Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1509.04941

Quantum Spontaneous Stochasticity

Gregory L. Eyink, Theodore D. Drivas

Published Sep 16, 2015• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum wave-function of a massive particle with small initial uncertainties (consistent with the uncertainty relation) is believed to spread very slowly, so that the dynamics is deterministic. This assumes that the classical motions for given initial data are unique. In fluid turbulence non-uniqueness due to "roughness" of the advecting velocity field is known to lead to stochastic motion of classical particles. Vanishingly small random perturbations are magnified by Richardson diffusion in a "nearly rough" velocity field so that motion remains stochastic as the noise disappears, or classical spontaneous stochasticity, . Analogies between stochastic particle motion in turbulence and quantum evolution suggest that there should be quantum spontaneous stochasticity (QSS). We show this for 1D models of a particle in a repulsive potential that is "nearly rough" with $V(x) \sim C|x|^{1+α}$ at distances $|x|\gg \ell$ , for some UV cut-off $\ell$, and for initial Gaussian wave-packet centered at 0. We consider the WKB limit with $\hbar/m \to 0$, then position-spread $σ\to 0$. The limit of the position density is non-deterministic, with equal probabilities of the particle following either of two, non-unique classical solutions and with "Richardson-like" spreading of the wave-packet. The splitting of the wave-packet occurs in a very short time $t\sim(\ell^{1+α}/C)^{1/2}$ for small $\ell$. QSS also occurs in the scattering of a wave-packet off the rough potential, for careful fine-tuning. We also consider other semi-classical limits by a numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation, observing QSS both in position- and momentum-space. Although the wave-function remains split into two widely separated branches in the classical limit, rapid phase oscillations within each branch prevent any coherent superposition. These effects should be observable in laboratory experiments.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1509.04941

Related papers

ON THE LONG TIME BEHAVIOR OF FREE STOCHASTIC SCHRÖDINGER EVOLUTIONS

Angelo Bassi, Detlef Dürr, Martin Kolb

We discuss the time evolution of the wave function which is the solution of a stochastic Schrödinger equation describing the dynamics of a free quantum particle subject to spontaneous localizations in space. We prove global existence and uniqueness of solutions. We observe that there exist three time regimes: the collapse regime, the classical regime and the diffusive regime. Concerning the latter, we assert that the general solution converges almost surely to a diffusing Gaussian wave function having a finite spread both in position as well as in momentum. This paper corrects and completes earlier works on this issue.

arXiv:0811.1877•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2010•21 citations

Relating quantum mechanics with hydrodynamic turbulence

Roumen Tsekov, Eyal Heifetz, Eliahu Cohen

In this letter we attempt to trace back the origin of quantum uncertainty. We show that the Schrödinger equation can be mapped into the inviscid Favre-Reynolds turbulence equations of classical compressible fluids, albeit in zero temperature. Under this mapping the probability density function becomes the Reynolds time mean density of the fluid, the real and the imaginary parts of the momentum become the mean and turbulent root-mean-square velocities, respectively, where the latter obeys the first Fick law of diffusion and saturates the lower bound of the uncertainty principle. The mean pressure is proportional to the divergence of the turbulent mass flux and is the source for stochasticity. The roles of the pressure gradient force and the Reynolds stress tensor convergence, under this mapping, are illustrated in two well-known systems, namely, the 1 s orbital hydrogen atom and the 1D dynamic Gaussian wavepacket. Finally, we analyze within an independent part of the letter, a conjecture according to which this pressure results from vacuum fluctuations at the zero-point energy, mediated by random collisions of the particle with virtual photons. This suggests that the typical turbulent eddy is of the size of the Compton wavelength corresponding to a Reynolds averaging time scale which is twice the Zitterbewegung period. Moreover, according to this interpretation the quantized characteristics of the particle result from interactions with virtual photons.

Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 27, 2018•11 citations

Quantum surface diffusion in Bohmian mechanics

Salvador Miret-Artés

Surface diffusion of small adsorbates is analyzed in terms of the so-called intermediate scattering function and dynamic structure factor, observables in experiments using the well-known quasielastic Helium atom scattering and Helium spin echo techniques. The linear theory applied is an extension of the neutron scattering due to van Hove and considers the time evolution of the position of the adsorbates in the surface. This approach allows us to use a stochastic trajectory description following the classical, quantum and Bohmian frameworks. Three different regimes of motion are clearly identified in the diffusion process: ballistic, Brownian and intermediate which are well characterized, for the first two regimes, through the mean square displacements and Einstein relation for the diffusion constant. The Langevin formalism is used by considering Ohmic friction, moderate surface temperatures and small coverages. In the Bohmian framework, analyzed here, the starting point is the so-called Schrödinger-Langevin equation which is a nonlinear, logarithmic differential equation. By assuming a Gaussian function for the probability density, the corresponding quantum stochastic trajectories are given by a dressing scheme consisting of a classical stochastic trajectory followed by the center of the Gaussian wave packet, and issued from solving the Langevin equation (particle property), plus the time evolution of its width governed by the damped Pinney differential equation (wave property). The Bohmian velocity autocorrelation function is the same as the classical one when the initial spread rate is assumed to be zero. If not, in the diffusion regime, the Brownian-Bohmian motion shows a weak anomalous diffusion.

arXiv:1805.09536•Journal of Physics Communications•Sep 11, 2018•5 citations

Quantum Dynamics in Stochastic Mechanics

J. M. A. Figueiredo

A study of the non-dissipative Brownian motion in vacuum is presented. The noise source associated to the stochastic process assumed in this work is vacuum fluctuations of some quantum field capable of interact with a massive particle. For the associated Fokker-Planck equation we do a perturbation theory which has terms presenting dynamics similar to that satisfied by the probability amplitude in Quantum Theory even though the physical interpretation be classical. In particular classical observables present expected values that coincide with those calculated using Quantum Mechanics.

arXiv:physics/0111194•Nov 27, 2001•0 citations

On stochastic theories of quantum mechanics

James G. Gilson

Introduction. There exists a very comprehensive theory concerning the time development of probabilistic systems. This is the Theory of Stochastic processes (1). Quantum mechanics as described by the Schrödinger equation rests very heavily on probabilistic interpretation, and yet, after forty years of remarkably rapid advances and successes, it is not clear how it is related to stochastic theory. The formal similarity of certain aspects of, and equations used in these two theories are well known. The diffusion equation corresponds to the Schrödinger equation, a correspondence only marred by a square root of minus unity appearing with the time derivative in the latter equation. The Kolmogoroff–Chapman relation for probabilities in Brownian motion has an analogue (2) in quantum mechanics, not for probabilities though, but for the complex probability amplitudes. The uncertainty relation also has a stochastic analogue (3). Some of these analogous characteristics are actually symptomatic of the gulf which separates these two theories. There are solutions to the diffusion equation which have a very clear physical probabilistic meaning. This is not the case with the corresponding and formally similar solutions to the Schrödinger equation and is partly due to the √ − 1 mentioned earlier. The probabilistic interpretation of the solutions to the diffusion equation is direct and immediate. On the other hand, the probabilistic interpretation of the solutions, ψ of the Schrödinger equation involve the introduction of the probability density, p = ψ*ψ. One great difference between these two theories lies in their each having distinct principles of linear superposition. In Stochastic Theory probabilities are superposed and in quantum mechanics amplitudes or wave functions are superposed.

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society•Oct 1, 1968•34 citations

On the Evolution of Converging Wave Packet of an Inverted Quantum Oscillator Driven by Homogeneous Harmonic Field

Чистяков Виктор Владимирович

The problem investigated refers to periodically driven 1D quantum inverted harmonic oscillator (IHO) with the Hamiltonian of . The model is used widely in huge quantum applications concerned unstable molecular complexes and ions under laser light affection. Non-stationary Schrödinger equation (NSE) was solved analytically and numerically by means of Maple 17 with initial wave function (w.f.) of generalized Gaussian type. This one described the converging 1D probability flux and fitted well the quantum operator of initial conditions (IC). For the IC one can observe, first, the collapse of w.f. packet into extremely narrow 1D space interval of length and, second, its spreading back up to its starting half width, and all that - at dimensionless times. At certain phases j defined by W and s0 the wave packet center displayed nonharmonic oscillating behavior near some slowly drifting space position within this time interval and after that leaved onto infinity while the unlimited packet spreading. And the phases themselves served as bifurcation points separating the NSE solutions with the outgoing to from those with. In “resonant” case of the values obeyed an inverted Fermi-Dirac formula of; for differing the asymptotic of obeyed well classical law.

Вестник Российского университета дружбы народов. Серия: Математика, информатика, физика•Jan 1, 2017•0 citations
The quantum wave-function of a massive particle with small initial uncertainties (consistent with the uncertainty relation) is believed to spread very slowly, so that the dynamics is deterministic. This assumes that the classical motions for given initial data are unique. In fluid turbulence non-uniqueness due to "roughness" of the advecting velocity field is known to lead to stochastic motion of classical particles. Vanishingly small random perturbations are magnified by Richardson diffusion in a "nearly rough" velocity field so that motion remains stochastic as the noise disappears, or classical spontaneous stochasticity, . Analogies between stochastic particle motion in turbulence and quantum evolution suggest that there should be quantum spontaneous stochasticity (QSS). We show this for 1D models of a particle in a repulsive potential that is "nearly rough" with V(x)∼C∣x∣1+αV(x) \sim C|x|^{1+α}V(x)∼C∣x∣1+α at distances ∣x∣≫ℓ|x|\gg \ell∣x∣≫ℓ , for some UV cut-off ℓ\ellℓ, and for initial Gaussian wave-packet centered at 0. We consider the WKB limit with ℏ/m→0\hbar/m \to 0ℏ/m→0, then position-spread σ→0σ\to 0σ→0. The limit of the position density is non-deterministic, with equal probabilities of the particle following either of two, non-unique classical solutions and with "Richardson-like" spreading of the wave-packet. The splitting of the wave-packet occurs in a very short time t∼(ℓ1+α/C)1/2t\sim(\ell^{1+α}/C)^{1/2}t∼(ℓ1+α/C)1/2 for small ℓ\ellℓ. QSS also occurs in the scattering of a wave-packet off the rough potential, for careful fine-tuning. We also consider other semi-classical limits by a numerical solution of the Schrödinger equation, observing QSS both in position- and momentum-space. Although the wave-function remains split into two widely separated branches in the classical limit, rapid phase oscillations within each branch prevent any coherent superposition. These effects should be observable in laboratory experiments.
We discuss the time evolution of the wave function which is the solution of a stochastic Schrödinger equation describing the dynamics of a free quantum particle subject to spontaneous localizations in space. We prove global existence and uniqueness of solutions. We observe that there exist three time regimes: the collapse regime, the classical regime and the diffusive regime. Concerning the latter, we assert that the general solution converges almost surely to a diffusing Gaussian wave function having a finite spread both in position as well as in momentum. This paper corrects and completes earlier works on this issue.
In this letter we attempt to trace back the origin of quantum uncertainty. We show that the Schrödinger equation can be mapped into the inviscid Favre-Reynolds turbulence equations of classical compressible fluids, albeit in zero temperature. Under this mapping the probability density function becomes the Reynolds time mean density of the fluid, the real and the imaginary parts of the momentum become the mean and turbulent root-mean-square velocities, respectively, where the latter obeys the first Fick law of diffusion and saturates the lower bound of the uncertainty principle. The mean pressure is proportional to the divergence of the turbulent mass flux and is the source for stochasticity. The roles of the pressure gradient force and the Reynolds stress tensor convergence, under this mapping, are illustrated in two well-known systems, namely, the 1 s orbital hydrogen atom and the 1D dynamic Gaussian wavepacket. Finally, we analyze within an independent part of the letter, a conjecture according to which this pressure results from vacuum fluctuations at the zero-point energy, mediated by random collisions of the particle with virtual photons. This suggests that the typical turbulent eddy is of the size of the Compton wavelength corresponding to a Reynolds averaging time scale which is twice the Zitterbewegung period. Moreover, according to this interpretation the quantized characteristics of the particle result from interactions with virtual photons.
Surface diffusion of small adsorbates is analyzed in terms of the so-called intermediate scattering function and dynamic structure factor, observables in experiments using the well-known quasielastic Helium atom scattering and Helium spin echo techniques. The linear theory applied is an extension of the neutron scattering due to van Hove and considers the time evolution of the position of the adsorbates in the surface. This approach allows us to use a stochastic trajectory description following the classical, quantum and Bohmian frameworks. Three different regimes of motion are clearly identified in the diffusion process: ballistic, Brownian and intermediate which are well characterized, for the first two regimes, through the mean square displacements and Einstein relation for the diffusion constant. The Langevin formalism is used by considering Ohmic friction, moderate surface temperatures and small coverages. In the Bohmian framework, analyzed here, the starting point is the so-called Schrödinger-Langevin equation which is a nonlinear, logarithmic differential equation. By assuming a Gaussian function for the probability density, the corresponding quantum stochastic trajectories are given by a dressing scheme consisting of a classical stochastic trajectory followed by the center of the Gaussian wave packet, and issued from solving the Langevin equation (particle property), plus the time evolution of its width governed by the damped Pinney differential equation (wave property). The Bohmian velocity autocorrelation function is the same as the classical one when the initial spread rate is assumed to be zero. If not, in the diffusion regime, the Brownian-Bohmian motion shows a weak anomalous diffusion.
A study of the non-dissipative Brownian motion in vacuum is presented. The noise source associated to the stochastic process assumed in this work is vacuum fluctuations of some quantum field capable of interact with a massive particle. For the associated Fokker-Planck equation we do a perturbation theory which has terms presenting dynamics similar to that satisfied by the probability amplitude in Quantum Theory even though the physical interpretation be classical. In particular classical observables present expected values that coincide with those calculated using Quantum Mechanics.
Introduction. There exists a very comprehensive theory concerning the time development of probabilistic systems. This is the Theory of Stochastic processes (1). Quantum mechanics as described by the Schrödinger equation rests very heavily on probabilistic interpretation, and yet, after forty years of remarkably rapid advances and successes, it is not clear how it is related to stochastic theory. The formal similarity of certain aspects of, and equations used in these two theories are well known. The diffusion equation corresponds to the Schrödinger equation, a correspondence only marred by a square root of minus unity appearing with the time derivative in the latter equation. The Kolmogoroff–Chapman relation for probabilities in Brownian motion has an analogue (2) in quantum mechanics, not for probabilities though, but for the complex probability amplitudes. The uncertainty relation also has a stochastic analogue (3). Some of these analogous characteristics are actually symptomatic of the gulf which separates these two theories. There are solutions to the diffusion equation which have a very clear physical probabilistic meaning. This is not the case with the corresponding and formally similar solutions to the Schrödinger equation and is partly due to the √ − 1 mentioned earlier. The probabilistic interpretation of the solutions to the diffusion equation is direct and immediate. On the other hand, the probabilistic interpretation of the solutions, ψ of the Schrödinger equation involve the introduction of the probability density, p = ψ*ψ. One great difference between these two theories lies in their each having distinct principles of linear superposition. In Stochastic Theory probabilities are superposed and in quantum mechanics amplitudes or wave functions are superposed.
The problem investigated refers to periodically driven 1D quantum inverted harmonic oscillator (IHO) with the Hamiltonian of . The model is used widely in huge quantum applications concerned unstable molecular complexes and ions under laser light affection. Non-stationary Schrödinger equation (NSE) was solved analytically and numerically by means of Maple 17 with initial wave function (w.f.) of generalized Gaussian type. This one described the converging 1D probability flux and fitted well the quantum operator of initial conditions (IC). For the IC one can observe, first, the collapse of w.f. packet into extremely narrow 1D space interval of length and, second, its spreading back up to its starting half width, and all that - at dimensionless times. At certain phases j defined by W and s0 the wave packet center displayed nonharmonic oscillating behavior near some slowly drifting space position within this time interval and after that leaved onto infinity while the unlimited packet spreading. And the phases themselves served as bifurcation points separating the NSE solutions with the outgoing to from those with. In “resonant” case of the values obeyed an inverted Fermi-Dirac formula of; for differing the asymptotic of obeyed well classical law.