Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1506.03305 · European Journal of Physics

A physically motivated quantization of the electromagnetic field

Robert G. Bennett, Thomas M. Barlow, Almut Beige

Published Oct 30, 2015• 37 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The notion that the electromagnetic field is quantized is usually inferred from observations such as the photoelectric effect and the black-body spectrum. However accounts of the quantization of this field are usually mathematically motivated and begin by introducing a vector potential, followed by the imposition of a gauge that allows the manipulation of the solutions of Maxwell's equations into a form that is amenable for the machinery of canonical quantization. By contrast, here we quantize the electromagnetic field in a less mathematically and more physically motivated way. Starting from a direct description of what one sees in experiments, we show that the usual expressions of the electric and magnetic field observables follow from Heisenberg's equation of motion. In our treatment, there is no need to invoke the vector potential in a specific gauge and we avoid the commonly used notion of a fictitious cavity that applies boundary conditions to the field.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/37/1/014001

Related papers

Quantum Maxwell's Equations Made Simple: Employing Scalar and Vector Potential Formulation

Weng Cho Chew, Dong-Yeop Na, Peter A. Bermel +3 more

We present a succinct way to quantize Maxwell's equations. We begin by discussing the random nature of quantum observables. Then we present the quantum Maxwell's equations and give their physical meanings. Due to the mathematical homomorphism between the classical and quantum cases [1], the derivation of quantum Maxwell's equations can be simplified. First, one needs only to verify that the classical equations of motion are derivable from a Hamiltonian by energy-conservation arguments. Then the quantum equations of motion follow due to homomorphism, which applies to sum-separable Hamiltonians. Hence, we first show the derivation of classical Maxwell's equations using Hamiltonian theory. Then the derivation of the quantum Maxwell's equations follows in an analogous fashion. Finally, we apply this quantization procedure to the dispersive medium case. (This article is written for the classical electromagnetic community assuming little knowledge of quantum theory, an introduction of which can be found in [2, Lecs. 38 and 39].)

IEEE Antennas and Propagation Magazine•Dec 9, 2020•29 citations

Source-Free Electromagnetism's Canonical Fields Reveal the Free-Photon Schrödinger Equation

Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

Classical equations of motion that are first-order in time and conserve energy can only be quantized after their variables have been transformed to canonical ones, i.e., variables in which the energy is the system's Hamiltonian. The source-free version of Maxwell's equations is purely dynamical, first-order in time and has well-defined nonnegative conserved field energy but is decidedly noncanonical. That should long ago have made source-free Maxwell equation canonical Hamiltonization a research priority, and afterward, standard textbook fare, but textbooks seem unaware of the issue. The opposite parities of the electric and magnetic fields and consequent curl operations that typify Maxwell's equations are especially at odds with their being canonical fields. Transformation of the magnetic field into the transverse part of the vector potential helps but is not sufficient; further simple nonnegative symmetric integral transforms, which commute with all differential operators, are needed for both fields; such transforms also supplant the curls in the equations of motion. The canonical replacements of the source-free electromagnetic fields remain transverse-vector fields, but are more diffuse than their predecessors, albeit less diffuse than the transverse vector potential. Combined as the real and imaginary parts of a complex field, the canonical fields prove to be the transverse-vector wave function of a time-dependent Schrodinger equation whose Hamiltonian operator is the quantization of the free photon's square-root relativistic energy. Thus proper quantization of the source-free Maxwell equations is identical to second quantization of free photons that have normal square-root energy. There is no physical reason why first and second quantization of any relativistic free particle ought not to proceed in precise parallel, utilizing the square-root Hamiltonian operator. This natural procedure leaves no role for the completely artificial Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations, as accords with their grossly unphysical properties.

Prespacetime journal•Dec 1, 2010•0 citations

Quantizing Maxwell's Equations

Thomas A. Garrity

: Our goal is to quantize Maxwell's equations, leading to a natural interpretation of light as being composed of photons. The key is that the quantization of harmonic oscillators (or, more prosaically, the mathematics of springs) is critical to understanding light. In particular, we show that the possible energies of light form a discrete set, linked to the classical frequency, giving us an interpretation for the photoelectric effect. Our Approach From Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect, light seems to be made up of photons, which in turn are somewhat particle-like. Can we start with the classical description of light as an electromagnetic wave solution to Maxwell's equations when there are no charges or currents, quantize, and then get something that can be identified with photons? That is the goal of this chapter. (As in the previous chapter, while all of this is standard, we will be following the outline given in chapter 2 of [41].) Maxwell's equations are linear. We will concentrate on the ‘monochromatic’ solutions, those with fixed frequency and direction. We will see that the Hamiltonians of these monochromatic solutions will have the same mathematical structure as a Hamiltonian for a harmonic oscillator. We know from the last chapter how to quantize the harmonic oscillator. More importantly, we saw that there are discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors for the corresponding Hamiltonian operator. When we quantize the Hamiltonians for the monochromatic waves in an analogous fashion, we will again have discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors. It is these eigenvectors that we can interpret as photons.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 19, 2015•0 citations

Simple Prescription for Quantizing Fields Applied to Interacting Spins in an Electromagnetic Field and to Other Systems

Marshall S. Sparks

A simple prescription for quantizing fields is developed and applied to the sytsem of interacting spins in an electromagnetic field. The classical equations of motion are written in the standard form $\ensuremath{-}i(\frac{d}{\mathrm{dt}})|V〉+\mathfrak{M}|V〉=0$, where the state vector $|V〉$ has the state variables, such as the generalized coordinates and momenta, as its components, and the time development operator $\mathfrak{M}$ contains derivative, integral, and matrix operators in general. By diagonalizing $\mathfrak{M}$ and replacing the resulting classical variables with operators obeying boson commutation relations, the system is quantized, and the Hamiltonian and Heisenberg equations of motion are automatically cast into the harmonic-oscillator form. Thus the quantization is reduced to the simple problem of diagonalizing a matrix. This avoids the laborious process of finding a Lagrangian density (by trial and error in general), determining the canonical variables, forming the Hamiltonian density, and inventing transformations to creation and annihilation operators. Problems with zero-frequency modes, which can be annoying in the standard treatment, are automatically eliminated by the prescription. The bookkeeping of forward and backward waves, different branches of dispersion curves, etc., is simplified. In addition to affording a straightforward and simple method of quantizing fields, the method also gives the necessary and sufficient conditions for a Hamiltonian to be transformable into harmonic-oscillator form, gives a direct relation between the classical equations of motion and the Heisenberg quantum-mechanical equations, and gives a simple method of determining the constants of the motion.

Physical Review•May 25, 1969•0 citations

Source-free electromagnetism's canonical fields reveal the free-photon Schroedinger equation

Steven Kenneth Kauffmann

Classical equations of motion that are first-order in time and conserve energy can only be quantized after their variables have been transformed to canonical ones, i.e., variables in which the energy is the system's Hamiltonian. The source-free version of Maxwell's equations is purely dynamical, first-order in time and has a well-defined nonnegative conserved field energy, but is decidedly noncanonical, an issue that has attracted little attention. The opposite parities of the electric and magnetic fields and consequent curl operations that typify Maxwell's equations are especially at odds with their being canonical fields. Transformation of the magnetic field into the transverse part of the vector potential helps but is not sufficient; further simple nonnegative symmetric integral transforms, which commute with all differential operators, are needed for both fields; such transforms also supplant the curls in the equations of motion. The canonical replacements of the source-free electromagnetic fields remain transverse-vector fields, but are more diffuse than their predecessors. Combined as the real and imaginary parts of a complex field, the canonical fields prove to be the transverse-vector wave function of a time-dependent Schroedinger equation whose Hamiltonian operator is the quantization of the free photon's square-root relativistic energy. Thus proper quantization of the source-free Maxwell equations is identical to second quantization of free photons that have normal square-root energy. There is no physical reason why first and second quantization of any relativistic free particle ought not to proceed in precise parallel, utilizing the square-root Hamiltonian operator. This natural procedure leaves no role for the completely artificial Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations, as accords with their grossly unphysical properties.

arXiv:1011.6578•Nov 29, 2010•4 citations

A field-theoretical approach to non-relativistic QED

L. Bányai, M. Bundaru

We give here a field-theoretical derivation of the Hamiltonian of the non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the Coulomb gauge using the Lagrange formalism. It leads to the same result as the usual derivation, where one just replaces the classical vector potential in the minimal coupling of the second quantized electron Hamiltonian by the quantized one and adds the photon energy. This approach illustrates however the proper use of the Euler-Lagrange equations and the canonical formalism that fail if one tries to build up the many-body quantum theory starting from the classical theory of point-like particles interacting with electromagnetic fields.

arXiv:1907.13053•Jul 30, 2019•0 citations
The notion that the electromagnetic field is quantized is usually inferred from observations such as the photoelectric effect and the black-body spectrum. However accounts of the quantization of this field are usually mathematically motivated and begin by introducing a vector potential, followed by the imposition of a gauge that allows the manipulation of the solutions of Maxwell's equations into a form that is amenable for the machinery of canonical quantization. By contrast, here we quantize the electromagnetic field in a less mathematically and more physically motivated way. Starting from a direct description of what one sees in experiments, we show that the usual expressions of the electric and magnetic field observables follow from Heisenberg's equation of motion. In our treatment, there is no need to invoke the vector potential in a specific gauge and we avoid the commonly used notion of a fictitious cavity that applies boundary conditions to the field.
We present a succinct way to quantize Maxwell's equations. We begin by discussing the random nature of quantum observables. Then we present the quantum Maxwell's equations and give their physical meanings. Due to the mathematical homomorphism between the classical and quantum cases [1], the derivation of quantum Maxwell's equations can be simplified. First, one needs only to verify that the classical equations of motion are derivable from a Hamiltonian by energy-conservation arguments. Then the quantum equations of motion follow due to homomorphism, which applies to sum-separable Hamiltonians. Hence, we first show the derivation of classical Maxwell's equations using Hamiltonian theory. Then the derivation of the quantum Maxwell's equations follows in an analogous fashion. Finally, we apply this quantization procedure to the dispersive medium case. (This article is written for the classical electromagnetic community assuming little knowledge of quantum theory, an introduction of which can be found in [2, Lecs. 38 and 39].)
Classical equations of motion that are first-order in time and conserve energy can only be quantized after their variables have been transformed to canonical ones, i.e., variables in which the energy is the system's Hamiltonian. The source-free version of Maxwell's equations is purely dynamical, first-order in time and has well-defined nonnegative conserved field energy but is decidedly noncanonical. That should long ago have made source-free Maxwell equation canonical Hamiltonization a research priority, and afterward, standard textbook fare, but textbooks seem unaware of the issue. The opposite parities of the electric and magnetic fields and consequent curl operations that typify Maxwell's equations are especially at odds with their being canonical fields. Transformation of the magnetic field into the transverse part of the vector potential helps but is not sufficient; further simple nonnegative symmetric integral transforms, which commute with all differential operators, are needed for both fields; such transforms also supplant the curls in the equations of motion. The canonical replacements of the source-free electromagnetic fields remain transverse-vector fields, but are more diffuse than their predecessors, albeit less diffuse than the transverse vector potential. Combined as the real and imaginary parts of a complex field, the canonical fields prove to be the transverse-vector wave function of a time-dependent Schrodinger equation whose Hamiltonian operator is the quantization of the free photon's square-root relativistic energy. Thus proper quantization of the source-free Maxwell equations is identical to second quantization of free photons that have normal square-root energy. There is no physical reason why first and second quantization of any relativistic free particle ought not to proceed in precise parallel, utilizing the square-root Hamiltonian operator. This natural procedure leaves no role for the completely artificial Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations, as accords with their grossly unphysical properties.
: Our goal is to quantize Maxwell's equations, leading to a natural interpretation of light as being composed of photons. The key is that the quantization of harmonic oscillators (or, more prosaically, the mathematics of springs) is critical to understanding light. In particular, we show that the possible energies of light form a discrete set, linked to the classical frequency, giving us an interpretation for the photoelectric effect. Our Approach From Einstein's explanation of the photoelectric effect, light seems to be made up of photons, which in turn are somewhat particle-like. Can we start with the classical description of light as an electromagnetic wave solution to Maxwell's equations when there are no charges or currents, quantize, and then get something that can be identified with photons? That is the goal of this chapter. (As in the previous chapter, while all of this is standard, we will be following the outline given in chapter 2 of [41].) Maxwell's equations are linear. We will concentrate on the ‘monochromatic’ solutions, those with fixed frequency and direction. We will see that the Hamiltonians of these monochromatic solutions will have the same mathematical structure as a Hamiltonian for a harmonic oscillator. We know from the last chapter how to quantize the harmonic oscillator. More importantly, we saw that there are discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors for the corresponding Hamiltonian operator. When we quantize the Hamiltonians for the monochromatic waves in an analogous fashion, we will again have discrete eigenvalues and eigenvectors. It is these eigenvectors that we can interpret as photons.
A simple prescription for quantizing fields is developed and applied to the sytsem of interacting spins in an electromagnetic field. The classical equations of motion are written in the standard form $\ensuremath{-}i(\frac{d}{\mathrm{dt}})|V〉+\mathfrak{M}|V〉=0$, where the state vector ∣V〉|V〉∣V〉 has the state variables, such as the generalized coordinates and momenta, as its components, and the time development operator M\mathfrak{M}M contains derivative, integral, and matrix operators in general. By diagonalizing M\mathfrak{M}M and replacing the resulting classical variables with operators obeying boson commutation relations, the system is quantized, and the Hamiltonian and Heisenberg equations of motion are automatically cast into the harmonic-oscillator form. Thus the quantization is reduced to the simple problem of diagonalizing a matrix. This avoids the laborious process of finding a Lagrangian density (by trial and error in general), determining the canonical variables, forming the Hamiltonian density, and inventing transformations to creation and annihilation operators. Problems with zero-frequency modes, which can be annoying in the standard treatment, are automatically eliminated by the prescription. The bookkeeping of forward and backward waves, different branches of dispersion curves, etc., is simplified. In addition to affording a straightforward and simple method of quantizing fields, the method also gives the necessary and sufficient conditions for a Hamiltonian to be transformable into harmonic-oscillator form, gives a direct relation between the classical equations of motion and the Heisenberg quantum-mechanical equations, and gives a simple method of determining the constants of the motion.
Classical equations of motion that are first-order in time and conserve energy can only be quantized after their variables have been transformed to canonical ones, i.e., variables in which the energy is the system's Hamiltonian. The source-free version of Maxwell's equations is purely dynamical, first-order in time and has a well-defined nonnegative conserved field energy, but is decidedly noncanonical, an issue that has attracted little attention. The opposite parities of the electric and magnetic fields and consequent curl operations that typify Maxwell's equations are especially at odds with their being canonical fields. Transformation of the magnetic field into the transverse part of the vector potential helps but is not sufficient; further simple nonnegative symmetric integral transforms, which commute with all differential operators, are needed for both fields; such transforms also supplant the curls in the equations of motion. The canonical replacements of the source-free electromagnetic fields remain transverse-vector fields, but are more diffuse than their predecessors. Combined as the real and imaginary parts of a complex field, the canonical fields prove to be the transverse-vector wave function of a time-dependent Schroedinger equation whose Hamiltonian operator is the quantization of the free photon's square-root relativistic energy. Thus proper quantization of the source-free Maxwell equations is identical to second quantization of free photons that have normal square-root energy. There is no physical reason why first and second quantization of any relativistic free particle ought not to proceed in precise parallel, utilizing the square-root Hamiltonian operator. This natural procedure leaves no role for the completely artificial Klein-Gordon and Dirac equations, as accords with their grossly unphysical properties.
We give here a field-theoretical derivation of the Hamiltonian of the non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics in the Coulomb gauge using the Lagrange formalism. It leads to the same result as the usual derivation, where one just replaces the classical vector potential in the minimal coupling of the second quantized electron Hamiltonian by the quantized one and adds the photon energy. This approach illustrates however the proper use of the Euler-Lagrange equations and the canonical formalism that fail if one tries to build up the many-body quantum theory starting from the classical theory of point-like particles interacting with electromagnetic fields.