Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1507.04099 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Linear dependencies between composite fermion states

M L Meyer, O Liabøtrø, S Viefers

Published Sep 7, 2016• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The formalism of composite fermions (CFs) has been one of the most prominent and successful approaches to describing the fractional quantum Hall effect, in terms of trial many-body wave functions. Testing the accuracy of the latter typically involves rather heavy numerical comparison to exact diagonalization results. Thus, optimizing computational efficiency has been an important technical issue in this field. One generic (and not yet fully understood) property of the CF approach is that it tends to overcount the number of linearly independent candidate states for fixed sets of quantum numbers. Technically speaking, CF Slater determinants that are orthogonal before projection to the lowest Landau level, may lead to wave functions that are identical, or possess linear dependencies, after projection. This leads to unnecessary computations, and has been pointed out in the literature both for fermionic and bosonic systems. We here present a systematic approach that enables us to reveal all linear dependencies between bosonic compact states in the lowest CF ‘cyclotron energy’ sub-band, and almost all dependencies in higher sub-bands, at the level of the CF Slater determinants, i.e. before projection, which implies a major computational simplification. Our approach is introduced for so-called simple states of two-species rotating bosons, and then generalized to generic compact bosonic states, both one- and two-species. Some perspectives also apply to fermionic systems. The identities and linear dependencies we find, are analytically exact for ‘brute force’ projection in the disk geometry.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/49/39/395201

Related papers

A Novel Projection: Towards a Deeper Understanding of Mathematical Structures in the Composite Fermion Formalism

Knut Halvor Helland

Composite fermion (CF) wave functions are used to describe both a two dimensional electron gas in a strong magnetic field (the quantum Hall effect system) and rotating two dimensional atomic gases that can be either bosons or fermions. In this thesis a new method for projecting fermionic CF wave functions (here called method 3) to the lowest Landau level is investigated. The new projection is based on attaching a Jastrow factor to a bosonic CF wave function projected in the standard way. This will be compared to two other projection methods: method 1 or Girvin-Jach projection and method 2 or Jain-Kamilla projection. I compare the minimal cyclotron energy compact CF ground state candidates for the ∇²δ interaction both to each other and to the exact ground state found by numerical diagonalization for up to 8 particles. The conclusion is that the CF candidates typically are good approximations of the exact ground state, and that method 3 is almost as good as the other two at this. An important motivation for method 3 is that it preserves linear dependencies from the bosonic states. The puzzle of linear dependencies is a part of CF theory that is not properly understood. Certain important results for low angular momentum states have been found for the bosonic case. Since method 3 works quite well in the cases tested here some of these results can be imported to the fermionic case. I have compared the linear dependencies among minimal cyclotron energy compact states for all three projection methods. If approximate linear dependencies are considered as proper linear dependencies then for all tested cases the same linear dependencies hold for all three projection methods, up to slightly different coefficients.

•Jan 1, 2018•0 citations

Composite fermion basis for two-component Bose gases

Ola Liabøtrø, Marius Meyer

Despite its success, the composite fermion (CF) construction possesses some mathematical features that have not been fully understood until recently. In particular, this construction is known to produce wave functions that are not necessarily orthogonal, or even linearly independent, after projection to the lowest Landau level. While this is usually not a problem in practice in the quantum Hall regime, we have previously shown that it presents a technical challenge for rotating Bose gases with low angular momenta. These are systems where the CF approach yields surprisingly good approximations to the exact eigenstates of weak short-range interactions, and so solving the problem of linearly dependent wave functions is of interest. It can also be useful for studying higher bands of fermionic quantum Hall states. Here we present several ways of constructing a basis for the space of so-called ``simple'' CF states for two-component rotating Bose gases in the lowest Landau level, and prove that they all give sets of linearly independent wave functions that span the space. Using this basis, we study the structure of the lowest-lying state using so-called restricted wave functions. We also examine the scaling of the overlap between the exact and CF wave functions at the maximal possible angular momentum for simple states.

arXiv:1701.04278•Physical Review A•Mar 30, 2017•2 citations

Composite fermion theory: A microscopic derivation without Landau level projection

Bo Yang

The composite fermion (CF) theory gives both a phenomenological description for many fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states, as well as a microscopic construction for large scale numerical calculation of these topological phases. The fundamental postulate of mapping FQH states of electrons to integer quantum Hall (IQH) states of CFs, however, was not formally established. The Landau level (LL) projection needed for the microscopic calculations is in some sense uncontrolled and unpredictable. We rigorously derive the unitary relationship between electrons and the CFs, showing the latter naturally emerge from special interactions within a single LL, without resorting to any projection by hand. In this framework, all FQH states topologically equivalent to those described by the conventional CF theory (e.g., the Jain series) have exact model Hamiltonians that can be explicitly derived, and we can easily generalize to FQH states from interacting CFs. Our derivations reveal fundamental connections between the CF theory and the pseudopotential/Jack polynomial constructions, and argue that all Abelian CF states are physically equivalent to the IQH states, while a plethora of non-Abelian CF states can be systematically constructed and classified. We also discuss about implications to experiments and effective field theory descriptions based on the descriptions with CFs as elementary particles.

arXiv:2207.12418•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Dec 16, 2022•7 citations

A duality construction for interacting quantum Hall systems

Johannes N. Kriel

ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The fractional quantum Hall effect represents a true many-body phenomenon in which the \ncollective behaviour of interacting electrons plays a central role. In contrast to its integral \ncounterpart, the appearance of a mobility gap in the fractional quantum Hall regime is due \nentirely to the Coulomb interaction and is not the result of a perturbed single particle gap. \nThe bulk of our theoretical understanding of the underlying many-body problem is based on \nLaughlin’s ansatz wave function and the composite fermion picture proposed by Jain. In the \nlatter the fractional quantum Hall effect of interacting electrons is formulated as the integral \nquantum Hall effect of weakly interacting quasiparticles called composite fermions. The composite \nfermion picture provides a qualitative description of the interacting system’s low-energy \nspectrum and leads to a generalisation of Laughlin’s wave functions for the electron ground \nstate. These predictions have been verified through extensive numerical tests. \nIn this work we present an alternative formulation of the composite fermion picture within \na more rigorous mathematical framework. Our goal is to establish the relation between the \nstrongly interacting electron problem and its dual description in terms of weakly interacting \nquasiparticles on the level of the microscopic Hamiltonian itself. This allows us to derive an \nanalytic expression for the interaction induced excitation gap which agrees very well with existing \nnumerical results. We also formulate a mapping between the states of the free particle and \ninteracting descriptions in which the characteristic Jastrow-Slater structure of the composite \nfermion ansatz appears naturally. Our formalism also serves to clarify several aspects of the \nstandard heuristic construction, particularly with regard to the emergence of the effective magnetic \nfield and the role of higher Landau levels. We also resolve a long standing issue regarding \nthe overlap of unprojected composite fermion trial wave functions with the lowest Landau level \nof the free particle Hamiltonian.

•Mar 1, 2011•0 citations

Composite fermion basis for M -component Bose gases

Vidar Skogvoll, Ola Liabøtrø

Abstract The composite fermion (CF) formalism produces wave functions that are not always linearly independent. This is especially so in the low angular momentum regime in the lowest Landau level, where a subclass of CF states, known as simple states, gives a good description of the low energy spectrum. For the two-component Bose gas, explicit bases avoiding the large number of redundant states have been found. We generalize one of these bases to the M -component Bose gas and prove its validity. We also show that the numbers of linearly independent simple states for different values of angular momentum are given by coefficients of q -multinomials.

arXiv:1704.01772•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 14, 2017•0 citations

Composite Fermions in the Hilbert Space of the Lowest Electronic Landau Level

Jainendra K. Jain, Rajiv K. Kamilla

Single particle basis functions for composite fermions are obtained from which many-composite fermion states confined to the lowest electronic Landau level can be constructed in the standard manner, i.e. by building Slater determinants. This representation enables a Monte Carlo study of systems containing a large number of composite fermions, yielding new quantitative and qualitative information. The ground state energy and the gaps to charged and neutral excitations are computed for a number of fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) states, earlier off-limits to a quantitative investigation. The ground state energies are estimated to be accurate to ~0.1% and the gaps at the level of a few percent. It is also shown that at Landau level fillings smaller than or equal to 1/9 the FQHE is unstable to a spontaneous creation of excitons of composite fermions. In addition, this approach provides new conceptual insight into the structure of the composite fermion wave functions, resolving in the affirmative the question of whether it is possible to motivate the composite fermion theory entirely within the lowest Landau level, without appealing to higher Landau levels.

arXiv:cond-mat/9704031•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Sep 10, 1997•237 citations
Abstract The formalism of composite fermions (CFs) has been one of the most prominent and successful approaches to describing the fractional quantum Hall effect, in terms of trial many-body wave functions. Testing the accuracy of the latter typically involves rather heavy numerical comparison to exact diagonalization results. Thus, optimizing computational efficiency has been an important technical issue in this field. One generic (and not yet fully understood) property of the CF approach is that it tends to overcount the number of linearly independent candidate states for fixed sets of quantum numbers. Technically speaking, CF Slater determinants that are orthogonal before projection to the lowest Landau level, may lead to wave functions that are identical, or possess linear dependencies, after projection. This leads to unnecessary computations, and has been pointed out in the literature both for fermionic and bosonic systems. We here present a systematic approach that enables us to reveal all linear dependencies between bosonic compact states in the lowest CF ‘cyclotron energy’ sub-band, and almost all dependencies in higher sub-bands, at the level of the CF Slater determinants, i.e. before projection, which implies a major computational simplification. Our approach is introduced for so-called simple states of two-species rotating bosons, and then generalized to generic compact bosonic states, both one- and two-species. Some perspectives also apply to fermionic systems. The identities and linear dependencies we find, are analytically exact for ‘brute force’ projection in the disk geometry.
Composite fermion (CF) wave functions are used to describe both a two dimensional electron gas in a strong magnetic field (the quantum Hall effect system) and rotating two dimensional atomic gases that can be either bosons or fermions. In this thesis a new method for projecting fermionic CF wave functions (here called method 3) to the lowest Landau level is investigated. The new projection is based on attaching a Jastrow factor to a bosonic CF wave function projected in the standard way. This will be compared to two other projection methods: method 1 or Girvin-Jach projection and method 2 or Jain-Kamilla projection. I compare the minimal cyclotron energy compact CF ground state candidates for the ∇²δ interaction both to each other and to the exact ground state found by numerical diagonalization for up to 8 particles. The conclusion is that the CF candidates typically are good approximations of the exact ground state, and that method 3 is almost as good as the other two at this. An important motivation for method 3 is that it preserves linear dependencies from the bosonic states. The puzzle of linear dependencies is a part of CF theory that is not properly understood. Certain important results for low angular momentum states have been found for the bosonic case. Since method 3 works quite well in the cases tested here some of these results can be imported to the fermionic case. I have compared the linear dependencies among minimal cyclotron energy compact states for all three projection methods. If approximate linear dependencies are considered as proper linear dependencies then for all tested cases the same linear dependencies hold for all three projection methods, up to slightly different coefficients.
Despite its success, the composite fermion (CF) construction possesses some mathematical features that have not been fully understood until recently. In particular, this construction is known to produce wave functions that are not necessarily orthogonal, or even linearly independent, after projection to the lowest Landau level. While this is usually not a problem in practice in the quantum Hall regime, we have previously shown that it presents a technical challenge for rotating Bose gases with low angular momenta. These are systems where the CF approach yields surprisingly good approximations to the exact eigenstates of weak short-range interactions, and so solving the problem of linearly dependent wave functions is of interest. It can also be useful for studying higher bands of fermionic quantum Hall states. Here we present several ways of constructing a basis for the space of so-called ``simple'' CF states for two-component rotating Bose gases in the lowest Landau level, and prove that they all give sets of linearly independent wave functions that span the space. Using this basis, we study the structure of the lowest-lying state using so-called restricted wave functions. We also examine the scaling of the overlap between the exact and CF wave functions at the maximal possible angular momentum for simple states.
The composite fermion (CF) theory gives both a phenomenological description for many fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states, as well as a microscopic construction for large scale numerical calculation of these topological phases. The fundamental postulate of mapping FQH states of electrons to integer quantum Hall (IQH) states of CFs, however, was not formally established. The Landau level (LL) projection needed for the microscopic calculations is in some sense uncontrolled and unpredictable. We rigorously derive the unitary relationship between electrons and the CFs, showing the latter naturally emerge from special interactions within a single LL, without resorting to any projection by hand. In this framework, all FQH states topologically equivalent to those described by the conventional CF theory (e.g., the Jain series) have exact model Hamiltonians that can be explicitly derived, and we can easily generalize to FQH states from interacting CFs. Our derivations reveal fundamental connections between the CF theory and the pseudopotential/Jack polynomial constructions, and argue that all Abelian CF states are physically equivalent to the IQH states, while a plethora of non-Abelian CF states can be systematically constructed and classified. We also discuss about implications to experiments and effective field theory descriptions based on the descriptions with CFs as elementary particles.
ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The fractional quantum Hall effect represents a true many-body phenomenon in which the \ncollective behaviour of interacting electrons plays a central role. In contrast to its integral \ncounterpart, the appearance of a mobility gap in the fractional quantum Hall regime is due \nentirely to the Coulomb interaction and is not the result of a perturbed single particle gap. \nThe bulk of our theoretical understanding of the underlying many-body problem is based on \nLaughlin’s ansatz wave function and the composite fermion picture proposed by Jain. In the \nlatter the fractional quantum Hall effect of interacting electrons is formulated as the integral \nquantum Hall effect of weakly interacting quasiparticles called composite fermions. The composite \nfermion picture provides a qualitative description of the interacting system’s low-energy \nspectrum and leads to a generalisation of Laughlin’s wave functions for the electron ground \nstate. These predictions have been verified through extensive numerical tests. \nIn this work we present an alternative formulation of the composite fermion picture within \na more rigorous mathematical framework. Our goal is to establish the relation between the \nstrongly interacting electron problem and its dual description in terms of weakly interacting \nquasiparticles on the level of the microscopic Hamiltonian itself. This allows us to derive an \nanalytic expression for the interaction induced excitation gap which agrees very well with existing \nnumerical results. We also formulate a mapping between the states of the free particle and \ninteracting descriptions in which the characteristic Jastrow-Slater structure of the composite \nfermion ansatz appears naturally. Our formalism also serves to clarify several aspects of the \nstandard heuristic construction, particularly with regard to the emergence of the effective magnetic \nfield and the role of higher Landau levels. We also resolve a long standing issue regarding \nthe overlap of unprojected composite fermion trial wave functions with the lowest Landau level \nof the free particle Hamiltonian.
Abstract The composite fermion (CF) formalism produces wave functions that are not always linearly independent. This is especially so in the low angular momentum regime in the lowest Landau level, where a subclass of CF states, known as simple states, gives a good description of the low energy spectrum. For the two-component Bose gas, explicit bases avoiding the large number of redundant states have been found. We generalize one of these bases to the M -component Bose gas and prove its validity. We also show that the numbers of linearly independent simple states for different values of angular momentum are given by coefficients of q -multinomials.
Single particle basis functions for composite fermions are obtained from which many-composite fermion states confined to the lowest electronic Landau level can be constructed in the standard manner, i.e. by building Slater determinants. This representation enables a Monte Carlo study of systems containing a large number of composite fermions, yielding new quantitative and qualitative information. The ground state energy and the gaps to charged and neutral excitations are computed for a number of fractional quantum Hall effect (FQHE) states, earlier off-limits to a quantitative investigation. The ground state energies are estimated to be accurate to ~0.1% and the gaps at the level of a few percent. It is also shown that at Landau level fillings smaller than or equal to 1/9 the FQHE is unstable to a spontaneous creation of excitons of composite fermions. In addition, this approach provides new conceptual insight into the structure of the composite fermion wave functions, resolving in the affirmative the question of whether it is possible to motivate the composite fermion theory entirely within the lowest Landau level, without appealing to higher Landau levels.