Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1503.06200 · Journal of Physics Condensed Matter

Full self-consistency versus quasiparticle self-consistency in diagrammatic approaches: exactly solvable two-site Hubbard model

A L Kutepov

Published Jul 22, 2015• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Self-consistent solutions of Hedin's equations (HE) for the two-site Hubbard model (HM) have been studied. They have been found for three-point vertices of increasing complexity (Γ = 1 (GW approximation), Γ1 from the first-order perturbation theory, and the exact vertex Γ(E)). Comparison is made between the cases when an additional quasiparticle (QP) approximation for Green's functions is applied during the self-consistent iterative solving of HE and when QP approximation is not applied. The results obtained with the exact vertex are directly related to the present open question-which approximation is more advantageous for future implementations, GW + DMFT or QPGW + DMFT. It is shown that in a regime of strong correlations only the originally proposed GW + DMFT scheme is able to provide reliable results. Vertex corrections based on perturbation theory (PT) systematically improve the GW results when full self-consistency is applied. The application of QP self-consistency combined with PT vertex corrections shows similar problems to the case when the exact vertex is applied combined with QP sc. An analysis of Ward Identity violation is performed for all studied in this work's approximations and its relation to the general accuracy of the schemes used is provided.

DOI
10.1088/0953-8984/27/31/315603

Related papers

Self-consistency in GWΓ formalism leading to quasiparticle-quasiparticle couplings

Carlos Mejuto-Zaera, Vojtěch Vlček

Within many-body perturbation theory, Hedin's formalism offers a systematic way to iteratively compute the self-energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ of any dynamically correlated interacting system, provided one can evaluate the interaction vertex $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ exactly. This is, however, impossible, in general, for it involves the functional derivative of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ with respect to the Green's function. Here, we analyze the structure of this derivative, splitting it into four contributions and outlining the type of quasiparticle interactions that each of them generate. Moreover, we show how, in the implementation of self-consistency, the action of these contributions can be classified into two: A quantitative renormalization of previously included interaction terms and the inclusion of qualitatively distinct interaction terms through successive functional derivatives of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ itself. Implementing this latter type of self-consistency can extend the validity of perturbative approximations based on Hedin's equations toward the high interaction limit, as we show in the example of the Hubbard dimer. Our analysis also provides a unifying perspective on the perturbation theory landscape, showing how the T-matrix approach is completely contained in Hedin's formalism.

arXiv:2203.05029•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Oct 26, 2022•44 citations

Self-consistent GW combined with single-site dynamical mean field theory for a Hubbard model

K. Karlsson

We combine the single-site dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) with the non-local GW method. This is done fully self-consistently and we apply our formalism to a one-band Hubbard model. Eventually at self-consistency the full self-energy and polarization operator of the system are retrieved. Some numerical results, in the metallic as well as the insulator regime, are presented and briefly discussed. Depending on the involved interaction (GW) parameters, substantial changes are found when the GW self-energy is incorporated. However, the main point of this work is to demonstrate the applicability of the method, not to make any strict comparison with exact results and experiments.

arXiv:cond-mat/0412733•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Nov 11, 2005•16 citations

Hedin Equations, GW, GW+DMFT, and All That

Karsten Held, Ciro Taranto, G. Rohringer +1 more

Historically, the GW approach was put forward by Hedin as the simplest approximation to the so-called Hedin equations. In Section 2, we will derive these Hedin equations from a Feynman-diagrammatical point of view. Section 3.1 shows how GW arises as an approximation to the Hedin equations. In Section 3.2, we briefly present some typical GW results for materials, including quasiparticle renormalizations, lifetimes, and band gap enhancements. In Section 4, the combination of GW and DMFT is summarized. Finally, as a prospective outlook, ab initio dynamical vertex approximation D$Γ$A is introduced in Section 5 as a unifying scheme for all that: GW, DMFT and non-local vertex correlations beyond.

arXiv:1109.3972•Sep 19, 2011•23 citations

Systematic Vertex Corrections through Iterative Solution of Hedin's Equations Beyond the GW Approximation

Arno Schindlmayr, Rex W. Godby

We present a general procedure for obtaining progressively more accurate functional expressions for the electron self-energy by iterative solution of Hedin's coupled equations. The iterative process starting from Hartree theory, which gives rise to the $\mathrm{GW}$ approximation, is continued further, and an explicit formula for the vertex function from the second full cycle is given. Calculated excitation energies for a Hubbard Hamiltonian demonstrate the convergence of the iterative process and provide further strong justification for the $\mathrm{GW}$ approximation.

arXiv:cond-mat/9710295•Physical Review Letters•Feb 23, 1998•84 citations

Self-consistent spin-spin and density-density correlations in the Hubbard model

Chris Gearhart, J. Charles Hicks

A linear combination of Hubbard projection operators is used to linearize the equations of motion for the Hubbard model. The Green's funtions in this linearization scheme depend explicitly on the value of the nearest-neighbor density-density correlation function. For the half-filled case we calculate this correlation function by taking variations of the equations of motion with respect to a density field. Three-body vertex corrections are ignored. The expressions we get for the correlation functions along with the equations of motion for the Green's functions form a system of equations that can be solved self-consistently. We solve these equations, both with and without effective vertex corrections, for a half-filled 12-site chain. These results are compared to numerically exact Lanczos solutions and to standard mean-field calculations. Calculations of on-site charge corelation, ground-state energy, and long-range spin-spin correlations for intermediate values of U show a significant improvement over standard mean-field techniques.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Sep 15, 1995•1 citation

Beyond the GW approximation: Combining correlation channels

Pina Romaniello, F. Bechstedt, Lucia Reining

In many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) the self-energy $\ensuremath{\Sigma}=iGW\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ plays a key role since it contains all the many-body effects of the system. The exact self-energy is not known; as a first approximation one can set the vertex function $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ to unity which leads to the GW approximation. The latter properly describes the high-density regime, where screening is important; in the low-density regime, instead, other approximations are proposed, such as the $T$ matrix, which describes multiple scattering between two particles. Here we combine the two approaches. Starting from the fundamental equations of MBPT, we show how one can derive the $T$-matrix approximation to the self-energy in a common framework with $GW$. This allows us to elucidate several aspects of this formulation, including the origin of, and link between, the electron-hole and the particle-particle $T$ matrix, the derivation of a screened $T$ matrix, and the conversion of the $T$ matrix into a vertex correction. The exactly solvable Hubbard molecule is used for illustration.

arXiv:1204.4463•Physical Review B•Apr 19, 2012•102 citations
Self-consistent solutions of Hedin's equations (HE) for the two-site Hubbard model (HM) have been studied. They have been found for three-point vertices of increasing complexity (Γ = 1 (GW approximation), Γ1 from the first-order perturbation theory, and the exact vertex Γ(E)). Comparison is made between the cases when an additional quasiparticle (QP) approximation for Green's functions is applied during the self-consistent iterative solving of HE and when QP approximation is not applied. The results obtained with the exact vertex are directly related to the present open question-which approximation is more advantageous for future implementations, GW + DMFT or QPGW + DMFT. It is shown that in a regime of strong correlations only the originally proposed GW + DMFT scheme is able to provide reliable results. Vertex corrections based on perturbation theory (PT) systematically improve the GW results when full self-consistency is applied. The application of QP self-consistency combined with PT vertex corrections shows similar problems to the case when the exact vertex is applied combined with QP sc. An analysis of Ward Identity violation is performed for all studied in this work's approximations and its relation to the general accuracy of the schemes used is provided.
Within many-body perturbation theory, Hedin's formalism offers a systematic way to iteratively compute the self-energy $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ of any dynamically correlated interacting system, provided one can evaluate the interaction vertex $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ exactly. This is, however, impossible, in general, for it involves the functional derivative of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}$ with respect to the Green's function. Here, we analyze the structure of this derivative, splitting it into four contributions and outlining the type of quasiparticle interactions that each of them generate. Moreover, we show how, in the implementation of self-consistency, the action of these contributions can be classified into two: A quantitative renormalization of previously included interaction terms and the inclusion of qualitatively distinct interaction terms through successive functional derivatives of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Gamma}}$ itself. Implementing this latter type of self-consistency can extend the validity of perturbative approximations based on Hedin's equations toward the high interaction limit, as we show in the example of the Hubbard dimer. Our analysis also provides a unifying perspective on the perturbation theory landscape, showing how the T-matrix approach is completely contained in Hedin's formalism.
We combine the single-site dynamical mean field theory (DMFT) with the non-local GW method. This is done fully self-consistently and we apply our formalism to a one-band Hubbard model. Eventually at self-consistency the full self-energy and polarization operator of the system are retrieved. Some numerical results, in the metallic as well as the insulator regime, are presented and briefly discussed. Depending on the involved interaction (GW) parameters, substantial changes are found when the GW self-energy is incorporated. However, the main point of this work is to demonstrate the applicability of the method, not to make any strict comparison with exact results and experiments.
Historically, the GW approach was put forward by Hedin as the simplest approximation to the so-called Hedin equations. In Section 2, we will derive these Hedin equations from a Feynman-diagrammatical point of view. Section 3.1 shows how GW arises as an approximation to the Hedin equations. In Section 3.2, we briefly present some typical GW results for materials, including quasiparticle renormalizations, lifetimes, and band gap enhancements. In Section 4, the combination of GW and DMFT is summarized. Finally, as a prospective outlook, ab initio dynamical vertex approximation DΓΓΓA is introduced in Section 5 as a unifying scheme for all that: GW, DMFT and non-local vertex correlations beyond.
We present a general procedure for obtaining progressively more accurate functional expressions for the electron self-energy by iterative solution of Hedin's coupled equations. The iterative process starting from Hartree theory, which gives rise to the GW\mathrm{GW}GW approximation, is continued further, and an explicit formula for the vertex function from the second full cycle is given. Calculated excitation energies for a Hubbard Hamiltonian demonstrate the convergence of the iterative process and provide further strong justification for the GW\mathrm{GW}GW approximation.
A linear combination of Hubbard projection operators is used to linearize the equations of motion for the Hubbard model. The Green's funtions in this linearization scheme depend explicitly on the value of the nearest-neighbor density-density correlation function. For the half-filled case we calculate this correlation function by taking variations of the equations of motion with respect to a density field. Three-body vertex corrections are ignored. The expressions we get for the correlation functions along with the equations of motion for the Green's functions form a system of equations that can be solved self-consistently. We solve these equations, both with and without effective vertex corrections, for a half-filled 12-site chain. These results are compared to numerically exact Lanczos solutions and to standard mean-field calculations. Calculations of on-site charge corelation, ground-state energy, and long-range spin-spin correlations for intermediate values of U show a significant improvement over standard mean-field techniques.
In many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) the self-energy $\ensuremath{\Sigma}=iGW\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ plays a key role since it contains all the many-body effects of the system. The exact self-energy is not known; as a first approximation one can set the vertex function $\ensuremath{\Gamma}$ to unity which leads to the GW approximation. The latter properly describes the high-density regime, where screening is important; in the low-density regime, instead, other approximations are proposed, such as the TTT matrix, which describes multiple scattering between two particles. Here we combine the two approaches. Starting from the fundamental equations of MBPT, we show how one can derive the TTT-matrix approximation to the self-energy in a common framework with GWGWGW. This allows us to elucidate several aspects of this formulation, including the origin of, and link between, the electron-hole and the particle-particle TTT matrix, the derivation of a screened TTT matrix, and the conversion of the TTT matrix into a vertex correction. The exactly solvable Hubbard molecule is used for illustration.