Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1512.02516 · Physical review. E

Aspects of quantum work

Peter Talkner A, Peter Hänggi A

Published Feb 23, 2016• 191 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Various approaches of defining and determining work performed on a quantum system are compared. Any operational definition of work, however, must allow for two facts: first, that work characterizes a process rather than an instantaneous state of a system and, second, that quantum systems are sensitive to the interactions with a measurement apparatus. We compare different measurement scenarios on the basis of the resulting postmeasurement states and the according probabilities for finding a particular work value. In particular, we analyze a recently proposed work meter for the case of a Gaussian pointer state and compare it with the results obtained by two projective and, alternatively, two Gaussian measurements. In the limit of a strong effective measurement strength the work distribution of projective two energy measurements can be recovered. In the opposite limit the average of work becomes independent of any measurement. Yet the fluctuations about this value diverge. The performance of the work meter is illustrated by the example of a spin in a suddenly changing magnetic field.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.93.022131

Related papers

Quantum fluctuation theorems and power measurements

B. Prasanna Venkatesh, Gentaro Watanabe, Peter Talkner A

Work in the paradigm of the quantum fluctuation theorems of Crooks and Jarzynski is determined by projective measurements of energy at the beginning and end of the force protocol. In analogy to classical systems, we consider an alternative definition of work given by the integral of the supplied power determined by integrating up the results of repeated measurements of the instantaneous power during the force protocol. We observe that such a definition of work, in spite of taking account of the process dependence, has different possible values and statistics from the work determined by the conventional two energy measurement approach (TEMA). In the limit of many projective measurements of power, the system’s dynamics is frozen in the power measurement basis due to the quantum Zeno effect leading to statistics only trivially dependent on the force protocol. In general the Jarzynski relation is not satisfied except for the case when the instantaneous power operator commutes with the total Hamiltonian at all times. We also consider properties of the joint statistics of power-based definition of work and TEMA work in protocols where both values are determined. This allows us to quantify their correlations. Relaxing the projective measurement condition, weak continuous measurements of power are considered within the stochastic master equation formalism. Even in this scenario the power-based work statistics is in general not able to reproduce qualitative features of the TEMA work statistics.

arXiv:1503.03228•New Journal of Physics•Aug 3, 2015•36 citations

Jarzynski equation for a simple quantum system: Comparing two definitions of work

Andreas Engel, Roman Nolte

The validity of the Jarzynski equation for a very simple, exactly solvable quantum system is analyzed. The implications of two different definitions of work proposed in the literature are investigated. The first one derives from measurements of the system energy at the beginning and at the end of the process under consideration making the work a classical stochastic variable with transition probabilities derived from quantum-mechanics. In the second definition an operator of work is introduced and the average in the Jarzynski equation is a quantum expectation value. For the first definition a general quantum-mechanical version of the Jarzynski equation is known to hold. For the second one the Jarzynski equation fails to yield the free energy difference at low temperature.

arXiv:cond-mat/0612527•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 6, 2007•64 citations

Measurement-dependent corrections to work distributions arising from quantum coherences

Paolo Solinas, Harry J. D. Miller, Janet Anders

For a quantum system undergoing a unitary, process work is commonly defined based on the two projective measurement protocols, which measures the energies of the system before and after the process. However, it is well known that projective measurements disregard quantum coherences of the system with respect to the energy basis, thus removing potential quantum signatures in the work distribution. Here we consider weak measurements of the system's energy difference and establish corrections to work averages arising from initial system coherences. We discuss two weak measurement protocols that couple the system to a detector, prepared and measured either in the momentum or the position eigenstates. Work averages are derived for when the system starts in the proper thermal state versus when the initial system state is a pure state with thermal diagonal elements and coherences characterized by a set of phases. We show that by controlling only the phase differences between the energy eigenstate contributions in the system's initial pure state, the average work done during the same unitary process can be controlled. By changing the phases alone, one can toggle from regimes where the system absorbs energy, i.e., a work cost, to the ones where it emits energy, i.e., work can be drawn. This suggests that the coherences are additional resources that can be used to manipulate or store energy in a quantum system.

arXiv:1705.10296•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2017•38 citations

Single-energy-measurement integral fluctuation theorem and nonprojective measurements

Daniel Alonso, A. Ruiz

We study a Jarzysnki-type equality for work in systems that are monitored using nonprojective unsharp measurements. The information acquired by the observer from the outcome f of an energy measurement and the subsequent conditioned normalized state ρ[over ̂](t,f) evolved up to a final time t are used to define work, as the difference between the final expectation value of the energy and the result f of the measurement. The Jarzynski equality obtained depends on the coherences that the state develops during the process, the characteristics of the meter used to measure the energy, and the noise it induces into the system. We analyze those contributions in some detail to unveil their role. We show that in very particular cases, but not in general, the effect of such noise gives a factor multiplying the result that would be obtained if projective measurements were used instead of nonprojective ones. The unsharp character of the measurements used to monitor the energy of the system, which defines the resolution of the meter, leads to different scenarios of interest. In particular, if the distance between neighboring elements in the energy spectrum is much larger than the resolution of the meter, then a similar result to the projective measurement case is obtained, up to a multiplicative factor that depends on the meter. A more subtle situation arises in the opposite case in which measurements may be noninformative, i.e., they may not contribute to update the information about the system. In this case a correction to the relation obtained in the nonoverlapping case appears. We analyze the conditions in which such a correction becomes negligible. We also study the coherences, in terms of the relative entropy of coherence developed by the evolved post-measurement state. We illustrate the results by analyzing a two-level system monitored by a simple meter.

arXiv:2212.13225•Physical review. E•Aug 15, 2023•3 citations

Quantum Fluctuations of Work and Generalised Quantum Measurements

Martí Perarnau-Llobet, Elisa Bäumer, Karen V. Hovhannisyan +2 more

An open question of fundamental importance in thermodynamics is how to describe the fluctuations of work for quantum coherent processes. In the standard approach, based on a projective energy measurement both at the beginning and at the end of the process, the first measurement destroys any initial coherence in the energy basis. Here we seek for extensions of this approach which can possibly account for initially coherent states. We therefore consider all measurement schemes to estimate work and require that (i) they agree with the standard two-measurement scheme for states with no coherence in the energy basis, and (ii) the expected value of the measurement outcomes is equal to the average energy difference of the unmeasured process for all states. We first show that such a scheme does not exist. Next, we consider the possibility of performing collective measurements on several copies of the state and prove that it still impossible to satisfy simultaneously requirements (i) and (ii). Nevertheless, improvements do appear, and in particular we develop a measurement scheme which acts simultaneously on two copies of the state and allows to describe a whole class of coherent transformations.

•Jun 27, 2016•2 citations

Quantum work and the thermodynamic cost of quantum measurements

Sebastian Deffner, Juan Pablo Paz, Wojciech Hubert Zurek

Quantum work is usually determined from two projective measurements of the energy at the beginning and at the end of a thermodynamic process. However, this paradigm cannot be considered thermodynamically consistent as it does not account for the thermodynamic cost of these measurements. To remedy this conceptual inconsistency we introduce a paradigm that relies only on the expected change of the average energy given the initial energy eigenbasis. In particular, we completely omit quantum measurements in the definition of quantum work, and hence quantum work is identified as a thermodynamic quantity of only the system. As main results we derive a modified quantum Jarzynski equality and a sharpened maximum work theorem in terms of the information free energy. A comparison of our results with the standard approach allows one to quantify the informational cost of projective measurements.

arXiv:1603.06509•Physical review. E•Jul 7, 2016•123 citations
Various approaches of defining and determining work performed on a quantum system are compared. Any operational definition of work, however, must allow for two facts: first, that work characterizes a process rather than an instantaneous state of a system and, second, that quantum systems are sensitive to the interactions with a measurement apparatus. We compare different measurement scenarios on the basis of the resulting postmeasurement states and the according probabilities for finding a particular work value. In particular, we analyze a recently proposed work meter for the case of a Gaussian pointer state and compare it with the results obtained by two projective and, alternatively, two Gaussian measurements. In the limit of a strong effective measurement strength the work distribution of projective two energy measurements can be recovered. In the opposite limit the average of work becomes independent of any measurement. Yet the fluctuations about this value diverge. The performance of the work meter is illustrated by the example of a spin in a suddenly changing magnetic field.
Work in the paradigm of the quantum fluctuation theorems of Crooks and Jarzynski is determined by projective measurements of energy at the beginning and end of the force protocol. In analogy to classical systems, we consider an alternative definition of work given by the integral of the supplied power determined by integrating up the results of repeated measurements of the instantaneous power during the force protocol. We observe that such a definition of work, in spite of taking account of the process dependence, has different possible values and statistics from the work determined by the conventional two energy measurement approach (TEMA). In the limit of many projective measurements of power, the system’s dynamics is frozen in the power measurement basis due to the quantum Zeno effect leading to statistics only trivially dependent on the force protocol. In general the Jarzynski relation is not satisfied except for the case when the instantaneous power operator commutes with the total Hamiltonian at all times. We also consider properties of the joint statistics of power-based definition of work and TEMA work in protocols where both values are determined. This allows us to quantify their correlations. Relaxing the projective measurement condition, weak continuous measurements of power are considered within the stochastic master equation formalism. Even in this scenario the power-based work statistics is in general not able to reproduce qualitative features of the TEMA work statistics.
The validity of the Jarzynski equation for a very simple, exactly solvable quantum system is analyzed. The implications of two different definitions of work proposed in the literature are investigated. The first one derives from measurements of the system energy at the beginning and at the end of the process under consideration making the work a classical stochastic variable with transition probabilities derived from quantum-mechanics. In the second definition an operator of work is introduced and the average in the Jarzynski equation is a quantum expectation value. For the first definition a general quantum-mechanical version of the Jarzynski equation is known to hold. For the second one the Jarzynski equation fails to yield the free energy difference at low temperature.
For a quantum system undergoing a unitary, process work is commonly defined based on the two projective measurement protocols, which measures the energies of the system before and after the process. However, it is well known that projective measurements disregard quantum coherences of the system with respect to the energy basis, thus removing potential quantum signatures in the work distribution. Here we consider weak measurements of the system's energy difference and establish corrections to work averages arising from initial system coherences. We discuss two weak measurement protocols that couple the system to a detector, prepared and measured either in the momentum or the position eigenstates. Work averages are derived for when the system starts in the proper thermal state versus when the initial system state is a pure state with thermal diagonal elements and coherences characterized by a set of phases. We show that by controlling only the phase differences between the energy eigenstate contributions in the system's initial pure state, the average work done during the same unitary process can be controlled. By changing the phases alone, one can toggle from regimes where the system absorbs energy, i.e., a work cost, to the ones where it emits energy, i.e., work can be drawn. This suggests that the coherences are additional resources that can be used to manipulate or store energy in a quantum system.
We study a Jarzysnki-type equality for work in systems that are monitored using nonprojective unsharp measurements. The information acquired by the observer from the outcome f of an energy measurement and the subsequent conditioned normalized state ρ[over ̂](t,f) evolved up to a final time t are used to define work, as the difference between the final expectation value of the energy and the result f of the measurement. The Jarzynski equality obtained depends on the coherences that the state develops during the process, the characteristics of the meter used to measure the energy, and the noise it induces into the system. We analyze those contributions in some detail to unveil their role. We show that in very particular cases, but not in general, the effect of such noise gives a factor multiplying the result that would be obtained if projective measurements were used instead of nonprojective ones. The unsharp character of the measurements used to monitor the energy of the system, which defines the resolution of the meter, leads to different scenarios of interest. In particular, if the distance between neighboring elements in the energy spectrum is much larger than the resolution of the meter, then a similar result to the projective measurement case is obtained, up to a multiplicative factor that depends on the meter. A more subtle situation arises in the opposite case in which measurements may be noninformative, i.e., they may not contribute to update the information about the system. In this case a correction to the relation obtained in the nonoverlapping case appears. We analyze the conditions in which such a correction becomes negligible. We also study the coherences, in terms of the relative entropy of coherence developed by the evolved post-measurement state. We illustrate the results by analyzing a two-level system monitored by a simple meter.
An open question of fundamental importance in thermodynamics is how to describe the fluctuations of work for quantum coherent processes. In the standard approach, based on a projective energy measurement both at the beginning and at the end of the process, the first measurement destroys any initial coherence in the energy basis. Here we seek for extensions of this approach which can possibly account for initially coherent states. We therefore consider all measurement schemes to estimate work and require that (i) they agree with the standard two-measurement scheme for states with no coherence in the energy basis, and (ii) the expected value of the measurement outcomes is equal to the average energy difference of the unmeasured process for all states. We first show that such a scheme does not exist. Next, we consider the possibility of performing collective measurements on several copies of the state and prove that it still impossible to satisfy simultaneously requirements (i) and (ii). Nevertheless, improvements do appear, and in particular we develop a measurement scheme which acts simultaneously on two copies of the state and allows to describe a whole class of coherent transformations.
Quantum work is usually determined from two projective measurements of the energy at the beginning and at the end of a thermodynamic process. However, this paradigm cannot be considered thermodynamically consistent as it does not account for the thermodynamic cost of these measurements. To remedy this conceptual inconsistency we introduce a paradigm that relies only on the expected change of the average energy given the initial energy eigenbasis. In particular, we completely omit quantum measurements in the definition of quantum work, and hence quantum work is identified as a thermodynamic quantity of only the system. As main results we derive a modified quantum Jarzynski equality and a sharpened maximum work theorem in terms of the information free energy. A comparison of our results with the standard approach allows one to quantify the informational cost of projective measurements.