Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1506.02581

Two Experimental Tests to Distinguish Decoherence from the Slicing Theory of Measurement

Clifford Chafin

Published May 1, 2015• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Here we propose a pair of experiments to distinguish the recently proposed "slicing theory" of quantum measurement, which gives a transient many worlds picture, and decoherence. Since these two theories are essentially "opposites" in their approach and both claim to arise from the many body Schrödinger equation itself, there is no chance of them being equivalent representations of the same reality. It will be explicitly shown that each theory gives very different answers to the questions of back reaction and revival of phase effects after measurement. We suggest that the kinds of isolated systems now possible in optical traps is now sufficient to generate a selective distinction between these two theories. In particular we show that the slicing theory gives examples of interference from "revival of histories" in controlled examples but no back reaction on the measurement devices whereas decoherence gives the opposite.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1506.02581

Related papers

The Slicing Theory of Quantum Measurement: Derivation of Transient Many Worlds Behavior

Clifford Chafin

An emergent theory of quantum measurement arises directly by considering the particular subset of many body wavefunctions that can be associated with classical condensed matter and its interaction with delocalized wavefunctions. This transfers questions of the "strangeness" of quantum mechanics from the wavefunction to the macroscopic material itself. An effectively many-worlds picture of measurement results for long times and induces a natural arrow of time. The challenging part is then justifying why our macroscopic world is dominated by such far-from-eigenstate matter. Condensing cold mesoscopic clusters provide a pathway to a partitioning of a highly correlated many body wavefunction to long lasting islands composed of classical-like bodies widely separated in Fock space. Low mass rapidly delocalizing matter that recombines with the solids "slice" the system into a set of nearby yet very weakly interacting subsystems weighted according to the Born statistics and yields a kind of many worlds picture but with the possibility of revived phase interference on iterative particle desorption, delocalization and readsorption. A proliferation of low energy photons competes with such a possibility. Causality problems associated with correlated quantum measurement are resolved and conserved quantities are preserved for the overall many body function despite their failure in each observer's bifurcating "slice-path." The necessity of such a state for a two state logic and reliable discrete state machine suggests that later stages of the universe's evolution will destroy the physical underpinnings required for consciousness and the arrow of time even without heat-death or atomic destruction. Some exotic possibilities outside the domain of usual quantum measurement are considered such as measurement with delocalized devices and revival of information from past measurements.

arXiv:1410.8238•Oct 30, 2014•4 citations

Measurement and decoherence

Michel Le Bellac

In this appendix we shall describe in more detail how the experiment of Brune et al. mentioned in Section 6.4.1 provided evidence of the phenomenon of decoherence in an entirely controlled manner. In addition to its intrinsic interest, this experiment is a prime example of actual experiments which allow the fundamentals of quantum mechanics to be tested with a precision undreamed of by its founders, and the study of this experiment constitutes a beautiful exercise in quantum physics. It will also allow us to give a small sample of the current ideas on the notion of measurement in quantum mechanics. We shall first return to the interference experiment of Section 1.4.4, this time discussing it within the framework of an elementary theory of measurement. Then we shall examine the realization of Ramsey fringes using Rydberg atoms, and show how the interaction of these atoms with an electromagnetic field progressively blurs these fringes when we try to answer the “which of the two trajectories?” question. Finally, we shall show how the use of a pair of atoms allows decoherence to be tested.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 23, 2006•1 citation

Is the Many Worlds Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics Consistent

Narayanankutty Karuppath, Vijay Shankar

Duality in quantum mechanical wave functions is manifest through the famous measurement problem. There have been several interpretations to explain this duality, but none have seen full consensus among physicists. The Copenhagen interpretation, which is at least to some extent the most widely accepted interpretation has the 'collapse' of the wave function (or state vector reduction) during measurement, does not attribute a physical reality to the wave function. Moreover, the idea of measurement having a role in defining reality shakes the very foundation of classical physics. On the other hand, the Many worlds interpretation proposed by Everett is a very brave attempt to attribute physical significance to the wave function. Though mathematically sound and elegant, 'the splitting of the universe' in the Many Worlds Interpretation completely redefines reality as we know it. We test Everett's original thought experiment in the presence of a super observer and for sequential measurements as well. We observe that the no-clone theorem helps the Many Worlds Interpretation, yet it does not provide a consistent picture for sequential measurements, unlike the Copenhagen Interpretation.

•May 1, 2021•0 citations

A survey on decoherence in the thermodynamic limit

Marco Frasca

Environment induced decoherence [1] has taught us that unitary evolution can be very fragile. Recent experiments with cavities [2], ion traps [3] and interference [4] confirm this expectation. All the experiments carried out so far do not help to answer a fundamental question: Can we maintain unitary evolution down to the Planck time? Different formulations of intrinsic decoherence [5-9] foresee that effects on smaller scales permit us to understand the breaking of the unitary evolution and in some way point out possible answers to our question. But, one can ask if some experiments in quantum optics can be devised to find an answer to the question with the present technology. Decoherence in the thermodynamic limit is a proposal to respond to these questions assuming that the Planck time should be a boundary between different physical theory, that is, we have a singular limit [10]. This singular limit is due to blurring in time and an experimental device will always introduce an average with its proper timescale. We show, with some examples recently presented in literature [11-15], how quantum optics can help to give a definite answer to the main question about unitary evolution, providing in this way direct hints for new physics. This approach to decoherence appears as a new understanding of the measurement problem in quantum mechanics.

Journal of Modern Optics•Apr 1, 2004•0 citations

Decoherence and the measurement problem

Hervé Zwirn C

The problem of measurement taken at face value shows clearly that there is an inconsistency inside the quantum formalism.The phenomenon of decoherence is often presented as a solution to it.A widely debated question is to decide between two different interpretations.The first one is to consider that the decoherence process has the effect to actually project a superposed state into one of its classically interpretable component, hence doing the same job as the reduction postulate.For the second one, decoherence is only a way to show why no macroscopic superposed state can be observed and so, to explain the classical appearance of the macroscopic world, while the quantum entanglement between the system, the apparatus and the environment never disappears.In this case, explaining why only one single definite outcome is observed remains to do.In this paper, we examine arguments for and against both interpretations and defend a position according to which the outcome that is observed is relative to the observer in close parallel to the Everett interpretation.

Proceedings of Frontiers of Fundamental Physics 14 — PoS(FFP14)•Sep 15, 2016•4 citations

Stopped Light as a Test Bed for the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation- A Fixed Spin Wave Null Test for Accumulated Interference

Larry Lim Kheng Cheong

This paper examines whether the established physics of slow light, stopped light, and optical quantum memory can provide a falsifiable experimental test of the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation, TWMSE. Existing stopped light experiments are not presented as evidence for TWMSE. Conventional electromagnetically induced transparency, dark state polariton theory, and modern photon storage theory already describe their principal observations. The paper instead constructs a fixed spin wave retrieval null test. Equivalent repeated preparations of the same stored spin wave are retrieved using different temporal control histories while preserving the conditions required by conventional photon retrieval theory, including optical depth, retrieval direction, spin wave reproducibility, coherence, and the applicable retrieval regime. Different retrieval controls may reshape the emitted temporal mode, so waveform equality is not used as the null observable. The principal comparison is the integrated retrieval efficiency difference, Δη = η(r,A) − η(r,B), for which the conventional expectation is zero within the stated experimental uncertainty. The canonical TWMSE collapse functional and evolution equation follow the author's revised unified account, Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21868322. Any EIT specific memory term must be derived from those canonical equations rather than introduced independently. The paper therefore does not assume that TWMSE predicts a nonflat memory kernel or a nonzero residual. A flat or conventionally equivalent effective kernel remains a valid possible result, in which case the proposed experiment yields no distinctive TWMSE prediction. Conventional EIT already contains integrated control history, so the mere presence of an integral over the past cannot distinguish the two theories. The relevant discriminator is the shape of the history weighting rather than its existence. The paper also incorporates the theory of inhomogeneously broadened photon storage. Warm atomic vapour remains a viable candidate platform when optical depth is sufficiently high and the differential Doppler shift of the relevant optical transitions is negligible. If a distinct TWMSE history weighting is eventually derived, the theory must determine the magnitude and scaling of the predicted residual before experimental data are examined. A null result obtained with sufficient precision would then constrain or exclude the relevant accumulated interference mechanism. The proposed scientific sequence is to derive the EIT limit from canonical TWMSE, recover the fixed spin wave retrieval result, derive any additional memory contribution, determine its magnitude and scaling, freeze the parameters, and only then perform the differential null experiment.

•Aug 10, 2026•0 citations
Here we propose a pair of experiments to distinguish the recently proposed "slicing theory" of quantum measurement, which gives a transient many worlds picture, and decoherence. Since these two theories are essentially "opposites" in their approach and both claim to arise from the many body Schrödinger equation itself, there is no chance of them being equivalent representations of the same reality. It will be explicitly shown that each theory gives very different answers to the questions of back reaction and revival of phase effects after measurement. We suggest that the kinds of isolated systems now possible in optical traps is now sufficient to generate a selective distinction between these two theories. In particular we show that the slicing theory gives examples of interference from "revival of histories" in controlled examples but no back reaction on the measurement devices whereas decoherence gives the opposite.
An emergent theory of quantum measurement arises directly by considering the particular subset of many body wavefunctions that can be associated with classical condensed matter and its interaction with delocalized wavefunctions. This transfers questions of the "strangeness" of quantum mechanics from the wavefunction to the macroscopic material itself. An effectively many-worlds picture of measurement results for long times and induces a natural arrow of time. The challenging part is then justifying why our macroscopic world is dominated by such far-from-eigenstate matter. Condensing cold mesoscopic clusters provide a pathway to a partitioning of a highly correlated many body wavefunction to long lasting islands composed of classical-like bodies widely separated in Fock space. Low mass rapidly delocalizing matter that recombines with the solids "slice" the system into a set of nearby yet very weakly interacting subsystems weighted according to the Born statistics and yields a kind of many worlds picture but with the possibility of revived phase interference on iterative particle desorption, delocalization and readsorption. A proliferation of low energy photons competes with such a possibility. Causality problems associated with correlated quantum measurement are resolved and conserved quantities are preserved for the overall many body function despite their failure in each observer's bifurcating "slice-path." The necessity of such a state for a two state logic and reliable discrete state machine suggests that later stages of the universe's evolution will destroy the physical underpinnings required for consciousness and the arrow of time even without heat-death or atomic destruction. Some exotic possibilities outside the domain of usual quantum measurement are considered such as measurement with delocalized devices and revival of information from past measurements.
In this appendix we shall describe in more detail how the experiment of Brune et al. mentioned in Section 6.4.1 provided evidence of the phenomenon of decoherence in an entirely controlled manner. In addition to its intrinsic interest, this experiment is a prime example of actual experiments which allow the fundamentals of quantum mechanics to be tested with a precision undreamed of by its founders, and the study of this experiment constitutes a beautiful exercise in quantum physics. It will also allow us to give a small sample of the current ideas on the notion of measurement in quantum mechanics. We shall first return to the interference experiment of Section 1.4.4, this time discussing it within the framework of an elementary theory of measurement. Then we shall examine the realization of Ramsey fringes using Rydberg atoms, and show how the interaction of these atoms with an electromagnetic field progressively blurs these fringes when we try to answer the “which of the two trajectories?” question. Finally, we shall show how the use of a pair of atoms allows decoherence to be tested.
Duality in quantum mechanical wave functions is manifest through the famous measurement problem. There have been several interpretations to explain this duality, but none have seen full consensus among physicists. The Copenhagen interpretation, which is at least to some extent the most widely accepted interpretation has the 'collapse' of the wave function (or state vector reduction) during measurement, does not attribute a physical reality to the wave function. Moreover, the idea of measurement having a role in defining reality shakes the very foundation of classical physics. On the other hand, the Many worlds interpretation proposed by Everett is a very brave attempt to attribute physical significance to the wave function. Though mathematically sound and elegant, 'the splitting of the universe' in the Many Worlds Interpretation completely redefines reality as we know it. We test Everett's original thought experiment in the presence of a super observer and for sequential measurements as well. We observe that the no-clone theorem helps the Many Worlds Interpretation, yet it does not provide a consistent picture for sequential measurements, unlike the Copenhagen Interpretation.
Environment induced decoherence [1] has taught us that unitary evolution can be very fragile. Recent experiments with cavities [2], ion traps [3] and interference [4] confirm this expectation. All the experiments carried out so far do not help to answer a fundamental question: Can we maintain unitary evolution down to the Planck time? Different formulations of intrinsic decoherence [5-9] foresee that effects on smaller scales permit us to understand the breaking of the unitary evolution and in some way point out possible answers to our question. But, one can ask if some experiments in quantum optics can be devised to find an answer to the question with the present technology. Decoherence in the thermodynamic limit is a proposal to respond to these questions assuming that the Planck time should be a boundary between different physical theory, that is, we have a singular limit [10]. This singular limit is due to blurring in time and an experimental device will always introduce an average with its proper timescale. We show, with some examples recently presented in literature [11-15], how quantum optics can help to give a definite answer to the main question about unitary evolution, providing in this way direct hints for new physics. This approach to decoherence appears as a new understanding of the measurement problem in quantum mechanics.
The problem of measurement taken at face value shows clearly that there is an inconsistency inside the quantum formalism.The phenomenon of decoherence is often presented as a solution to it.A widely debated question is to decide between two different interpretations.The first one is to consider that the decoherence process has the effect to actually project a superposed state into one of its classically interpretable component, hence doing the same job as the reduction postulate.For the second one, decoherence is only a way to show why no macroscopic superposed state can be observed and so, to explain the classical appearance of the macroscopic world, while the quantum entanglement between the system, the apparatus and the environment never disappears.In this case, explaining why only one single definite outcome is observed remains to do.In this paper, we examine arguments for and against both interpretations and defend a position according to which the outcome that is observed is relative to the observer in close parallel to the Everett interpretation.
This paper examines whether the established physics of slow light, stopped light, and optical quantum memory can provide a falsifiable experimental test of the Total Wave Modified Schrödinger Equation, TWMSE. Existing stopped light experiments are not presented as evidence for TWMSE. Conventional electromagnetically induced transparency, dark state polariton theory, and modern photon storage theory already describe their principal observations. The paper instead constructs a fixed spin wave retrieval null test. Equivalent repeated preparations of the same stored spin wave are retrieved using different temporal control histories while preserving the conditions required by conventional photon retrieval theory, including optical depth, retrieval direction, spin wave reproducibility, coherence, and the applicable retrieval regime. Different retrieval controls may reshape the emitted temporal mode, so waveform equality is not used as the null observable. The principal comparison is the integrated retrieval efficiency difference, Δη = η(r,A) − η(r,B), for which the conventional expectation is zero within the stated experimental uncertainty. The canonical TWMSE collapse functional and evolution equation follow the author's revised unified account, Zenodo DOI 10.5281/zenodo.21868322. Any EIT specific memory term must be derived from those canonical equations rather than introduced independently. The paper therefore does not assume that TWMSE predicts a nonflat memory kernel or a nonzero residual. A flat or conventionally equivalent effective kernel remains a valid possible result, in which case the proposed experiment yields no distinctive TWMSE prediction. Conventional EIT already contains integrated control history, so the mere presence of an integral over the past cannot distinguish the two theories. The relevant discriminator is the shape of the history weighting rather than its existence. The paper also incorporates the theory of inhomogeneously broadened photon storage. Warm atomic vapour remains a viable candidate platform when optical depth is sufficiently high and the differential Doppler shift of the relevant optical transitions is negligible. If a distinct TWMSE history weighting is eventually derived, the theory must determine the magnitude and scaling of the predicted residual before experimental data are examined. A null result obtained with sufficient precision would then constrain or exclude the relevant accumulated interference mechanism. The proposed scientific sequence is to derive the EIT limit from canonical TWMSE, recover the fixed spin wave retrieval result, derive any additional memory contribution, determine its magnitude and scaling, freeze the parameters, and only then perform the differential null experiment.