Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1411.7293 · WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Information Processing with Page–Wootters States

Stam Nicolis

Published Dec 9, 2014• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In order to perceive that a physical system evolves in time, two requirements must be met: (a) it must be possible to define a "clock" and (b) it must be possible to make a copy of the state of the system, that can be reliably retrieved to make a comparison. We investigate what constraints quantum mechanics poses on these issues, in light of recent experiments with entangled photons.

DOI
10.1142/9789814602136_0007

Related papers

Measuring time in a timeless universe

Samuel Kuypers, Simone Rijavec

Physical systems are usually assumed to evolve relative to an external time parameter, which is problematic because in quantum theory that parameter is not a physical observable. Page and Wootters (1984) solved this by proposing that the Universe is in a stationary state, eliminating the need for the external time parameter. Instead, their model contains an isolated subsystem, a clock, with which other subsystems are entangled, making the latter appear to evolve relative to different states of the clock. While this resolves the problem of the time parameter, the assumption that the clock is isolated prevents it from being measured, as this requires an interaction with another system. We prove that the clock can be measured while preserving the core features of the Page-Wootters construction. We also discuss clock synchronization.

arXiv:2406.14642•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Aug 24, 2025•10 citations

Time from quantum entanglement: An experimental illustration

Ekaterina V. Moreva, G. Brida, Marco Gramegna +3 more

In previous years several theoretical papers discussed if time can be an emergent property deriving from quantum correlations. Here, to provide insight into how this phenomenon can occur, we present an experiment that illustrates Page and Wootters' mechanism of ``static'' time [D. N. Page and W. K. Wootters, Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885 (1983)], and Gambini et al. for subsequent refinements [R. Gambini et al., Phys. Rev. D 79, 041501(R) (2009)]. A static, entangled state between a clock system and the rest of the universe is perceived as evolving by internal observers that test the correlations between the two subsystems. We implement this mechanism using an entangled state of the polarization of two photons, one of which is used as a clock to gauge the evolution of the second: An ``internal'' observer that becomes correlated with the clock photon sees the other system evolve, while an ``external'' observer that only observes global properties of the two photons can prove it is static.

arXiv:1310.4691•Physical Review A•May 20, 2014•151 citations

The time as an emergent property of quantum mechanics, a synthetic description of a first experimental approach

Ekaterina V. Moreva, G. Brida, Marco Gramegna +3 more

The ''problem of time" in present physics substantially consists in the fact that a straightforward quantization of the general relativistic evolution equation and constraints generates for the Universe wave function the Wheeler-De Witt equation, which describes a static Universe. Page and Wootters considered the fact that there exist states of a system composed by entangled subsystems that are stationary, but one can interpret the component subsystems as evolving: this leads them to suppose that the global state of the universe can be envisaged as one of this static entangled state, whereas the state of the subsystems can evolve. Here we synthetically present an experiment, based on PDC polarization entangled photons, that shows a practical example where this idea works, i.e. a subsystem of an entangled state works as a 'clock" of another subsystem.

arXiv:1502.03264•Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jul 3, 2015•6 citations

The preferred-time problem in the conditional interpretation of time

Ovidiu Cristinel Stoica

In timeless formulations of quantum theory, the Page-Wootters proposal (PW) recovers time and dynamics as relative clock-and-world states. By interpreting the total timeless system as a clock entangled with the world, the states having a definite clock reading appear to recover the temporal states of the world as relative states, and dynamics emerges. But an entangled state admits infinitely many decompositions as a superposition of product states, each decomposition corresponding to a different but equally valid time operator of the same clock system. Different valid choices of the time operator for the same clock system lead to different physical histories, where the world states in a history are superpositions of the world states from another history. Fixing one operator as "the" clock time would import the temporal meaning that the Page-Wootters proposal is meant to explain in the first place. Therefore, the interpretation of PW that the world state is passively conditioned on the clock state cannot hold. The timeless state is resolved into time-dependent states by the intrinsic pointer observables of the world, without having to outsource the role of the time operator to a separate clock. Fortunately, the formalism of PW remains valid, provided that it is interpreted in terms of intrinsic pointer observables of the world itself.

quant-pharXiv:2608.16732•Aug 18, 2026•0 citations

Robustness of the Page-Wootters construction across different pictures, states of the universe, and system-clock interactions

Simone Rijavec

In quantum theory, the concept of time rests on shaky ground. One way to address this problem is to remove the usual background time parameter as a primitive entity and explain its emergence via correlations between physical systems. This approach was adopted by Page and Wootters [Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885 (1983)], who showed how time can emerge in a stationary quantum universe from the correlations between two of its subsystems, one of them acting as a clock for the other. In this work, I study the robustness of the Page-Wootters construction across different pictures, states of the universe, and clock interactions, clarifying the role and the nature of the correlations between the subsystems of the universe. I start by showing how to formulate the Page-Wootters construction in the Heisenberg picture via a unitary change of basis. I consider both pure and mixed states of the universe and extend the analysis to include interactions between the clock and the other subsystem of the universe. The study reveals what kind of correlations are necessary for the construction to work. Interestingly, entanglement is not required as long as there are no interactions with the clock. The study also shows that these interactions can lead to a nonunitary evolution for some mixed states of the universe. In a simple two-level system, this aspect becomes relevant at scales where one would expect strong relativistic effects. At these scales, I also observe an inversion in the system's direction of time.

arXiv:2204.11740•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Sep 11, 2023•15 citations

Time emerging from quantum correlations

Ekaterina V. Moreva, G. Brida, Marco Gramegna +3 more

Page and Wootters’ mechanism of “static” time is experimentally realized using a static, entangled state of the polarization of two photons, one of which serves as a clock to gauge the evolution of the second.

Research in Optical Sciences•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations
In order to perceive that a physical system evolves in time, two requirements must be met: (a) it must be possible to define a "clock" and (b) it must be possible to make a copy of the state of the system, that can be reliably retrieved to make a comparison. We investigate what constraints quantum mechanics poses on these issues, in light of recent experiments with entangled photons.
Physical systems are usually assumed to evolve relative to an external time parameter, which is problematic because in quantum theory that parameter is not a physical observable. Page and Wootters (1984) solved this by proposing that the Universe is in a stationary state, eliminating the need for the external time parameter. Instead, their model contains an isolated subsystem, a clock, with which other subsystems are entangled, making the latter appear to evolve relative to different states of the clock. While this resolves the problem of the time parameter, the assumption that the clock is isolated prevents it from being measured, as this requires an interaction with another system. We prove that the clock can be measured while preserving the core features of the Page-Wootters construction. We also discuss clock synchronization.
In previous years several theoretical papers discussed if time can be an emergent property deriving from quantum correlations. Here, to provide insight into how this phenomenon can occur, we present an experiment that illustrates Page and Wootters' mechanism of ``static'' time [D. N. Page and W. K. Wootters, Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885 (1983)], and Gambini et al. for subsequent refinements [R. Gambini et al., Phys. Rev. D 79, 041501(R) (2009)]. A static, entangled state between a clock system and the rest of the universe is perceived as evolving by internal observers that test the correlations between the two subsystems. We implement this mechanism using an entangled state of the polarization of two photons, one of which is used as a clock to gauge the evolution of the second: An ``internal'' observer that becomes correlated with the clock photon sees the other system evolve, while an ``external'' observer that only observes global properties of the two photons can prove it is static.
The ''problem of time" in present physics substantially consists in the fact that a straightforward quantization of the general relativistic evolution equation and constraints generates for the Universe wave function the Wheeler-De Witt equation, which describes a static Universe. Page and Wootters considered the fact that there exist states of a system composed by entangled subsystems that are stationary, but one can interpret the component subsystems as evolving: this leads them to suppose that the global state of the universe can be envisaged as one of this static entangled state, whereas the state of the subsystems can evolve. Here we synthetically present an experiment, based on PDC polarization entangled photons, that shows a practical example where this idea works, i.e. a subsystem of an entangled state works as a 'clock" of another subsystem.
In timeless formulations of quantum theory, the Page-Wootters proposal (PW) recovers time and dynamics as relative clock-and-world states. By interpreting the total timeless system as a clock entangled with the world, the states having a definite clock reading appear to recover the temporal states of the world as relative states, and dynamics emerges. But an entangled state admits infinitely many decompositions as a superposition of product states, each decomposition corresponding to a different but equally valid time operator of the same clock system. Different valid choices of the time operator for the same clock system lead to different physical histories, where the world states in a history are superpositions of the world states from another history. Fixing one operator as "the" clock time would import the temporal meaning that the Page-Wootters proposal is meant to explain in the first place. Therefore, the interpretation of PW that the world state is passively conditioned on the clock state cannot hold. The timeless state is resolved into time-dependent states by the intrinsic pointer observables of the world, without having to outsource the role of the time operator to a separate clock. Fortunately, the formalism of PW remains valid, provided that it is interpreted in terms of intrinsic pointer observables of the world itself.
In quantum theory, the concept of time rests on shaky ground. One way to address this problem is to remove the usual background time parameter as a primitive entity and explain its emergence via correlations between physical systems. This approach was adopted by Page and Wootters [Phys. Rev. D 27, 2885 (1983)], who showed how time can emerge in a stationary quantum universe from the correlations between two of its subsystems, one of them acting as a clock for the other. In this work, I study the robustness of the Page-Wootters construction across different pictures, states of the universe, and clock interactions, clarifying the role and the nature of the correlations between the subsystems of the universe. I start by showing how to formulate the Page-Wootters construction in the Heisenberg picture via a unitary change of basis. I consider both pure and mixed states of the universe and extend the analysis to include interactions between the clock and the other subsystem of the universe. The study reveals what kind of correlations are necessary for the construction to work. Interestingly, entanglement is not required as long as there are no interactions with the clock. The study also shows that these interactions can lead to a nonunitary evolution for some mixed states of the universe. In a simple two-level system, this aspect becomes relevant at scales where one would expect strong relativistic effects. At these scales, I also observe an inversion in the system's direction of time.