Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1508.02658

Modified Bohms Dynamics: A Stable Version

Kazemi, Mohammad Javad, Meysam Mashhadi, Mohammad Hosein Barati

Published Aug 11, 2015• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Recently, it has been shown that the quantum equilibrium distribution in the original Bohm's model is unstable and so it isn't a tenable physical theory [Proc. R. Soc. A 470 20140288 (2014)]. In this paper we show that a natural modification of the Bohm's quantum force leads to a stable quantum equilibrium without any change to statistical predictions of this model in equilibrium state. Moreover, it is shown that an initial non-equilibrium phase space distribution relaxes to equilibrium distribution via a coarse grained H-theorem. But before end of the relaxation process, for example in the early universe, this modified quantum force can lead to the new predictions beyond standard quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1508.02658

Related papers

Instability of quantum equilibrium in Bohm's dynamics

Samuel Colin, Antony Valentini

We consider Bohm's second-order dynamics for arbitrary initial conditions in phase space. In principle, Bohm's dynamics allows for 'extended' non-equilibrium, with initial momenta not equal to the gradient of phase of the wave function (as well as initial positions whose distribution departs from the Born rule). We show that extended non-equilibrium does not relax in general and is in fact unstable. This is in sharp contrast with de Broglie's first-order dynamics, for which non-standard momenta are not allowed and which shows an efficient relaxation to the Born rule for positions. On this basis, we argue that, while de Broglie's dynamics is a tenable physical theory, Bohm's dynamics is not. In a world governed by Bohm's dynamics, there would be no reason to expect to see an effective quantum theory today (even approximately), in contradiction with observation.

arXiv:1306.1576•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Sep 3, 2014•33 citations

Quantum non-equilibrium and relaxation to equilibrium for a class of de Broglie–Bohm-type theories

Samuel Colin, Ward Struyve

The de Broglie–Bohm theory is about non-relativistic point-particles that move deterministically along trajectories. The theory reproduces the predictions of standard quantum theory, given that the distribution of particles over an ensemble of systems, all described by the same wavefunction ψ, equals the quantum equilibrium distribution |ψ| 2 . Numerical simulations done by Valentini and Westman (2005 Proc. R. Soc. A 461 253) have illustrated that non-equilibrium particle distributions may relax to quantum equilibrium after some time. Here we consider non-equilibrium distributions and their relaxation properties for a particular class of trajectory theories (first studied in detail by Deotto and Ghirardi (1998 Found. Phys. 28 1)) that are empirically equivalent to the de Broglie–Bohm theory in quantum equilibrium. In the examples we studied of such theories, we found a speed-up of the relaxation, compared to the ordinary de Broglie–Bohm theory. Hence non-equilibrium predictions that depend strongly on relaxation properties, such as those studied recently by Valentini, may vary across different trajectory theories. As such, these theories might be experimentally distinguishable.

arXiv:0911.2823•New Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 2010•31 citations

Dynamical quantum phase transitions (Review Article)

Andrei A. Zvyagin

During recent years the interest to dynamics of quantum systems has grown considerably. Quantum many body systems out of equilibrium often manifest behavior, different from the one predicted by standard statistical mechanics and thermodynamics in equilibrium. Since the dynamics of a many-body quantum system typically involve many excited eigenstates, with a non-thermal distribution, the time evolution of such a system provides an unique way for investigation of non-equilibrium quantum statistical mechanics. Last decade such new subjects like quantum quenches, thermalization, pre-thermalization, equilibration, generalized Gibbs ensemble, etc. are among the most attractive topics of investigation in modern quantum physics. One of the most interesting themes in the study of dynamics of quantum many-body systems out of equilibrium is connected with the recently proposed important concept of dynamical quantum phase transitions. During the last few years a great progress has been achieved in studying of those singularities in the time dependence of characteristics of quantum mechanical systems, in particular, in understanding how the quantum critical points of equilibrium thermodynamics affect their dynamical properties. Dynamical quantum phase transitions reveal universality, scaling, connection to the topology, and many other interesting features. Here we review the recent achievements of this quickly developing part of low-temperature quantum physics. The study of dynamical quantum phase transitions is especially important in context of their connection to the problem of the modern theory of quantum information, where namely non-equilibrium dynamics of many-body quantum system plays the major role.

arXiv:1701.08851•Low Temperature Physics•Nov 1, 2016•157 citations

Bohm’s quantum-force time series: Stable distribution, flat power spectrum, and implication

Boon Leong Lan

New insight into the nature of Bohm's quantum force is presented. Based on our numerical study, we conclude that, for the kicked pendulum, Bohm's quantum-force time-series for nonstationary states is typically or generically non-Gaussian stable distributed with a flat power spectrum. For fixed system parameters and initial wave function, the stable parameters and the constant value of the power spectrum are independent of the initial Bohmian angle. We conjecture that these properties of the quantum-force time-series are also typical or generic for other classically chaotic Hamiltonian dynamical systems since the kicked pendulum is a prototypical member of this class of systems. A new method of calculating the quantum probability density of a particle's position implied by these quantum-force properties is described.

Physical Review A•Mar 16, 2001•13 citations

Dynamical origin of quantum probabilities

Antony Valentini, Hans Westman

We study the origin of the Born probability rule ρ = | ψ | 2 in the de Broglie–Bohm pilot–wave formulation of quantum theory. It is argued that quantum probabilities arise dynamically, and have a status similar to thermal probabilities in ordinary statistical mechanics. This is illustrated by numerical simulations for a two–dimensional system. We show that a simple initial ensemble, with a non–standard distribution ρ ≠ | ψ | 2 of particle positions, evolves towards the quantum distribution to high accuracy. The relaxation process ρ →| ψ | 2 is quantified in terms of a coarse–grained H –function (equal to minus the relative entropy of ρ with respect to | ψ | 2 ), which is found to decrease approximately exponentially over time, with a time constant that accords with a simple theoretical estimate.

arXiv:quant-ph/0403034•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Oct 26, 2004•237 citations

Time scales for dynamical relaxation to the Born rule

Mike D. Towler, N. J. Russell, Antony Valentini

We illustrate through explicit numerical calculations how the Born rule probability densities of non-relativistic quantum mechanics emerge naturally from the particle dynamics of de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory. The time evolution of a particle distribution initially not equal to the absolute square of the wave function is calculated for a particle in a two-dimensional infinite potential square well. Under the de Broglie–Bohm ontology, the box contains an objectively existing ‘pilot wave’ which guides the electron trajectory, and this is represented mathematically by a Schrödinger wave function composed of a finite out-of-phase superposition of M energy eigenstates (with M ranging from 4 to 64). The electron density distributions are found to evolve naturally into the Born rule ones and stay there; in analogy with the classical case this represents a decay to ‘quantum equilibrium’. The proximity to equilibrium is characterized by the coarse-grained subquantum H -function which is found to decrease roughly exponentially towards zero over the course of time. The time scale τ for this relaxation is calculated for various values of M and the coarse-graining length ε . Its dependence on M is found to disagree with an earlier theoretical prediction. A power law, τ ∝ M −1 , is found to be fairly robust for all coarse-graining lengths and, although a weak dependence of τ on ε is observed, it does not appear to follow any straightforward scaling. A theoretical analysis is presented to explain these results. This improvement in our understanding of time scales for relaxation to quantum equilibrium is likely to be of use in the development of models of relaxation in the early Universe, with a view to constraining possible violations of the Born rule in inflationary cosmology.

arXiv:1103.1589•Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Nov 30, 2011•123 citations
Recently, it has been shown that the quantum equilibrium distribution in the original Bohm's model is unstable and so it isn't a tenable physical theory [Proc. R. Soc. A 470 20140288 (2014)]. In this paper we show that a natural modification of the Bohm's quantum force leads to a stable quantum equilibrium without any change to statistical predictions of this model in equilibrium state. Moreover, it is shown that an initial non-equilibrium phase space distribution relaxes to equilibrium distribution via a coarse grained H-theorem. But before end of the relaxation process, for example in the early universe, this modified quantum force can lead to the new predictions beyond standard quantum mechanics.
We consider Bohm's second-order dynamics for arbitrary initial conditions in phase space. In principle, Bohm's dynamics allows for 'extended' non-equilibrium, with initial momenta not equal to the gradient of phase of the wave function (as well as initial positions whose distribution departs from the Born rule). We show that extended non-equilibrium does not relax in general and is in fact unstable. This is in sharp contrast with de Broglie's first-order dynamics, for which non-standard momenta are not allowed and which shows an efficient relaxation to the Born rule for positions. On this basis, we argue that, while de Broglie's dynamics is a tenable physical theory, Bohm's dynamics is not. In a world governed by Bohm's dynamics, there would be no reason to expect to see an effective quantum theory today (even approximately), in contradiction with observation.
The de Broglie–Bohm theory is about non-relativistic point-particles that move deterministically along trajectories. The theory reproduces the predictions of standard quantum theory, given that the distribution of particles over an ensemble of systems, all described by the same wavefunction ψ, equals the quantum equilibrium distribution |ψ| 2 . Numerical simulations done by Valentini and Westman (2005 Proc. R. Soc. A 461 253) have illustrated that non-equilibrium particle distributions may relax to quantum equilibrium after some time. Here we consider non-equilibrium distributions and their relaxation properties for a particular class of trajectory theories (first studied in detail by Deotto and Ghirardi (1998 Found. Phys. 28 1)) that are empirically equivalent to the de Broglie–Bohm theory in quantum equilibrium. In the examples we studied of such theories, we found a speed-up of the relaxation, compared to the ordinary de Broglie–Bohm theory. Hence non-equilibrium predictions that depend strongly on relaxation properties, such as those studied recently by Valentini, may vary across different trajectory theories. As such, these theories might be experimentally distinguishable.
During recent years the interest to dynamics of quantum systems has grown considerably. Quantum many body systems out of equilibrium often manifest behavior, different from the one predicted by standard statistical mechanics and thermodynamics in equilibrium. Since the dynamics of a many-body quantum system typically involve many excited eigenstates, with a non-thermal distribution, the time evolution of such a system provides an unique way for investigation of non-equilibrium quantum statistical mechanics. Last decade such new subjects like quantum quenches, thermalization, pre-thermalization, equilibration, generalized Gibbs ensemble, etc. are among the most attractive topics of investigation in modern quantum physics. One of the most interesting themes in the study of dynamics of quantum many-body systems out of equilibrium is connected with the recently proposed important concept of dynamical quantum phase transitions. During the last few years a great progress has been achieved in studying of those singularities in the time dependence of characteristics of quantum mechanical systems, in particular, in understanding how the quantum critical points of equilibrium thermodynamics affect their dynamical properties. Dynamical quantum phase transitions reveal universality, scaling, connection to the topology, and many other interesting features. Here we review the recent achievements of this quickly developing part of low-temperature quantum physics. The study of dynamical quantum phase transitions is especially important in context of their connection to the problem of the modern theory of quantum information, where namely non-equilibrium dynamics of many-body quantum system plays the major role.
New insight into the nature of Bohm's quantum force is presented. Based on our numerical study, we conclude that, for the kicked pendulum, Bohm's quantum-force time-series for nonstationary states is typically or generically non-Gaussian stable distributed with a flat power spectrum. For fixed system parameters and initial wave function, the stable parameters and the constant value of the power spectrum are independent of the initial Bohmian angle. We conjecture that these properties of the quantum-force time-series are also typical or generic for other classically chaotic Hamiltonian dynamical systems since the kicked pendulum is a prototypical member of this class of systems. A new method of calculating the quantum probability density of a particle's position implied by these quantum-force properties is described.
We study the origin of the Born probability rule ρ = | ψ | 2 in the de Broglie–Bohm pilot–wave formulation of quantum theory. It is argued that quantum probabilities arise dynamically, and have a status similar to thermal probabilities in ordinary statistical mechanics. This is illustrated by numerical simulations for a two–dimensional system. We show that a simple initial ensemble, with a non–standard distribution ρ ≠ | ψ | 2 of particle positions, evolves towards the quantum distribution to high accuracy. The relaxation process ρ →| ψ | 2 is quantified in terms of a coarse–grained H –function (equal to minus the relative entropy of ρ with respect to | ψ | 2 ), which is found to decrease approximately exponentially over time, with a time constant that accords with a simple theoretical estimate.
We illustrate through explicit numerical calculations how the Born rule probability densities of non-relativistic quantum mechanics emerge naturally from the particle dynamics of de Broglie–Bohm pilot-wave theory. The time evolution of a particle distribution initially not equal to the absolute square of the wave function is calculated for a particle in a two-dimensional infinite potential square well. Under the de Broglie–Bohm ontology, the box contains an objectively existing ‘pilot wave’ which guides the electron trajectory, and this is represented mathematically by a Schrödinger wave function composed of a finite out-of-phase superposition of M energy eigenstates (with M ranging from 4 to 64). The electron density distributions are found to evolve naturally into the Born rule ones and stay there; in analogy with the classical case this represents a decay to ‘quantum equilibrium’. The proximity to equilibrium is characterized by the coarse-grained subquantum H -function which is found to decrease roughly exponentially towards zero over the course of time. The time scale τ for this relaxation is calculated for various values of M and the coarse-graining length ε . Its dependence on M is found to disagree with an earlier theoretical prediction. A power law, τ ∝ M −1 , is found to be fairly robust for all coarse-graining lengths and, although a weak dependence of τ on ε is observed, it does not appear to follow any straightforward scaling. A theoretical analysis is presented to explain these results. This improvement in our understanding of time scales for relaxation to quantum equilibrium is likely to be of use in the development of models of relaxation in the early Universe, with a view to constraining possible violations of the Born rule in inflationary cosmology.