Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1412.7112 · Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences

The complex and quaternionic quantum bit from relativity of simultaneity on an interferometer

Andrew J. P. Garner, Markus P. Müller, Oscar Dahlsten

Published Dec 1, 2017• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The patterns of fringes produced by an interferometer have long been important testbeds for our best contemporary theories of physics. Historically, interference has been used to contrast quantum mechanics with classical physics, but recently experiments have been performed that test quantum theory against even more exotic alternatives. A physically motivated family of theories are those where the state space of a two-level system is given by a sphere of arbitrary dimension. This includes classical bits, and real, complex and quaternionic quantum theory. In this paper, we consider relativity of simultaneity (i.e. that observers may disagree about the order of events at different locations) as applied to a two-armed interferometer, and show that this forbids most interference phenomena more complicated than those of complex quantum theory. If interference must depend on some relational property of the setting (such as path difference), then relativity of simultaneity will limit state spaces to standard complex quantum theory, or a subspace thereof. If this relational assumption is relaxed, we find one additional theory compatible with relativity of simultaneity: quaternionic quantum theory. Our results have consequences for current laboratory interference experiments: they have to be designed carefully to avoid rendering beyond-quantum effects invisible by relativity of simultaneity.

DOI
10.1098/rspa.2017.0596

Related papers

Higher-order interference and single-system postulates characterizing quantum theory

Howard Barnum, Markus P Müller, Cozmin Ududec

We present a new characterization of quantum theory in terms of simple physical principles that is different from previous ones in two important respects: first, it only refers to properties of single systems without any assumptions on the composition of many systems; and second, it is closer to experiment by having absence of higher-order interference as a postulate, which is currently the subject of experimental investigation.We give three postulates-no higher-order interference, classical decomposability of states, and strong symmetry-and prove that the only non-classical operational probabilistic theories satisfying them are real, complex, and quaternionic quantum theory, together with threelevel octonionic quantum theory and ball state spaces of arbitrary dimension.Then we show that adding observability of energy as a fourth postulate yields complex quantum theory as the unique solution, relating the emergence of the complex numbers to the possibility of Hamiltonian dynamics.We also show that there may be interesting non-quantum theories satisfying only the first two of our postulates, which would allow for higher-order interference in experiments while still respecting the contextuality analogue of the local orthogonality principle.

arXiv:1403.4147•New Journal of Physics•Dec 10, 2014•161 citations

Phase and interference phenomena in generalised probabilistic theories

Andrew J. P. Garner

Phase lies at the heart of quantum physics and quantum information theory. A quantum bit is qualitatively different from a classical bit as it allows for the coherent superposition of possibilities, which demonstrate different behaviours depending on the phase between them. These behaviours constitute as interference phenomena, and lie behind the existence of algorithms in quantum computing which are arguably faster than the best classical alternatives. The concept of phase is deeply steeped in the structure of Hilbert spaces: the mathematical framework that underlies quantum theory. What if quantum theory did not hold in all scenarios, or was only a limiting case of some broader theory? In this case, would we still be able to meaningfully talk about phase and interference? In this thesis, we will adopt an operational generalisation of quantum theory known as the framework of generalised probabilistic theories. We will provide a reasonable definition of phase in this framework. Using this, we shall explore single-particle interferometry set-ups (particularly Mach-Zehnder interferometers): experiments whose output is highly dependent on the phase between the spatially disjoint branches through which a particle might be traversing. By applying physically-motivated locality considerations, we identify the crucial role that the uncertainty principle and its generalisations play in quantum theory as an enabler of non-trivial interference. By taking into account relativity of simultaneity, we will also provide a physical motivation for why standard quantum theory provides the best description of the location of a particle traversing such a system. Finally, we apply our generalised definition of phase in the related context of particle exchange behaviour, and identify a method for classifying post-quantum particles. All of this will demonstrate that phase between possibilities and its consequences are not uniquely quantum phenomena. Much of the behaviour we might ascribe to phase in quantum theory in fact holds generally true for phase in probabilistic theories.

•Jan 1, 2015•4 citations

Proposal for an Interference Experiment to Test the Applicability of Quantum Theory to Event-Based Processes

Kristel F. L. Michielsen, Thomas Lippert, Marcus Richter +3 more

We analyze a single-particle Mach-Zehnder interferometer experiment in which the path length of one arm may change (randomly or systematically) according to the value of an external two-valued variable $x$, for each passage of a particle through the interferometer. Quantum theory predicts an interference pattern that is independent of the sequence of the values of $x$. On the other hand, corpuscular models that reproduce the results of quantum optics experiments carried out up to this date show a reduced visibility and a shift of the interference pattern depending on the details of the sequence of the values of $x$. The proposed experiment will show that: (1) it can be described by quantum theory, and thus not by the current corpuscular models, or (2) it cannot be described by quantum theory but can be described by the corpuscular models or variations thereof, or (3) it can neither be described by quantum theory nor by corpuscular models. Therefore, the proposed experiment can be used to determine to what extent quantum theory provides a description of observed events beyond the usual statistical level.

arXiv:1006.0174•Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Feb 24, 2012•8 citations

General relativistic effects in quantum interference of photons

Magdalena Zych, Fabio Costa, Igor Pikovski +2 more

Quantum mechanics and general relativity have been extensively and independently confirmed in many experiments. However, the interplay of the two theories has never been tested: all experiments that measured the influence of gravity on quantum systems are consistent with non-relativistic, Newtonian gravity. On the other hand, all tests of general relativity can be described within the framework of classical physics. Here we discuss a quantum interference experiment with single photons that can probe quantum mechanics in curved space-time. We consider a single photon traveling in superposition along two paths in an interferometer, with each arm experiencing a different gravitational time dilation. If the difference in the time dilations is comparable with the photon's coherence time, the visibility of the quantum interference is predicted to drop, while for shorter time dilations the effect of gravity will result only in a relative phase shift between the two arms. We discuss what aspects of the interplay between quantum mechanics and general relativity are probed in such experiments and analyze the experimental feasibility.

arXiv:1206.0965•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Oct 18, 2012•119 citations

A modified Mach-Zehnder experiment to test the applicability of quantum theory to single-particle experiments

Kristel F. L. Michielsen, Th. Lippert, M. Richter +3 more

We propose a modified single-particle Mach-Zehnder interferometer experiment in which the path length of one arm may change (randomly or systematically) according to the value of an external two-valued variable x, for each passage of a particle through the interferometer. Quantum theory predicts an interference pattern that is independent of the sequence of the values of x. On the other hand, corpuscular models that reproduce the results of quantum optics experiments carried out up to this date show a reduced visibility and a shift of the interference pattern depending on the details of the sequence of the values of x. The key question to be answered in a real laboratory experiment is: Which interference pattern is observed? Despite the general believe that quantum theory might be used to describe all single particle experiments, this is an interesting question to be answered since in the proposed experiment the experimental conditions not only continuously change but they might also have causal effects on the passage of the photons through the interferometer. The proposed experiment can be used to determine to what extent quantum theory provides a description of observed events beyond the usual statistical level.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Sep 8, 2011•1 citation

Elementary analysis of interferometers for wave—particle duality test and the prospect of going beyond the complementarity principle

Zhiyuan Li

A distinct method to show a quantum object behaving both as wave and as particle is proposed and described in some detail. We make a systematic analysis using the elementary methodology of quantum mechanics upon Young's two-slit interferometer and the Mach—Zehnder two-arm interferometer with the focus placed on how to measure the interference pattern (wave nature) and the which-way information (particle nature) of quantum objects. We design several schemes to simultaneously acquire the which-way information for an individual quantum object and the high-contrast interference pattern for an ensemble of these quantum objects by placing two sets of measurement instruments that are well separated in space and whose perturbation of each other is negligibly small within the interferometer at the same time. Yet, improper arrangement and cooperation of these two sets of measurement instruments in the interferometer would lead to failure of simultaneous observation of wave and particle behaviors. The internal freedoms of quantum objects could be harnessed to probe both the which-way information and the interference pattern for the center-of-mass motion. That quantum objects can behave beyond the wave—particle duality and the complementarity principle would stimulate new conceptual examination and exploration of quantum theory at a deeper level.

arXiv:1409.1652•Chinese Physics B•Nov 1, 2014•13 citations
The patterns of fringes produced by an interferometer have long been important testbeds for our best contemporary theories of physics. Historically, interference has been used to contrast quantum mechanics with classical physics, but recently experiments have been performed that test quantum theory against even more exotic alternatives. A physically motivated family of theories are those where the state space of a two-level system is given by a sphere of arbitrary dimension. This includes classical bits, and real, complex and quaternionic quantum theory. In this paper, we consider relativity of simultaneity (i.e. that observers may disagree about the order of events at different locations) as applied to a two-armed interferometer, and show that this forbids most interference phenomena more complicated than those of complex quantum theory. If interference must depend on some relational property of the setting (such as path difference), then relativity of simultaneity will limit state spaces to standard complex quantum theory, or a subspace thereof. If this relational assumption is relaxed, we find one additional theory compatible with relativity of simultaneity: quaternionic quantum theory. Our results have consequences for current laboratory interference experiments: they have to be designed carefully to avoid rendering beyond-quantum effects invisible by relativity of simultaneity.
We present a new characterization of quantum theory in terms of simple physical principles that is different from previous ones in two important respects: first, it only refers to properties of single systems without any assumptions on the composition of many systems; and second, it is closer to experiment by having absence of higher-order interference as a postulate, which is currently the subject of experimental investigation.We give three postulates-no higher-order interference, classical decomposability of states, and strong symmetry-and prove that the only non-classical operational probabilistic theories satisfying them are real, complex, and quaternionic quantum theory, together with threelevel octonionic quantum theory and ball state spaces of arbitrary dimension.Then we show that adding observability of energy as a fourth postulate yields complex quantum theory as the unique solution, relating the emergence of the complex numbers to the possibility of Hamiltonian dynamics.We also show that there may be interesting non-quantum theories satisfying only the first two of our postulates, which would allow for higher-order interference in experiments while still respecting the contextuality analogue of the local orthogonality principle.
Phase lies at the heart of quantum physics and quantum information theory. A quantum bit is qualitatively different from a classical bit as it allows for the coherent superposition of possibilities, which demonstrate different behaviours depending on the phase between them. These behaviours constitute as interference phenomena, and lie behind the existence of algorithms in quantum computing which are arguably faster than the best classical alternatives. The concept of phase is deeply steeped in the structure of Hilbert spaces: the mathematical framework that underlies quantum theory. What if quantum theory did not hold in all scenarios, or was only a limiting case of some broader theory? In this case, would we still be able to meaningfully talk about phase and interference? In this thesis, we will adopt an operational generalisation of quantum theory known as the framework of generalised probabilistic theories. We will provide a reasonable definition of phase in this framework. Using this, we shall explore single-particle interferometry set-ups (particularly Mach-Zehnder interferometers): experiments whose output is highly dependent on the phase between the spatially disjoint branches through which a particle might be traversing. By applying physically-motivated locality considerations, we identify the crucial role that the uncertainty principle and its generalisations play in quantum theory as an enabler of non-trivial interference. By taking into account relativity of simultaneity, we will also provide a physical motivation for why standard quantum theory provides the best description of the location of a particle traversing such a system. Finally, we apply our generalised definition of phase in the related context of particle exchange behaviour, and identify a method for classifying post-quantum particles. All of this will demonstrate that phase between possibilities and its consequences are not uniquely quantum phenomena. Much of the behaviour we might ascribe to phase in quantum theory in fact holds generally true for phase in probabilistic theories.
We analyze a single-particle Mach-Zehnder interferometer experiment in which the path length of one arm may change (randomly or systematically) according to the value of an external two-valued variable xxx, for each passage of a particle through the interferometer. Quantum theory predicts an interference pattern that is independent of the sequence of the values of xxx. On the other hand, corpuscular models that reproduce the results of quantum optics experiments carried out up to this date show a reduced visibility and a shift of the interference pattern depending on the details of the sequence of the values of xxx. The proposed experiment will show that: (1) it can be described by quantum theory, and thus not by the current corpuscular models, or (2) it cannot be described by quantum theory but can be described by the corpuscular models or variations thereof, or (3) it can neither be described by quantum theory nor by corpuscular models. Therefore, the proposed experiment can be used to determine to what extent quantum theory provides a description of observed events beyond the usual statistical level.
Quantum mechanics and general relativity have been extensively and independently confirmed in many experiments. However, the interplay of the two theories has never been tested: all experiments that measured the influence of gravity on quantum systems are consistent with non-relativistic, Newtonian gravity. On the other hand, all tests of general relativity can be described within the framework of classical physics. Here we discuss a quantum interference experiment with single photons that can probe quantum mechanics in curved space-time. We consider a single photon traveling in superposition along two paths in an interferometer, with each arm experiencing a different gravitational time dilation. If the difference in the time dilations is comparable with the photon's coherence time, the visibility of the quantum interference is predicted to drop, while for shorter time dilations the effect of gravity will result only in a relative phase shift between the two arms. We discuss what aspects of the interplay between quantum mechanics and general relativity are probed in such experiments and analyze the experimental feasibility.
We propose a modified single-particle Mach-Zehnder interferometer experiment in which the path length of one arm may change (randomly or systematically) according to the value of an external two-valued variable x, for each passage of a particle through the interferometer. Quantum theory predicts an interference pattern that is independent of the sequence of the values of x. On the other hand, corpuscular models that reproduce the results of quantum optics experiments carried out up to this date show a reduced visibility and a shift of the interference pattern depending on the details of the sequence of the values of x. The key question to be answered in a real laboratory experiment is: Which interference pattern is observed? Despite the general believe that quantum theory might be used to describe all single particle experiments, this is an interesting question to be answered since in the proposed experiment the experimental conditions not only continuously change but they might also have causal effects on the passage of the photons through the interferometer. The proposed experiment can be used to determine to what extent quantum theory provides a description of observed events beyond the usual statistical level.
A distinct method to show a quantum object behaving both as wave and as particle is proposed and described in some detail. We make a systematic analysis using the elementary methodology of quantum mechanics upon Young's two-slit interferometer and the Mach—Zehnder two-arm interferometer with the focus placed on how to measure the interference pattern (wave nature) and the which-way information (particle nature) of quantum objects. We design several schemes to simultaneously acquire the which-way information for an individual quantum object and the high-contrast interference pattern for an ensemble of these quantum objects by placing two sets of measurement instruments that are well separated in space and whose perturbation of each other is negligibly small within the interferometer at the same time. Yet, improper arrangement and cooperation of these two sets of measurement instruments in the interferometer would lead to failure of simultaneous observation of wave and particle behaviors. The internal freedoms of quantum objects could be harnessed to probe both the which-way information and the interference pattern for the center-of-mass motion. That quantum objects can behave beyond the wave—particle duality and the complementarity principle would stimulate new conceptual examination and exploration of quantum theory at a deeper level.