Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1510.04669 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Comment on “New analytic solution of Schrödinger's equation” by Eleuch H. et al.

Alexander Moroz

Published Feb 1, 2017• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Some of the conclusions of an improved JWKB method by Eleuch H., Rostovtsev Y. V. and Scully M. O., EPL, 89 (2010) 50004 are clarified. The degree of approximation to exact solutions is quantitatively assessed. The improved JWKB method is also contrasted with the method of comparison equations.
DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/117/40001

Related papers

New analytic solution of Schrödinger's equation

Hichem Eleuch, Yuri V. Rostovtsev, Marlan O. Scully

We obtain an analytic solution beyond adiabatic approximation by transferring the 1D Schrödinger equation into the Ricatti equation. Then we show that our solution is more accurate than JWKB approximation. The generalizations of the approach to 3D are suggested, and possible applications of obtained solutions are discussed.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Mar 1, 2010•38 citations

A comparison of solutions to the time dependent Schrödinger equation

Chi-Ming Chang

Various methods providing approximate solutions to the time dependent Schrödinger equation proposed in a previous paper are compared using two examples for which the exact analytic solutions are known. Results show that the new method proposed in the previous paper is better than the traditional method for time dependent parameters.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 15, 1977•0 citations

Comment on ‘‘Optimization of approximate solutions to the time-dependent Schrödinger equation’’

José M. Maidagan, Rubén Darío Piacentini

In a previous work [A. B. Weglein, Phys. Rev. A 17, 1810 (1978)], an optimization method to approximate solutions to the time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation proposed by Chang and Rapp was further developed. We show that, if correct in a mathematical sense, it leads to results which are physically inadequate.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1985•3 citations

A NEW APPROACH TO THE JWKB TREATMENT.

Nasr Youssef. Saad

The JWKB approximation is widely used in many problems in quantum mechanics for its simplicity and also because a closed-form solution often provides more insight than a numerical one. Unfortunately, like all approximations, the JWKB method has its limitations: Firstly, it may fail near or at a classical turning point, and secondly, it employs solutions for a potential which deviates from the actual potential W(x). In this work, a new method is proposed to avoid the limitations of the JWKB method while keeping its advantages. First, the singularity around the classical turning point is resolved not only for a linear potential as proposed by Langer, but also for any potential with a linear leading term through the turning point, and second, a solution is constructed in closed form which is an exact solution for the actual potential W(x). The new method consists in finding a substitute potential U(x) in such a way that, together with its (DELTA){U,x} it is equal to the actual W(x). The solution is then based on U(x) but actually is the solution for W(x) because W(x) = U(x) + (DELTA){U,x}. The new method is first applied to potentials with only two turning points. The eigenvalue problem is reduced to the solution of a linear equation and the energy eigenvalues are exactly given. Then, potentials with more than two turning points are studied and the eigenvalue problem is again reduced to the solution of a polynomial equation whose order depends upon the number of turning points. Then the method is applied to the hindered or restricted rotation. The energy levels are found to be associated with the N-th roots of 1 in the complex plane, i.e. on the unit circle. The method described here is of rather general nature and can be used to solve a number of problems in quantum mechanics, where a solution for the Schrodinger equation in closed form is needed. The applications provided in this work are only given as examples of the applicability and the relative simplicity of the method.Dept. of Physics. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis1980 .S223. Source: Dissertation Abstracts International, Volume: 41-03, Section: B, page: 1002. Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 1980.

•Jan 1, 1980•0 citations

Quantum Harmonic Oscillator

Coşkun Deniz

Quantum harmonic oscillator (QHO) involves square law potential (x2) in the Schrodinger equation and is a fundamental problem in quantum mechanics. It can be solved by various conventional methods such as (i) analytical methods where Hermite polynomials are involved, (ii) algebraic methods where ladder operators are involved, and (iii) approximation methods where perturbation, variational, semiclassical, etc. techniques are involved. Here we present the general outcomes of the two conventional semiclassical approximation methods: the JWKB method (named after Jeffreys, Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin) and the MAF method (abbreviated for “modified Airy functions”) to solve the QHO in a very good precision. Although JWKB is an approximation method, it interestingly gives the exact solution for the QHO except for the classical turning points (CTPs) where it diverges as typical to the JWKB. As the MAF method, it enables very approximate wave functions to be written in terms of Airy functions without any discontinuity in the entire domain, though, it needs careful treatment since Airy functions exhibit too much oscillatory behavior. Here, we make use of the parity conditions of the QHO to find the exact JWKB and approximate MAF solutions of the QHO within the capability of these methods.

IntechOpen eBooks•May 16, 2019•2 citations

On Solutions of the Killingbeck Potential and Clarifying Comments on a Related Analytical Approach

Fatma Zohra Khaled, Mustafa Moumni, Mokhtar Falek

The work presents analytical solutions to the Schrodinger equation for the Killingbeck potential, a Hybrid model combining harmonic, linear and Coulomb terms, and which is also an approximate model of Yukawa-type potentials. The radial Schrodinger equation is solved by means of the series expansion method, thus yielding the exact expressions of both bound-states solutions and eigen-functions for the systems; these systems include quarkonium and confined hydrogen-like atoms in plasma environments. Furthermore, we offer a constructive commentary on the work of Obu et al. (East Eur. J. Phys. 3, 146-157, 2023), with the aim of clarifying a mathematical misstatement used in their analytical treatment of analogous systems.

quant-pharXiv:2607.19611•Jul 23, 2026
The JWKB approximation is widely used in many problems in quantum mechanics for its simplicity and also because a closed-form solution often provides more insight than a numerical one. Unfortunately, like all approximations, the JWKB method has its limitations: Firstly, it may fail near or at a classical turning point, and secondly, it employs solutions for a potential which deviates from the actual potential W(x). In this work, a new method is proposed to avoid the limitations of the JWKB method while keeping its advantages. First, the singularity around the classical turning point is resolved not only for a linear potential as proposed by Langer, but also for any potential with a linear leading term through the turning point, and second, a solution is constructed in closed form which is an exact solution for the actual potential W(x). The new method consists in finding a substitute potential U(x) in such a way that, together with its (DELTA){U,x} it is equal to the actual W(x). The solution is then based on U(x) but actually is the solution for W(x) because W(x) = U(x) + (DELTA){U,x}. The new method is first applied to potentials with only two turning points. The eigenvalue problem is reduced to the solution of a linear equation and the energy eigenvalues are exactly given. Then, potentials with more than two turning points are studied and the eigenvalue problem is again reduced to the solution of a polynomial equation whose order depends upon the number of turning points. Then the method is applied to the hindered or restricted rotation. The energy levels are found to be associated with the N-th roots of 1 in the complex plane, i.e. on the unit circle. The method described here is of rather general nature and can be used to solve a number of problems in quantum mechanics, where a solution for the Schrodinger equation in closed form is needed. The applications provided in this work are only given as examples of the applicability and the relative simplicity of the method.Dept. of Physics. Paper copy at Leddy Library: Theses & Major Papers - Basement, West Bldg. / Call Number: Thesis1980 .S223. Source: Dissertation Abstracts International, Volume: 41-03, Section: B, page: 1002. Thesis (Ph.D.)--University of Windsor (Canada), 1980.
Quantum harmonic oscillator (QHO) involves square law potential (x2) in the Schrodinger equation and is a fundamental problem in quantum mechanics. It can be solved by various conventional methods such as (i) analytical methods where Hermite polynomials are involved, (ii) algebraic methods where ladder operators are involved, and (iii) approximation methods where perturbation, variational, semiclassical, etc. techniques are involved. Here we present the general outcomes of the two conventional semiclassical approximation methods: the JWKB method (named after Jeffreys, Wentzel, Kramers, and Brillouin) and the MAF method (abbreviated for “modified Airy functions”) to solve the QHO in a very good precision. Although JWKB is an approximation method, it interestingly gives the exact solution for the QHO except for the classical turning points (CTPs) where it diverges as typical to the JWKB. As the MAF method, it enables very approximate wave functions to be written in terms of Airy functions without any discontinuity in the entire domain, though, it needs careful treatment since Airy functions exhibit too much oscillatory behavior. Here, we make use of the parity conditions of the QHO to find the exact JWKB and approximate MAF solutions of the QHO within the capability of these methods.
The work presents analytical solutions to the Schrodinger equation for the Killingbeck potential, a Hybrid model combining harmonic, linear and Coulomb terms, and which is also an approximate model of Yukawa-type potentials. The radial Schrodinger equation is solved by means of the series expansion method, thus yielding the exact expressions of both bound-states solutions and eigen-functions for the systems; these systems include quarkonium and confined hydrogen-like atoms in plasma environments. Furthermore, we offer a constructive commentary on the work of Obu et al. (East Eur. J. Phys. 3, 146-157, 2023), with the aim of clarifying a mathematical misstatement used in their analytical treatment of analogous systems.