely compared with the analytical solution of exactly solvable models. In this work, we perform such a comparison for the damped Jaynes-Cummings model of a qubit in a leaky cavity, for which an analytical solution is available in the one-excitation subspace. We consider the non-Markovian time-convolutionless master equation up to the second (Redfield) and fourth orders as well as three types of Markovian master equations: the coarse-grained, cumulant, and standard rotating-wave approximation (RWA) Lindblad equations. We compare the exact solution to these master equations for three different spectral densities: impulse, Ohmic, and triangular. We demonstrate that the coarse-grained master equation outperforms the standard RWA-based Lindblad master equation for weak coupling or high qubit frequency (relative to the spectral density high-frequency cutoff ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{c}$), where the Markovian approximation is valid. In the presence of non-Markovian effects characterized by oscillatory, nondecaying behavior, the time-convolutionless approximation closely matches the exact solution for short evolution times (in units of ${\ensuremath{\omega}}_{c}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$) even outside the regime of validity of the Markovian approximations. For long evolution times, all master equations perform poorly, as quantified in terms of the trace-norm distance from the exact solution. The fourth-order time-convolutionless master equation achieves the top performance in all cases. Our results highlight the need for reliable approximation methods to describe open-system quantum dynamics beyond the short-time limit.
Abstract The Lindblad form of the master equation has proven to be one of the most convenient ways to describe the impact of an environment interacting with a quantum system of interest. For single systems the jump operators characterizing these interactions usually take simple forms with a clear interpretation. However, for coupled systems these operators take significantly different forms and the full dynamics cannot be described by jump operators acting on the individual subsystems only. In this work, we investigate the differences between a common phenomenological model for the master equation and the more rigorous dressed-state master equation for optomechanical systems. We provide an analytical method to obtain the absorption spectrum of the system for both models and show the breakdown of the phenomenological model in both the bad cavity and the ultra-strong coupling limit. We present a careful discussion of the indirect dephasing of the optical cavity in both models and its role in the differences of their predicted absorption spectra. Our work provides a simple experimental test to determine whether the simpler phenomenological model can be used to describe the system and is a step forward toward a better understanding of the role of the coupling between subsystems for open-quantum-system dynamics.
In the standard theory of cavity quantum electrodynamics (QED), coupling between photons inside and outside a cavity (cavity system and environment) is given conserving the total number of photons. However, when the cavity photons (ultrastrongly) interact with atoms or excitations in matters, the system-environment coupling must be determined from a more fundamental viewpoint. Based on the Maxwell's boundary conditions in the QED theory for dielectric media, we derive the quantum Langevin equation and input-output relation, in which the total number of polaritons (not photons) inside the cavity and photons outside is conserved.
Abstract This article reviews theoretical methods developed in the last decade to understand cavity quantum electrodynamics in the ultrastrong‐coupling regime, where the strength of the light–matter interaction becomes comparable to the photon frequency. Along with profound modifications of fundamental quantum optical effects giving rise to a rich phenomenology, this regime introduces significant theoretical challenges. One of the most important is the break‐down of the rotating‐wave approximation which neglects all non‐resonant terms in light–matter interaction Hamiltonians. Consequently, a large part of the quantum optical theoretical framework has to be revisited in order to accurately account for all interaction terms in this regime. In this article, a broad overview of the recent progress is given, ranging from analytical estimates of ground‐state properties to proper derivations of master equations and computation of photodetection signals. For each aspect of the theory, the basic principles of the methods are illustrated on paradigmatic models such as quantum Rabi and spin‐boson models. The validity of effective Hamiltonians for the different experimental platforms is discussed in the last part of the article, addressing recent debates on fundamental issues related to gauge invariance in the ultrastrong‐coupling regime.