Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1601.02364 · Molecular Physics

Role of the ward identity and relevance of the G0W0 approximation in normal and superconducting states

Yasutami Takada

Published Jan 8, 2016• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

On the basis of the self-consistent calculation scheme for the electron self-energy Σ with the use of the three-point vertex function Γ always satisfying the Ward identity, we find that the obtained quasi-particle dispersion in the normal state in gapped systems, such as semiconductors, insulators, and molecules, is well reproduced by that in the one-shot GW (or G0W0) approximation. In calculating the superconducting transition temperature Tc, we also find a similar situation; the result for Tc in the gauge-invariant self-consistent framework including the effect of Γ satisfying the Ward identity is different from that in the conventional Eliashberg theory (which amounts to the GW approximation for superconductivity) but is close to that in the G0W0 approximation. Those facts indicate that the G0W0 approximation actually takes proper account of both vertex and high-order self-energy corrections in a mutually cancelling manner and thus we can understand that the G0W0 approximation is better than the fully self-consistent GW one in obtaining some of physical quantities.

DOI
10.1080/00268976.2015.1131860

Related papers

Self-consistent density-functional approach to the correlated ground states and an unrestricted many-body perturbation theory

Behnam Farid

We introduce a scheme through which the ground-state electronic density n and total energy Ev [n] of inhomogeneous interacting systems can be determined in a self-consistent (SC) way. It is based on a SC perturbation expansion for the single-particle Green function G. Our employed expansion is argued to be valid under all conditions provided that the ground-state charge density of the interacting system is pure-state non-interacting v representable. The formalism discussed in this paper has been applied to a quasi-one-dimensional periodic system. It has even been possible to carry out SC calculations with the dynamically screened exchange diagram (the so-called GW diagram, where W is the dynamically screened electron-electron interaction function) for the self-energy operator Σ. A coherent mode of interpretation of a number of our results entails that the overwhelming success of the GW framework in relatively accurately reproducing the experimental energy gaps of a number of semiconductors and insulators may be a direct consequence of non-self-consistency effects; whereas a non-self-consistent calculation in our tests increases the value of the local-density approximation (LDA) gap in the range of 40–65% of the ‘experimental’ gaps, self-consistency effects reduce this range to 14–17%. The same line of argument leads us to conclude that, in our model, 26–35% of the LDA error in the gap energies is due to the absence of a well known discontinuity in the LDA exchange-correlation potential, and the remaining part is due to the Kohn-Sham eigenvalues not being identifiable with one-particle excitation energies. A natural conclusion that may be drawn from these observations is that a correct description of excitation energies (e.g. of the gap energy) cannot be achieved without including, at least approximately, the vertex part of Σ, which is entirely absent in the GW scheme.

Philosophical Magazine B•Aug 1, 1997•18 citations

Vertex function compliant with the Ward identity for quasiparticle self-consistent calculations beyond GW

Alexey A. Tal, Wei Chen, Alfredo Pasquarello

We extend the quasiparticle self-consistent approach beyond the $GW$ approximation by using a range-separated vertex function. The developed approach yields band gaps, dielectric constants, and band positions with an accuracy similar to highest-level electronic-structure calculations without exceeding the cost of regular quasiparticle self-consistent $GW$. We introduce an exchange-correlation kernel that accounts for the vertex over the full spatial range. In the long range it complies with the Ward identity, while it is approximated through the adiabatic local density functional in the short range. In this approach, the renormalization factor is balanced and the higher-order diagrams are effectively taken into account.

Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 8, 2021•34 citations

A unified description of ground and excited state properties of finite systems: the self-consistent GW approach

Fabio Caruso, Patrick Rinke, Xinguo Ren +2 more

Fully self-consistent GW (sc-GW) – based on the iterative solution of Dyson’s equation – incorporates many-body correlation effects in the electronic ground-state, providing a recipe to consistently describe ground- and excited-states on an equal footing. We have implemented sc-GW in the localized basis all-electron code FHIaims [1]. We show that, for finite systems, the ground-state properties as well as the excitation spectrum of the sc-GW Green’s function are unique and are not affected by different initialization of the sc-GW loop, curing the pathological dependence on the starting point of one-shot GW (G0W0). In addition, self-consistency systematically improves ionization energies and Galitskii-Migdal total energies of closed shell systems compared to G0W0 based on Hartree-Fock and density-functional theory in local and semilocal approximations. Since our implementation is based on interacting Green’s functions (unlike all G0W0 implementations) it is also a first step towards going beyond the GW approach.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Revival of Single-Particle Transport Theory for the Normal State of High-Tc Superconductors: II. Vertex Correction

Osamu Narikiyo

The vertex correction for the electric current is discussed on the basis of the Fermi-liquid theory. It does not alter the qualitative description of the electric transport by the relaxation-time approximation in the case of the normal state of high-Tc superconductors. The failure of the transport theory employing the fluctuation-exchange (FLEX) approximation is pointed out. It becomes manifest by considering the Ward identity for the fluctuation mode.

arXiv:1301.5996•Jan 25, 2013•2 citations

Superconductivity in high- Tc and related strongly correlated systems from variational perspective: Beyond mean field theory

Józef Spałek, Maciej Fidrysiak, M. Zegrodnik +1 more

The principal purpose of this topical review is to single out some of the universal features of high-temperature (high-Tc) and related strongly-correlated systems, which can be compared with experiment in a quantitative manner. The description starts with the concept of exchange-interaction-mediated (real-space) pairing, combined with strong correlations among narrow band electrons, for which the reference state is that of the Mott–Hubbard insulator. The physical discussion of concrete properties relies on variational approach, starting from generalized renormalized mean-field theory (RMFT) in the form of statistically-consistent Gutzwiller approximation (SGA), and its subsequent generalization, i.e., a systematic Diagrammatic Expansion of the Variational (Gutzwiller-type) Wave Function (DE-GWF). The solution leads to the two energy scales, one involving unconventional quasiparticles close to the Fermi energy, and the other reflecting the fully correlated state, involving electrons deeper below the Fermi surface. Those two regimes are separated by a kink in the dispersion relation, which is observed in photoemission. As a result, one obtains both the doping dependent properties in the correlated state, and effective renormalized quasiparticles. The reviewed ground-state characteristics for high-Tc systems encompass high-Tc superconductivity, nematicity, charge- (and pair-) density-wave effects, as well as non-BCS kinetic energy gain in the paired state. The calculated dynamic properties are: the universal Fermi velocity, the Fermi wave-vector, the effective mass enhancement, the pseudogap; and the d-wave gap magnitude. We discuss that, within the variational approach, the minimal realistic model is represented by the so-called t-J-U Hamiltonian. Inadequacy of the t-J and Hubbard models, particularly of their RMFT versions, is discussed explicitly. For heavy fermion systems, modeled by the Anderson lattice model and with the DE-GWF approach, we discuss the phase diagram, encompassing superconducting, Kondo insulating, ferro- and anti-ferromagnetic states. The superconducting state is then a two-d-wave gap system. If the orbital degeneracy of f-electrons is included, the coexistent ferromagnetic- (spin–triplet) superconducting phases appear and match those observed for UGe2 in a semiquantitative manner. Finally, in the second part, we generalize our approach to the collective spin and charge fluctuations in high-Tc systems, starting from variational approach, defining the saddle-point state, and combining it with 1/N expansion. The present scheme differs essentially from that starting from the saddle-point Hartree–Fock approximation, and incorporating the fluctuations in the random phase approximation (RPA). The spectrum of collective spin and charge excitations is determined for the Hubbard and t-J-U models, and subsequently compared quantitatively with recent experiments. The Appendices provide formal details to make this review self-contained.

arXiv:2202.05113•Physics Reports•Mar 17, 2022•49 citations

Self-consistentGWfor a quasi-one-dimensional semiconductor

H. J. de Groot, P. A. Bobbert, W. van Haeringen

We present self-consistent GW calculations for a quasi-one-dimensional model semiconductor, using multipole representations for W, the screened interaction, and G, the electron Green function. In the case of G, we distinguish between the quasiparticle contribution and the so-called incoherent contribution. We consider various strengths of the external potential. For two different starting points of the self-consistency cycle, local-density approximation and Hartree-Fock, the band gaps converge to the same values. The self-consistent GW band gaps differ very little from the Hartree-Fock band gaps. There is considerable disagreement with quantum Monte Carlo calculations for the same model, indicating the importance of vertex corrections.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 15, 1995•36 citations
On the basis of the self-consistent calculation scheme for the electron self-energy Σ with the use of the three-point vertex function Γ always satisfying the Ward identity, we find that the obtained quasi-particle dispersion in the normal state in gapped systems, such as semiconductors, insulators, and molecules, is well reproduced by that in the one-shot GW (or G0W0) approximation. In calculating the superconducting transition temperature Tc, we also find a similar situation; the result for Tc in the gauge-invariant self-consistent framework including the effect of Γ satisfying the Ward identity is different from that in the conventional Eliashberg theory (which amounts to the GW approximation for superconductivity) but is close to that in the G0W0 approximation. Those facts indicate that the G0W0 approximation actually takes proper account of both vertex and high-order self-energy corrections in a mutually cancelling manner and thus we can understand that the G0W0 approximation is better than the fully self-consistent GW one in obtaining some of physical quantities.
We introduce a scheme through which the ground-state electronic density n and total energy Ev [n] of inhomogeneous interacting systems can be determined in a self-consistent (SC) way. It is based on a SC perturbation expansion for the single-particle Green function G. Our employed expansion is argued to be valid under all conditions provided that the ground-state charge density of the interacting system is pure-state non-interacting v representable. The formalism discussed in this paper has been applied to a quasi-one-dimensional periodic system. It has even been possible to carry out SC calculations with the dynamically screened exchange diagram (the so-called GW diagram, where W is the dynamically screened electron-electron interaction function) for the self-energy operator Σ. A coherent mode of interpretation of a number of our results entails that the overwhelming success of the GW framework in relatively accurately reproducing the experimental energy gaps of a number of semiconductors and insulators may be a direct consequence of non-self-consistency effects; whereas a non-self-consistent calculation in our tests increases the value of the local-density approximation (LDA) gap in the range of 40–65% of the ‘experimental’ gaps, self-consistency effects reduce this range to 14–17%. The same line of argument leads us to conclude that, in our model, 26–35% of the LDA error in the gap energies is due to the absence of a well known discontinuity in the LDA exchange-correlation potential, and the remaining part is due to the Kohn-Sham eigenvalues not being identifiable with one-particle excitation energies. A natural conclusion that may be drawn from these observations is that a correct description of excitation energies (e.g. of the gap energy) cannot be achieved without including, at least approximately, the vertex part of Σ, which is entirely absent in the GW scheme.
We extend the quasiparticle self-consistent approach beyond the GWGWGW approximation by using a range-separated vertex function. The developed approach yields band gaps, dielectric constants, and band positions with an accuracy similar to highest-level electronic-structure calculations without exceeding the cost of regular quasiparticle self-consistent GWGWGW. We introduce an exchange-correlation kernel that accounts for the vertex over the full spatial range. In the long range it complies with the Ward identity, while it is approximated through the adiabatic local density functional in the short range. In this approach, the renormalization factor is balanced and the higher-order diagrams are effectively taken into account.
Fully self-consistent GW (sc-GW) – based on the iterative solution of Dyson’s equation – incorporates many-body correlation effects in the electronic ground-state, providing a recipe to consistently describe ground- and excited-states on an equal footing. We have implemented sc-GW in the localized basis all-electron code FHIaims [1]. We show that, for finite systems, the ground-state properties as well as the excitation spectrum of the sc-GW Green’s function are unique and are not affected by different initialization of the sc-GW loop, curing the pathological dependence on the starting point of one-shot GW (G0W0). In addition, self-consistency systematically improves ionization energies and Galitskii-Migdal total energies of closed shell systems compared to G0W0 based on Hartree-Fock and density-functional theory in local and semilocal approximations. Since our implementation is based on interacting Green’s functions (unlike all G0W0 implementations) it is also a first step towards going beyond the GW approach.
The principal purpose of this topical review is to single out some of the universal features of high-temperature (high-Tc) and related strongly-correlated systems, which can be compared with experiment in a quantitative manner. The description starts with the concept of exchange-interaction-mediated (real-space) pairing, combined with strong correlations among narrow band electrons, for which the reference state is that of the Mott–Hubbard insulator. The physical discussion of concrete properties relies on variational approach, starting from generalized renormalized mean-field theory (RMFT) in the form of statistically-consistent Gutzwiller approximation (SGA), and its subsequent generalization, i.e., a systematic Diagrammatic Expansion of the Variational (Gutzwiller-type) Wave Function (DE-GWF). The solution leads to the two energy scales, one involving unconventional quasiparticles close to the Fermi energy, and the other reflecting the fully correlated state, involving electrons deeper below the Fermi surface. Those two regimes are separated by a kink in the dispersion relation, which is observed in photoemission. As a result, one obtains both the doping dependent properties in the correlated state, and effective renormalized quasiparticles. The reviewed ground-state characteristics for high-Tc systems encompass high-Tc superconductivity, nematicity, charge- (and pair-) density-wave effects, as well as non-BCS kinetic energy gain in the paired state. The calculated dynamic properties are: the universal Fermi velocity, the Fermi wave-vector, the effective mass enhancement, the pseudogap; and the d-wave gap magnitude. We discuss that, within the variational approach, the minimal realistic model is represented by the so-called t-J-U Hamiltonian. Inadequacy of the t-J and Hubbard models, particularly of their RMFT versions, is discussed explicitly. For heavy fermion systems, modeled by the Anderson lattice model and with the DE-GWF approach, we discuss the phase diagram, encompassing superconducting, Kondo insulating, ferro- and anti-ferromagnetic states. The superconducting state is then a two-d-wave gap system. If the orbital degeneracy of f-electrons is included, the coexistent ferromagnetic- (spin–triplet) superconducting phases appear and match those observed for UGe2 in a semiquantitative manner. Finally, in the second part, we generalize our approach to the collective spin and charge fluctuations in high-Tc systems, starting from variational approach, defining the saddle-point state, and combining it with 1/N expansion. The present scheme differs essentially from that starting from the saddle-point Hartree–Fock approximation, and incorporating the fluctuations in the random phase approximation (RPA). The spectrum of collective spin and charge excitations is determined for the Hubbard and t-J-U models, and subsequently compared quantitatively with recent experiments. The Appendices provide formal details to make this review self-contained.
We present self-consistent GW calculations for a quasi-one-dimensional model semiconductor, using multipole representations for W, the screened interaction, and G, the electron Green function. In the case of G, we distinguish between the quasiparticle contribution and the so-called incoherent contribution. We consider various strengths of the external potential. For two different starting points of the self-consistency cycle, local-density approximation and Hartree-Fock, the band gaps converge to the same values. The self-consistent GW band gaps differ very little from the Hartree-Fock band gaps. There is considerable disagreement with quantum Monte Carlo calculations for the same model, indicating the importance of vertex corrections.