Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1510.06712

A Live Alternative to Quantum Spooks

Huw Price, K. B. Wharton

Published Oct 22, 2015• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum weirdness has been in the news recently, thanks to an ingenious new experiment by a team led by Roland Hanson, at the Delft University of Technology. Much of the coverage presents the experiment as good (even conclusive) news for spooky action-at-a-distance, and bad news for local realism. We point out that this interpretation ignores an alternative, namely that the quantum world is retrocausal. We conjecture that this loophole is missed because it is confused for superdeterminism on one side, or action-at-a-distance itself on the other. We explain why it is different from these options, and why it has clear advantages, in both cases.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1510.06712

Related papers

Comment on "Loophole-free Bell inequality"

Robert B. Griffiths

A recent experiment yielding results in agreement with quantum theory and violating Bell inequalities was interpreted [Nature 526 (29 Octobert 2015) p. 682 and p. 649] as ruling out any local realistic theory of nature. But quantum theory itself is both local and realistic when properly interpreted using a quantum Hilbert space rather than the classical hidden variables used to derive Bell inequalities. There is no spooky action at a distance in the real world we live in if it is governed by the laws of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1512.01443•Dec 4, 2015•2 citations

After Bell

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We analyze foundational consequences of recently announced loophole free tests of violation of Bell's inequality. We consider two interpretations of these remarkable experiments. By the conventional one Einstein was wrong and Bohr was right, there is spooky action at a distance, quantum realism is incompatible with locality. However, we show that it is still possible to treat quantum mechanics without appealing to nonlocality or denying realism. We hope that this note will attract attention of the experts in quantum foundations and convince them to come with their own comments on the final Bell's test.

•Mar 29, 2016•4 citations

After Bell

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We analyze foundational consequences of recently reported loophole free tests of violation of Bell's inequality. We consider two interpretations of these remarkable experiments. The conventional one is “Einstein was wrong and Bohr was right, there is spooky action at a distance, quantum realism is incompatible with locality.” However, in line with discussions in literature during last decade, we show that it is still possible to treat quantum mechanics without appealing to nonlocality or denying realism. We hope that this note will call the attention of experts in quantum foundations and convince them that the case is not closed, so that they should come with their own comments on the status of the final Bell test.

arXiv:1603.08674•Fortschritte der Physik•Sep 7, 2016•27 citations

The Atomic World Spooky? It Ain't Necessarily So!

Theo van Holten

The present book takes the discovery that quantum-like behaviour is not solely reserved to atomic particles one step further. If electrons are modelled as vibrating droplets instead of the usually assumed point objects, and if the classical laws of nature are applied, then exactly the same behaviour as in quantum theory is found, quantitatively correct! The world of atoms is strange and quantum mechanics, the theory of this world, is almost magic. Or is it? Tiny droplets of oil bouncing round on a fluid surface can also mimic the world of quantum mechanics. For the layman - for whom the main part of this book is written - this is good news. If the everyday laws of nature can conspire to show up quantum-like phenomena, there is hope to form mental pictures how the atomic world works. The book is almost formula-free, and explains everything by using many sketches and diagrams. The mathematical derivations underlying the main text are kept separate in a -peer reviewed - appendix. The author, a retired professor of Flight Mechanics and Propulsion at the Delft University of Technology, chose to publish his findings in this mixed popular and scientific form, because he found that interested laymen more often than professional physicists feel the need to form visualisations of quantum phenomena.

Atlantis Press eBooks•Dec 9, 2016•2 citations

Explaining 'spooky Action at a Distance'

Gerard van der Ham

Accepting Einstein's viewpoint of local realism correlation in Bell tests is very well explainable.

•Aug 1, 2019•0 citations

Quantum Mechanics Reframed - The Weirdness Was Ours

Eric McLean

What if quantum mechanics was never weird? For a century, we've treated superposition, entanglement, and wave function collapse as paradoxes demanding explanation. We've built interpretations (Copenhagen, Many Worlds, pilot waves) each trying to make sense of a reality that seems to defy common sense. This paper proposes we've been solving the wrong problem. Every major interpretation shares one assumption: that separability is fundamental, that the universe is made of distinct things in distinct places, and quantum mechanics somehow violates this. But what if we have it backwards? What if unity is the baseline, and separation is what emerges? Invert the assumption, and the paradoxes dissolve. Superposition isn't particles in two places; it's coherence that hasn't yet differentiated. Entanglement isn't spooky action at a distance; it's correlation that was never broken. Collapse isn't mysterious; it's self-reference crossing a threshold. The math stays the same. The predictions stay the same. What changes is the sense of paradox. This isn't mysticism. It's a formal reframe with testable implications, from quantum biology to consciousness correlates. The paper lays out the argument and invites pushback. I'm genuinely asking: where does this break? What am I missing? The framework is falsifiable, and I'd rather find the cracks now than later. Read it. Tell me where it fails.

•Jan 25, 2026•0 citations
Quantum weirdness has been in the news recently, thanks to an ingenious new experiment by a team led by Roland Hanson, at the Delft University of Technology. Much of the coverage presents the experiment as good (even conclusive) news for spooky action-at-a-distance, and bad news for local realism. We point out that this interpretation ignores an alternative, namely that the quantum world is retrocausal. We conjecture that this loophole is missed because it is confused for superdeterminism on one side, or action-at-a-distance itself on the other. We explain why it is different from these options, and why it has clear advantages, in both cases.
A recent experiment yielding results in agreement with quantum theory and violating Bell inequalities was interpreted [Nature 526 (29 Octobert 2015) p. 682 and p. 649] as ruling out any local realistic theory of nature. But quantum theory itself is both local and realistic when properly interpreted using a quantum Hilbert space rather than the classical hidden variables used to derive Bell inequalities. There is no spooky action at a distance in the real world we live in if it is governed by the laws of quantum mechanics.
We analyze foundational consequences of recently announced loophole free tests of violation of Bell's inequality. We consider two interpretations of these remarkable experiments. By the conventional one Einstein was wrong and Bohr was right, there is spooky action at a distance, quantum realism is incompatible with locality. However, we show that it is still possible to treat quantum mechanics without appealing to nonlocality or denying realism. We hope that this note will attract attention of the experts in quantum foundations and convince them to come with their own comments on the final Bell's test.
We analyze foundational consequences of recently reported loophole free tests of violation of Bell's inequality. We consider two interpretations of these remarkable experiments. The conventional one is “Einstein was wrong and Bohr was right, there is spooky action at a distance, quantum realism is incompatible with locality.” However, in line with discussions in literature during last decade, we show that it is still possible to treat quantum mechanics without appealing to nonlocality or denying realism. We hope that this note will call the attention of experts in quantum foundations and convince them that the case is not closed, so that they should come with their own comments on the status of the final Bell test.
The present book takes the discovery that quantum-like behaviour is not solely reserved to atomic particles one step further. If electrons are modelled as vibrating droplets instead of the usually assumed point objects, and if the classical laws of nature are applied, then exactly the same behaviour as in quantum theory is found, quantitatively correct! The world of atoms is strange and quantum mechanics, the theory of this world, is almost magic. Or is it? Tiny droplets of oil bouncing round on a fluid surface can also mimic the world of quantum mechanics. For the layman - for whom the main part of this book is written - this is good news. If the everyday laws of nature can conspire to show up quantum-like phenomena, there is hope to form mental pictures how the atomic world works. The book is almost formula-free, and explains everything by using many sketches and diagrams. The mathematical derivations underlying the main text are kept separate in a -peer reviewed - appendix. The author, a retired professor of Flight Mechanics and Propulsion at the Delft University of Technology, chose to publish his findings in this mixed popular and scientific form, because he found that interested laymen more often than professional physicists feel the need to form visualisations of quantum phenomena.
What if quantum mechanics was never weird? For a century, we've treated superposition, entanglement, and wave function collapse as paradoxes demanding explanation. We've built interpretations (Copenhagen, Many Worlds, pilot waves) each trying to make sense of a reality that seems to defy common sense. This paper proposes we've been solving the wrong problem. Every major interpretation shares one assumption: that separability is fundamental, that the universe is made of distinct things in distinct places, and quantum mechanics somehow violates this. But what if we have it backwards? What if unity is the baseline, and separation is what emerges? Invert the assumption, and the paradoxes dissolve. Superposition isn't particles in two places; it's coherence that hasn't yet differentiated. Entanglement isn't spooky action at a distance; it's correlation that was never broken. Collapse isn't mysterious; it's self-reference crossing a threshold. The math stays the same. The predictions stay the same. What changes is the sense of paradox. This isn't mysticism. It's a formal reframe with testable implications, from quantum biology to consciousness correlates. The paper lays out the argument and invites pushback. I'm genuinely asking: where does this break? What am I missing? The framework is falsifiable, and I'd rather find the cracks now than later. Read it. Tell me where it fails.