An explanation of polarization entanglement is presented using Maxwells classical electromagnetic theory.Two key features are required to understand these classical origins.The first is that all waves diffract and weakly diffracting waves,with a principal direction of propagation in the laboratory frame, travel along that direction at speeds ever so slightly less than c.This allows nontrivial Lorentz transformations that can act on selected forward F waves or selected waves R traveling in the opposite direction to show that both can arise from a single zero momentum frame where all the waves are transverse to the original principal direction.Such F and R waves then both belong to a single relativistic entity where correlations between the two are unremarkable.The second feature requires the avoidance of using the Coulomb gauge.Waves, tending to plane waves in the limit of zero diffraction,can then be shown to be composed of two coupled sets of E and B fields that demonstrate the classical entanglement of F and R waves.Being derived from Maxwells equations,the theory is compatible with special relativity.This is used to account for entanglement between waves traveling at arbitrary angles from a source.In spite of a classical explanation,selection of appropriate F and R waves means entanglement is likely to remain a quantum phenomenon.
An explanation of polarization entanglement is presented using Maxwells classical electromagnetic theory.Two key features are required to understand these classical origins.The first is that all waves diffract and weakly diffracting waves,with a principal direction of propagation in the laboratory frame, travel along that direction at speeds ever so slightly less than c.This allows nontrivial Lorentz transformations that can act on selected forward F waves or selected waves R traveling in the opposite direction to show that both can arise from a single zero momentum frame where all the waves are transverse to the original principal direction.Such F and R waves then both belong to a single relativistic entity where correlations between the two are unremarkable.The second feature requires the avoidance of using the Coulomb gauge.Waves, tending to plane waves in the limit of zero diffraction,can then be shown to be composed of two coupled sets of E and B fields that demonstrate the classical entanglement of F and R waves.Being derived from Maxwells equations,the theory is compatible with special relativity.This is used to account for entanglement between waves traveling at arbitrary angles from a source.In spite of a classical explanation,selection of appropriate F and R waves means entanglement is likely to remain a quantum phenomenon.
With the help of light cone coordinates and light cone field representations of Maxwell’s classical equations, quantum polarization entanglement is explained using the relativistic results of a companion paper that shows how conventional or reference waves can have an adjoint wave, travelling in phase with the reference wave, but in a proper relativistic frame that travels in the opposing direction to the proper frame of the reference wave. This subsequently allows waves, travelling in opposite directions, to have the same proper frame and consequently such waves can be regarded as relativistically local. The light cone coordinates offer a classical form of a quantum wave function and demonstrate a classical equivalent of a mixed quantum state.
This chapter provides the ubiquitous equation for the probability amplitude of polarization entanglement of two photons moving away in different directions, from a common source. The first derivation is performed from a Hamiltonian approach using the two-state infrastructure taught to by R. P. Feynman. The second derivation utilizes an interferometric approach, while the third approach is based on the original analysis used by Ward. The initial link between quantum mechanical concepts and the polarization correlation of photons propagating in opposite directions was given by Wheeler: “According to the pair theory, if one of these photons is polarized in one plane, then the photon that goes off in the opposite direction with equal momentum is linearly polarized in the perpendicular plane.” The theory of entangled quantum polarizations, central to A. Einstein, B. Podolsky, and N. Rosen-type optical experiments, was established in the 1947–1949 period by M. H. Pryce and J. C. Ward and independently by H. S. Snyder et al.
A new explanation is given for correlated measurements on widely separated entangled particles. This explanation uses relativity where events in the same proper frame can be local to one another. Proper frames are shown to be possible, even for light waves, because of diffraction. Waves ΨA and ΨB with distinct proper frames Гp and Гn, travel in opposing directions to reach well separated observers A and B. Consideration of the formality of combined time-frequency-reversal leads to concepts of adjoint waves ΨAa and ΨBa with phase velocities still travelling to A and B respectively. Measurements are now associated with ΨAa*ΨA and ΨBa*ΨB rather than ΨA*ΨA and ΨB*ΨB. It is shown how waves ΨA and ΨBa* can have the same proper frame Гp while ΨAa* and ΨB can have the same proper frame Гn. Consequently these waves ΨA and ΨBa* can be said to be relativistically local and could have correlated properties without any violation of the principle of locality. Similar remarks apply to ΨAa* and ΨB. It is no longer surprising if widely separated particles, represented by measurements of ΨAa*ΨA and ΨBa*ΨB, have correlated properties though the theory’s generality prevents detailing specific correlations. Similar arguments are advanced for Dirac waves. However essential quantum aspects of entanglement lie in carefully timed measurements that choose the correct waves with the correct proper frames. Classical measurements at A and B contain random sets of waves from different proper frames averaged over time and this generally returns uncorrelated measurements. The paper provides satisfying links between relativity, entanglement, quantum wave collapse, and classical independence of non-local observations.
The theory of Quantum Electromagnetics presents a wave equation which is constructed, in compliance with Galilean transformations, for electromagnetic and matter waves. A fundamental feature entirely different from the principle of relativity is that the wave equation is referred specifically to the proposed local-ether frame. For electromagnetic wave, the local-ether wave equation accounts for a wide variety of experiments on propagation and interference. For matter wave, the wave equation leads to modifications of Schrodinger’s equation which in turn lead to a unified quantum theory of electromagnetic and gravitational forces in conjunction with the origin and the identity of inertial and gravitational mass. Further, it leads to modifications of the Lorentz force law and of Maxwell’s equations. Moreover, the wave equation leads to the dispersion of matter wave, from which the speed-dependence in the mass of a particle and in the wavelength, angular frequency, and quantum energy of a matter wave can be derived. The consequences of the wave equation are in accord with a wide variety of experiments that are commonly ascribed to the special relativity, the general relativity, the Lorentz mass-variation law, or to the de Broglie matter wave. Thereby, the local-ether wave equation unifies quantum mechanics, electromagnetics, and gravitation.
Classically, light is an electromagnetic phenomenon, described by Maxwell's equations. However, under certain conditions, such as low intensity or in the presence of certain nonlinear optical materials, light starts to behave differently, and we have to construct a ‘quantum theory of light’. We can exploit this quantum behaviour of light for quantum information processing, which is the subject of this book. In this chapter, we develop the quantum theory of the free electromagnetic quantum field. This means that we do not yet consider the interaction between light and matter; we postpone that to Chapter 7. We start from first principles, using the canonical quantization procedure in the Coulomb gauge: we derive the field equations of motion from the classical Lagrangian density for the vector potential, and promote the field and its canonical momentum to operators and impose the canonical commutation relations. This will lead to the well-known creation and annihilation operators, and ultimately to the concept of the photon. After quantization of the free electromagnetic field we consider transformations of the mode functions of the field. We will demonstrate the intimate relation between these linear mode transformations and the effect of beam splitters, phase shifters, and polarization rotations, and show how they naturally give rise to the concept of squeezing. Finally, we introduce coherent and squeezed states.