Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1411.2296 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

A novel quantum-mechanical interpretation of the Dirac equation

M K-H Kiessling, A S Tahvildar-Zadeh

Published Feb 19, 2016• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract A novel interpretation is given of Dirac’s ‘wave equation for the relativistic electron’ as a quantum-mechanical one-particle equation. In this interpretation the electron and the positron are merely the two different ‘topological spin’ states of a single more fundamental particle, not distinct particles in their own right. The new interpretation is backed up by the existence of such ‘bi-particle’ structures in general relativity, in particular the ring singularity present in any spacelike section of the spacetime singularity of the maximal-analytically extended, topologically non-trivial, electromagnetic Kerr–Newman (KN)spacetime in the zero-gravity limit (here, ‘zero-gravity’ means the limit , where G is Newton’s constant of universal gravitation). This novel interpretation resolves the dilemma that Dirac’s wave equation seems to be capable of describing both the electron and the positron in ‘external’ fields in many relevant situations, while the bi-spinorial wave function has only a single position variable in its argument, not two—as it should if it were a quantum-mechanical two-particle wave equation. A Dirac equation is formulated for such a ring-like bi-particle which interacts with a static point charge located elsewhere in the topologically non-trivial physical space associated with the moving ring particle, the motion being governed by a de Broglie–Bohm type law extracted from the Dirac equation. As an application, the pertinent general-relativistic zero-gravity hydrogen problem is studied in the usual Born–Oppenheimer approximation. Its spectral results suggest that the zero- G KN magnetic moment be identified with the so-called ‘anomalous magnetic moment of the physical electron,’ not with the Bohr magneton, so that the ring radius is only a tiny fraction of the electron’s reduced Compton wavelength.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/49/13/135301

Related papers

A Planck-Einstein-Dirac Wave Model of Electron

Zhaoxin Wang

The spherical model of electron cannot explain Bohr magneton, de Broglie wave, etc. To explain these properties physically, we propose that spin, one core concept of quantum theory, is a reality, and introduce this alternative solely based on experimental findings, Planck’s, Einstein’s, and Dirac’s insights, and follows classical laws, that an electron is an electrical wave with a literal $\frac{1}{2}$ spin (Dirac), i.e., spins two circles in one cycle, both angular momentum are ℏ. Its wavelength is determined by $E=h\nu_{m_0}=\frac{hc}{\lambda_{m_0}}=m_0c^2$ (Plank and Einstein), λ m 0 is the Compton wavelength. As E⃗ ⊥ c⃗ for a transverse wave, it has a net electricity due to the first spin, $f(E_q)=\frac{1}{2}E_0\left(1-\cos(2\omega_0t)\right)$, half of its cycle, i.e., the minimal meaningful unit as F = E q , is related with its charge, q = E q ϵ 0 . Moreover, an electron has a ring shape due to the second spin, 2 π R 0 = λ m 0 , λ m 0 is the electron-impact cross section. As $\hbar=\frac{h}{\lambda_{m_0}}\frac{\lambda_{m_0}}{2\pi}=m_0cR_0$, it has a quantized classical angular momentum, with a speed of c . The Bohr magneton, $\vec{\mu_B}=\vec{\frac{q}{2m_0}\hbar}$, g -factor is 2. Critically, the full Dirac’s equation of an electron with a constant velocity is $\vec{mc} = \vec{\hbar_\perp}+\vec{p_\perp } +\vec{\hbar_{//}} +\vec{p_{//}}$, and its electromagnetic properties due to charge are $\vec{f(E_q)} = \vec{f(E_q)\frac{\sqrt{c^2-v^{'2}}}{c}} + \vec{f(E_q) \frac{v\rq}{c}} = \vec{E_{net}^{//}} + \vec{E_q^\perp}$, $\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_\perp}$ or $\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_{//}}$, and $\vec{v\rq} // \vec{E_{net}}$. Assuming heavy charged particles have equivalent though shall not identical mechanisms, mathematically this model is equivalent to Special Relativity, and supports ALL its formulas, i.e., v < c , E = m c 2 , direction-insensitive m = γ m 0 and $t=\frac{t_0}{\gamma}$; Moreover, the net electricity $\vec{E_{net}^{//}}$ and Bohr magneton is orientation-quantized, direction-sensitive and follows Lorentz transformation, leading to Lorentz transformation of length contraction; while following Relativity, magnetism can be defined by $\vec{f(B)} =\vec{f(E_q)\frac{v\rq}{c^2}}$, which is not circularly symmetric and self-evidently does not follow Lorentz transformation. The temporospatial averaged magnetic intensity of a current is relativistic, $\bar{\vec{B}} =\sum\vec{{f(E_q)}\frac{\Delta v}{c^2 }}=\frac{\vec{I}}{2 \pi \epsilon_0 c^2}=\frac{\mu_0\vec{I}}{2\pi}$, and μ 0 ϵ 0 c 2 = 1, supporting Maxwell’s equations. Further implications include chirality therefore magnetic spatial quantization, de Broglie wave, etc. The spherical model should be just an observation due to orientation quantization of $\vec{E_{net}}$. We conclude this model of electron may provide one step further to the ultimate Quantum Theory in a nonrelativistic spacetime.

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

Aspects of Single-Particle Bohmian Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

David L. Bartley

The connection between the (orthodox) single-particle Newton-Wigner position and the Bohm/de Broglie hidden-particle position in the relativistic regime is investigated. The effect of non-positive excursions of the ensemble density for extreme cases of positive-energy waves is easily computed using an integral of the equations of motion developed here and is interpreted in terms of virtual-like pair creation and annihilation beneath the Compton wavelength. A Bohm-theoretic description of the acausal explosion of Newton-Wigner-localized states is presented in detail for spin-0 particles in attempt to relate Bohm/de Broglie and orthodox positions. Spin-1/2 particles are considered as well with the assumption that the convective current component describes ensemble dynamics as with the spin-0 theory. For spin-1/2 particles, a specific second-rank tensor is defined in terms of Dirac spinors for generalizing from simply a quantum potential to a stress tensor required to account for the force of pilot wave on particle. A simple dependence of the stress tensor on a two-component spin pseudovector field is determined for approaching a non-relativistic limit. Consistency is found with an earlier non-relativistic theory of objects with spin.

•Sep 11, 2016•0 citations

Dirac equation for electrodynamic model particles

J. X. Zheng-Johansson

We set up the Maxwell's equations and subsequently the classical wave equations for the electromagnetic waves which together with their generating source, an oscillatory charge of zero rest mass in general travelling, make up a particle travelling similarly as the source at velocity ν in the field of an external scalar and vector potentials. The direct solutions in constant external field are Doppler-displaced plane waves propagating at the velocity of light c ; at the de Broglie wavelength scale and expressed in terms of the dynamically equivalent and appropriate geometric mean wave variables, these render as functions identical to the space-time functions of a corresponding Dirac spinor, and in turn identical to de Broglie phase waves previously obtained from explicit superposition. For two spin-half particles of a common set of space-time functions constrained with antisymmetric spin functions as follows the Pauli principle for same charges and as separately indirectly induced based on experiment for opposite charges, the complete wave functions are identical to the Dirac spinor. The back-substitution of the so explicitly determined complete wave functions in the corresponding classical wave equations of the two particles, subjected further to reductions appropriate for the stationary-state particle motion and to rotation invariance when in three dimensions, give a Dirac equation set; the procedure and conclusion are directly extendible to arbitrarily varying potentials by use of the Furious theorem and to particle motions in three dimensions by virtue of the characteristics of de Broglie particle motion. Through the derivation of the Dirac equation, the study hopes to lend insight into the connections between the Dirac wave functions and the electrodynamic components of simple particles under the government by the well established basic laws of electrodynamics.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2008•4 citations

Potential scattering of Dirac particles

Bernd Thaller

Considers the Dirac equation with external electromagnetic fields and gives a careful formulation of the Stuckelberg-Feynman interpretation. This electron-positron theory may be applied whenever electron and positron states can be separated, which is possible for a wide class of time-independent potentials vanishing at infinity. One then may introduce a system of observables with a position operator X(t) which is free of Zitterbewegung and yields the usual relativistic connection between momentum and velocity. The Stuckelberg-Feynman interpretation is usually associated with a scattering theory (propagator formalism), which differs from the one of a one-particle interpretation (formalism imitating non-relativistic techniques). For the above-mentioned potentials there is a simple relationship between these physically different formalisms. There are, however, more general potentials for which the Stuckelberg-Feynman interpretation may still be applied asymptotically. With the help of Klein's paradox the authors show that the Dirac equation may then have unphysical solutions not conserving the total charge.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 1, 1981•10 citations

Topological Origins of Fermionic States: Deriving the Dirac Equation via the Linearization of Relativistic Wave Mechanics

S. Conde

The Dirac equation stands as the cornerstone of relativistic quantum mechanics, successfully predicting spin and antimatter. However, its derivation is typically presented as a formal algebraic requirement—the linearization of the Hamiltonian—without a clear physical ontology explaining why nature demands such a structure. In this work, building upon a previously established model of particles as topologically anchored wave-defects in a continuous medium, we demonstrate that the Dirac equation is not merely an algebraic curiosity but a structural necessity. We show that the requirement to describe the causal, first-order evolution of a relativistic standing wave compels the state variable to possess a multi-component spinor structure. We explicitly derive the Clifford algebra of the dynamical operators and identify the emergent 4-component state space with the physical degrees of freedom of the defect: a local vibrational duality (Spin) coupled to a global topological orientability (Charge). Thus, the ”quantum strangeness” of the fermion—its spin-1/2 nature and antiparticle partner—are demystified, emerging as the natural description of a relativistic object with non-trivial topology.

•Jan 11, 2026•0 citations

Resolving the Paradox of the Dirac Equation through Phenomenology

С. Ф. Тимашев

Abstract F. Wilf’s results on the need to consider the rules of quantum-mechanical correspondence in the Dirac equation for an electron are used to show that the equation obtained by giving physical meaning to α‑Dirac operators should be considered a phenomenological equation for a particle of non-zero size (the EM polaron introduced earlier by the author). This allows a solution to be found to the inherent paradox of the Dirac equation, which consists of the equality of the velocity of the moving particles to the speed of light in a vacuum, which is a priori unobtainable, and to understand the physical essence of spin as the intrinsic mechanical moment of an EM polaron. It is also shown that the Dirac–Wilf equation for a single spatial dimension can be considered a generalization of the Schrödinger equation for relativistic energies.

arXiv:2404.08009•Russian Journal of Physical Chemistry A•Apr 1, 2024•1 citation
Abstract A novel interpretation is given of Dirac’s ‘wave equation for the relativistic electron’ as a quantum-mechanical one-particle equation. In this interpretation the electron and the positron are merely the two different ‘topological spin’ states of a single more fundamental particle, not distinct particles in their own right. The new interpretation is backed up by the existence of such ‘bi-particle’ structures in general relativity, in particular the ring singularity present in any spacelike section of the spacetime singularity of the maximal-analytically extended, topologically non-trivial, electromagnetic Kerr–Newman (KN)spacetime in the zero-gravity limit (here, ‘zero-gravity’ means the limit , where G is Newton’s constant of universal gravitation). This novel interpretation resolves the dilemma that Dirac’s wave equation seems to be capable of describing both the electron and the positron in ‘external’ fields in many relevant situations, while the bi-spinorial wave function has only a single position variable in its argument, not two—as it should if it were a quantum-mechanical two-particle wave equation. A Dirac equation is formulated for such a ring-like bi-particle which interacts with a static point charge located elsewhere in the topologically non-trivial physical space associated with the moving ring particle, the motion being governed by a de Broglie–Bohm type law extracted from the Dirac equation. As an application, the pertinent general-relativistic zero-gravity hydrogen problem is studied in the usual Born–Oppenheimer approximation. Its spectral results suggest that the zero- G KN magnetic moment be identified with the so-called ‘anomalous magnetic moment of the physical electron,’ not with the Bohr magneton, so that the ring radius is only a tiny fraction of the electron’s reduced Compton wavelength.
The spherical model of electron cannot explain Bohr magneton, de Broglie wave, etc. To explain these properties physically, we propose that spin, one core concept of quantum theory, is a reality, and introduce this alternative solely based on experimental findings, Planck’s, Einstein’s, and Dirac’s insights, and follows classical laws, that an electron is an electrical wave with a literal 12\frac{1}{2}21​ spin (Dirac), i.e., spins two circles in one cycle, both angular momentum are ℏ. Its wavelength is determined by E=hνm0=hcλm0=m0c2E=h\nu_{m_0}=\frac{hc}{\lambda_{m_0}}=m_0c^2E=hνm0​​=λm0​​hc​=m0​c2 (Plank and Einstein), λ m 0 is the Compton wavelength. As E⃗ ⊥ c⃗ for a transverse wave, it has a net electricity due to the first spin, f(Eq)=12E0(1−cos⁡(2ω0t))f(E_q)=\frac{1}{2}E_0\left(1-\cos(2\omega_0t)\right)f(Eq​)=21​E0​(1−cos(2ω0​t)), half of its cycle, i.e., the minimal meaningful unit as F = E q , is related with its charge, q = E q ϵ 0 . Moreover, an electron has a ring shape due to the second spin, 2 π R 0 = λ m 0 , λ m 0 is the electron-impact cross section. As ℏ=hλm0λm02π=m0cR0\hbar=\frac{h}{\lambda_{m_0}}\frac{\lambda_{m_0}}{2\pi}=m_0cR_0ℏ=λm0​​h​2πλm0​​​=m0​cR0​, it has a quantized classical angular momentum, with a speed of c . The Bohr magneton, μB⃗=q2m0ℏ⃗\vec{\mu_B}=\vec{\frac{q}{2m_0}\hbar}μB​​=2m0​q​ℏ​, g -factor is 2. Critically, the full Dirac’s equation of an electron with a constant velocity is mc⃗=ℏ⊥⃗+p⊥⃗+ℏ//⃗+p//⃗\vec{mc} = \vec{\hbar_\perp}+\vec{p_\perp } +\vec{\hbar_{//}} +\vec{p_{//}}mc=ℏ⊥​​+p⊥​​+ℏ//​​+p//​​, and its electromagnetic properties due to charge are f(Eq)⃗=f(Eq)c2−v′2c⃗+f(Eq)v′c⃗=Enet//⃗+Eq⊥⃗\vec{f(E_q)} = \vec{f(E_q)\frac{\sqrt{c^2-v^{'2}}}{c}} + \vec{f(E_q) \frac{v\rq}{c}} = \vec{E_{net}^{//}} + \vec{E_q^\perp}f(Eq​)​=f(Eq​)cc2−v′2​​​+f(Eq​)cv′​​=Enet//​​+Eq⊥​​, v′⃗//ℏ⊥⃗\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_\perp}v′//ℏ⊥​​ or v′⃗//ℏ//⃗\vec{v\rq} // \vec{\hbar_{//}}v′//ℏ//​​, and v′⃗//Enet⃗\vec{v\rq} // \vec{E_{net}}v′//Enet​​. Assuming heavy charged particles have equivalent though shall not identical mechanisms, mathematically this model is equivalent to Special Relativity, and supports ALL its formulas, i.e., v < c , E = m c 2 , direction-insensitive m = γ m 0 and t=t0γt=\frac{t_0}{\gamma}t=γt0​​; Moreover, the net electricity Enet//⃗\vec{E_{net}^{//}}Enet//​​ and Bohr magneton is orientation-quantized, direction-sensitive and follows Lorentz transformation, leading to Lorentz transformation of length contraction; while following Relativity, magnetism can be defined by f(B)⃗=f(Eq)v′c2⃗\vec{f(B)} =\vec{f(E_q)\frac{v\rq}{c^2}}f(B)​=f(Eq​)c2v′​​, which is not circularly symmetric and self-evidently does not follow Lorentz transformation. The temporospatial averaged magnetic intensity of a current is relativistic, B⃗ˉ=∑f(Eq)Δvc2⃗=I⃗2πϵ0c2=μ0I⃗2π\bar{\vec{B}} =\sum\vec{{f(E_q)}\frac{\Delta v}{c^2 }}=\frac{\vec{I}}{2 \pi \epsilon_0 c^2}=\frac{\mu_0\vec{I}}{2\pi}Bˉ=∑f(Eq​)c2Δv​​=2πϵ0​c2I​=2πμ0​I​, and μ 0 ϵ 0 c 2 = 1, supporting Maxwell’s equations. Further implications include chirality therefore magnetic spatial quantization, de Broglie wave, etc. The spherical model should be just an observation due to orientation quantization of Enet⃗\vec{E_{net}}Enet​​. We conclude this model of electron may provide one step further to the ultimate Quantum Theory in a nonrelativistic spacetime.
The connection between the (orthodox) single-particle Newton-Wigner position and the Bohm/de Broglie hidden-particle position in the relativistic regime is investigated. The effect of non-positive excursions of the ensemble density for extreme cases of positive-energy waves is easily computed using an integral of the equations of motion developed here and is interpreted in terms of virtual-like pair creation and annihilation beneath the Compton wavelength. A Bohm-theoretic description of the acausal explosion of Newton-Wigner-localized states is presented in detail for spin-0 particles in attempt to relate Bohm/de Broglie and orthodox positions. Spin-1/2 particles are considered as well with the assumption that the convective current component describes ensemble dynamics as with the spin-0 theory. For spin-1/2 particles, a specific second-rank tensor is defined in terms of Dirac spinors for generalizing from simply a quantum potential to a stress tensor required to account for the force of pilot wave on particle. A simple dependence of the stress tensor on a two-component spin pseudovector field is determined for approaching a non-relativistic limit. Consistency is found with an earlier non-relativistic theory of objects with spin.
We set up the Maxwell's equations and subsequently the classical wave equations for the electromagnetic waves which together with their generating source, an oscillatory charge of zero rest mass in general travelling, make up a particle travelling similarly as the source at velocity ν in the field of an external scalar and vector potentials. The direct solutions in constant external field are Doppler-displaced plane waves propagating at the velocity of light c ; at the de Broglie wavelength scale and expressed in terms of the dynamically equivalent and appropriate geometric mean wave variables, these render as functions identical to the space-time functions of a corresponding Dirac spinor, and in turn identical to de Broglie phase waves previously obtained from explicit superposition. For two spin-half particles of a common set of space-time functions constrained with antisymmetric spin functions as follows the Pauli principle for same charges and as separately indirectly induced based on experiment for opposite charges, the complete wave functions are identical to the Dirac spinor. The back-substitution of the so explicitly determined complete wave functions in the corresponding classical wave equations of the two particles, subjected further to reductions appropriate for the stationary-state particle motion and to rotation invariance when in three dimensions, give a Dirac equation set; the procedure and conclusion are directly extendible to arbitrarily varying potentials by use of the Furious theorem and to particle motions in three dimensions by virtue of the characteristics of de Broglie particle motion. Through the derivation of the Dirac equation, the study hopes to lend insight into the connections between the Dirac wave functions and the electrodynamic components of simple particles under the government by the well established basic laws of electrodynamics.
Considers the Dirac equation with external electromagnetic fields and gives a careful formulation of the Stuckelberg-Feynman interpretation. This electron-positron theory may be applied whenever electron and positron states can be separated, which is possible for a wide class of time-independent potentials vanishing at infinity. One then may introduce a system of observables with a position operator X(t) which is free of Zitterbewegung and yields the usual relativistic connection between momentum and velocity. The Stuckelberg-Feynman interpretation is usually associated with a scattering theory (propagator formalism), which differs from the one of a one-particle interpretation (formalism imitating non-relativistic techniques). For the above-mentioned potentials there is a simple relationship between these physically different formalisms. There are, however, more general potentials for which the Stuckelberg-Feynman interpretation may still be applied asymptotically. With the help of Klein's paradox the authors show that the Dirac equation may then have unphysical solutions not conserving the total charge.
The Dirac equation stands as the cornerstone of relativistic quantum mechanics, successfully predicting spin and antimatter. However, its derivation is typically presented as a formal algebraic requirement—the linearization of the Hamiltonian—without a clear physical ontology explaining why nature demands such a structure. In this work, building upon a previously established model of particles as topologically anchored wave-defects in a continuous medium, we demonstrate that the Dirac equation is not merely an algebraic curiosity but a structural necessity. We show that the requirement to describe the causal, first-order evolution of a relativistic standing wave compels the state variable to possess a multi-component spinor structure. We explicitly derive the Clifford algebra of the dynamical operators and identify the emergent 4-component state space with the physical degrees of freedom of the defect: a local vibrational duality (Spin) coupled to a global topological orientability (Charge). Thus, the ”quantum strangeness” of the fermion—its spin-1/2 nature and antiparticle partner—are demystified, emerging as the natural description of a relativistic object with non-trivial topology.
Abstract F. Wilf’s results on the need to consider the rules of quantum-mechanical correspondence in the Dirac equation for an electron are used to show that the equation obtained by giving physical meaning to α‑Dirac operators should be considered a phenomenological equation for a particle of non-zero size (the EM polaron introduced earlier by the author). This allows a solution to be found to the inherent paradox of the Dirac equation, which consists of the equality of the velocity of the moving particles to the speed of light in a vacuum, which is a priori unobtainable, and to understand the physical essence of spin as the intrinsic mechanical moment of an EM polaron. It is also shown that the Dirac–Wilf equation for a single spatial dimension can be considered a generalization of the Schrödinger equation for relativistic energies.