Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1502.05736 · European Journal of Physics

Experiment and theory: the case of the Doppler effect for photons

Giuseppe Giuliani

Published May 24, 2013• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In 1907, Einstein suggested an experiment with flying atoms for corroborating time dilation. In that paper, the flying atom was conceived as a flying clock: the reference to the Doppler effect was only indirect (the experiments by Stark to the first order of $v/c$). In 1922, Schrödinger showed that the emission of a light quantum by a (flying) atom is regulated by the conservation laws of energy and linear momentum. Therefore, the Doppler effect for photons is the consequence of the energy and momentum exchange between the atom and the photon: a central role is played by the quantum energy jump $ΔE$ of the transition (a relativistic invariant). The first realization of the experiment devised by Einstein is due to Ives and Stilwell (1938). Since then till nowadays experiments of this kind have been repeated in search of better precision and/or a deviation from the predictions of special relativity. The striking feature is that all the papers dealing with these experiments completely neglect Schrödinger's dynamical treatment. The origins of this omission are of different kind: pragmatic (agreement between formulas, wherever coming from, and experiments), historical (deep rooting of the wave theory of light) and epistemological (neglect of basic epistemological rules).

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/34/4/1035

Related papers

On the Doppler effect for photons in rotating systems

Giuseppe Giuliani

The analysis of the Doppler effect for photons in rotating systems, studied using the Mössbauer effect, confirms the general conclusions of a previous paper dedicated to experiments with photons emitted/absorbed by atoms/nuclei in inertial flight. The wave theory of light is so deeply rooted that it continues to be applied to describe phenomena in which the fundamental entities at work are discrete (photons). The fact that the wave theory of light can describe one aspect of these phenomena should not overshadow two issues: the corpuscular theory of light, first applied to the Doppler effect for photons by Schrödinger in 1922, is by far more complete since it describes all of the features of the studied phenomena; the wave theory can only be used when the number of photons at work is statistically significant. This disregarding of basic methodological criteria may appear to be a minor fault. However, the historical development of quantum physics shows that the predominance of the wave theory of radiation, beyond its natural application domain, has hampered the reorientation toward the photon description of the underlying phenomena.

arXiv:1502.00990•European Journal of Physics•Jan 31, 2014•5 citations

A Simple Quantum Picture of the Relativistic Doppler Effect

Daniel Hodgson, Sara Kanzi, Almut Beige

The relativistic Doppler effect comes from the fact that observers in different inertial reference frames experience space and time differently, while the speed of light always remains the same. Consequently, a wave packet of light exhibits different frequencies, wavelengths, and amplitudes. In this paper, we present a local approach to the relativistic Doppler effect based on relativity, spatial and time translational symmetries, and energy conservation. Afterwards, we investigate the implications of the relativistic Doppler effect for the quantum state transformations of wave packets of light and show that a local photon is a local photon at the same point in the spacetime diagram in all inertial frames.

arXiv:2401.02175•Symmetry•Feb 28, 2024•3 citations

A justification of the invariance of the speed of light by quantum theoretical considerations

Michael Cordin

phenomena can often be analysed in a visually clear way by thought experiments. In the present work a new thought experiment is analysed, which describes the emission of a photon by a special mechanism. The analysis leads to the finding, that there is a natural connection between the energy-time uncertainty and the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty principle. A deeper analysis of this thought experiment, especially with regard to a justification of the Doppler effect from the uncertainty principle, leads to the conclusion, that the speed of light is invariant. Therefore it seems reasonable to assume, that the origin of relativistic laws lies in non-relativistic quantum mechanics.

Scientific Reports•Jan 13, 2021•0 citations

Wave and photon descriptions of light: historical highlights, epistemological aspects and teaching practices

B. Buonaura, Giuseppe Giuliani

Abstract The wave and the photon descriptions of light are discussed in connection with interference and the Doppler effect. Both phenomena can be described in terms of waves or in terms of photons. However, the two descriptions are not equivalent. While the photon description deals with a single photon, the wave one deals with the behaviour of many (enough) photons. The wave description’s predictions are in agreement with experiment only when the high number of photons used (one at a time or all together) overshadows their spatially localised interaction with the detectors. These arguments are dealt with on the basis of historical breakthroughs in the light epistemological considerations and teaching implementations.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 27, 2016•10 citations

The Interconnection of Wave- and Particle-Natures

Mituo Taketani, Masayuki Nagasaki

Although the calculation of the Compton effect on the basis of the theory of light quantum is well known through text books in modern physics, it is not so well known that Compton attempted to explain the result of X-ray scattering by means of the effect of interference, but confronted with a serious difficulty, and thus turned to the theory of light quantum. About the time of the discovery of the Compton effect, Schrödinger derived, by making use of the conservation law of energy and momentum, from the standpoint of the theory of light quantum, the formula for the Doppler effect, and Duane, by applying the quantum condition and also from the viewpoint of the theory of light quantum, the Bragg formula for X-ray scattering. It is interesting to see the process by which they came to apply the theory of light theory to wave phenomena. It should be noted especially that de Broglie's wave theory actually resulted from the theory of light quantum. As we shall see in the text, de Broglie's attempt to understand the particle-nature of light quantum by means of the rest mass of light quantum brought forth, rather, the concept of the wave-nature of material particles. Bohr, who was in doubt about the theory of light quantum, proposed in collaboration with Kramers and Slater the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. They proposed the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. Their proposal of the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum was, however, negated immediately by Compton and Simon's experiment with the use of a Wilson chamber. It is scarcely told, so far, in textbooks on the history of science that Kramers and Heisenberg, in generalizing Kramers' wave-theoretical formula for the dispersion of light to include the case of incoherent scattering of light, took account of Smekal's study of the scattering of light on the basis of the theory of light quantum.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 1, 2001•0 citations

Quantum dynamics

Gennaro Auletta, Mauro Fortunato, Giorgio Parisi A

In the first two chapters we have examined the basic principles – superposition (p. 18), complementarity (p. 19), quantization (p. 44), statistical algorithm (p. 57), and correspondence (p. 72) (see also Subsec. 2.3.4) – and the basic entities, observables and states, of quantum mechanics, as well as the main differences with respect to classical mechanics. While what we have discussed so far is rather a static picture of observables and states, in this chapter we shall deal with quantum dynamics, i.e. with the time evolution of quantum-mechanical systems. Historically, after Bohr had provided a quantized description of the atom (see Subsec. 1.5.4), Einstein showed the quantized nature of photons (see Subsec. 1.2.1), and de Broglie hypothized the wave-like nature of matter (see Subsec. 1.5.5), the first building block of quantum mechanics was provided by the commutation relations, proposed by Heisenberg in 1925, whose consequence is represented by the uncertainty relation (see Subsec. 2.2.7 and Sec. 2.3). This was the subject of the previous chapters. The dynamical part of the theory was proposed by Schrödinger in 1926, and is known as the Schrödinger equation. It is also known as wave mechanics (see Subsec. 1.5.7). In this chapter we shall show that Heisenberg's and Schrödinger's formulations are only two different aspects of the same theory. We shall also come back to this point in Sec. 8.1.1. Here, first we shall derive the fundamental equation which rules quantum dynamics (Sec. 3.1), and, in Sec. 3.2, we shall summarize the main properties of the Schrödinger equation.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 16, 2009•0 citations
In 1907, Einstein suggested an experiment with flying atoms for corroborating time dilation. In that paper, the flying atom was conceived as a flying clock: the reference to the Doppler effect was only indirect (the experiments by Stark to the first order of v/cv/cv/c). In 1922, Schrödinger showed that the emission of a light quantum by a (flying) atom is regulated by the conservation laws of energy and linear momentum. Therefore, the Doppler effect for photons is the consequence of the energy and momentum exchange between the atom and the photon: a central role is played by the quantum energy jump ΔEΔEΔE of the transition (a relativistic invariant). The first realization of the experiment devised by Einstein is due to Ives and Stilwell (1938). Since then till nowadays experiments of this kind have been repeated in search of better precision and/or a deviation from the predictions of special relativity. The striking feature is that all the papers dealing with these experiments completely neglect Schrödinger's dynamical treatment. The origins of this omission are of different kind: pragmatic (agreement between formulas, wherever coming from, and experiments), historical (deep rooting of the wave theory of light) and epistemological (neglect of basic epistemological rules).
The analysis of the Doppler effect for photons in rotating systems, studied using the Mössbauer effect, confirms the general conclusions of a previous paper dedicated to experiments with photons emitted/absorbed by atoms/nuclei in inertial flight. The wave theory of light is so deeply rooted that it continues to be applied to describe phenomena in which the fundamental entities at work are discrete (photons). The fact that the wave theory of light can describe one aspect of these phenomena should not overshadow two issues: the corpuscular theory of light, first applied to the Doppler effect for photons by Schrödinger in 1922, is by far more complete since it describes all of the features of the studied phenomena; the wave theory can only be used when the number of photons at work is statistically significant. This disregarding of basic methodological criteria may appear to be a minor fault. However, the historical development of quantum physics shows that the predominance of the wave theory of radiation, beyond its natural application domain, has hampered the reorientation toward the photon description of the underlying phenomena.
The relativistic Doppler effect comes from the fact that observers in different inertial reference frames experience space and time differently, while the speed of light always remains the same. Consequently, a wave packet of light exhibits different frequencies, wavelengths, and amplitudes. In this paper, we present a local approach to the relativistic Doppler effect based on relativity, spatial and time translational symmetries, and energy conservation. Afterwards, we investigate the implications of the relativistic Doppler effect for the quantum state transformations of wave packets of light and show that a local photon is a local photon at the same point in the spacetime diagram in all inertial frames.
phenomena can often be analysed in a visually clear way by thought experiments. In the present work a new thought experiment is analysed, which describes the emission of a photon by a special mechanism. The analysis leads to the finding, that there is a natural connection between the energy-time uncertainty and the Heisenberg position-momentum uncertainty principle. A deeper analysis of this thought experiment, especially with regard to a justification of the Doppler effect from the uncertainty principle, leads to the conclusion, that the speed of light is invariant. Therefore it seems reasonable to assume, that the origin of relativistic laws lies in non-relativistic quantum mechanics.
Abstract The wave and the photon descriptions of light are discussed in connection with interference and the Doppler effect. Both phenomena can be described in terms of waves or in terms of photons. However, the two descriptions are not equivalent. While the photon description deals with a single photon, the wave one deals with the behaviour of many (enough) photons. The wave description’s predictions are in agreement with experiment only when the high number of photons used (one at a time or all together) overshadows their spatially localised interaction with the detectors. These arguments are dealt with on the basis of historical breakthroughs in the light epistemological considerations and teaching implementations.
Although the calculation of the Compton effect on the basis of the theory of light quantum is well known through text books in modern physics, it is not so well known that Compton attempted to explain the result of X-ray scattering by means of the effect of interference, but confronted with a serious difficulty, and thus turned to the theory of light quantum. About the time of the discovery of the Compton effect, Schrödinger derived, by making use of the conservation law of energy and momentum, from the standpoint of the theory of light quantum, the formula for the Doppler effect, and Duane, by applying the quantum condition and also from the viewpoint of the theory of light quantum, the Bragg formula for X-ray scattering. It is interesting to see the process by which they came to apply the theory of light theory to wave phenomena. It should be noted especially that de Broglie's wave theory actually resulted from the theory of light quantum. As we shall see in the text, de Broglie's attempt to understand the particle-nature of light quantum by means of the rest mass of light quantum brought forth, rather, the concept of the wave-nature of material particles. Bohr, who was in doubt about the theory of light quantum, proposed in collaboration with Kramers and Slater the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. They proposed the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum and treated the dispersion of light as a typical wave phenomenon. Their proposal of the law of statistical conservation of energy and momentum was, however, negated immediately by Compton and Simon's experiment with the use of a Wilson chamber. It is scarcely told, so far, in textbooks on the history of science that Kramers and Heisenberg, in generalizing Kramers' wave-theoretical formula for the dispersion of light to include the case of incoherent scattering of light, took account of Smekal's study of the scattering of light on the basis of the theory of light quantum.
In the first two chapters we have examined the basic principles – superposition (p. 18), complementarity (p. 19), quantization (p. 44), statistical algorithm (p. 57), and correspondence (p. 72) (see also Subsec. 2.3.4) – and the basic entities, observables and states, of quantum mechanics, as well as the main differences with respect to classical mechanics. While what we have discussed so far is rather a static picture of observables and states, in this chapter we shall deal with quantum dynamics, i.e. with the time evolution of quantum-mechanical systems. Historically, after Bohr had provided a quantized description of the atom (see Subsec. 1.5.4), Einstein showed the quantized nature of photons (see Subsec. 1.2.1), and de Broglie hypothized the wave-like nature of matter (see Subsec. 1.5.5), the first building block of quantum mechanics was provided by the commutation relations, proposed by Heisenberg in 1925, whose consequence is represented by the uncertainty relation (see Subsec. 2.2.7 and Sec. 2.3). This was the subject of the previous chapters. The dynamical part of the theory was proposed by Schrödinger in 1926, and is known as the Schrödinger equation. It is also known as wave mechanics (see Subsec. 1.5.7). In this chapter we shall show that Heisenberg's and Schrödinger's formulations are only two different aspects of the same theory. We shall also come back to this point in Sec. 8.1.1. Here, first we shall derive the fundamental equation which rules quantum dynamics (Sec. 3.1), and, in Sec. 3.2, we shall summarize the main properties of the Schrödinger equation.