Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1601.06101 · Nature Communications

Memory effects can make the transmission capability of a communication channel uncomputable

David Elkouss, David Pérez-García

Published Mar 14, 2018• 27 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Most communication channels are subjected to noise. One of the goals of information theory is to add redundancy in the transmission of information so that the information is transmitted reliably and the amount of information transmitted through the channel is as large as possible. The maximum rate at which reliable transmission is possible is called the capacity. If the channel does not keep memory of its past, the capacity is given by a simple optimization problem and can be efficiently computed. The situation of channels with memory is less clear. Here we show that for channels with memory the capacity cannot be computed to within precision 1/5. Our result holds even if we consider one of the simplest families of such channels-information-stable finite state machine channels-restrict the input and output of the channel to 4 and 1 bit respectively and allow 6 bits of memory.

DOI
10.1038/s41467-018-03428-0

Related papers

Quantum capacity of Pauli channels with memory

Peng Fei Huang, Guangqiang He, Yuan Lu +1 more

The amount of coherent quantum information that can be reliably transmitted down the memory Pauli channels with Markovian correlated noise is investigated. Two methods for evaluating the quantum capacity of the memory Pauli channels are proposed to try to trace the memory effect on the transmissions of quantum information. We show that the evaluation of quantum capacity can be reduced to the calculation of the initial memory state of each successive transmission. Furthermore, we derive quantum capacities of the memory phase flip channel, bit flip channel and bit-phase flip channel. Also, a lower bound of the quantum capacity of the memory depolarizing channel is obtained. An increase of the degree of memory of the channels has a positive effect on the increase of their quantum capacities.

Physica Scripta•Dec 8, 2010•7 citations

Bounds on classical information capacities for a class of quantum memory channels

Garry Bowen, Igor Devetak, Stefano Mancini

The maximum rates for information transmission through noisy quantum channels has primarily been developed for memoryless channels, where the noise on each transmitted state is treated as independent. Many real-world communication channels experience noise which is modeled better by errors that are correlated between separate channel uses. In this Brief Report, upper bounds on the classical information capacities of a class of quantum memory channels are derived. The class of channels consists of indecomposable quantum memory channels, a generalization of classical indecomposable finite-state channels.

arXiv:quant-ph/0312216•Physical Review A•Mar 24, 2005•47 citations

Information Storage and Transmission under Markovian Noise

Satvik Singh, Nilanjana Datta

We study the information transmission capacities of quantum Markov semigroups acting on finite-dimensional quantum systems. We show that, in the limit of infinite time, the capacities can be efficiently computed in terms of the structure of the peripheral space of the semigroup, are strongly additive, and satisfy the strong converse property. We also establish convergence bounds to show that the infinite-time capacities are reached after time scaling quadratically with the system dimension. From a data storage perspective, our analysis provides tight bounds on the number of bits or qubits that can be reliably stored for long times in a quantum memory experiencing Markovian noise. From a practical standpoint, we show that typically, a quantum memory with Markovian noise acting independently and identically on all qubits and a fixed time-independent global error correction mechanism becomes useless for storage after time scaling exponentially with the number of qubits. In contrast, if the error correction is local, the memory becomes useless much more quickly, i.e., after time scaling logarithmically with the number of qubits. In the setting of point-to-point communication between two spatially separated parties, our analysis provides efficiently computable bounds on the optimal rate at which bits or qubits can be reliably transmitted via long Markovian communication channels, both in the finite block-length and asymptotic regimes.

arXiv:2409.17743•PRX Quantum•Feb 18, 2026•10 citations

The strong converse theorem for the product-state capacity of quantum channels with ergodic Markovian memory

T. C. Dorlas, Ciara Morgan

Establishing the strong converse theorem for a communication channel confirms that the capacity of that channel, that is, the maximum achievable rate of reliable information communication, is the ultimate limit of communication over that channel. Indeed, the strong converse theorem for a channel states that coding at a rate above the capacity of the channel results in the convergence of the error to its maximum value 1 and that there is no trade-off between communication rate and decoding error. Here we prove that the strong converse theorem holds for the product-state capacity of quantum channels with ergodic Markovian correlated memory.

arXiv:1602.08362•Feb 26, 2016•0 citations

Better transmission with lower capacity: lossy compression over quantum channels

Sristy Agrawal, Rajashik Tarafder, Graeme Smith +2 more

Shannon's channel coding theorem describes the maximum possible rate of reliable information transfer through a classical noisy communication channel. It, together with the source coding theorem, characterizes lossless channel communication in the classical regime. Lossy compression scenarios require the additional description provided by rate-distortion theory, which characterizes the trade-off between compression rate and the distortion of the compressed signal. Even in this context, the capacity characterizes the usefulness of a channel -- a channel with more capacity will always outperform a channel with less capacity. We show that this is no longer true when sending classical information over a quantum channel. In particular, we find a pair of quantum channels where the channel with the lower capacity causes less distortion than the higher capacity channel when both are used at a fixed rate.

arXiv:2105.06617•May 14, 2021•1 citation

No information transmission through quantum channels above capacity

Hao-Chung Cheng, Marco Tomamichel

We show that the capacity of a quantum channel demarcates a phase transition: while reliable transmission below capacity is always possible, any attempt to transmit information above it fails catastrophically. Specifically, we prove exponential strong converse theorems for unassisted quantum and classical communication over arbitrary finite-dimensional memoryless quantum channels. At rates beyond the respective capacity, the entanglement-generation fidelity and the success probability for classical communication decay exponentially with the number of channel uses. This rules out transmission above capacity even when one tolerates arbitrarily large errors. Our proof follows the classical Arimoto strategy, augmented by a crucial new ingredient: integral representations of Rényi information measures that lead to asymptotic continuity bounds for Rényi capacities.

quant-pharXiv:2609.08998•Sep 9, 2026•6 citations
Most communication channels are subjected to noise. One of the goals of information theory is to add redundancy in the transmission of information so that the information is transmitted reliably and the amount of information transmitted through the channel is as large as possible. The maximum rate at which reliable transmission is possible is called the capacity. If the channel does not keep memory of its past, the capacity is given by a simple optimization problem and can be efficiently computed. The situation of channels with memory is less clear. Here we show that for channels with memory the capacity cannot be computed to within precision 1/5. Our result holds even if we consider one of the simplest families of such channels-information-stable finite state machine channels-restrict the input and output of the channel to 4 and 1 bit respectively and allow 6 bits of memory.
The amount of coherent quantum information that can be reliably transmitted down the memory Pauli channels with Markovian correlated noise is investigated. Two methods for evaluating the quantum capacity of the memory Pauli channels are proposed to try to trace the memory effect on the transmissions of quantum information. We show that the evaluation of quantum capacity can be reduced to the calculation of the initial memory state of each successive transmission. Furthermore, we derive quantum capacities of the memory phase flip channel, bit flip channel and bit-phase flip channel. Also, a lower bound of the quantum capacity of the memory depolarizing channel is obtained. An increase of the degree of memory of the channels has a positive effect on the increase of their quantum capacities.
The maximum rates for information transmission through noisy quantum channels has primarily been developed for memoryless channels, where the noise on each transmitted state is treated as independent. Many real-world communication channels experience noise which is modeled better by errors that are correlated between separate channel uses. In this Brief Report, upper bounds on the classical information capacities of a class of quantum memory channels are derived. The class of channels consists of indecomposable quantum memory channels, a generalization of classical indecomposable finite-state channels.
We study the information transmission capacities of quantum Markov semigroups acting on finite-dimensional quantum systems. We show that, in the limit of infinite time, the capacities can be efficiently computed in terms of the structure of the peripheral space of the semigroup, are strongly additive, and satisfy the strong converse property. We also establish convergence bounds to show that the infinite-time capacities are reached after time scaling quadratically with the system dimension. From a data storage perspective, our analysis provides tight bounds on the number of bits or qubits that can be reliably stored for long times in a quantum memory experiencing Markovian noise. From a practical standpoint, we show that typically, a quantum memory with Markovian noise acting independently and identically on all qubits and a fixed time-independent global error correction mechanism becomes useless for storage after time scaling exponentially with the number of qubits. In contrast, if the error correction is local, the memory becomes useless much more quickly, i.e., after time scaling logarithmically with the number of qubits. In the setting of point-to-point communication between two spatially separated parties, our analysis provides efficiently computable bounds on the optimal rate at which bits or qubits can be reliably transmitted via long Markovian communication channels, both in the finite block-length and asymptotic regimes.
Establishing the strong converse theorem for a communication channel confirms that the capacity of that channel, that is, the maximum achievable rate of reliable information communication, is the ultimate limit of communication over that channel. Indeed, the strong converse theorem for a channel states that coding at a rate above the capacity of the channel results in the convergence of the error to its maximum value 1 and that there is no trade-off between communication rate and decoding error. Here we prove that the strong converse theorem holds for the product-state capacity of quantum channels with ergodic Markovian correlated memory.
Shannon's channel coding theorem describes the maximum possible rate of reliable information transfer through a classical noisy communication channel. It, together with the source coding theorem, characterizes lossless channel communication in the classical regime. Lossy compression scenarios require the additional description provided by rate-distortion theory, which characterizes the trade-off between compression rate and the distortion of the compressed signal. Even in this context, the capacity characterizes the usefulness of a channel -- a channel with more capacity will always outperform a channel with less capacity. We show that this is no longer true when sending classical information over a quantum channel. In particular, we find a pair of quantum channels where the channel with the lower capacity causes less distortion than the higher capacity channel when both are used at a fixed rate.
We show that the capacity of a quantum channel demarcates a phase transition: while reliable transmission below capacity is always possible, any attempt to transmit information above it fails catastrophically. Specifically, we prove exponential strong converse theorems for unassisted quantum and classical communication over arbitrary finite-dimensional memoryless quantum channels. At rates beyond the respective capacity, the entanglement-generation fidelity and the success probability for classical communication decay exponentially with the number of channel uses. This rules out transmission above capacity even when one tolerates arbitrarily large errors. Our proof follows the classical Arimoto strategy, augmented by a crucial new ingredient: integral representations of Rényi information measures that lead to asymptotic continuity bounds for Rényi capacities.