Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1508.05097 · Physical review. B./Physical review. B

Forward approximation as a mean-field approximation for the Anderson and many-body localization transitions

Francesca Pietracaprina, Valentina Ros, Antonello Scardicchio

Published Feb 1, 2016• 98 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper we analyze the predictions of the forward approximation in some models which exhibit an Anderson (single-body) or many-body localized phase. This approximation, which consists of summing over the amplitudes of only the shortest paths in the locator expansion, is known to overestimate the critical value of the disorder which determines the onset of the localized phase. Nevertheless, the results provided by the approximation become more and more accurate as the local coordination (dimensionality) of the graph, defined by the hopping matrix, is made larger. In this sense, the forward approximation can be regarded as a mean-field theory for the Anderson transition in infinite dimensions. The sum can be efficiently computed using transfer matrix techniques, and the results are compared with the most precise exact diagonalization results available. For the Anderson problem, we find a critical value of the disorder which is $0.9%$ off the most precise available numerical value already in 5 spatial dimensions, while for the many-body localized phase of the Heisenberg model with random fields the critical disorder ${h}_{c}=4.0\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.3$ is strikingly close to the most recent results obtained by exact diagonalization. In both cases we obtain a critical exponent $\ensuremath{\nu}=1$. In the Anderson case, the latter does not show dependence on the dimensionality, as it is common within mean-field approximations. We discuss the relevance of the correlations between the shortest paths for both the single- and many-body problems, and comment on the connections of our results with the problem of directed polymers in random medium.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.93.054201

Related papers

Investigating Localization Transitions with the Forward Approximation

Francesca Pietracaprina

In this Ph.D. thesis we review the Anderson localization problem and its relevance in the current panorama of Physics; we discuss the single- and many-body problem and the features of the localization transition. We discuss in detail the forward approximation of the locator expansion, showing how it is a powerful tool for inspecting both the single- and the many-body localization transition. We analyze its predictions in the Bethe lattice, in the hypercubic lattice, and in a many-body Heisenberg model. The approximation provides an upper bound for the transition point; this result becomes increasingly accurate as the dimensionality of the system increases. We also find that the forward approximation result can be closely approximated by a single term as long as cancellations in the full series expansion are not relevant (this happens in the single particle Anderson systems but not in the many-body case). Moreover, we study a system interacting with a mesoscopic bath which shows peculiar localization properties; this is done both analytically through the forward approximation and numerically through exact diagonalization techniques. We find that, as the coupling with the bath increases, the system goes through a crossover between two mechanisms for localization, i.e. from Anderson to Zeno localization. The stability of the localized state is a non-monotonic function of the coupling with the bath, as the increasing hybridization of the bath states allows different particle hopping processes.

•Nov 27, 2015•0 citations

Localization on Certain Graphs with Strongly Correlated Disorder

Sthitadhi Roy, David E. Logan

Many-body localization in interacting quantum systems can be cast as a disordered hopping problem on the underlying Fock-space graph. A crucial feature of the effective Fock-space disorder is that the Fock-space site energies are strongly correlated-maximally so for sites separated by a finite distance on the graph. Motivated by this, and to understand the effect of such correlations more fundamentally, we study Anderson localization on Cayley trees and random regular graphs, with maximally correlated disorder. Since such correlations suppress short distance fluctuations in the disorder potential, one might naively suppose they disfavor localization. We find however that there exists an Anderson transition, and indeed that localization is more robust in the sense that the critical disorder scales with graph connectivity K as sqrt[K], in marked contrast to KlnK in the uncorrelated case. This scaling is argued to be intimately connected to the stability of many-body localization. Our analysis centers on an exact recursive formulation for the local propagators as well as a self-consistent mean-field theory; with results corroborated using exact diagonalization.

arXiv:2007.10357•Physical Review Letters•Dec 15, 2020•42 citations

Universality in Anderson localization on random graphs with varying connectivity

Piotr Sierant, Maciej Lewenstein, Antonello Scardicchio

We perform a thorough and complete analysis of the Anderson localization transition on several models of random graphs with regular and random connectivity. The unprecedented precision and abundance of our exact diagonalization data (both spectra and eigenstates), together with new finite size scaling and statistical analysis of the graph ensembles, unveils a universal behavior which is described by two simple, integer, scaling exponents. A by-product of such analysis is a reconciliation of the tension between the results of perturbation theory coming from strong disorder and earlier numerical works, which seemed to suggest that there should be a non-ergodic region above a given value of disorder $W_{E}$ which is strictly less than the Anderson localization critical disorder $W_C$, and that of other works which suggest that there is no such region. We find that, although no separate $W_{E}$ exists from $W_C$, the length scale at which fully developed ergodicity is found diverges like $|W-W_C|^{-1}$, while the critical length over which delocalization develops is $\sim |W-W_C|^{-1/2}$. The separation of these two scales at the critical point allows for a true non-ergodic, delocalized region. In addition, by looking at eigenstates and studying leading and sub-leading terms in system size-dependence of participation entropies, we show that the former contain information about the non-ergodicity volume which becomes non-trivial already deep in the delocalized regime. We also discuss the quantitative similarities between the Anderson transition on random graphs and many-body localization transition.

arXiv:2205.14614•May 29, 2022•17 citations

Many-body localization due to correlated disorder in Fock space

Soumi Ghosh, Atithi Acharya, Subhayan Sahu +1 more

In the presence of strong enough disorder one-dimensional systems of interacting spinless fermions at nonzero filling factor are known to be in a many-body localized phase. When represented in `Fock space,' the Hamiltonian of such a system looks like that of a single `particle' hopping on a Fock lattice in the presence of a random disordered potential. The coordination number of the Fock lattice increases linearly with the system size $L$ in one dimension. Thus in the thermodynamic limit $L\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, the disordered interacting problem in one dimension maps on to an Anderson model with infinite coordination number. Despite this, this system displays localization which appears counterintuitive. A close observation of the on-site disorder potentials on the Fock lattice reveals a large degree of correlation among them as they are derived from an exponentially smaller number of on-site disorder potentials in real space. This indicates that the correlations between the on-site disorder potentials on a Fock lattice has a strong effect on the localization properties of the corresponding many-body system. This intuition is also consistent with studies of quantum random energy model where the typical mid-spectrum states are ergodic and the on-site potentials in Fock space are completely uncorrelated. In this work we perform a systematic quantitative exploration of the nature of correlations of the Fock space potential required for localization. We study different functional variations of the disorder correlation in Fock lattice by analyzing the eigenspectrum obtained through exact diagonalization. Without changing the typical strength of the on-site disorder potential in Fock lattice we show that changing the correlation strength can induce thermalization or localization in systems. From among the various forms of correlations we study, we find that only the linear variation of correlations with Hamming distance in Fock space is able to drive a thermal-MBL phase transition where the transition is driven by the correlation strength. Systems with the other forms of correlations we study are found to be ergodic.

arXiv:1901.04384•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 22, 2019•35 citations

Universality in Anderson localization on random graphs with varying connectivity

Piotr Sierant, Maciej Lewenstein, Antonello Scardicchio

We perform a thorough and complete analysis of the Anderson localization transition on several models of random graphs with regular and random connectivity. The unprecedented precision and abundance of our exact diagonalization data (both spectra and eigenstates), together with new finite size scaling and statistical analysis of the graph ensembles, unveils a universal behavior which is described by two simple, integer, scaling exponents. A by-product of such analysis is a reconciliation of the tension between the results of perturbation theory coming from strong disorder and earlier numerical works, which seemed to suggest that there should be a non-ergodic region above a given value of disorder W_{E} W E which is strictly less than the Anderson localization critical disorder W_C W C , and that of other works which suggest that there is no such region. We find that, although no separate W_{E} W E exists from W_C W C , the length scale at which fully developed ergodicity is found diverges like |W-W_C|^{-1} | W − W C | − 1 , while the critical length over which delocalization develops is \sim |W-W_C|^{-1/2} ∼ | W − W C | − 1 / 2 . The separation of these two scales at the critical point allows for a true non-ergodic, delocalized region. In addition, by looking at eigenstates and studying leading and sub-leading terms in system size-dependence of participation entropies, we show that the former contain information about the non-ergodicity volume which becomes non-trivial already deep in the delocalized regime. We also discuss the quantitative similarities between the Anderson transition on random graphs and many-body localization transition.

SciPost Physics•Aug 3, 2023•51 citations

How periodic driving stabilizes and destabilizes Anderson localization on random trees

Sthitadhi Roy, Roderich Moessner, Achilleas Lazarides

Motivated by the link between Anderson localization on high-dimensional graphs and many-body localization, we study the effect of periodic driving on Anderson localization on random trees. The time dependence is eliminated in favor of an extra dimension, resulting in an extended graph wherein the disorder is correlated along the new dimension. The extra dimension increases the number of paths between any two sites and allows for interference between their amplitudes. We study the localization problem within the forward scattering approximation (FSA), which we adapt to this extended graph. At low frequency, this favors delocalization as the availability of a large number of extra paths dominates. By contrast, at high frequency, it stabilizes localization compared to the static system. These lead to a regime of re-entrant localization in the phase diagram. Analyzing the statistics of path amplitudes within the FSA, we provide a detailed theoretical picture of the physical mechanisms governing the phase diagram.

arXiv:2101.00018•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 23, 2021•4 citations
In this paper we analyze the predictions of the forward approximation in some models which exhibit an Anderson (single-body) or many-body localized phase. This approximation, which consists of summing over the amplitudes of only the shortest paths in the locator expansion, is known to overestimate the critical value of the disorder which determines the onset of the localized phase. Nevertheless, the results provided by the approximation become more and more accurate as the local coordination (dimensionality) of the graph, defined by the hopping matrix, is made larger. In this sense, the forward approximation can be regarded as a mean-field theory for the Anderson transition in infinite dimensions. The sum can be efficiently computed using transfer matrix techniques, and the results are compared with the most precise exact diagonalization results available. For the Anderson problem, we find a critical value of the disorder which is 0.90.9%0.9 off the most precise available numerical value already in 5 spatial dimensions, while for the many-body localized phase of the Heisenberg model with random fields the critical disorder hc=4.0\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi0.3{h}_{c}=4.0\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}0.3hc​=4.0\ifmmode±\else\textpm\fi0.3 is strikingly close to the most recent results obtained by exact diagonalization. In both cases we obtain a critical exponent \ensuremathν=1\ensuremath{\nu}=1\ensuremathν=1. In the Anderson case, the latter does not show dependence on the dimensionality, as it is common within mean-field approximations. We discuss the relevance of the correlations between the shortest paths for both the single- and many-body problems, and comment on the connections of our results with the problem of directed polymers in random medium.
In this Ph.D. thesis we review the Anderson localization problem and its relevance in the current panorama of Physics; we discuss the single- and many-body problem and the features of the localization transition. We discuss in detail the forward approximation of the locator expansion, showing how it is a powerful tool for inspecting both the single- and the many-body localization transition. We analyze its predictions in the Bethe lattice, in the hypercubic lattice, and in a many-body Heisenberg model. The approximation provides an upper bound for the transition point; this result becomes increasingly accurate as the dimensionality of the system increases. We also find that the forward approximation result can be closely approximated by a single term as long as cancellations in the full series expansion are not relevant (this happens in the single particle Anderson systems but not in the many-body case). Moreover, we study a system interacting with a mesoscopic bath which shows peculiar localization properties; this is done both analytically through the forward approximation and numerically through exact diagonalization techniques. We find that, as the coupling with the bath increases, the system goes through a crossover between two mechanisms for localization, i.e. from Anderson to Zeno localization. The stability of the localized state is a non-monotonic function of the coupling with the bath, as the increasing hybridization of the bath states allows different particle hopping processes.
Many-body localization in interacting quantum systems can be cast as a disordered hopping problem on the underlying Fock-space graph. A crucial feature of the effective Fock-space disorder is that the Fock-space site energies are strongly correlated-maximally so for sites separated by a finite distance on the graph. Motivated by this, and to understand the effect of such correlations more fundamentally, we study Anderson localization on Cayley trees and random regular graphs, with maximally correlated disorder. Since such correlations suppress short distance fluctuations in the disorder potential, one might naively suppose they disfavor localization. We find however that there exists an Anderson transition, and indeed that localization is more robust in the sense that the critical disorder scales with graph connectivity K as sqrt[K], in marked contrast to KlnK in the uncorrelated case. This scaling is argued to be intimately connected to the stability of many-body localization. Our analysis centers on an exact recursive formulation for the local propagators as well as a self-consistent mean-field theory; with results corroborated using exact diagonalization.
We perform a thorough and complete analysis of the Anderson localization transition on several models of random graphs with regular and random connectivity. The unprecedented precision and abundance of our exact diagonalization data (both spectra and eigenstates), together with new finite size scaling and statistical analysis of the graph ensembles, unveils a universal behavior which is described by two simple, integer, scaling exponents. A by-product of such analysis is a reconciliation of the tension between the results of perturbation theory coming from strong disorder and earlier numerical works, which seemed to suggest that there should be a non-ergodic region above a given value of disorder WEW_{E}WE​ which is strictly less than the Anderson localization critical disorder WCW_CWC​, and that of other works which suggest that there is no such region. We find that, although no separate WEW_{E}WE​ exists from WCW_CWC​, the length scale at which fully developed ergodicity is found diverges like ∣W−WC∣−1|W-W_C|^{-1}∣W−WC​∣−1, while the critical length over which delocalization develops is ∼∣W−WC∣−1/2\sim |W-W_C|^{-1/2}∼∣W−WC​∣−1/2. The separation of these two scales at the critical point allows for a true non-ergodic, delocalized region. In addition, by looking at eigenstates and studying leading and sub-leading terms in system size-dependence of participation entropies, we show that the former contain information about the non-ergodicity volume which becomes non-trivial already deep in the delocalized regime. We also discuss the quantitative similarities between the Anderson transition on random graphs and many-body localization transition.
In the presence of strong enough disorder one-dimensional systems of interacting spinless fermions at nonzero filling factor are known to be in a many-body localized phase. When represented in `Fock space,' the Hamiltonian of such a system looks like that of a single `particle' hopping on a Fock lattice in the presence of a random disordered potential. The coordination number of the Fock lattice increases linearly with the system size LLL in one dimension. Thus in the thermodynamic limit $L\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, the disordered interacting problem in one dimension maps on to an Anderson model with infinite coordination number. Despite this, this system displays localization which appears counterintuitive. A close observation of the on-site disorder potentials on the Fock lattice reveals a large degree of correlation among them as they are derived from an exponentially smaller number of on-site disorder potentials in real space. This indicates that the correlations between the on-site disorder potentials on a Fock lattice has a strong effect on the localization properties of the corresponding many-body system. This intuition is also consistent with studies of quantum random energy model where the typical mid-spectrum states are ergodic and the on-site potentials in Fock space are completely uncorrelated. In this work we perform a systematic quantitative exploration of the nature of correlations of the Fock space potential required for localization. We study different functional variations of the disorder correlation in Fock lattice by analyzing the eigenspectrum obtained through exact diagonalization. Without changing the typical strength of the on-site disorder potential in Fock lattice we show that changing the correlation strength can induce thermalization or localization in systems. From among the various forms of correlations we study, we find that only the linear variation of correlations with Hamming distance in Fock space is able to drive a thermal-MBL phase transition where the transition is driven by the correlation strength. Systems with the other forms of correlations we study are found to be ergodic.
We perform a thorough and complete analysis of the Anderson localization transition on several models of random graphs with regular and random connectivity. The unprecedented precision and abundance of our exact diagonalization data (both spectra and eigenstates), together with new finite size scaling and statistical analysis of the graph ensembles, unveils a universal behavior which is described by two simple, integer, scaling exponents. A by-product of such analysis is a reconciliation of the tension between the results of perturbation theory coming from strong disorder and earlier numerical works, which seemed to suggest that there should be a non-ergodic region above a given value of disorder W_{E} W E which is strictly less than the Anderson localization critical disorder W_C W C , and that of other works which suggest that there is no such region. We find that, although no separate W_{E} W E exists from W_C W C , the length scale at which fully developed ergodicity is found diverges like |W-W_C|^{-1} | W − W C | − 1 , while the critical length over which delocalization develops is \sim |W-W_C|^{-1/2} ∼ | W − W C | − 1 / 2 . The separation of these two scales at the critical point allows for a true non-ergodic, delocalized region. In addition, by looking at eigenstates and studying leading and sub-leading terms in system size-dependence of participation entropies, we show that the former contain information about the non-ergodicity volume which becomes non-trivial already deep in the delocalized regime. We also discuss the quantitative similarities between the Anderson transition on random graphs and many-body localization transition.
Motivated by the link between Anderson localization on high-dimensional graphs and many-body localization, we study the effect of periodic driving on Anderson localization on random trees. The time dependence is eliminated in favor of an extra dimension, resulting in an extended graph wherein the disorder is correlated along the new dimension. The extra dimension increases the number of paths between any two sites and allows for interference between their amplitudes. We study the localization problem within the forward scattering approximation (FSA), which we adapt to this extended graph. At low frequency, this favors delocalization as the availability of a large number of extra paths dominates. By contrast, at high frequency, it stabilizes localization compared to the static system. These lead to a regime of re-entrant localization in the phase diagram. Analyzing the statistics of path amplitudes within the FSA, we provide a detailed theoretical picture of the physical mechanisms governing the phase diagram.