Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1510.02158 · Physical Review A

Effective microscopic models for sympathetic cooling of atomic gases

Roberto Onofrio, Bala Sundaram

Published Sep 28, 2015• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Thermalization of a system in the presence of a heat bath has been the subject of many theoretical investigations especially in the framework of solid-state physics. In this setting, the presence of a large bandwidth for the frequency distribution of the harmonic oscillators schematizing the heat bath is crucial, as emphasized in the Caldeira-Leggett model. By contrast, ultracold gases in atomic traps oscillate at well-defined frequencies and therefore seem to lie outside the Caldeira-Leggett paradigm. We introduce interaction Hamiltonians which allow us to adapt the model to an atomic physics framework. The intrinsic nonlinearity of these models differentiates them from the original Caldeira-Leggett model and calls for a nontrivial stability analysis to determine effective ranges for the model parameters. These models allow for molecular-dynamics simulations of mixtures of ultracold gases, which is of current relevance for optimizing sympathetic cooling in degenerate Bose-Fermi mixtures.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.92.033422

Related papers

Thermodynamical approaches to efficient sympathetic cooling in ultracold Fermi-Bose atomic mixtures

Michael Brown-Hayes, Qun Wei, Carlo Presilla A +1 more

We discuss the cooling efficiency of ultracold Fermi-Bose mixtures in species-selective traps using a thermodynamical approach. The dynamics of evaporative cooling trajectories is analyzed in the specific case of bichromatic optical dipole traps also taking into account the effect of partial spatial overlap between the Fermi gas and the thermal component of the Bose gas. We show that large trapping frequency ratios between the Fermi and the Bose species allow for the achievement of a deeper Fermi degeneracy, consolidating in a thermodynamic setting earlier arguments based on more restrictive assumptions. In particular, we confirm that the minimum temperature of the mixture is obtained at the crossover between boson and fermion heat capacities, and that below such a temperature sympathetic cooling vanishes. When the effect of partial overlap is taken into account, optimal sympathetic cooling of the Fermi species may be achieved by properly tuning the relative trapping strength of the two species in a time-dependent fashion. Alternatively, the dimensionality of the trap in the final stage of cooling can be changed by increasing the confinement strength, which also results in a crossover of the heat capacities at deeper Fermi degeneracies. This technique may be extended to Fermi-Bose degenerate mixtures in optical lattices.

arXiv:0810.4481•Physical Review A•Jul 16, 2008•11 citations

APPROACH TO EQUILIBRIUM IN THE CALDEIRA–LEGGETT MODEL

Venkitesh Ayyar, Berndt Müller

The Caldeira–Leggett (CL) model describes a microscopic quantum system, represented by a harmonic oscillator, in interaction with a heat bath, represented by a large number of harmonic oscillators with a range of frequencies. We consider the case when the system oscillator starts out in the ground state and then thermalizes due to interactions with the heat bath, which is at temperature θ. We calculate the position autocorrelation function 〈x(t')x(t)〉 of the system oscillator at two different times and study its behavior in the small and large time limits. Our results show that the system oscillator thermalizes as expected. We also confirm by explicit calculation that the position autocorrelation function exhibits periodicity for imaginary values of the time difference t'-t = iτ at late-(real) times t.

arXiv:1212.3538•International Journal of Modern Physics E•Mar 1, 2013•2 citations

Universal and anomalous behavior in the thermalization of strongly interacting harmonically trapped gas mixtures

Francisco Jauffred, Roberto Onofrio, Bala Sundaram

Abstract We report on the dynamics of thermalization by extending a generalization of the Caldeira–Leggett model, developed in the context of cold atomic gases confined in a harmonic trap, to higher dimensions. Universal characteristics en route to thermalization which appear to be independent of dimensionality are highlighted, which additionally suggest a scaling analogous to turbulent mixing in fluid dynamics. We then focus on features dependent on dimensionality, with particular regard to the role of angular momentum of the two atomic clouds, having in mind the goal of efficient thermalization between the two species. Finally, by considering asymmetry in species numbers, we find that nonlinear interspecies interactions provide a mode locking mechanism between the majority and minority species, relevant to recent experiments involving Fermi–Bose mixtures in the normal phase.

arXiv:1704.06527•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•May 12, 2017•8 citations

Optimized sympathetic cooling of atomic mixtures via fast adiabatic strategies

Stephen U. S. Choi, Roberto Onofrio, Bala Sundaram

We discuss fast frictionless cooling techniques in the framework of sympathetic cooling of cold atomic mixtures. It is argued that optimal cooling of an atomic species---in which the deepest quantum degeneracy regime is achieved---may be obtained by means of sympathetic cooling with another species whose trapping frequency is dynamically changed to maintain constancy of the Lewis-Riesenfeld adiabatic invariant. Advantages and limitations of this cooling strategy are discussed, with particular regard to the possibility of cooling Fermi gases to a deeper degenerate regime.

arXiv:1109.4908•Physical Review A•Nov 9, 2011•48 citations

Toward the universality of the Caldeira-Leggett oscillator bath as a model for quantum environments I

Seyyed M. H. Halataei

Open quantum systems often interact with complex, intractable quantum environments. Establishing a minimal solvable model that captures the essential effects of these environments on central quantum systems has long been of interest in physics, dating back to the origins of quantum mechanics. The Caldeira-Leggett oscillator bath model has become a prominent minimal model that effectively represents many quantum environments. However, it has been argued that this model cannot capture the main effects of spin environments on central two-level systems when the couplings between the spins and the central systems are strong. In contrast, I adopt an appropriate spectral density function for the Caldeira-Leggett model and demonstrate that it can effectively replicate the essential effects of spin environments in the regime of interest. This suggests that the class of the Caldeira-Leggett model is more universal than previously recognized.

Scientific Reports•Dec 11, 2025•0 citations

Modeling sympathetic cooling of molecules by ultracold atoms

Jongseok Lim, Matthew D. Frye, Jeremy M. Hutson +1 more

We model sympathetic cooling of ground-state CaF molecules by ultracold Li and Rb atoms. The molecules are moving in a microwave trap, while the atoms are trapped magnetically. We calculate the differential elastic cross sections for CaF-Li and CaF-Rb collisions, using model Lennard-Jones potentials adjusted to give typical values for the $s$-wave scattering length. Together with trajectory calculations, these differential cross sections are used to simulate the cooling of the molecules, the heating of the atoms, and the loss of atoms from the trap. We show that a hard-sphere collision model based on an energy-dependent momentum transport cross section accurately predicts the molecule cooling rate but underestimates the rates of atom heating and loss. Our simulations suggest that Rb is a more effective coolant than Li for ground-state molecules, and that the cooling dynamics is less sensitive to the exact value of the $s$-wave scattering length when Rb is used. Using realistic experimental parameters, we find that molecules can be sympathetically cooled to $100\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{K}$ in about 10 s. By applying evaporative cooling to the atoms, the cooling rate can be increased and the final temperature of the molecules can be reduced to $1 \ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{K}$ within 30 s.

arXiv:1508.03987•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2015•57 citations
Thermalization of a system in the presence of a heat bath has been the subject of many theoretical investigations especially in the framework of solid-state physics. In this setting, the presence of a large bandwidth for the frequency distribution of the harmonic oscillators schematizing the heat bath is crucial, as emphasized in the Caldeira-Leggett model. By contrast, ultracold gases in atomic traps oscillate at well-defined frequencies and therefore seem to lie outside the Caldeira-Leggett paradigm. We introduce interaction Hamiltonians which allow us to adapt the model to an atomic physics framework. The intrinsic nonlinearity of these models differentiates them from the original Caldeira-Leggett model and calls for a nontrivial stability analysis to determine effective ranges for the model parameters. These models allow for molecular-dynamics simulations of mixtures of ultracold gases, which is of current relevance for optimizing sympathetic cooling in degenerate Bose-Fermi mixtures.
We discuss the cooling efficiency of ultracold Fermi-Bose mixtures in species-selective traps using a thermodynamical approach. The dynamics of evaporative cooling trajectories is analyzed in the specific case of bichromatic optical dipole traps also taking into account the effect of partial spatial overlap between the Fermi gas and the thermal component of the Bose gas. We show that large trapping frequency ratios between the Fermi and the Bose species allow for the achievement of a deeper Fermi degeneracy, consolidating in a thermodynamic setting earlier arguments based on more restrictive assumptions. In particular, we confirm that the minimum temperature of the mixture is obtained at the crossover between boson and fermion heat capacities, and that below such a temperature sympathetic cooling vanishes. When the effect of partial overlap is taken into account, optimal sympathetic cooling of the Fermi species may be achieved by properly tuning the relative trapping strength of the two species in a time-dependent fashion. Alternatively, the dimensionality of the trap in the final stage of cooling can be changed by increasing the confinement strength, which also results in a crossover of the heat capacities at deeper Fermi degeneracies. This technique may be extended to Fermi-Bose degenerate mixtures in optical lattices.
The Caldeira–Leggett (CL) model describes a microscopic quantum system, represented by a harmonic oscillator, in interaction with a heat bath, represented by a large number of harmonic oscillators with a range of frequencies. We consider the case when the system oscillator starts out in the ground state and then thermalizes due to interactions with the heat bath, which is at temperature θ. We calculate the position autocorrelation function 〈x(t')x(t)〉 of the system oscillator at two different times and study its behavior in the small and large time limits. Our results show that the system oscillator thermalizes as expected. We also confirm by explicit calculation that the position autocorrelation function exhibits periodicity for imaginary values of the time difference t'-t = iτ at late-(real) times t.
Abstract We report on the dynamics of thermalization by extending a generalization of the Caldeira–Leggett model, developed in the context of cold atomic gases confined in a harmonic trap, to higher dimensions. Universal characteristics en route to thermalization which appear to be independent of dimensionality are highlighted, which additionally suggest a scaling analogous to turbulent mixing in fluid dynamics. We then focus on features dependent on dimensionality, with particular regard to the role of angular momentum of the two atomic clouds, having in mind the goal of efficient thermalization between the two species. Finally, by considering asymmetry in species numbers, we find that nonlinear interspecies interactions provide a mode locking mechanism between the majority and minority species, relevant to recent experiments involving Fermi–Bose mixtures in the normal phase.
We discuss fast frictionless cooling techniques in the framework of sympathetic cooling of cold atomic mixtures. It is argued that optimal cooling of an atomic species---in which the deepest quantum degeneracy regime is achieved---may be obtained by means of sympathetic cooling with another species whose trapping frequency is dynamically changed to maintain constancy of the Lewis-Riesenfeld adiabatic invariant. Advantages and limitations of this cooling strategy are discussed, with particular regard to the possibility of cooling Fermi gases to a deeper degenerate regime.
Open quantum systems often interact with complex, intractable quantum environments. Establishing a minimal solvable model that captures the essential effects of these environments on central quantum systems has long been of interest in physics, dating back to the origins of quantum mechanics. The Caldeira-Leggett oscillator bath model has become a prominent minimal model that effectively represents many quantum environments. However, it has been argued that this model cannot capture the main effects of spin environments on central two-level systems when the couplings between the spins and the central systems are strong. In contrast, I adopt an appropriate spectral density function for the Caldeira-Leggett model and demonstrate that it can effectively replicate the essential effects of spin environments in the regime of interest. This suggests that the class of the Caldeira-Leggett model is more universal than previously recognized.
We model sympathetic cooling of ground-state CaF molecules by ultracold Li and Rb atoms. The molecules are moving in a microwave trap, while the atoms are trapped magnetically. We calculate the differential elastic cross sections for CaF-Li and CaF-Rb collisions, using model Lennard-Jones potentials adjusted to give typical values for the sss-wave scattering length. Together with trajectory calculations, these differential cross sections are used to simulate the cooling of the molecules, the heating of the atoms, and the loss of atoms from the trap. We show that a hard-sphere collision model based on an energy-dependent momentum transport cross section accurately predicts the molecule cooling rate but underestimates the rates of atom heating and loss. Our simulations suggest that Rb is a more effective coolant than Li for ground-state molecules, and that the cooling dynamics is less sensitive to the exact value of the sss-wave scattering length when Rb is used. Using realistic experimental parameters, we find that molecules can be sympathetically cooled to $100\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}\ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{K}$ in about 10 s. By applying evaporative cooling to the atoms, the cooling rate can be increased and the final temperature of the molecules can be reduced to $1 \ensuremath{\mu}\mathrm{K}$ within 30 s.